Mexico's Government: Monarchy Or Republic?

Mexico is currently a federal republic composed of 31 states and a Federal District. However, Mexico has had a tumultuous political history, with several shifts in power between various factions. The country's first constitution was drafted after Mexico gained independence from Spain in 1821, establishing a short-lived constitutional monarchy under Emperor Agustín de Iturbide, also known as Agustin I. This was the first independent government of Mexico and the only former Spanish colony to establish a monarchy after independence. The Mexican monarchy was plagued by conflicts between the emperor and congress, leading to Iturbide's abdication and the abolition of the monarchy in 1823. Since then, Mexico has had a complex political journey, with a new constitution enacted in 1857 and further amendments made in the 20th century.

Explore related products

Government Palace, Monterrey, Mexico Monterrey, Original Postcard

$8.99

The Revolutionary Imaginations of Greater Mexico: Chicana/o Radicalism, Solidarity Politics, and Latin American Social Movements

$29.06 $29.95

Roots of Brazil (ND Kellogg Inst Int'l Studies) (Kellogg Institute Series on Democracy and Development)

$25.42 $28

Rome, the Greek World, and the East: Volume 2: Government, Society, and Culture in the Roman Empire (Studies in the History of Greece and Rome)

$29.99 $55

American Ultra

$3.79

The Royalist Revolution: Monarchy and the American Founding

$26 $26

Mexico's first constitution was drafted after the short-lived monarchy of Agustin I

Mexico is currently a federal republic composed of 31 states and the Federal District. However, it has not always been this way. Mexico's first emperor, Agustín I, was crowned on July 21, 1822, at the Mexico City Cathedral. He was born into an aristocratic landowning family of Basque noble origin and was a military commander in the Mexican War of Independence.

Agustín I's reign lasted from 1822 to 1823, and during this time, he struggled with the legislature, ultimately shutting down Congress and replacing it with loyalists. This alienated his supporters and the military, who turned against him. He was unable to bring order to the nation's finances, and in April 1823, he reassembled Congress and offered his abdication, leading to his exile.

Following Agustín I's short-lived monarchy, Mexico continued to experience political controversies and instability. The Constitution of Apatzingán, which was printed and distributed after Mexico won its independence from Spain, was never implemented due to the defeat of Morelos in 1815. The Plan of Iguala, or the Plan of the Three Guarantees, was a proclamation made in the final stage of the Mexican War of Independence in 1821, leading to independence under a commonwealth system with constitutional monarchy maintaining ties to Spain. However, Spain refused to provide a monarch, and Iturbide himself assumed the throne.

The First Mexican Republic was established, and the first presidential elections were held the same week that the constitution was promulgated. However, this period was marked by fierce political controversies, and every administration during the First Republic, except for the inaugural office holder, was overthrown by a military coup d'état. The Constitution of 1824 was repealed in 1835, and the Federal Republic became a unitary state, the Centralist Republic.

In the following decades, there were continued debates and attempts to establish a monarchy in Mexico, with some advocating for a foreign prince to assume the throne. In 1857, a new Constitution was enacted, and the liberal government of Benito Juárez came into power. However, their suspension of debt payments led to foreign intervention and the establishment of a monarchy with Archduke Maximilian of Austria as emperor in 1861. This regime was tainted by a lack of legitimacy from the start due to its imposition by foreign forces.

Mexico's history with monarchy has been complex, and while it is no longer a monarchy, the legacy of these periods has influenced the country's political and constitutional development.

The first Mexican Empire was a constitutional monarchy

Mexico is currently a federal republic composed of 31 states and the Federal District. However, the country's form of government has not always been this way. The First Mexican Empire, the first independent government of Mexico, was a constitutional monarchy.

The First Mexican Empire was established following Mexico's War of Independence from Spain, which began in 1810. During this conflict, insurgents fought for independence from Spain, while royalists aimed to maintain the existing colonial order. Mexico gained its independence in September 1821 under the leadership of Agustín de Iturbide, a Mexican military commander and former member of the Spanish army.

Following independence, the Mexican Congress established a regency council, headed by Iturbide. On May 18, 1822, Iturbide was elected as Mexico's first emperor, with mass demonstrations in his favour preceding the decision. The First Mexican Empire was intended to be an independent constitutional monarchy governed by a Spanish prince, with all Mexicans and Spanish citizens in the country enjoying equal rights. The Roman Catholic Church was also to retain its privileges and position as the official and exclusive religion of the land.

However, the First Mexican Empire was short-lived and plagued by questions of legality, conflicts between congress and the emperor, and financial issues. Iturbide's struggles with congress revealed his desire to dominate the legislature, which contradicted the ideal of a constitutional monarchy. He shut down congress in October 1822, but by December, he had begun to lose the support of the army, which revolted in favour of restoring congress. Iturbide ultimately reassembled congress in March 1823 and offered his abdication, leading to the abolition of the monarchy.

Mexico is a federal republic composed of 31 states

Mexico is a federal republic, which means that it is a union of member states that are partially governed by a central government and partially by their own state governments. Mexico is composed of 31 states and the Federal District, Mexico City. Each state has its own congress and constitution, and the federal constitution guarantees personal freedoms and civil liberties, as well as establishing economic and political principles for the country.

The history of Mexico's federal system is long and complex. The country gained independence from Spain in 1821 under the Plan of Iguala, also known as the Plan of the Three Guarantees, which was a conservative reaction against the outbreak of the Trienio Liberal in Spain. This plan outlined a commonwealth system with a constitutional monarchy maintaining ties to Spain. Commissioners were sent to Spain to offer the throne to a Spanish prince, but the offer was refused. This led to a popular demonstration in favour of crowning Agustín de Iturbide, who became Mexico's first emperor in 1822. However, Iturbide struggled to work with the legislature and wanted to dominate it, going so far as to shut down congress and replace it with a smaller body of loyal deputies. This led to the military turning against Iturbide, and he was exiled from the nation in 1823.

Following Iturbide's exile, there was controversy over whether the new republic would be a federal or a unitary system. The Founding Plan of the Federal Republic was enacted in 1823, and the Federal Constitution of the United Mexican States was created in 1824, officially forming the United Mexican States, which was composed of 19 states and 4 federal territories. However, the country continued to experience financial and political instability, and every administration during the First Republic (except the inaugural office holder) was overthrown by a military coup d'état. The First Republic collapsed in the 1830s, and the Federal Republic became a unitary state.

In 1857, a new Constitution was enacted, and the liberal government of Benito Juárez was established. However, the suspension of payments to bondholders gave European powers, particularly France, a pretext to intervene militarily. Mexican conservatives invited Archduke Maximilian of Austria to become emperor, and he established a regime with the support of French and Mexican Imperial forces.

In the late 20th century, Mexico was under one-party rule, and the president had strong control over the entire system. However, since then, the Congress has gained a larger share of power. The federal constitution gives several powers to the 31 states and the Federal District, including the ability to raise local taxes. Each state has a unicameral legislature called the Chamber of Deputies, and governors are popularly elected to six-year terms and cannot be reelected.

Explore related products

The Role of Monarchy in Modern Democracy: European Monarchies Compared (Hart Studies in Comparative Public Law)

$42.39 $44.95

Coronation: A History of the British Monarchy

$15.9 $34.99

The Monarchy and the Constitution

$78 $78

Absolute Monarchy and the Stuart Constitution

$31

Constitutional Monarchy of the Twenty-First Century

$125.45 $159

Founding Partisans: Hamilton, Madison, Jefferson, Adams and the Brawling Birth of American Politics

$15.3 $32.5

The idea of monarchy gained Mexican support after the War of the Reform

Mexico is a federal republic composed of 31 states and the Federal District of Mexico City. The country gained its independence in 1821, and briefly became a monarchy under Emperor Agustín de Iturbide. However, Iturbide's reign lasted just over a year, and he was forced to abdicate and go into exile in 1823. Following this, Mexico established a federated republic in 1824.

The idea of monarchy persisted, and in 1845, the Spanish Prime Minister, Ramón María Narváez, gave instructions to the Spanish minister to Mexico, Salvador Bermúdez de Castro, to turn Mexico into a constitutional monarchy under a prince of the Spanish royal family. This idea attracted support from Mexican General Mariano Paredes, politician Lucas Alamán, wealthy businessmen, landowners, high clergy, people persecuted by the Liberal Party, and the northern Mexican states.

The idea of monarchy gained further Mexican support after the War of the Reform (1858-1860), which was sparked by the promulgation of the liberal Constitution of 1857. The victorious liberal government of Benito Juárez suspended payment to bondholders, which provided a pretext for European powers to intervene militarily for debt collection. Mexican conservatives, seeking to distance themselves from an increasingly liberal Spain, invited Archduke Maximilian of Austria to become emperor, with the military and financial backing of French Emperor Napoleon III.

In 1861, French forces invaded central Mexico and established a new monarchy with Maximilian as emperor. This regime lacked legitimacy from the start due to its foreign imposition and the fact that Juárez never left the national territory, remaining the legitimate head of state in the eyes of the United States. Despite some initial support, Maximilian's government was plagued by ongoing warfare against supporters of the Mexican republic, and it ultimately fell when Napoleon III withdrew his aid.

The Mexican monarchy was plagued by questions about its legality

Mexico is currently a federal republic composed of 31 states and the Federal District of Mexico City. However, this was not always the case. In the 19th century, there were two attempts to establish a monarchy in Mexico, both of which were plagued by questions about their legality.

The First Mexican Empire was established in 1821 when Mexico gained independence from Spain. The new nation was faced with the question of what form of government to adopt. Monarchism was the default position of the era, but there was also a strong republican sentiment. In the absence of a suitable candidate from a European royal house, Agustín de Iturbide, a criollo royalist general, was elected as emperor in 1822. However, Iturbide's reign was short-lived as he soon alienated his supporters by attempting to dominate the legislature, shutting down congress, and replacing it with a body of loyal deputies. The military turned against him, and he was forced to abdicate in 1823, going into exile shortly thereafter.

The Second Mexican Empire was established in 1861 with the support of French forces under Napoleon III and Mexican conservatives, who invited Archduke Maximilian of Austria to become emperor. However, the regime's legitimacy was tainted from the start due to the foreign intervention in its establishment. Furthermore, Mexican conservatives expected the monarch to adhere to conservative principles, but Maximilian was politically liberal and ratified many of the reforms of the previous liberal republican government. With the end of the American Civil War, the United States was able to provide material support to the republican forces of Juárez, leading to the collapse of the empire in 1867 and the execution of Maximilian.

Both attempts to establish a monarchy in Mexico were ultimately unsuccessful, and the country returned to a republican form of government. The experience of monarchy discredited the idea of monarchism in Mexico, and the country has since established itself as a federal republic with a constitution that guarantees personal freedoms and civil liberties.

Frequently asked questions