Gift-Giving: Diplomacy And Peace Between Native Nations

Gift-giving has long been a key part of diplomacy, playing a role in creating and maintaining reciprocal bonds between nations. In the context of diplomacy between natives and colonists, gift-giving took on a more complex dynamic, shaped by cultural differences and misunderstandings. For instance, in early Virginia Indian society, gift exchange was fundamental to relationship-building, with failures to reciprocate leading to dissolution of bonds and sometimes even violence. On the other hand, colonists' attempts to establish friendly relations through gift-giving were not always successful, as they often misunderstood the cultural nuances of gift-giving in indigenous societies.

Explore related products

Iroquois Diplomacy on the Early American Frontier (The Penguin Library of American Indian History)

$15.99 $24

Diplomacy and Indian Gifts: Anglo-French Rivalry Along the Ohio and Northwest Frontiers, 1748-1763

$3.99 $29.95

Colonial Georgia and the Creeks: Anglo-Indian Diplomacy on the Southern Frontier, 1733 1763

$53.48

War Paths, Peace Paths: An Archaeology of Cooperation and Conflict in Native Eastern North America (Issues in Eastern Woodlands Archaeology)

$53

Beneath the Backbone of the World: Blackfoot People and the North American Borderlands, 1720–1877 (The David J. Weber Series in the New Borderlands History)

$29.98 $34.95

Invading Guatemala: Spanish, Nahua, and Maya Accounts of the Conquest Wars

$24.95

Gifts as symbols of esteem and welcome

Gifts have long been central to diplomacy and the creation and maintenance of reciprocal bonds between nations. They are often given as symbols of esteem and welcome, and can showcase the unique culture, history, and craftsmanship of the gifting nation.

In the United States, gifts are often exchanged in a ceremonial climate of toasts, banquets, speeches, and formal greetings when Secretaries of State are travelling abroad or receiving visitors. Gifts of state may showcase fine or folk arts, crafts, or local craftsmanship, and they may display wealth in precious stones or metals, fine textiles, and apparel. They may also draw from a rich heritage of antiques and antiquities or an expressive storehouse of cultural icons.

The symbolic value of diplomatic gifts is paramount. They can capture the essence of a nation, allowing the promotion of domestic brands and cultural craftsmanship at the highest levels of government and public relations. Gifts can also convey deep-seated intentions, and their selection is increasingly flexible. For example, gifts may be chosen based on the interests of the recipient or to impress through a lavish gift. Gifts may also be used to showcase the bilateral relationship between the two nations or to praise the culture and values of the receiving nation.

Gift-giving has been a long-standing tradition in diplomacy between nations and indigenous peoples. For example, in the 18th century, British policy towards Native American tribes included the exchange of gifts, such as clocks, guns, animals (especially thoroughbred horses), jewels, and artwork. Similarly, the East India Company's relations with Indian princes involved gift-giving, although this failed to persuade the Chinese emperor to open his markets in 1793. In another instance, British and French colonists gave medals to Indian tribal chiefs during the colonial period in North America, which continued as a ritual between the Americans and Indian tribes until the end of the American Civil War.

Gifts to showcase local culture and craftsmanship

Gifts have long been central to diplomacy, playing a recognised role in creating and maintaining reciprocal bonds between nations. Gifts can showcase the unique culture and people of the gifting country, emphasising local craftsmanship, historical craftsmanship, local businesses, local luxuries, materials, and domestic brands.

In the United States, diplomatic gifts embody symbols of esteem and welcome for Secretaries of State when travelling abroad or receiving visitors. Gifts of state may showcase traditions of fine or folk arts, crafts or local craftsmanship. They may also display wealth in precious stones or metals, fine textiles and apparel. Gifts may draw from a rich heritage of antiques and antiquities or an expressive storehouse of cultural icons.

In the 18th century, clocks, guns, animals (especially thoroughbred horses), jewels and artworks (especially portraits) were sent abroad to smooth negotiations and commerce with foreign powers. Gifts were also an intrinsic part of British policy towards Native American tribes and of the East India Company's relations with Indian princes.

Gift-giving was also a key part of diplomacy in early Virginia Indian society, where exchanges served to enhance friendship and convey deep-seated intentions. However, ignorance and misunderstanding of the Indian gift-exchange system sometimes led to violence. For example, in 1561, a Virginia Indian named Paquiquineo was baptised and given the name Don Luís de Velasco. Don Luís ultimately left the missionaries and returned to a village in the interior. Months later, he returned and killed the Jesuits with their own hatchets.

In modern times, gifts continue to play a role in diplomacy, with the practice representing peaceful diplomatic relations. For example, in 1972, China gifted two pandas to the United States after President Nixon's visit.

Gifts to strengthen relationships and alliances

Gift-giving has long been a central part of diplomacy, playing a recognised role in creating and maintaining reciprocal bonds between individuals, groups, and nations. Gifts to strengthen relationships and alliances have been a key feature of diplomacy since ancient times, with the earliest recorded instance of diplomatic gift-giving being the exchange of engraved stone vessels between Egypt and its Hittite neighbours.

In the context of diplomacy between natives and colonists in early Virginia Indian Society, gift-giving was of paramount importance. The exchange of gifts served as a means to establish and solidify relationships, with kinship being at the core of the exchange process. Native communities often determined trading partners based on family relationships, and traders frequently married Native women to establish themselves as kin and gain access to their kin networks for trade. Gifts were used to foster goodwill and friendly relations, with the expectation of reciprocity. Failure to reciprocate could lead to the dissolution of bonds and even violent reactions.

Similarly, in North America during the colonial period, British and French colonists gave medals to Indian tribal chiefs as diplomatic gifts. This tradition lasted until the end of the American Civil War and symbolised loyalty and recognition. In the 18th century, clocks, guns, animals (especially thoroughbred horses), jewels, and artworks were commonly sent abroad by the British to smoothen negotiations and commerce with foreign powers, including native American tribes.

Diplomatic gifts are often chosen to showcase the culture, craftsmanship, and unique characteristics of the gifting country, promoting peaceful diplomatic relations and strengthening alliances. Gifts can also convey personal messages, such as Secretary Condoleezza Rice's gift of small porcelain boxes with a portrait of Sojourner Truth, honouring the 19th-century African-American female abolitionist and suffragette.

While gift-giving can strengthen relationships and alliances, it is not without its complexities. Gifts can create anxieties and doubts about the motives and expectations of the giver, as well as the obligations of the receiver. High-value gifts, for example, may be perceived as monetary transactions or bribes rather than symbolic gestures. Nevertheless, the tradition of gift-giving in diplomacy persists due to its ability to capture the essence of a nation and promote peaceful relations between countries.

Explore related products

Japan 1941: Countdown to Infamy

$13.29 $19

Don't Give Up the Ship!: Myths of the War of 1812

$14.95 $25.95

Journal of the American Revolution 2016: Annual Volume (Journal of the American Revolution Books)

$39.71

Kearny's Dragoons Out West: The Birth of the U.S. Cavalry

$32.65 $39.95

The Duel: Pakistan on the Flight Path of American Power

$15.99

Uprising in Pakistan: How to Bring Down a Dictatorship

$19.95

Gifts to display wealth and power

Gift-giving has long been a central aspect of diplomacy, playing a recognised role in creating and maintaining reciprocal bonds between nations. In the context of native cultures, gift-giving practices can serve as a means to display wealth and power, with the exchange of valuable items signifying the strength and prominence of the giver.

One notable example of gift-giving traditions among natives is the potlatch, a term derived from the Chinook Jargon, meaning "to give away" or "a gift". The potlatch ceremony was practised by various tribal societies, including the Kwakwaka'wakw, and involved the competitive exchange of gifts, where hosts challenged guests to exceed them in their ability to give away or destroy goods. This dynamic served to reinforce hierarchical relations within and between clans, villages, and nations, with status determined not solely by material wealth but by the distribution of resources.

The Ojibwe people, engaged in the fur trade, also exemplified the significance of gift-giving in displaying wealth and power. The Ojibwe held a strong belief in reciprocity, giving back to the natural world through gifts and ceremonies. This culture of generosity fostered social bonds and turned strangers into allies. Traders who adopted the Ojibwe practice of gift-giving further solidified their relationships with the Ojibwe, integrating themselves into their kin networks through marriage alliances.

In the context of early Virginia Indian Society, gift-exchange economies were commonplace, with participants valuing relationships over material possessions. The Algonquian-speaking Virginia Indians during the Late Woodland Period (AD 900-1650) practised a gift-exchange system where the failure to give, accept, and reciprocate could lead to punishments. This stood in contrast to the commodity-exchange system familiar to Europeans, leading to misunderstandings and tensions.

Gift-giving as a means to display wealth and power extends beyond native cultures and remains prevalent in modern international relations. Diplomatic gifts exchanged between nations often embody symbols of esteem and welcome, showcasing a country's unique culture, craftsmanship, and wealth. These gifts, while fostering peaceful relations, can also evoke questions about the impact of symbolism and the complex dynamics of diplomatic interactions.

Gifts to convey hidden intentions

Gifts have long been used as a tool in diplomacy, and their role in international relations is often underpinned by symbolic value. Gifts can be used to showcase the culture, craftsmanship, and wealth of a nation, as well as to convey hidden intentions.

In the context of gift-giving between natives and colonists, the act of giving and receiving gifts served multiple purposes. For example, in the case of early Virginia Indian Society, gift-giving was integral to relationship-building. The exchange of gifts helped establish and maintain reciprocal bonds, with kinship being at the center of the exchange process. This is evident in the practice of traders marrying Native women, which created a kin network of customers. However, gift-giving could also lead to misunderstandings and violence if not properly understood or reciprocated.

Diplomatic gifts can convey hidden intentions or serve as a subtle means to achieve certain ends. For instance, gifts can be used to cultivate beneficial diplomatic relationships, showcase national strength, or even as a form of bribery. The selection of gifts is carefully chosen to convey specific messages or achieve certain diplomatic goals. Gifts may emphasize local craftsmanship, historical artefacts, or local luxuries and materials. They can also be personalized, such as when Secretary Condoleezza Rice gave small porcelain boxes with a portrait of Sojourner Truth, an African-American abolitionist and suffragette.

Furthermore, gifts can be used to convey a sense of hierarchy and power dynamics between nations. In ancient times, gifts were often given in the name of Nagong by the conquered to reflect their submission to the conquering nation. This hierarchical aspect of gift-giving has evolved with modern diplomacy's pursuit of equality, where gifts are exchanged to maintain friendly relations.

While the symbolic nature of diplomatic gifts can enhance friendship between nations, it can also lead to complexities and ethical dilemmas. Gifts of high value may be perceived as bribes, and the exchange of gifts can create doubts about the motives and expectations of the giver, as well as the obligations of the receiver. Thus, gifts can have hidden intentions that may not always be positive and can sometimes lead to unintended consequences.

Frequently asked questions