Hinduism: India's Constitutional Religion?

The Indian Constitution guarantees freedom of religion for all citizens, with Article 25 stating that all persons are entitled to freedom of conscience and the right to freely profess, practice, and propagate their religion. The Constitution also shields individual religions or groups by adding religious rights as fundamental rights. However, the term Hindu has been used ambiguously in the Constitution to denote persons following Hinduism, Jainism, Buddhism, or Sikhism, which has been challenged by some groups. The Indian Constitution aims for a comprehensive social transformation, with religion appearing to be a key target, and India has been a secular state since its constitution was adopted. Despite this, there have been instances of religious intolerance and violence, with some claiming that the secular Constitution is deforming or destroying Hinduism.

Explore related products

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights

$9.99 $9.99

The RSS: And the Making of the Deep Nation

$13.99

A Hand-Book of Hindu Pantheism: The Panchadasi of Sreemut Vidyaranya Swami (Classic Reprint)

$10.87

Creative Ministry

$8.99 $17

Mesocosm: Hinduism and the Organization of a Traditional Newar City in Nepal

$18.23 $50

Liberty and Dharma

$2.99 $3.99

The Indian Constitution's impact on a society saturated by religion

India is the birthplace of four major religions: Jainism, Hinduism, Buddhism, and Sikhism. The Indian Constitution guarantees freedom of religion for all its citizens, with Article 25 stating that "all persons are equally entitled to freedom of conscience and the right to freely profess, practice, and propagate religion subject to public order, morality, and health". The Constitution also prohibits caste-based discrimination, including the practice of untouchability, and the government has enacted economic advancement policies for Dalits, Scheduled Tribes, and OBC communities.

The Indian Constitution has a significant impact on a society saturated by religion. It attempts to bring about a comprehensive social transformation, targeting religion as the main driver of this change. The Constitution strives to conserve the pluralism of ethical religions in India, acting against any attempt at religious homogenization or exclusion. It prevents a tight connection between social norms and ethical religion, ensuring that no single religious framework becomes totalizing. This is in contrast to the Abrahamic traditions, where the connection between ethics and social norms is deeply intertwined, forming a single system.

The Constitution's impact on society is also reflected in its attempt to destroy the deeply hierarchical caste system at the core of India's dominant social religion. This marks it as an instrument for social revolution. While the Constitution guarantees freedom of religion, several state-level "freedom of religion" acts prohibit "forcible" or "induced" conversions to protect religious groups and maintain social equality. These laws have been challenged by Christians, who argue that propagation of their faith is an important part of their religion.

Despite living under the same constitution, members of India's major religious communities often feel they have little in common with each other. A majority of Hindus and Muslims, for example, see themselves as very different from each other. However, there are also shared values and beliefs that cross religious lines, such as the belief in karma and the purifying power of the Ganges River. Respecting elders is also considered very important across all major religious groups in India.

In conclusion, the Indian Constitution has a significant impact on a society saturated by religion. It attempts to bring about social transformation, conserve pluralism, prevent religious homogenization, and destroy the hierarchical caste system. While it guarantees freedom of religion, it also includes regulations to protect religious groups and maintain social equality. The Constitution's impact is reflected in the shared values and beliefs that cross religious lines, as well as the sense of difference between religious communities.

Hinduism's historical development within local Indian populations

Hinduism is a major world religion that originated on the Indian subcontinent. It is often regarded as the oldest religion in the world, with roots and customs that date back more than 4,000 years. However, scholars argue that Hinduism is a relatively recent synthesis of various Indian cultures and traditions, with diverse roots and no single founder, which emerged around the beginning of the Common Era. The history of Hinduism is often divided into periods of development, with the first being the pre-Vedic period, which includes the Indus Valley Civilization and local prehistoric religions.

The roots of Hinduism can be traced back to the schools of commentary and debate preserved in epic and Vedic writings from the 2nd millennium BCE. The Vedic period, which followed the pre-Vedic period in northern India, saw the introduction of the historical Vedic religion (sometimes called Vedic Hinduism or ancient Hinduism) by the Indo-Aryan migrations, starting somewhere between 1900 BCE and 1400 BCE. This period saw the emergence of new texts and poet-saints, who recorded their spiritual sentiments.

During the time of Islamic rule in India, from about 1200 to 1757, Islamic rulers prevented Hindus from worshipping their deities, and some temples were destroyed. The British rule, which began in 1757 and lasted until 1947, initially allowed Hindus to practice their religion without interference. However, the British soon attempted to exploit aspects of Indian culture, such as exacerbating Hindu caste divisions, as leverage for political control.

In the 19th century, Hinduism developed a large number of new religious movements, partly inspired by European Romanticism, nationalism, scientific racism, and esotericism. The term "Hinduism" itself was coined by British writers during this time, building on centuries-old usages of the word "Hindu". The idea of a unified body of religious praxis, or Hinduism as a single world religious tradition, was popularised by 19th-century missionaries and European Indologists. This notion was also adopted by Hindu reform movements, such as the Brahmo Samaj, which promoted "Hindu modernism".

Despite its global presence, Hinduism is best understood through its many distinctive regional manifestations. Contemporary Hinduism is a compilation of many traditions and philosophies, with Hindus worshipping a variety of gods and minor deities, honouring multiple symbols, and respecting several different holy books. While the Indian Constitution has declared India a secular state with no state religion, some argue that the Indian state privileges Hinduism as a state-sponsored religion.

The Indian Constitution's role in conserving ethical religion pluralism

The Indian Constitution plays a significant role in conserving ethical religion pluralism in the country. India is regarded as a hopeful example of a pluralist democracy, with a long history of religious diversity and tolerance. The Constitution's role in conserving this pluralism can be examined through its relationship with Indian religions and its impact on society.

Firstly, the Indian Constitution strives to conserve the country's immense pluralism of ethical religions. Unlike Europe, where people have had to fight for the pluralisation of ethics, India's tradition has allowed for greater innovation and the proliferation of ethical frameworks. People have been able to move freely between different ethical frameworks, and the Constitution acts against any attempts at religious homogenisation or exclusion. This reflects a form of segmented pluralism, where religious and secular forms exist separately.

Secondly, the Indian Constitution prevents a tight connection between social norms and ethical religion. By doing so, it ensures that religion does not become totalising, as seen in other parts of the world, such as Latin Christianity or Saudi Islam. This loose connection between ethics and social norms has allowed for ethical flexibility in India, where individuals can choose their path to self-fulfilment while still adhering to common social norms. This reflects a form of multi-confessional pluralism, where multiple religious beliefs coexist.

Thirdly, the Indian Constitution's main objective is to transform India's dominant social religion by destroying its deeply hierarchical caste system. The caste system lies at the core of social norms and has resulted in great rigidity and inequality within society. By targeting this system, the Constitution aims to bring about a social revolution and establish equal citizenship, which is a key element of covenantal pluralism.

Finally, the Indian Constitution provides fundamental rights and freedoms that contribute to the conservation of ethical religion pluralism. Article 25 guarantees freedom of conscience and the right to freely profess, practice, and propagate religion, while Article 26 ensures that religious denominations can manage their own affairs. These rights are subject to regulation by the State to maintain public order, morality, and health. However, the Constitution also shields individual religions or groups by adding these religious rights as fundamental rights.

In conclusion, the Indian Constitution plays a crucial role in conserving ethical religion pluralism in India by striving to maintain and protect the country's diverse religious landscape. It achieves this through its unique approach to the relationship between ethics and social norms, its transformative objectives, and the fundamental rights it guarantees to its citizens.

Explore related products

Kriya Yoga Exposed: The Truth About Current Kriya Yoga Gurus, Organizations & Going Beyond Kriya, Contains the Explanation of a Special Technique Never Revealed Before in Kriya Literature (Real Yoga)

$17.29 $17.29

The Light of Asia: The Poem that Defined The Buddha

$12.99 $25.95

Le Concile du Vatican: Ses préliminaires et sa constitution (French Edition)

$9.2 $9.2

Manusmṛti, Vol. 2 (Chapters 7-12): The First Constitution of Humanity on the Earth (Manusmriti)

$6.99 $12.99

Pink Revolutions: Globalization, Hindutva, and Queer Triangles in Contemporary India (Critical Insurgencies)

$39.55 $40

Hindu Nationalism: A Reader

$7.99 $26

The distinction between ethical and social religion in India

India is a country saturated by religion, with religion being prominent in the lives of Indians regardless of socioeconomic status. The Indian Constitution, however, attempts a comprehensive social transformation, targeting religion to effect this social revolution. Scholars have distinguished between ethical and social religion in India to understand the relationship between the Constitution and Indian religions.

Ethical religion refers to individual ethics of self-fulfilment, or a framework for meaningful living and dying. It involves making decisions about right and wrong, defining concepts such as good and bad, virtue and vice, justice and crime, etc. Ethical religions provide a path to enlightenment and salvation, with ethical mandates and recommendations for virtuous behaviour. In India, a profound pluralism of ethical religions exists, with Hindus, Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, Buddhists, and Jains all coexisting. Despite their different ethical frameworks, followers of these religions participate in much the same caste-ridden social religion.

Social religion refers to social norms of everyday conduct, including rituals and ceremonies of social interaction, and norms governing interpersonal relations. This includes whom one should or should not interact with, marry, or dine with, as well as societal job allocations. In the Abrahamic traditions, the connection between ethics and social norms is very tight, with the term 'religion' referring to the entire system. In India, however, the connection between ethics and social norms is much looser, allowing for greater innovation and the proliferation of ethical frameworks.

The Indian Constitution strives to conserve this immense pluralism of ethical religions, acting against any attempt at religious homogenisation or exclusion. It prevents a tight connection between social norms and ethical religion, ensuring that religion does not become totalising, as has been seen in Latin Christianity and Saudi Islam. By breaking the monopoly of any one religion, the Constitution presents options beyond dominant ideas of self-fulfilment and builds norms of social equality that transcend religious identities.

In summary, the distinction between ethical and social religion in India is important for understanding how the Indian Constitution relates to the country's diverse religious landscape. Ethical religion in India refers to the plurality of individual ethical frameworks, while social religion encompasses the shared social norms and rituals that cut across religious lines. The Constitution works to conserve this ethical pluralism and prevent the totalising influence of any single religion on society.

The Indian Constitution's secular nature and its implications for religious freedom

India is one of the most religiously diverse countries in the world, with a society whose culture is based on religious principles. The Indian Constitution recognises this diversity and attempts a comprehensive social transformation to effect a social revolution. The Constitution's preamble includes the word "secular", and articles 25 to 28 imply that the state will not discriminate, patronise, or interfere in the profession of any religion.

The Indian Constitution's secular nature has several implications for religious freedom in the country. Firstly, it guarantees freedom of conscience and the right to freely profess, practice, and propagate religion, as outlined in Article 25. This right is further reinforced by Article 18 and 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which state that freedom of thought, conscience, and religion is a basic human right. Additionally, Article 26 of the Indian Constitution ensures that all denominations can manage their own affairs in matters of religion.

However, the Constitution also shields individual religions or groups by adding religious rights as fundamental rights. For example, Article 25 (2b) uses the term "Hindus" for all classes and sections of Hindus, Jains, Buddhists, and Sikhs, guaranteeing the right of members of the Sikh faith to bear a Kirpan. The Constitution also includes regulations, such as those concerning cow slaughter, that protect the religious beliefs of some Hindus.

While the Indian Constitution guarantees religious freedom, there have been challenges in practice. Several state-level "freedom of religion" acts prohibit "forcible" or "induced" conversions, and affirmative action policies also impact religious conversions. Additionally, appealing for votes on the basis of religion or caste is considered a "corrupt practice". Despite these challenges, India's experience with secularism and religious freedom can serve as a model for other countries with diverse societies and religions, such as Ethiopia.

Frequently asked questions