The Constitution's Debate Venue: A Historical Perspective

The debates over the United States Constitution took place in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, in 1787. The Constitutional Convention was convened to revise the Articles of Confederation, which was the nation's first constitution. The delegates debated various topics, including representation in Congress, slavery, and the powers and election of the president. The final draft of the Constitution was signed on September 17, 1787, and it has since functioned effectively as the governing document of the United States for over 200 years.

Explore related products

The Anti-Federalist Papers and the Constitutional Convention Debates (Signet Classics)

$8.32 $8.95

The Constitutional Convention: A Narrative History from the Notes of James Madison (Modern Library Classics)

$12.95 $22

Notes of Debates in the Federal Convention of 1787

$35 $34.99

Decision in Philadelphia: The Constitutional Convention of 1787

$18 $18

Madison’s Hand: Revising the Constitutional Convention

$26 $26

The Summer of 1787: The Men Who Invented the Constitution (The Simon & Schuster America Collection)

$11.29 $19.99

Representation in Congress

The debate over the U.S. Constitution took place in Philadelphia in 1787, with 55 delegates in attendance. The convention was held to revise the Articles of Confederation, which was the nation's first constitution. The Articles of Confederation had created a weak central government, consisting of a single-house Congress in which each state had only one vote.

One of the major debates at the convention was over representation in Congress. The question was whether representation should be based on population or divided equally among the states. The large and small states disagreed over representation in the first chamber of the legislature, with the southern states fearing that a New England-dominated Congress might damage their economic life through export taxes. The framers of the Constitution compromised by giving each state one representative for every 30,000 people in the House of Representatives and two representatives in the Senate. They also agreed to count enslaved Africans as three-fifths of a person.

The debates over representation in Congress were closely linked to the issue of slavery. The economy of many southern states depended heavily on agricultural products produced by slaves. To protect their economy, the southern states proposed two measures: banning Congress from taxing exports and forbidding Congress from banning the importation of slaves. The delegates agreed that the slave trade could continue until 1808, and while the word "slave" was never used in the Constitution, the issue was a thorny one that threatened to derail the Union.

Another debate concerned the powers of the president and how they should be elected. The delegates discussed how long the president's term should be and whether there should be limits on the number of terms a president could serve. Underlying this debate was a fear of a monarchy or despot taking over the country. The convention decided on a four-year term with no limit on re-election.

Powers of the President

The United States Constitution was drafted and debated in Philadelphia, where 55 delegates gathered in 1787 for the Constitutional Convention. The debates took place over four months, and the final document was produced on September 17, 1787.

The President of the United States derives their powers from Article II of the Constitution. The President has the power to:

• Serve as the Commander-in-Chief of the US military and militia when called to service.
• Approve or veto bills and resolutions passed by Congress.
• Write checks through the Treasury Department pursuant to appropriation laws.
• Preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States, as per the Oath of Office.
• Require principal officers of executive departments to provide written opinions on the duties of their offices.
• Grant reprieves, commutations, and pardons for federal offences against the United States, except in cases of impeachment.
• Make treaties, with the advice and consent of Congress.
• Nominate ambassadors and other officials, again with the advice and consent of Congress.
• Convene one or both houses of Congress during extraordinary occasions and adjourn them when necessary.
• Receive ambassadors and other public ministers.
• Ensure that laws are faithfully executed.
• Commission the officers of the United States.

The President also has certain emergency powers, though these are not expressly granted in the Constitution. For example, Abraham Lincoln unilaterally suspended habeas corpus without Congressional approval in 1861, claiming that the rebellion constituted a national emergency.

The President's power to pardon can be controversial, especially when it appears to be politically motivated. For example, President George W. Bush commuted the sentence of White House staffer Lewis "Scooter" Libby, and President Donald Trump pardoned Roger Stone.

How to elect the President (Electoral College)

The debates over the US Constitution took place in Philadelphia, where 55 delegates convened in May 1787 to revise the Articles of Confederation, the nation's first constitution. The debates were intense and covered various topics, including representation in Congress, slavery, and the new executive branch. On August 6, 1787, the convention accepted the first draft of the Constitution, and by mid-September, they had produced the final document that has governed the United States for over 200 years.

Now, here is an explanation of how the Electoral College, a process established by the Founding Fathers in the Constitution, elects the President:

The Electoral College is a process for electing the President and Vice President of the United States. It is not a physical place, but a process that involves the selection of electors, their meeting, and the counting of their votes by Congress. Each state has a number of electors equal to the number of its members of Congress (both the House and Senate), and including Washington, D.C.'s three electors, there are currently 538 electors in total. Each political party in each state chooses its own slate of potential electors, and on Election Day, voters in each state choose these electors to serve in the Electoral College. The general election is held every four years, and the projected winner is usually announced on election night in November. However, the actual Electoral College vote takes place in mid-December when the electors meet in their states to vote for President and Vice President.

To win the presidential election, a candidate needs to receive at least 270 electoral votes, which is more than half of all the electors. In most states, the winner takes all the electors, but some states have variations of proportional representation. While the Constitution does not require electors to vote for the candidate chosen by their state's popular vote, some states enforce this through fines or other penalties for electors who vote differently. It is possible to win the Electoral College and lose the popular vote, as has happened a few times in history. If no candidate receives the majority of electoral votes, the vote goes to the House of Representatives to decide the President, as has happened twice in history.

Explore related products

The Constitutional Convention of 1787: Constructing the American Republic (Reacting to the Past™)

$19.99 $32.5

Debates in the Federal Convention of 1787 by James Madison, a Member

$0.99 $99

1787: The Grand Convention

$15.65 $28.95

The Debate on the Constitution: Federalist and Anti-Federalist Speeches, Articles, and Letters During the Struggle over Ratification 1787-1788: A Library of America Boxed Set

$60.52 $85

The Debate on the Constitution : Federalist and Antifederalist Speeches, Articles, and Letters During the Struggle over Ratification : Part One, September 1787-February 1788 (Library of America)

$32.82 $42.5

The Debate on the Constitution : Federalist and Antifederalist Speeches, Articles and Letters During the Struggle over Ratification, Part Two: January to August 1788 (Library of America)

$27.9 $42.5

Slave trade

The issue of the slave trade was a contentious topic during the debates over the US Constitution, with strong opinions voiced on both sides. The Constitutional Convention of 1787, held in Philadelphia, saw a bitter dispute emerge over a proposal from South Carolina to prohibit the federal government from regulating the Atlantic slave trade.

The controversy centred on the economic and moral implications of the slave trade, with Southern states relying heavily on slavery as a pivotal part of their economy. The Southern states, led by South Carolina and Georgia, threatened to refuse to join the Union if the Constitution restricted the slave trade. This was a significant concern for the framers, who sought to preserve national unity. As a result, the framers sidestepped the issue of slavery, leaving it to be regulated by individual states, and avoided using explicit terms such as "slave" in the Constitution.

Several delegates, including Luther Martin of Maryland, a slaveholder himself, argued that the slave trade should be subject to federal regulation. He believed that it was inconsistent with the principles of the American Revolution and dishonoured American character. Virginia delegate George Mason, who owned hundreds of slaves, also spoke out against slavery, stating that it discouraged arts and manufactures and corrupted slaveholders. He further warned that slavery would bring "the judgment of heaven on a country." Gouverneur Morris, another delegate, echoed these sentiments, calling slavery a "nefarious institution" and the "curse of heaven."

On the other side of the debate, John Rutledge of South Carolina forcefully responded to calls for federal regulation, stating that "religion and humanity have nothing to do with this question." He insisted that unless the regulation of the slave trade was left to the states, the southernmost states "shall not be parties to the union."

The controversy was ultimately settled through a series of compromises. The Importation Clause, or the Slave Trade Clause, was included in Article 1, Section 9, Clause 1 of the Constitution, prohibiting the federal government from banning the importation of "persons" (referring to enslaved African persons) for 20 years from the Constitution taking effect. This compromise allowed the Southern states to continue the slave trade until 1808, after which President Thomas Jefferson and Congress passed a law banning the international slave trade.

Another compromise was the Three-Fifths Clause in Article 1, Section 2, which apportioned representatives based on the population of free persons and "three-fifths of all other persons," referring to slaves. This gave the Southern states additional representation in the House of Representatives and the Electoral College. Additionally, the Fugitive Slave Clause, in Article IV, Section 2, required the return of runaway slaves to their owners, further protecting the interests of slaveholding states.

Regulation of commerce

The debates over the United States Constitution took place in Philadelphia, with 55 delegates attending the convention in 1787. The debates were held over four months, and the final document was produced on September 17, 1787.

The regulation of commerce was a highly controversial issue during the Constitutional debates. The Commerce Clause, or Article 1, Section 8, Clause 3 of the U.S. Constitution, grants Congress the power "to regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes."

The Southern states, which relied on the export of raw materials, rice, indigo, and tobacco, feared that a New England-dominated Congress might impose export taxes that would harm their economic interests. C.C. Pinckney, a representative of the South, argued that if Congress had the power to regulate trade, the Southern states would be reduced to "nothing more than overseers for the Northern States."

The debate over commerce was closely linked to the issue of slavery. The Southern states' economies depended heavily on agricultural products produced by slaves, and they sought to protect this economic system. They proposed two measures: banning Congress from taxing exports and prohibiting Congress from banning the importation of slaves.

The Commerce Clause has been interpreted and applied in various court cases over the years. In Gibbons v. Ogden (1824), the Supreme Court held that intrastate activity could be regulated under the Commerce Clause if it was part of a larger interstate commercial scheme. In Swift and Company v. United States (1905), the Court ruled that Congress could regulate local commerce if it was part of a continuous "current" of interstate commerce.

The Commerce Clause also affects state governments through the Dormant Commerce Clause, which prohibits states from passing legislation that discriminates against or excessively burdens interstate commerce. For example, in West Lynn Creamery Inc. v. Healy, the Supreme Court struck down a Massachusetts state tax on milk products because it impeded interstate commerce by discriminating against non-Massachusetts entities.

The interpretation of the word "commerce" in the Commerce Clause has been debated, with some arguing it refers simply to trade or exchange, while others contend that it describes a broader concept of commercial and social intercourse between citizens.

Frequently asked questions