Understanding California's Nonviolent Crime Classification

In California, violent crimes are defined as those that cause harm to another person, and they are treated with the utmost seriousness within the legal system. However, there is no clear definition of what constitutes a non-violent crime in California law. This has led to some crimes, such as domestic violence and certain sex crimes, being legally considered non-violent, which has allowed some offenders to be released early. Non-violent crimes in California include white-collar crimes, drug possession, theft, and DUI, and they are typically penalized with imprisonment and heavy fines.

Explore related products

Criminalization of Activism: Historical, Present and Future Perspectives (Routledge Studies in Crime and Society)

$48.63 $63.99

Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Life: Life-Changing Tools for Healthy Relationships (Nonviolent Communication Guides)

$11.41 $21.99

Starvation Heights: A True Story of Murder and Malice in the Woods of the Pacific Northwest

$6.99 $20

Toward a New Common School Movement (Critical Interventions)

$59.99 $59.99

Pontius Pilate: A Novel

$14.52 $16.99

Rethinking the American Prison Movement (American Social and Political Movements of the 20th Century)

$52.99 $52.99

Nonviolent crimes in California are broadly defined as any crime that does not cause harm to another person

Violent crimes in California include murder, voluntary manslaughter, mayhem, rape, sodomy, oral copulation, lewd or lascivious acts, felony punishable by death or life imprisonment, felony with great bodily injury inflicted, robbery, arson, sexual penetration, attempted murder, violations involving bombs, kidnapping, assault with intent to commit a felony, continuous sexual abuse of a child, carjacking, spousal rape, sexual penetration in concert, extortion, threats to victims or witnesses, burglary, and assault.

Notably, California's legal system treats some violent crimes as nonviolent, which has led to criticism and efforts to expand the list of violent crimes. For example, domestic violence and some rape crimes are considered nonviolent offenses, which can lead to early releases for convicted abusers and limit prosecutors' ability to pursue stiffer sentences for repeat offenders.

Nonviolent crimes in California can range from misdemeanors to felonies. Examples of nonviolent felonies include white-collar crimes such as money laundering, fraud, and counterfeiting, as well as burglary, theft above $950, some drug offenses, prostitution, DUI, and criminal property damage. While nonviolent felonies may not carry the same severe penalties as violent felonies, they can still result in substantial fines and jail time, with more serious offenses leading to longer prison terms or higher fines.

Proposition 57, passed by California voters in 2016, addresses nonviolent offenses by increasing parole and good behavior opportunities for convicted nonviolent felons and allowing judges to determine if a juvenile should be tried as an adult. Additionally, Proposition 47 provides for reduced jail time or reclassification of nonviolent crimes from felonies to misdemeanors.

Proposition 57 permits parole consideration for people with nonviolent convictions

In California, a violent crime is defined as any crime that causes harm to another person. Murder, rape, burglary, carjacking, arson, and kidnapping are all considered violent crimes. A non-violent crime, therefore, does not cause harm to another person. Some examples of non-violent crimes that are felonies in California include white-collar crimes like money laundering, fraud, and counterfeiting. Certain theft and drug possession crimes are also considered non-violent and have been reclassified as misdemeanors.

Despite its name, California considers domestic violence a 'nonviolent' offense, which means convicted abusers can seek expedited release from prison. Similarly, sex offenders are entitled to early release because their crimes are not on the violent crime list.

Proposition 57, or "The Public Safety and Rehabilitation Act of 2016," was passed by a majority of California voters on November 8, 2016. It permits parole consideration for people with nonviolent convictions. The proposition does not create a right for nonviolent offenders to be released from prison, but it gives the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) and the Board of Parole Hearings the authority to review eligible offenders and approve their release if they no longer pose a threat. This process applies to determinately-sentenced nonviolent offenders who have served the full term of their primary offense in state prison.

Proposition 57 also gives the CDCR the authority to award additional good conduct and program credits to prisoners in approved rehabilitative and educational programs. It eliminates the presumption that juveniles aged 14 to 17 who commit serious crimes will be prosecuted in adult court, giving judges the power to decide when juvenile cases will be transferred. Additionally, it provides state corrections officials with new authority to award sentencing credits to reduce prison sentences.

While Proposition 57 offers early parole consideration for certain nonviolent offenders, it is important to note that the term "nonviolent offenses" has yet to be firmly defined in the context of this proposition. Criminal defense attorneys generally consider "nonviolent offenses" as any crime not defined as violent under Penal Code § 667.5(c). This includes offenses such as murder, rape, arson, kidnapping, and more.

Nonviolent crimes may be misdemeanours or felonies

In California, non-violent crimes are those that do not cause harm to another person. While they are typically considered less serious than violent crimes, non-violent crimes may be misdemeanours or felonies and carry harsh penalties, including imprisonment and heavy fines. These penalties can have life-changing consequences, threatening an individual's reputation, career, relationships and future.

California's Three Strikes and You're Out law imposes increased penalties for repeat violent felony offences. However, non-violent crimes may not be classified as strikes, but they can still result in significant punishment. A conviction for a non-violent felony can lead to a prison sentence and negatively impact various areas of an offender's life.

Proposition 57, passed by California voters in 2016, addresses non-violent offences by increasing parole and good behaviour opportunities for convicted non-violent felons. It also allows judges to determine if a juvenile should be tried as an adult. While Proposition 57 provides benefits for non-violent offenders, the absence of a clear definition of "nonviolent offences" has led to legal complexities. As of 2021, there was no firm definition of "non-violent offences" under Proposition 57, creating ambiguity in its implementation.

In California, certain crimes that may be perceived as violent are legally considered non-violent. For example, domestic violence and some rape crimes are classified as non-violent offences, allowing convicted abusers to seek early release from prison and limiting steeper sentences for repeat offenders. Efforts to reclassify these crimes as violent have faced challenges, with the state's commitment to criminal justice reform taking precedence.

Non-violent felonies in California include white-collar crimes such as money laundering, fraud, and counterfeiting. Additionally, burglary, theft above a certain monetary value, some drug offences, prostitution, DUI, and criminal property damage are charged as non-violent felonies. While these offences typically carry less severe penalties than violent felonies, they can still result in substantial fines and jail time, with more serious felonies leading to longer prison terms or higher fines.

Explore related products

Dangerous Testimony (Pacific Coast Private Eyes)

$4.99

Drugs, Women, and Justice: Roles of the Criminal Justice System for Drug-Affected Women

$23.19 $28.99

Massacred for Gold: The Chinese in Hells Canyon

$19.85 $19.95

All God's Children: Inside the Dark and Violent World of Street Families

$14.99

Curtailing Corruption: People Power for Accountability and Justice

$15.1 $25

Detecting Malingering and Deception (Pacific Institute Series on Forensic Psychology)

$63.99 $79.99

Nonviolent felonies include white-collar crimes, some theft, and drug possession

In California, nonviolent crimes are those that do not cause harm to another person. While nonviolent felonies are generally punished less severely than violent felonies, they can still carry substantial fines and some jail time. The more serious the felony, the greater the chance of a longer prison term or higher fine if convicted.

Theft is another example of a nonviolent felony. In California, theft of over $950 is considered a felony. This includes theft of goods, as well as theft through embezzlement or forgery. Drug possession is also considered a nonviolent felony in California. Drug-related crimes are the second most common type of nonviolent crime after property crimes. Drug possession can lead to charges of drug manufacturing or distribution, which are felonies.

While these crimes are considered nonviolent, they can still have serious consequences. In addition to fines and jail time, those convicted of nonviolent felonies may face loss of rights and other long-term consequences, such as difficulty renting housing. It is important to consult with an attorney for any felony charge, even if it is nonviolent, as defenses and punishments can vary by case and jurisdiction.

California controversially considers domestic violence a nonviolent crime

The state's definition of "domestic violence" is outlined in the California Penal Code and includes any form of abuse committed against an "intimate partner." This encompasses a broad range of relationships, including spouses and former spouses, domestic partners, co-parents, current and former live-in partners, dating partners, and more. The abuse can take various forms, including physical violence, elder abuse, child abuse, emotional abuse, and threatening to commit violent crimes.

The classification of domestic violence as nonviolent in California has sparked controversy and criticism. Many argue that this classification minimises the seriousness of domestic violence and fails to recognise the devastating impact it can have on victims and their families. Critics advocate for reclassifying domestic violence as a violent crime, which would enable prosecutors to seek stricter penalties and better reflect the severity of the offense.

While California has faced pressure to reevaluate its classification of domestic violence, the state has been resistant to change. Efforts to expand the list of violent crimes to include domestic violence have been met with opposition from dominant Democrats in the Legislature, who prioritise "criminal justice reform." Despite the public outcry and calls for change, the state's lawmakers have yet to take steps to address this controversial issue.

The impact of California's classification of domestic violence as a nonviolent crime extends beyond the legal realm. It can influence public perception and awareness of the issue, potentially leading to a misunderstanding of the severity and complexity of domestic violence. This classification can also have practical implications for victims, affecting their access to support services, legal protections, and the justice they deserve.

Frequently asked questions