Woodrow Wilson's Opposition To Dollar Diplomacy Explained

why did woodrow wilson not support dollar diplomacy

Woodrow Wilson's foreign policy was based on his philosophical belief that America had an obligation to spread its principles while reflecting the 'truisms' of American thought. Wilson's policy, known as 'moral diplomacy', emphasized promoting democracy and moral principles rather than economic interests. This set him apart from his predecessors, including Taft, whose 'dollar diplomacy' aimed to use economic power to influence foreign affairs and secure markets for American businesses. Wilson's approach was intended to reduce the United States' role in foreign affairs unless there was a moral imperative, and he believed that if the U.S. placed economic strain on undemocratic countries, they would shift their values and become democratic.

Characteristics Values
Wilson's foreign policy approach "Moral diplomacy"
Dollar diplomacy approach Economic leverage to influence foreign affairs
Wilson's policy emphasis Promoting democracy and moral principles
Dollar diplomacy aim Secure markets and opportunities for American businessmen
Wilson's stance on intervention Only when there is a moral imperative
Dollar diplomacy focus Latin America and East Asia
Wilson's policy intention Reduce the US role in foreign affairs
Dollar diplomacy strategy Replace military intervention with economic leverage
Wilson's belief about American values Superior to the rest of the world
Wilson's policy on American interference Only when circumstances rose to a moral imperative

cycivic

Wilson's focus on 'moral diplomacy'

Woodrow Wilson's foreign policy was based on his messianic philosophical belief that America had the obligation to spread its principles while reflecting the 'truisms' of American thought. This approach was known as 'moral diplomacy'. Wilson's policy emphasised promoting democracy and moral principles rather than economic interests. He believed that the United States had a responsibility to support democratic nations and promote peace, setting him apart from his predecessors, including Taft.

Wilson's moral diplomacy was a shift in foreign policy to be hinged upon moral values rather than imperialist interests. Under this diplomacy, the United States sought to offer support to nations that agreed to uphold democratic values and principles. Wilson's policy involved support of smaller nations who agreed to abide by 'American' values of political democracy and self-determination, and economic and military pressure towards nations who rejected such values. In his view, American interference in another nation's affairs should occur only when the circumstances rose to the level of a moral imperative.

In practice, Wilson found it difficult to keep the United States out of world affairs. For example, in Mexico, Wilson refused to recognise the authoritarian rule of General Victoriano Huerta, who had overthrown the democratically elected president Francisco Madero in 1913. Wilson's stance encouraged anti-Huerta forces in northern Mexico led by Venustiano Carranza. In April 1914, Mexican officials in Tampico arrested a few American sailors who blundered into a prohibited area, and Wilson used the incident to justify ordering the US Navy to occupy the port city of Veracruz. The move greatly weakened Huerta's control, and he abandoned power to Carranza, whom Wilson immediately recognised as the de facto president of Mexico.

Wilson also fought against Japan's demands regarding China at the Paris Peace Conference in 1919, but backed down upon realising the Japanese delegation had widespread support. In 1922, the US brokered a solution to the Shandong Problem, awarding nominal sovereignty over the Shandong Peninsula to China, while in practice, Japan's economic dominance continued.

In his "Fourteen Points" speech delivered to Congress on January 8, 1918, Wilson outlined his vision for a "new diplomacy" consisting of "open covenants openly arrived at". He proposed a general disarmament after the war, with the Germans and Austrians giving up their armed forces first. Wilson wanted to dismantle the imperial order by opening up colonial holdings to eventual self-rule and all European sections of the Ottoman and Austro-Hungarian empires to immediate independence.

cycivic

Wilson's opposition to imperialism

Woodrow Wilson's foreign policy was based on his philosophical belief that America had the obligation to spread its principles while reflecting the 'truisms' of American thought. This approach was known as "moral diplomacy", which was a departure from the Dollar Diplomacy of his predecessor, William Howard Taft. Wilson's policy emphasised promoting democracy and moral principles rather than economic interests. He believed that the United States had a responsibility to support democratic nations and promote peace, and that American interference in another nation's affairs should occur only when the circumstances rose to the level of a moral imperative.

Wilson's policy was a direct opposition to imperialism. He believed that the nation needed to intervene in international affairs only when there was a moral imperative to do so. This was a shift from the previous administration's strictly nationalist foreign policy, which sought to expand the American Empire and advocate for its interests abroad. Wilson's approach was idealistic and based on morality, rather than American self-interest. He advocated for world involvement along liberal-internationalist lines.

Wilson's appointment of William Jennings Bryan as Secretary of State was indicative of this new direction. Bryan had long been a leading opponent of imperialism and militarism and a pioneer in the world peace movement. Bryan encouraged nations around the world to sign "cooling-off treaties", under which they agreed to resolve international disputes through diplomacy and outside fact-finding commissions, rather than war. Wilson himself signed 22 such bilateral treaties.

Wilson's "Fourteen Points" speech delivered to Congress on January 8, 1918, outlined his vision for a "new diplomacy". He called for open covenants, an end to secret treaties, and the dismantling of the imperial order by opening up colonial holdings to eventual self-rule. He also proposed a general disarmament after World War I, with the Germans and Austrians giving up their armed forces first.

In practice, Wilson found it difficult to maintain a less interventionist stance, especially as Europe's political situation grew more desperate in the lead-up to World War I. Despite his efforts, he could only postpone American involvement in the war, not avert it completely. Similarly, while Wilson strove to be less of an interventionist, he found it challenging in reality, as the United States continued to be interventionist in areas where its interests were threatened.

cycivic

Dollar diplomacy's association with President Taft

Dollar diplomacy was a foreign policy initiative of President William Howard Taft. It was designed to use economic power to influence foreign affairs and secure markets and opportunities for American businesses, especially in Latin America and East Asia. The policy aimed to replace military intervention with economic leverage to promote stability and improve diplomatic relations.

Taft's dollar diplomacy was a continuation and expansion of the Roosevelt Corollary to the Monroe Doctrine, which stated that the United States had the right and obligation to intervene in any nation in the Western Hemisphere that was vulnerable to European control. Taft justified this policy in Central America as a means to protect the Panama Canal. He also attempted to establish control over Honduras by buying up its debt to British bankers.

In his message to Congress on December 3, 1912, Taft described his program as "substituting dollars for bullets," appealing to humanitarian sentiments, sound policy, strategy, and commercial aims. However, critics coined the term "dollar diplomacy" to describe what they saw as Taft's self-interested dealings with other countries.

Taft's administration also attempted to implement dollar diplomacy in China, but it was even less successful, both in terms of the ability of the US to supply loans and in terms of world reaction. The failure of dollar diplomacy in China sparked a widespread "Railway Protection Movement" revolt against foreign investment that overthrew the Chinese government.

When Woodrow Wilson became president in 1913, he immediately cancelled all support for dollar diplomacy. Wilson's foreign policy emphasized promoting democracy and moral principles rather than economic interests. He believed that the United States should only intervene in international affairs when there was a moral imperative to do so. Wilson's approach, known as "moral diplomacy," set him apart from his predecessors, including Taft.

cycivic

Wilson's foreign policy in Latin America

Woodrow Wilson's foreign policy in Latin America was characterised by his rejection of Dollar Diplomacy and his commitment to moral diplomacy. Dollar Diplomacy, a strategy of President William Howard Taft, aimed to use economic power to influence foreign affairs and secure markets for American businesses, particularly in Latin America. In contrast, Wilson's approach emphasised morality and democracy, promoting American friendship with Latin American countries. Wilson believed that the United States should not intervene in foreign affairs unless there was a moral imperative to do so.

In his 1913 Address Before the Southern Commercial Congress, Wilson emphasised unity and sympathy with the Latin American peoples, stating that the United States should prove itself as a true friend. He advocated for a departure from the self-interested economic policies of his predecessors, instead prioritising moral principles and democracy. Wilson's policy of moral diplomacy aimed to support smaller nations that embraced democratic values and self-determination while applying economic and military pressure on those that did not.

One notable example of Wilson's foreign policy in Latin America was his stance on Mexico. In 1913, Mexico came under the rule of General Victoriano Huerta, who imposed a bloody authoritarian regime. Wilson refused to recognise Huerta's government, denouncing it as a "government of butchers". He supported anti-Huerta forces led by Venustiano Carranza and applied pressure on the regime by occupying the port city of Veracruz in 1914 after a diplomatic incident involving the arrest of American sailors in Tampico. As a result, Huerta's control weakened, and he eventually abandoned power, leading to Carranza becoming the de facto president of Mexico.

Wilson's approach to Latin America reflected his overall foreign policy goals of promoting democracy, moral principles, and collective security. He sought to reduce American interventionism and replace it with a focus on shared values and ideals. However, he faced challenges in balancing his idealistic vision with the practical realities of international relations.

cycivic

Wilson's stance on military intervention

Woodrow Wilson's foreign policy was based on his philosophical belief that America had an obligation to spread its principles while reflecting the 'truisms' of American thought. Wilson's policy was known as 'moral diplomacy', which emphasised promoting democracy and moral principles rather than economic interests. This set him apart from his predecessors, including Taft, who favoured Dollar Diplomacy. Wilson's stance was that the United States had a responsibility to support democratic nations and promote peace, and that American interference in another nation's affairs should occur only when the circumstances rose to the level of a moral imperative.

Wilson's approach to military intervention was informed by this stance. He believed that the use of military force should be a last resort and that diplomacy should always be the first option. This is evident in his signing of twenty-two bilateral treaties that agreed to cooling-off periods and outside fact-finding commissions as alternatives to war. Wilson also encouraged nations around the world to sign "cooling-off treaties", under which they agreed to resolve international disputes through diplomacy and to submit any grievances to an international commission.

However, Wilson did authorise the use of military force in certain situations. For example, in 1914, he ordered the US Navy to occupy the port city of Veracruz in Mexico, in response to the arrest of American sailors by Mexican officials. Wilson also authorised the use of force against Mexico in 1914, when Mexican forces refused to make amends for the arrest of American sailors. In addition, Wilson's policy of 'moral diplomacy' included the use of economic and military pressure towards nations who rejected American values of political democracy and self-determination.

During World War I, Wilson struggled to maintain American neutrality, as he believed that Germany's war tactics were morally reprehensible and put American free trade at risk. Despite his initial neutrality, Wilson eventually authorised American involvement in the war. At the Paris Peace Conference in 1919, Wilson fought against Japan's demands regarding China but ultimately backed down when he realised the widespread support for the Japanese delegation. Wilson also proposed a general disarmament after the war, with the Germans and Austrians giving up their armed forces first.

Frequently asked questions

Dollar Diplomacy was a foreign policy initiative of President William Howard Taft, which aimed to use American economic power to influence and secure markets and opportunities for American businessmen, particularly in Latin America.

Woodrow Wilson's foreign policy was based on morality and the promotion of democracy. He believed that the United States should only intervene in international affairs when there was a moral imperative to do so. Wilson's policy was known as 'moral diplomacy'.

Wilson's foreign policy was a departure from President Taft's Dollar Diplomacy, which was seen as a form of economic imperialism. Wilson's policy emphasized promoting democracy and moral principles rather than economic interests.

Wilson's 'moral diplomacy' involved supporting smaller nations that agreed to abide by 'American' values of political democracy and self-determination. It also involved economic and military pressure on nations that rejected such values. Wilson's policy sought to extend American friendship to Latin America and reduce the country's interventionist role in foreign affairs.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment