Renting To Undocumented Immigrants: Criminal Offense Or Not?

The act of renting to an illegal immigrant is a complex issue that varies depending on location. While it is not illegal in some states and cities across the U.S., other areas have attempted to implement laws to criminalize it. For example, Alabama's House Bill (H.B.) 56 makes it unlawful to harbor an alien unlawfully present in the United States by entering into a rental agreement. However, federal preemption severely limits the ability of state and local governments to create laws intended to identify or punish those who rent to illegal immigrants. The Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) also does not prohibit landlords from renting out properties to undocumented migrants, but they must be cautious not to aid illegal migration. Landlords who rent to illegal immigrants may face criminal charges, as seen in the case of a landlord in Kentucky who was charged for renting to illegal immigrants and hiring an illegal immigrant as a manager.

Does renting to an illegal immigrant constitute a crime?

Explore related products

Immigration Law Pocket Field Guide 2025 Edition [LATEST EDITION]

$50

Immigration Law for Beginners Guide: Easy-to-Follow Steps to Successfully Navigate Immigration Law, Simplifying the Path to Legal Residency and Citizenship for First-Time Applicants and Immigrants

$14.99

Immigration Law and Procedure in a Nutshell (Nutshells)

$62

Immigration Law: A Quickstudy Laminated Reference Guide

$8.95

Immigration and Nationality Laws of the United States: Selected Statutes, Regulations and Forms, 2024

$71

UNDERSTANDING REMOVAL PROCEEDINGS IN THE IMMIGRATION COURT: A layperson's guide to deportation and deportation defense in the U.S. Immigration Court

$3.99

Landlord rights and responsibilities

While federal preemption severely limits state and local governments' ability to create laws intended to identify illegal aliens or punish those who knowingly or recklessly shelter them, a few cities and states have tried to implement measures to punish landlords for renting to illegal immigrants. For example, Section 13(a)(4) of Alabama's House Bill (H.B.) 56 makes it unlawful to "harbor an alien unlawfully present in the United States by entering into a rental agreement". However, the Kentucky Chapter of the ACLU maintains that it is not illegal to rent an apartment to an illegal alien, nor is it a landlord's duty to check a tenant's immigration status.

Regardless of the immigration status of tenants, landlords have certain rights and responsibilities. These include:

• Providing tenants with the name, address, and telephone number of the person authorized to accept notice or legal service on behalf of the landlord
• Presenting the property at the beginning of the tenancy in a clean, safe, and sanitary condition, free of vermin and rodents
• Supplying hot and cold water as reasonably required by the tenant and adequate heat as required by the Housing Code (at least 68º)
• Checking all smoke detectors prior to occupancy to ensure they are in working order and replacing them after ten years
• Providing tenants with at least 24 hours' notice before making non-emergency repairs and at least 72 hours' notice prior to any DHCA inspection scheduled by Housing Code Enforcement
• Providing tenants with the contact name and number of someone who is available at all times in an emergency
• Investigating and resolving formal complaints from tenants and landlords, and mediating disputes
• Approving rental housing licenses and inspecting rental properties to ensure compliance with all applicable housing codes
• Referring tenants to available emergency services as necessary
• Returning the security deposit to tenants within 14 days of their move-out date. If the landlord keeps any of the deposits, they must provide a list explaining each deduction
• Charging late fees only when rent is more than 5 days late, and ensuring that the fees do not exceed $50 or 5% of the monthly rent, whichever is less

Tenants, regardless of their immigration status, also have certain rights. In New York City, for instance, the New York City Human Rights Law protects tenants from discrimination based on their actual or perceived immigration status. This means that landlords cannot deny a lease, refuse to rent, or demand special papers based solely on a tenant's immigration status. Additionally, tenants in rent-regulated apartments are entitled to protections, including guaranteed renewal leases with limited rent increases.

Immigration status and rental agreements

While federal preemption severely limits what state and local governments can do in terms of creating laws intended to identify illegal aliens or punish those who knowingly or recklessly employ, transport, or shelter them, some cities and states have tried to pass laws to punish landlords for renting to illegal aliens. For example, Alabama's House Bill (H.B.) 56 makes it unlawful to "harbor an alien unlawfully present in the United States by entering into a rental agreement". However, federal courts have consistently held that laws that purport to penalize landlords for renting to illegal aliens are preempted by federal immigration law, emphasizing the federal government's "exclusive control" over the regulation of immigration.

In the state of New York, the New York City Human Rights Law protects residents from discrimination based on actual or perceived immigration status. This means that a landlord cannot deny a lease, refuse to rent, or demand special papers based on a tenant's immigration status. The New York City Tenant Protection Act also makes it illegal for landlords to repeatedly demand that a tenant accepts unwanted buyout offers intended to make them leave their home. The New York State Human Rights Law also prohibits landlords, property managers, and their agents from refusing to rent to, renew the lease of, or otherwise discriminate against, any person or group of persons based on their national origin.

In California, a housing provider may not ask about immigration status but can ask for a driver's license, social security number, and income history.

In Kentucky, the ACLU has taken the position that it is not illegal to rent an apartment to an illegal alien, nor is it a landlord’s duty to check a tenant’s immigration status.

Discrimination and anti-discrimination laws

While federal preemption limits the ability of state and local governments to create laws intended to identify illegal aliens or punish those who knowingly or unknowingly employ, transport, or shelter them, there are no clear federal laws that indicate whether renting to an illegal immigrant constitutes a crime. However, there have been instances where landlords have faced criminal charges for renting to illegal immigrants.

The Federal Fair Housing Act (Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1968) establishes laws that make it illegal to discriminate against a protected class when renting a property. This Act applies to all real estate transactions, including buying, renting, financing, and selling property. The protected classes under this Act include race, colour, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, or handicap. The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) is responsible for enforcing the Fair Housing Act.

The Fair Housing Act also applies to any person who deals with tenants and prospective tenants, including real estate agents, property owners, landlords, and managers. Landlords are not allowed to discriminate against tenants or prospective tenants based on their immigration status. For example, in New York City, the New York City Human Rights Law prohibits discrimination based on actual or perceived immigration status. Landlords cannot deny a lease, refuse to rent, or demand special papers based on a person's immigration status.

Additionally, some exemptions apply if the homeowner is renting a limited number of units or if the property is owner-occupied with four or fewer units. Federally exempt properties include senior housing, owner-occupied housing, some single-family homes, and housing owned by religious organizations and private clubs. However, local and state housing discrimination laws may still apply to these exempt properties, and landlords must base tenant selection on pre-established and objective criteria.

Housing discrimination is a serious violation, and tenants can file complaints if they believe they are being discriminated against based on their immigration status.

Explore related products

Immigration Law for Paralegals

$86.62 $97

Immigration Law Made Simple for Paralegals: A Practical Guide with Tools and Strategies

$15.99

U.S. Immigration Made Easy

$28.07 $44.99

Understanding Immigration Law and Practice [Connected eBook] (Aspen Paralegal Series)

$130 $187.95

Immigration Law: Statutory Supplement 2025

$9.34

A Guide to Immigration Law of the United States of America

$12

The legality of renting to undocumented migrants

In the United States, the Fifth Circuit Court has held that laws penalizing landlords for renting to undocumented migrants are unconstitutional, as they contravene the federal government's exclusive authority over immigration regulation. The U.S. Supreme Court has also struck down portions of Arizona's immigration bill, asserting federal preemption over state laws attempting to identify or punish those who shelter undocumented migrants. Despite these rulings, some cities and states continue to seek ways to deter landlords from renting to undocumented migrants, often through permit or licensing systems that require disclosure of immigration status.

On the other hand, tenant protection laws in certain states, such as New York, explicitly prohibit discrimination based on immigration status. The New York City Human Rights Law and the New York State Human Rights Law protect tenants from eviction, threats, or harassment due to their actual or perceived immigration status. These laws also make it illegal for landlords to demand specific immigration-related documents or information. New York City's Tenant Protection Act further safeguards tenants from repeated unwanted buyout offers, ensuring that landlords cannot pressure immigrants to leave their homes.

While the legality of renting to undocumented migrants remains ambiguous in many jurisdictions, landlords must be mindful of both federal and local laws when making rental decisions. In some cases, landlords have faced criminal charges for renting to undocumented migrants, particularly when they are found to be knowingly employing or harboring undocumented individuals. However, landlord advocacy groups argue that private citizens should not be coerced into enforcing immigration policies and that such enforcement could lead to liability for businesses that serve undocumented migrants.

The consequences of aiding illegal migration

In other cases, individuals or organizations that aid illegal migration may be subject to criminal charges and penalties. This can include transporting, sheltering, or providing transportation or travel services to those who are unlawfully present in a country. For example, human smugglers who aid undocumented immigrants in crossing borders illegally can face legal consequences. The dangers and risks associated with illegal migration, such as unsafe travel conditions, exploitation, and detention, also highlight the potential consequences for those who facilitate or encourage such journeys.

To combat illegal migration, countries have implemented various measures, such as border security, visa restrictions, and information campaigns. For instance, the United States has prioritized the deportation of individuals apprehended crossing the border illegally and has established refugee processing programs in Central American countries to provide a safe and legal path for those seeking humanitarian protection. Similarly, the European Union has introduced measures to strengthen its external borders and increase information sharing among member states to better manage migration and prevent illegal entry.

While the consequences of aiding illegal migration can be significant, it is important to recognize the complexities surrounding this issue. Poverty, crises, natural disasters, and violence are among the factors that drive people to migrate illegally. As such, addressing the root causes of illegal migration and providing safe and legal pathways for migration can play a crucial role in mitigating the potential consequences for both migrants and the societies they seek to enter.

Frequently asked questions