Implied Powers: Understanding Tax Levies And Collections

The ability to lay and collect taxes is a crucial power of any government, as it enables the funding of government services and programs. The US Constitution grants Congress the power to lay and collect taxes, as outlined in Article I, Section 8, also known as the Taxing Clause. This clause provides Congress with broad authority to impose and collect taxes for federal debts, common defence, and the general welfare of the United States. The establishment of the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is an example of an implied power related to the ability to lay and collect taxes. The Sixteenth Amendment, ratified in 1913, solidified the power to establish a national income tax, demonstrating the flexibility of implied powers in effective governance.

Explore related products

Christian Perspectives on the Role of the State, Justice, and Taxation

$223.93 $279

Taxation, Citizenship and Democracy in the 21st Century

$152.19

State & Local Taxation Volume Two, 9th ed. (2019)

$125

The Supreme Court, Federal and State Taxation, and the Constitution, Second Edition

$149.24

State and Local Taxation Volume One, 9th ed. 2019

$125

Criminal Procedure: Constitutional Constraints Upon Investigation and Proof

$213.6 $225

The power to tax income

Prior to the Sixteenth Amendment, the national government faced significant challenges due to its limited power to raise revenue. Under the Articles of Confederation, the government could only request that states contribute to the national treasury. However, states often failed to comply with these requests, resulting in severe underfunding that threatened national security and the government's ability to function effectively.

The Sixteenth Amendment addressed this issue by granting Congress the explicit authority to impose income taxes. This power is derived from Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution, which states that "Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States."

The establishment of the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) further solidified the power to tax income. The IRS was created to collect income taxes based on the authority granted by the Sixteenth Amendment. This demonstrates how implied powers enable Congress to implement policies necessary for effective governance and adapt to practical needs, such as tax collection.

The power to establish a national income tax

Prior to the Sixteenth Amendment, the national government faced challenges in raising funds due to its inability to tax individuals directly. Under the Articles of Confederation, the government could only request states to contribute tax revenue to the national treasury, often resulting in insufficient funding. The Sixteenth Amendment rectified this issue by granting Congress the explicit authority to impose income taxes.

The establishment of the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) further solidified the power to collect national income taxes. The IRS was created to collect income taxes based on the power granted by the Sixteenth Amendment. This demonstrates how implied powers enable Congress to implement policies necessary for effective governance, adapting to practical needs beyond the specific powers outlined in the Constitution.

The power to tax income is essential for the financial operations of the federal government. Income tax plays a significant role in funding government services and programs, providing the resources needed for policing, national defence, and regulating commerce. Without the power to tax, a government's ability to function is severely limited.

The Sixteenth Amendment's impact extended beyond economics, also carrying significant social implications. It represented a shift towards a more centralized institution, with the federal government sourcing substantial funding through individual incomes. This amendment also reflected the Progressive Era's focus on social and political reform, including the goal of a fairer tax system where the burden was shifted from the middle class and the poor to the wealthy.

The power to collect taxes

The inclusion of this clause in the Constitution was a deliberate decision by the Framers, who recognised the need for a centralised taxing authority. Prior to the adoption of the Constitution, under the Articles of Confederation, the national government lacked the power to tax individuals directly and relied on requesting financial contributions from the states, which often fell short of what was needed. This resulted in a severely underfunded national government, highlighting the importance of establishing a robust taxing power in the new Constitution.

While the power to collect taxes is broad, it is not without limitations. Judicial decisions have played a role in shaping the scope of Congress's taxing power, with court cases establishing precedents and constraints on how taxes are imposed, the objects for which they are levied, and the subject matter of taxation. Additionally, certain exceptions are outlined within the Constitution itself, such as the prohibition on taxing articles exported from any state.

In conclusion, the power to collect taxes is a vital component of governance, providing the financial resources necessary for a government to function effectively. The United States Constitution grants this power to Congress, enabling them to raise revenue for the nation's debts, defence, and welfare. The establishment of the IRS further exemplifies the practical application of implied powers in tax collection, ensuring the efficient gathering of income taxes. However, it is important to recognise that this power is balanced by judicial interpretations and constitutional exceptions to prevent its unchecked exercise.

Explore related products

What <em> IS </em> in a Name?: Taxation and Regulation across Constitutional Domains

$30 $38

The Supreme Court on the Incidence and Effects of Taxation: An Analysis of Economic Theory Embedded in the Constitutional Law Derived from the Explicit Tax Clauses.

$26.74

Tax Law, Religion, and Justice (Law and Religion)

$190 $55.99

Racial Capitalism and International Tax Law: The Story of Global Jim Crow

$125 $125

DC Vote: Fighting Against Taxation Without Representation

$10.95

Liberal Suppression: Section 501(c)(3) and the Taxation of Speech

$37.99 $58.99

The power to impose taxes on individuals and corporations

The ability to tax is a significant departure from the Articles of Confederation, which merely allowed Congress to request financial contributions from the states. This often resulted in insufficient funding for the national government, threatening national security and its ability to govern effectively. The adoption of the U.S. Constitution, therefore, granted Congress the much-needed authority to directly tax individuals and corporations.

The establishment of the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is a notable example of how Congress has utilised its implied powers to create an agency dedicated to tax collection, including income taxes. The IRS plays a crucial role in ensuring the efficient and effective collection of taxes, further supporting the government's financial operations.

In conclusion, the power to impose taxes on individuals and corporations is a vital tool for any government, providing the necessary financial resources to govern effectively, protect national security, and deliver essential services to its citizens.

The power to regulate tax-exempt status

In the United States, the federal government and many state tax systems offer exemptions or allowances for individuals and organisations. For example, charitable organisations are often exempt from property taxes and income taxes, and veterans may also receive tax exemptions. Religious organisations, fraternal organisations, and public charities serving homeless persons are also commonly granted tax-exempt status.

To qualify for tax exemption in the US, organisations must be created and operated for tax-exempt purposes, which include more than 28 types of organisations. Most organisations must apply for tax-exempt status with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) or be a religious or apostolic organisation. The specific requirements for exemption vary depending on the type of organisation and the relevant Internal Revenue Code (IRC) section.

The process of applying for tax-exempt status typically involves several steps and the completion of specific forms, such as Form 1023 or Form 1024, which must be submitted electronically to the IRS. The ability to regulate tax-exempt status allows the government to provide relief to individuals and organisations while also ensuring that taxes are collected effectively to fund government services and programmes.

Frequently asked questions