Protected Classes: Constitutional Rights And Their Legality

are protected classes constitutional

Protected classes refer to groups of people who are shielded from discrimination under federal, state, or local laws. While federal laws protect certain 'immutable characteristics' or characteristics inherent to an individual's identity, other attributes like political affiliation, physical appearance, and income level are not protected under federal law. This is largely due to the First Amendment, which protects the constitutional rights to freedom of speech and association.

Characteristics Values
Federal laws Protect certain "immutable characteristics" or characteristics inherent to an individual's identity
State laws Also define protected classes
Local laws Also define protected classes
Immutable characteristics Traits a person cannot control or change, like race or gender
Other attributes Political affiliation, physical appearance, and income level are not protected under federal law

cycivic

Federal anti-discrimination laws

Protected classes are groups of people who are shielded against discrimination under federal, state, or local laws. Federal anti-discrimination laws, such as the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, and the Americans with Disabilities Act, enumerate certain characteristics that constitute protected classes. These can include race, gender, age, disability, national origin, and religion.

While federal laws protect certain "immutable characteristics)", other attributes like political affiliation, physical appearance, and income level are not explicitly protected under federal law. The reasoning behind this distinction revolves around constitutional considerations, the subjective nature of the characteristic, and its changeability. For example, political beliefs can change and are a matter of personal choice, so they are not afforded the same inherent protection as immutable characteristics.

It's important to note that the understanding of protected classes may continue to evolve through courts or federal legislation. Societal responses to new issues of discrimination often initiate this process, and it's worth mentioning that many states and local jurisdictions offer additional safeguards beyond federal protections.

cycivic

State and local laws

Protected classes are defined by both federal and state laws. While federal laws protect certain 'immutable characteristics' or characteristics inherent to an individual's identity, other attributes like political affiliation, physical appearance, and income level are viewed differently. These distinctions are based on a combination of constitutional considerations, the subjective nature of the characteristic, and the dynamics surrounding its changeability.

Despite the lack of federal protections, many states and local jurisdictions offer additional safeguards for some of these categories. For example, the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was designed to address the pressing issue of racial discrimination, particularly prevalent in areas such as employment, housing, and public services. Under this Act, any form of differentiation or discrimination based on race by employers is illegal.

Additionally, states can also expand upon existing federal protections. For example, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act prohibits discrimination based on age in employment practices. However, a state may choose to enact legislation that extends this protection to other areas beyond employment, such as housing or education.

It's important to note that the understanding of protected classes is not static and can continue to evolve over time. Societal responses to new issues of discrimination often drive this evolution, either through court rulings or federal legislation. As a result, the definition of protected classes at the state and local levels can adapt to meet the changing needs and priorities of their communities.

cycivic

Immutable characteristics

Protected classes refer to people who are shielded from discrimination under federal, state, or local laws. While federal laws protect certain "immutable characteristics", other attributes like political affiliation, physical appearance, and income level are viewed differently.

In the United States, federal anti-discrimination laws, like the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, and the Americans with Disabilities Act, enumerate certain characteristics that constitute protected classes. These can include race, gender, age, disability, national origin, religion, and more.

The understanding of protected classes may continue to evolve, either incrementally through the courts or through federal legislation. It's worth noting that despite the lack of federal protections, many states and local jurisdictions offer additional safeguards for some of these categories.

cycivic

Political affiliation

The reasoning behind not providing federal protection for political affiliation largely revolves around the First Amendment. In the United States, the freedom of speech and association are constitutional rights. As a result, individuals can freely associate with political parties or ideologies. Since political beliefs can change and are a matter of personal choice, it has been argued that they don't warrant the same inherent protection as immutable characteristics like race or gender.

It's worth noting that despite the lack of federal protections for political affiliation, many states and local jurisdictions offer additional safeguards for some of these categories. The understanding of protected classes may continue to evolve, either incrementally through the courts or through federal legislation.

cycivic

Race and gender

Protected classes are groups of people who are shielded from discrimination under federal, state, or local laws. While federal laws protect certain "immutable characteristics", other attributes like political affiliation, physical appearance, and income level are not protected under federal law. This is because these characteristics are subjective, changeable, and a matter of personal choice.

Similarly, gender is also a protected class under federal law. While the specific laws surrounding gender discrimination may vary, the general principle is that individuals should not be discriminated against based on their gender. This includes discrimination based on pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions.

It is important to note that the understanding of protected classes may continue to evolve through courts or federal legislation. For example, while sexual orientation and gender identity discrimination were not initially included as protected classes under Title VII, the Court later clarified that these forms of discrimination are indeed types of sex discrimination. This demonstrates the dynamic nature of protected classes and how they can adapt to address new issues of discrimination.

In conclusion, race and gender are considered protected classes under federal law, as they are inherent and immutable characteristics of an individual's identity. Federal anti-discrimination laws aim to protect individuals from being discriminated against based on these characteristics, ensuring equal opportunities for all.

Frequently asked questions

A protected class refers to people who are shielded against discrimination under federal, state or local laws.

Protected classes can include race, gender, age, disability, national origin and religion.

No, protected classes are defined by federal, state and local laws.

The reasoning behind not providing federal protection for political affiliation largely revolves around the First Amendment. In the United States, the freedom of speech and association are constitutional rights. As a result, individuals can freely associate with political parties or ideologies.

Immutable characteristics are traits that a person cannot control or change, like race or gender. These are often the basis for protected classes in federal anti-discrimination law.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment