The Constitution's Critical Period: Why Was It So?

The period from the adoption of the Articles of Confederation to the adoption of the Federal Constitution (1781-89) is considered a critical period in American history. During this time, the newly formed nation faced significant challenges, including large amounts of debt, high taxes, foreign affairs issues, and military concerns. The Articles of Confederation, America's first constitution, gave the Confederation Congress the power to make rules and request funds from the states, but it lacked enforcement powers, the ability to regulate commerce, and the authority to print money. The states' disputes over territory, war pensions, taxation, and trade threatened to tear the country apart, prompting calls for a stronger national government. The critical period eventually led to the creation of the Constitution in 1787, which established a more robust central government to address the nation's challenges.

Explore related products

The Critical Period of American History, 1783-1789

$7.95 $13.66

Race & politics;: "bleeding Kansas" and the coming of the Civil War, (Critical periods of history)

$25.63

From Independence to the U.S. Constitution: Reconsidering the Critical Period of American History (Early American Histories)

$34.5 $34.5

The Napoleonic revolution (Critical periods of history)

$22.64 $29.95

Lincoln and the First Shot (Classic Reprint)

$25.72 $25.72

War and Society: The United States 1941-1945

$65

The Articles of Confederation were inadequate

The Articles of Confederation, America's first constitution, gave the Confederation Congress the power to make rules and request funds from the states. However, it had no enforcement powers, couldn't regulate commerce, or print money. This led to economic chaos, with differing currencies between states, plummeting values, and unemployment. The central government was too weak, and the states' disputes over territory, war pensions, taxation, and trade threatened to tear the young country apart. George Washington described the states as being held together by a "rope of sand".

The Articles of Confederation left the country ill-equipped to deal with foreign and domestic challenges. Under the Treaty of Paris of 1783, the British had pledged to vacate their military posts within the boundaries of the new country, and the Americans had promised to recommend strongly to the states that they make fair settlements with the Loyalists who had lost property during the war. However, the Congress made no progress on the compensation issue, and the British showed no haste in withdrawing from American territory.

The Articles of Confederation also caused chaos with no federal regulation, making trade between states difficult. The lack of a uniform currency further complicated trade, as converting currencies made trade costly and time-consuming. The Articles of Confederation also failed to provide the country with adequate military protection. The country was unable to raise a military force, and the states were relied on for defence, leaving the nation vulnerable to foreign threats.

The inadequacies of the Articles of Confederation led to calls for a more vigorous national government, resulting in the creation of the Constitution in 1787. The Constitution addressed the issues faced during the critical period, establishing a stronger central government with the power to regulate commerce, raise armies, and collect taxes uniformly. The Constitution also provided a framework for adding new states to the union and ensured equal representation regardless of population size.

Foreign affairs and domestic challenges

The period from 1781 to 1789, following the American Revolution, is considered a critical period in American history due to the significant foreign affairs and domestic challenges faced by the newly formed nation. The Articles of Confederation, America's first constitution, established a weak central government that struggled to address these pressing issues effectively.

Foreign Affairs

One of the critical foreign affairs challenges during this period was the issue of British military presence within the boundaries of the new country. According to the Treaty of Paris of 1783, which recognised American independence, the British had pledged to vacate their military posts. However, the British showed no urgency in withdrawing from American territory. Additionally, there were challenges in dealing with Loyalists who had lost property during the war, as the Congress made little progress on compensation issues.

Domestic Challenges

The young nation faced various domestic challenges, including economic chaos, high taxes, and state disputes. The country slipped into a period of inflation and depression, with varying currencies across states and a decline in the value of exchange media. Workers in war production faced unemployment, and tension arose between the farming interests of the west and the manufacturing and shipping interests of the eastern cities, leading to Shays' Rebellion in Massachusetts in 1786.

The Articles of Confederation gave the Confederation Congress the power to make rules and request funds from the states, but it lacked enforcement powers and could not regulate commerce or print money. This led to disputes over territory, war pensions, taxation, and trade, threatening to tear the country apart. The states retained considerable power, and the central government struggled to exert authority.

The Rise of a Stronger Central Government

The foreign affairs and domestic challenges faced during this critical period prompted calls for a stronger national government. Federalists advocated for a powerful central government to address the nation's challenges effectively. Alexander Hamilton helped convince Congress to organise a Grand Convention of state delegates to revise the Articles of Confederation, leading to the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia in May 1787. The new Constitution gave Congress the power to regulate intrastate commerce and address the pressing issues facing the nation.

Economic chaos and unemployment

The period following the American Revolution was a critical juncture for the newly formed nation, as it was fraught with economic chaos and unemployment. The Articles of Confederation, America's first constitution, had established a weak central government with no enforcement powers, unable to regulate commerce or print money. This led to states' disputes over territory, war pensions, taxation, and trade, threatening to tear the country apart.

The young nation faced significant economic challenges, including high taxes, large amounts of debt, and difficulties in interstate trade due to varying currencies. The lack of federal regulation caused chaos, and the conversion of currencies made trade especially challenging, with the continental dollar becoming virtually worthless. The inability to collect sufficient taxes and raise a military force further exacerbated the situation.

The war's conclusion brought about an era of inflation and depression. Workers previously engaged in war production faced prolonged unemployment as the value of many media of exchange plummeted. Most states experienced tension between the frontier or farming interests of the west and the wealthier eastern cities' shipping or manufacturing interests. This tension culminated in Shays' Rebellion in Massachusetts in 1786, highlighting the need for a stronger central government.

The critical period witnessed economic instability and unemployment, threatening the unity of the newly independent nation. The shortcomings of the Articles of Confederation prompted calls for a stronger central government, leading to the creation of the U.S. Constitution in 1787. The Constitution addressed these economic issues by granting Congress the power to regulate intrastate commerce and providing a framework for a more robust and unified nation.

Explore related products

The Historical Writings Of John Fiske: The Critical Period Of American History, 1783-1789

$41.95

For Ourselves and Our Posterity: The Preamble to the Federal Constitution in American History (Critical Historical Encounters Series)

$10.47 $13.99

Critical Approaches to the History of Western Herbal Medicine: From Classical Antiquity to the Early Modern Period

$33.75 $51.95

The History of the American Indians: A Critical Edition

$39.94

The Cambridge Critical Guide to Latin Literature

$64.99

The Changing Constitution: Constitutional Law in the Trump-Era Supreme Court

$36.21 $39.99

State disputes threatened to tear the country apart

The period from the adoption of the Articles of Confederation to the adoption of the Federal Constitution (1781-89) has been labelled the "critical period" of American history. During this time, the young nation faced a series of problems and challenges that threatened to tear it apart.

The Articles of Confederation, America's first constitution, gave the Confederation Congress the power to make rules and request funds from the states, but it had no enforcement powers, couldn't regulate commerce, and couldn't print money. This led to disputes between the states over territory, war pensions, taxation, and trade. The states were held together by a "rope of sand", as George Washington described it.

Economic chaos also plagued the country during this period. America slipped into an era of inflation and depression, with currencies varying among the states and the value of many media of exchange plummeting. Unemployment was high, especially for workers previously employed in war production. Additionally, there was tension between the frontier or farming interests of the west and the wealthier shipping or manufacturing interests of the eastern cities, which eventually boiled over in Shays' Rebellion in Massachusetts in 1786.

The country also faced foreign and domestic challenges. Under the Treaty of Paris of 1783, which recognised American independence, the British had pledged to vacate their military posts within the boundaries of the new country. However, they showed no haste in withdrawing, and the Congress made no progress on the issue. The Americans also struggled with the issue of compensating Loyalists who had lost property during the war.

The "critical period" highlighted the inadequacies of the Articles of Confederation and the need for a stronger central government. James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and George Washington feared their country was on the brink of collapse and worked to revise the Articles. The Constitutional Convention assembled in Philadelphia in May 1787, leading to the creation of the U.S. Constitution.

The need for a stronger central government

The time period following the American Revolution, known as the "critical period", was a challenging time for the newly formed nation. The Articles of Confederation, America's first constitution, had established a weak central government that struggled to address the various problems facing the country. This prompted calls for a stronger central government, leading to the creation of the Constitution in 1787.

The Articles of Confederation had given the Confederation Congress the power to make rules and request funds from the states, but it lacked enforcement powers and could not regulate commerce or print money. This led to disputes between the states over territory, war pensions, taxation, and trade, threatening to tear the country apart. The country was also facing economic chaos, with inflation, depression, and varying currencies between states. There were also issues with high taxes, foreign affairs, domestic challenges, and military concerns, including the presence of British troops on American territory.

The Federalists, a group that supported a strong central government, played a crucial role in the ratification of the Constitution. They faced opposition from the Anti-Federalists, who saw the strong central government as a reminder of the monarchy they had just overthrown and wanted a stronger protection of individual liberties. The Federalists proposed a compromise, known as "vote now, amend later", which helped secure victory in key states and ultimately led to the ratification of the Constitution.

The Constitution established a stronger central government, addressing the issues faced during the critical period. It gave Congress the power to regulate commerce, including intrastate trade, and provided a framework for a more unified nation. The Constitution also included the first 10 amendments, known as the Bill of Rights, which guaranteed the protection of natural rights and individual liberties, addressing some of the concerns raised by the Anti-Federalists.

Frequently asked questions