Constitutional Monarchy: A Democratic Contradiction Or Stable System?

A constitutional monarchy is a system of government in which a monarch acts as head of state, but the power to make laws lies with a separate elected parliament. The monarch may be the de facto head of state or a purely ceremonial leader. While the monarch may be recognised as the symbolic head of state, the government is technically led by a prime minister. Constitutional monarchies are the opposite of absolute monarchies, in which the monarch wields total power over the government and the people.

Explore related products

The Royalist Revolution: Monarchy and the American Founding

$26 $26

The Role of Monarchy in Modern Democracy: European Monarchies Compared (Hart Studies in Comparative Public Law)

$42.39 $44.95

Coronation: A History of the British Monarchy

$15.9 $34.99

Constitutional Monarchy of the Twenty-First Century

$125.45 $159

The Monarchy and the Constitution

$78 $78

The Canadian Kingdom: 150 Years of Constitutional Monarchy

$12.99 $25

The monarch's role

A constitutional monarchy is a system of government in which a monarch acts as head of state, but the legislature and judiciary hold the power to govern. The monarch may be the de facto head of state or a purely ceremonial leader. The monarch's role in a constitutional monarchy is often described as "reigning but not ruling". This means that while the monarch may hold formal authority and the government may operate in their name, they do not personally set public policy or choose political leaders. Instead, they serve as a symbol of national unity, pride, and tradition.

The powers of a constitutional monarch are generally limited and outlined in a written or unwritten constitution, which the monarch must follow rather than their personal political preferences. The monarch's role can vary depending on the country's specific constitutional framework. In some countries, like Liechtenstein, Monaco, and Morocco, the constitution grants substantial discretionary powers to the sovereign. In other countries, like the United Kingdom and other Commonwealth realms, the monarch's powers are significantly more limited, and they may only exercise certain reserved powers.

In most constitutional monarchies, the monarch's duties are largely ceremonial. They may include dissolving parliament or giving royal assent to legislation, but these powers are typically exercised only in accordance with constitutional principles rather than the sovereign's preferences. The British political scientist Walter Bagehot identified three main political rights of a constitutional monarch: the right to be consulted, the right to encourage, and the right to warn.

Some constitutional monarchies, like Malaysia and Cambodia, are elective monarchies, where the ruler is periodically selected by a small electoral college. In contrast, other constitutional monarchies are hereditary, with the monarchy passing power down through their lineage.

Separation of powers

A constitutional monarchy is a system of government in which a monarch shares power with a constitutionally organized government. The monarch may be the de facto head of state or a ceremonial leader. In a constitutional monarchy, the constitution allocates the government's powers to the legislature and judiciary, and the monarch exercises their authority in accordance with a constitution and is not alone in making decisions.

In terms of the separation of powers, a constitutional monarchy differs from an absolute monarchy, in which a monarch holds absolute power and is the only decision-maker. In a constitutional monarchy, the monarch's powers and authorities are limited and exercised within a legal framework. The constitution may grant the monarch substantial discretionary powers, or they may retain less personal discretion in the exercise of their authority, depending on the country.

The present-day concept of a constitutional monarchy developed in the United Kingdom, where democratically elected parliaments and their leader, the prime minister, exercise power, with the monarch as a titular position. The monarch may hold formal powers, such as dissolving parliament or giving royal assent to legislation, but these powers are generally exercised in accordance with constitutional principles rather than personal political preferences.

In the transition to democracy, some autocracies transformed into republics, while others evolved into constitutional monarchies, where power is shared between the monarch and a liberal challenger to royal authority. This power-sharing arrangement can be seen as a form of separation of powers, where the monarch and the liberal challenger coexist and govern over successive periods, each conferring benefits such as office rents and the right to pursue one's preferred policy.

History

The oldest constitutional monarchy, dating back to ancient times, was that of the Hittites. The Hittites were an ancient Anatolian people who lived during the Bronze Age, and whose king shared authority with an assembly called the Panku, which was the equivalent of a modern-day legislature.

In Europe, the transition from absolute monarchy to constitutional monarchy was initiated by the transformation of the Estates General of 1789 into the National Assembly. France became an executive constitutional monarchy with the French Constitution of 1791, which was short-lived as the monarchy was overthrown in 1792. Several years later, in 1804, Napoleon Bonaparte proclaimed himself Emperor of the French in what was ostensibly a constitutional monarchy, though modern historians often refer to his reign as an absolute monarchy.

The Kingdom of England's constitutional monarchy was furthered by the Glorious Revolution of 1688, which was restricted by laws such as the Bill of Rights of 1689 and the Act of Settlement of 1701. The first form of a constitution was enacted with the Magna Carta of 1215. The Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, formed after the Union of Lublin in 1569, also operated much like many modern European constitutional monarchies.

Many countries that were once constitutional monarchies have since become republics, including Brazil, which was a constitutional monarchy from 1822 until 1889 when Pedro II was deposed by a military coup, and the Anglo-Corsican Kingdom, which existed from 1794 to 1796. The Hashemite Kingdom of Iraq was a constitutional monarchy until 1958, when King Faisal II was deposed in a military coup, and Barbados was a constitutional monarchy from 1966 until 2021 when it became a republic.

Explore related products

The Monarchy According to the Charter

$33.95

Canada's Constitutional Monarchy: An Introduction to Our Form of Government

$8.99 $32.99

Modern Monarchy: The British Royal Family Today

$43.53

Timeline of the British Monarchy

$20.79 $25.99

Abolish the Monarchy: Why we should and how we will

$14.5 $33.99

A History of England, Period III

$109.9

Examples of constitutional monarchies

A constitutional monarchy is a system of government in which a monarch acts as the head of state, but the political power is held by a constitutionally organized body. The monarch's role is often largely ceremonial, and they may be a symbolic figurehead. The constitution defines the distribution of powers and limits of authority for each branch of the government.

Some examples of constitutional monarchies include:

The United Kingdom

The United Kingdom is a well-known example of a constitutional monarchy, with the monarch as the head of state and an appointed prime minister leading the government. The UK parliament, composed of the House of Commons and the House of Lords, holds the legislative power.

Belgium

Belgium is another example of a constitutional monarchy, where the monarch formally appoints a representative to preside over the creation of a coalition government following a parliamentary election.

Norway

In Norway, the King chairs special meetings of the cabinet and is the nominal chief executive, but the country's political process is democratic, and the monarch's powers are limited.

Japan and Thailand

Japan and Thailand are the two most populous constitutional monarchies in the world, located in Asia. In these countries, the prime minister holds the day-to-day powers of governance, and the monarch has residual powers that can be significant.

Canada

Canada is another example of a constitutional monarchy, where the monarch is the head of state, and the country is divided into provinces.

Comparison with other systems

A constitutional monarchy is a system of government in which a monarch shares power with a constitutionally organized government. The monarch may be the head of state or a ceremonial leader, while the constitution allocates the rest of the government's power to the legislature and judiciary. This is in contrast to an absolute monarchy, where the monarch holds total power over the government and the people.

Constitutional monarchies can vary in the level of power granted to the sovereign. For example, in Liechtenstein, Monaco, Morocco, Jordan, Kuwait, Bahrain, and Bhutan, the constitution gives the sovereign substantial discretionary powers. In contrast, in countries like the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, Spain, Belgium, Denmark, Norway, Sweden, and Japan, the monarch has significantly less, if any, personal discretion in exercising their authority.

The concept of a constitutional monarchy emerged as a compromise between blind trust in a lineage of monarchs and the belief in the political wisdom of the ruled. It blends monarchical rule with representative democracy, and the monarch often serves as a symbol of national unity, pride, and tradition. While the monarch may hold formal authority, they typically do not personally set public policy or choose political leaders. Instead, they may have ceremonial duties and limited formal powers, such as dissolving parliament or giving royal assent to legislation, which must be exercised within constitutional principles.

Constitutional monarchies differ from other systems, such as absolute monarchies and republics. Absolute monarchies, like those in Vatican City, Brunei, and Saudi Arabia, grant the monarch total unchallenged political and legislative power, derived from the ancient concept of the "Divine Right of Kings." On the other hand, republics, like the United States, have an elected head of state rather than a monarch. While constitutional monarchies may face criticism for their blend of inherited power and democracy, they offer a middle ground between the extremes of absolute monarchy and anarchy or dictatorship.

Frequently asked questions