African Americans' Political Shift: The 1932 Party Preference Revealed

In 1932, African Americans overwhelmingly shifted their political allegiance from the Republican Party, which had been their traditional home since the Civil War and Reconstruction, to the Democratic Party. This significant realignment was largely due to the economic devastation of the Great Depression and the perceived responsiveness of Democratic presidential candidate Franklin D. Roosevelt to the plight of marginalized communities. While the Republican Party, under President Herbert Hoover, was blamed for the economic crisis, Roosevelt’s New Deal policies promised relief, recovery, and reform, resonating with African American voters who were disproportionately affected by unemployment, poverty, and racial discrimination. Additionally, the efforts of Democratic activists and organizations to court Black voters, coupled with the growing influence of African American leaders like Mary McLeod Bethune, further solidified this shift, marking a pivotal moment in the political history of African Americans.

Explore related products

1932 Back In The Day - 24-page Greeting Card / Booklet with Envelope (5 x 7 Size) – Great for Birthdays, Anniversaries, Reunions, Graduations, Client & Corporate Gifts

$6.99

Political Parties: A Sociological Study of the Oligarchial Tendencies of Modern Democracy

$11.95

Political Parties

$70.13 $105.63

How America’s Political Parties Change (and How They Don’t)

$20.3 $23.99

Political Parties : A Sociological Study of the Oligarchical Tendencies of Modern Democracy

$1.99 $24.95

American Political Parties and Elections: A Very Short Introduction

$12.99 $7.99

Historical Context of 1932 Election

The 1932 presidential election unfolded against the backdrop of the Great Depression, a cataclysmic economic collapse that left one-quarter of Americans jobless and millions destitute. For African Americans, the crisis exacerbated long-standing racial inequalities, as they faced higher unemployment rates, systemic discrimination in relief efforts, and continued disenfranchisement in the Jim Crow South. This dire context forced Black voters to reevaluate their political allegiances, setting the stage for a historic shift in their partisan preferences.

Historically, African Americans had been a reliable voting bloc for the Republican Party, the party of Lincoln and Emancipation. However, by 1932, disillusionment with Republican leadership, particularly President Hoover’s perceived indifference to Black suffering, had deepened. Hoover’s administration failed to address racial violence, such as the 1930 lynching of Henry Lowry in Florida, and offered no targeted relief for Black communities. Meanwhile, Democratic candidate Franklin D. Roosevelt’s promise of a New Deal, though vague on racial specifics, offered a glimmer of hope for economic recovery and federal intervention.

Roosevelt’s campaign strategically courted African American voters, a departure from previous Democratic strategies that had often ignored or alienated Black citizens. Key figures like Mary McLeod Bethune, a prominent Black educator, advised Roosevelt and helped bridge the gap between the Democratic Party and Black voters. Additionally, Eleanor Roosevelt’s public support for anti-lynching legislation and her engagement with Black leaders signaled a willingness to address racial injustices, albeit cautiously.

The election results reflected this shifting tide. While voting data from the era is limited due to widespread disenfranchisement, anecdotal evidence and post-election analyses suggest that African Americans began to favor the Democratic Party in 1932. In Northern cities like Chicago and New York, where Black voters had more political agency, the Democratic vote share surged. This marked the beginning of a long-term realignment, as African Americans increasingly identified the Democratic Party as their best hope for economic relief and civil rights progress.

In retrospect, the 1932 election was a turning point in African American political history, driven by the intersection of economic desperation and strategic outreach. While the New Deal’s benefits were often uneven and exclusionary, the election laid the groundwork for a new political alliance. It demonstrated that African Americans were not a monolithic voting bloc but a strategic demographic capable of leveraging their electoral power—however limited—to demand change. This shift would culminate in the Civil Rights era, when the Democratic Party solidified its position as the party of Black America.

African American Voting Patterns Shift

In 1932, African American voting patterns underwent a significant shift, marking a turning point in their political alignment. Historically, African Americans had been largely affiliated with the Republican Party, the party of Abraham Lincoln, who had emancipated slaves during the Civil War. However, the Great Depression and the perceived indifference of the Republican administration under President Herbert Hoover to the plight of African Americans led to a reevaluation of their political loyalties. This period saw the beginnings of a migration toward the Democratic Party, a shift that would become more pronounced in subsequent decades.

The Democratic Party’s nomination of Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1932 played a crucial role in this transition. Roosevelt’s New Deal policies, aimed at economic recovery and relief, resonated with African American voters who were disproportionately affected by unemployment and poverty. While Roosevelt did not explicitly address racial issues in his campaign, his promise of a more inclusive and responsive government began to attract African American support. For instance, prominent African American leaders like Mary McLeod Bethune, who later became an advisor to Roosevelt, started to advocate for a shift in allegiance, recognizing the potential for greater representation and aid under a Democratic administration.

This shift was not immediate or universal. Many African Americans remained skeptical of the Democratic Party, which was still dominated by segregationist Southern Democrats. However, the cracks in the Republican Party’s hold on African American voters were evident. The 1932 election marked the first time a significant portion of African Americans voted for a Democratic presidential candidate, though the majority still voted Republican. This election laid the groundwork for the eventual realignment of African American political loyalty, which would solidify during Roosevelt’s subsequent terms and the civil rights advancements of the mid-20th century.

To understand this shift, consider the practical realities of the time. African American voters in the North, where they had the right to vote, were more likely to experiment with Democratic candidates than those in the South, where voter suppression and Jim Crow laws severely limited their political participation. For those in urban areas hit hardest by the Depression, the promise of federal relief programs like the Works Progress Administration (WPA) and the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) was a tangible incentive to support Roosevelt. While these programs were not initially racially equitable, they offered a glimmer of hope that the Democratic Party might be more attentive to their needs.

In conclusion, the 1932 election was a pivotal moment in African American political history, signaling the beginning of a long-term shift from the Republican to the Democratic Party. While the change was gradual and uneven, it reflected a growing recognition among African American voters that their interests might be better served by a party willing to address economic inequality, even if it fell short on racial justice. This shift laid the foundation for the Democratic Party’s eventual dominance among African American voters, a trend that continues to shape American politics today.

Franklin D. Roosevelt’s Appeal

The 1932 presidential election marked a significant shift in African American political allegiance, with Franklin D. Roosevelt’s Democratic campaign capturing their support for the first time in decades. This reversal was not merely a reaction to Herbert Hoover’s failures during the Great Depression but a calculated response to Roosevelt’s strategic outreach and perceived empathy. Roosevelt’s appeal lay in his ability to frame the New Deal as inclusive, even if its implementation often fell short for Black Americans. His administration’s acknowledgment of their struggles, coupled with symbolic gestures like appointing Black advisors, created a sense of recognition that resonated deeply within the community.

To understand Roosevelt’s appeal, consider his rhetorical strategy. Unlike Hoover, who seemed detached from the plight of marginalized groups, Roosevelt employed a tone of collective suffering and shared destiny. His fireside chats, though not explicitly addressing racial inequality, conveyed a message of hope and solidarity that Black Americans, disproportionately affected by the Depression, found compelling. For instance, his promise to provide relief to the "forgotten man" was interpreted by many African Americans as a tacit acknowledgment of their systemic exclusion, even if the reality of New Deal programs often reinforced segregation.

A critical factor in Roosevelt’s success was his behind-the-scenes engagement with Black leaders. He cultivated relationships with figures like Mary McLeod Bethune, who served as an informal advisor and a bridge to the Black community. This strategic alliance allowed Roosevelt to navigate the complexities of racial politics without alienating Southern Democrats. While his public stance on racial issues remained cautious, these private efforts signaled a willingness to listen and act, however incrementally. This duality—public moderation paired with private outreach—became a cornerstone of his appeal to African American voters.

Practically, Roosevelt’s administration introduced policies that, while flawed, offered tangible benefits to Black Americans. The Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) and the Works Progress Administration (WPA), for example, provided jobs to thousands of Black workers, even if they were often relegated to segregated units. Similarly, the Social Security Act of 1935 excluded agricultural and domestic workers—professions dominated by African Americans—but it laid the groundwork for future reforms. These measures, though imperfect, contrasted sharply with Hoover’s perceived indifference, making Roosevelt the lesser of two evils in the eyes of many Black voters.

In retrospect, Roosevelt’s appeal to African Americans in 1932 was less about radical change and more about symbolic inclusion and pragmatic improvement. His ability to balance progressive rhetoric with political realism created an opening for Black voters to shift their allegiance from the Republican Party, which had been their traditional home since the Civil War. While the New Deal’s legacy remains contested, Roosevelt’s strategic outreach marked the beginning of a long-term realignment that would eventually solidify the Democratic Party as the dominant choice for African American voters. This shift underscores the power of perception and incremental action in shaping political loyalties.

Explore related products

On the Abolition of All Political Parties (NYRB Classics)

$13.9 $14.95

Political Ideologies and Political Parties in America (Cambridge Studies in Public Opinion and Political Psychology)

$24.34 $32

Political Parties: A Kid's Guide (Kids' Guide to Elections)

$6.27 $7.95

Political Parties

$27.25

The Hollow Parties: The Many Pasts and Disordered Present of American Party Politics (Princeton Studies in American Politics)

$15.59 $35

Life of the Parties

$57.66 $62

Republican Party’s Decline Among Blacks

The 1932 election marked a turning point in African American political alignment, as the Republican Party, once the party of Lincoln and emancipation, began to lose its stronghold on Black voters. This shift was not sudden but rather a culmination of decades of changing political landscapes and strategic decisions that alienated a significant portion of the African American electorate. To understand this decline, one must examine the historical context, the actions of key political figures, and the evolving priorities of Black communities during the early 20th century.

Historically, African Americans had been staunch supporters of the Republican Party since the Civil War, largely due to its role in abolishing slavery and advancing civil rights during Reconstruction. However, by the 1930s, the party’s commitment to these principles had waned. The rise of the "Lily-White Movement" within the Republican Party in the early 20th century sought to purge Black members from leadership positions and diminish the party’s focus on racial equality. This internal shift signaled to African American voters that their interests were no longer a priority, creating a rift that would widen over time.

The Great Depression further accelerated this decline. While African Americans suffered disproportionately during the economic crisis, the Republican Party’s response was seen as inadequate and out of touch. President Herbert Hoover’s administration failed to address the unique challenges faced by Black communities, such as higher unemployment rates and systemic discrimination. In contrast, Franklin D. Roosevelt’s Democratic Party began to court African American voters with promises of economic relief and a more inclusive political agenda. Roosevelt’s New Deal programs, though imperfect in their implementation, offered tangible benefits that resonated with Black voters, laying the groundwork for a political realignment.

A critical moment in this decline was the 1932 election itself. African American leaders, such as W.E.B. Du Bois, publicly endorsed Roosevelt, marking a significant break from the Republican Party. This endorsement was not merely symbolic; it reflected a growing sentiment among Black voters that the Democratic Party, despite its historical ties to segregation, was more willing to address their immediate economic and social needs. The Republican Party’s failure to adapt to these changing priorities further alienated African American voters, setting the stage for a long-term shift in political allegiance.

To reverse this decline, the Republican Party would need to reevaluate its approach to racial equality and economic justice. Practical steps could include actively recruiting Black leaders, addressing systemic discrimination within the party, and developing policies that directly benefit African American communities. However, by 1932, the damage was already done. The Republican Party’s inability to evolve with the times cemented its decline among Black voters, a trend that would persist for decades. This historical lesson underscores the importance of political parties remaining responsive to the needs and priorities of diverse constituencies, lest they risk losing their support entirely.

Impact of the Great Depression

The Great Depression, a period of severe economic downturn, disproportionately affected African Americans, who were already marginalized in American society. By 1932, unemployment among African Americans reached a staggering 50%, compared to 30% for whites. This stark disparity was rooted in systemic racism, as African Americans were often the first to be laid off and the last to be rehired. Sharecroppers in the South faced eviction and destitution, while urban workers in the North encountered widespread discrimination in relief efforts. This economic devastation forced African Americans to reevaluate their political allegiances, setting the stage for a significant shift in their voting behavior.

The Republican Party, which had traditionally garnered African American support since the Civil War due to its association with emancipation, failed to address the unique struggles of Black communities during the Depression. President Herbert Hoover’s administration offered little targeted relief for African Americans, and his policies were perceived as indifferent to their plight. For instance, the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, established to provide loans to banks and businesses, largely excluded Black-owned institutions. This neglect eroded the longstanding loyalty of African Americans to the Republican Party, leaving them disillusioned and seeking alternatives.

In contrast, the Democratic Party, under Franklin D. Roosevelt, began to appeal to African Americans through the New Deal programs. While these initiatives were not initially designed with racial equity in mind, they provided tangible benefits to Black communities. The Works Progress Administration (WPA) and the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) offered jobs to African Americans, albeit often in segregated and lower-paying positions. Additionally, First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt’s advocacy for civil rights issues signaled a shift in the Democratic Party’s attitude toward racial justice. These efforts, though imperfect, were enough to capture the attention of African American voters.

The 1932 election marked a turning point, as African Americans began to favor the Democratic Party in significant numbers. This shift was not immediate or universal, but it laid the groundwork for the eventual realignment of Black voters. The Great Depression exposed the inadequacies of the Republican Party in addressing racial and economic inequality, while the Democrats’ New Deal programs offered a glimmer of hope. This period underscored the importance of economic policies in shaping political loyalties, as African Americans sought a party that would actively work to improve their dire circumstances.

In practical terms, the impact of the Great Depression on African American political preferences can be seen as a lesson in the power of policy responsiveness. For modern political parties, this historical shift highlights the need to address the specific needs of marginalized communities during times of crisis. By failing to do so, parties risk losing the support of these groups, while proactive and inclusive policies can foster long-term loyalty. The 1932 election serves as a reminder that economic hardship can be a catalyst for political realignment, particularly when one party demonstrates a willingness to act on behalf of the most vulnerable.

Frequently asked questions