Understanding Transfer Pricing: Related Party Definition

Transfer pricing is an accounting and tax concept that aims to establish the prices for goods and services exchanged between subsidiaries, affiliates, or commonly controlled companies that are part of the same larger enterprise. Transfer pricing can lead to tax savings for corporations, but tax authorities may dispute their claims. A transfer price is based on market prices in charging another division, subsidiary, or holding company for services rendered. Companies use transfer pricing to reduce the overall tax burden of the parent company. Companies charge a higher price to divisions in high-tax countries (reducing profit) while charging a lower price (increasing profits) for divisions in low-tax countries. A related party is any entity that can exercise control or significant influence over the operating policies of another entity.

Explore related products

Transfer Pricing Agreements: Structure Advance Pricing Agreements APAs, Cost Contribution Arrangements CCAs, Safe Harbor, Service Contract for OECD ... ... Compliance with Transfer Price Rules

$39.95 $44.95

A practical summary of the 2017 OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines: including the 2020 TP Guidance on Financial Transactions

$60

Transfer Pricing of Intangibles: Empirical Study of Transfer Pricing and the Intangibles: Why Tax Authorities must look beyond Methodology

$200

Transfer Pricing Survival Guide: A management guidance to identifying and mitigating transfer pricing risks

$9.99

Transfer Pricing Guidelines in 2020, Transfer Pricing Impact on Loans and Financial Transactions, Transfer Pricing Impact on Distribution Arrangements (International Tax Law)

$200

Practical Experience with the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (Ifa Congress Seminar Series, 23B)

$95.95

Control and influence

Transfer pricing is a concept in accounting and taxation that determines the prices of goods, services, and even intellectual property exchanged between different divisions of the same company, subsidiaries, or holding companies. Transfer pricing is used to reduce the overall tax burden of the parent company.

Related parties are those that are considered to be "associated companies or enterprises". These are companies that are related or associated with each other directly or indirectly. This means that one company controls the other, or both are controlled by the same person or entity.

The definition of direct and indirect control varies according to the tax laws of each country. However, direct control generally refers to a company that determines the affairs of another company due to shareholding, voting rights, or powers within the articles of association or other regulatory documents.

In the context of global trade, a related party is an individual or business that holds at least a 10% interest in both the exporter and the ultimate consignee. Related parties can also include foreign subsidiaries and parent companies.

Related-party transactions, therefore, refer to the transfer of resources, services, or obligations between related parties, regardless of whether a price is charged. These transactions can include the charging of management fees, licensing of intangible assets, the purchase and resale of tangible goods, financing or loan arrangements, and back-office support services.

Shareholding and ownership

A related party transaction occurs when there is a transfer of resources, services, or obligations between related parties, regardless of whether a price is charged. This can include various business operations such as loans, acquisitions, or sales. In the context of shareholding and ownership, a related party is typically defined as an entity that has a significant influence on or control over another entity due to their shareholding or ownership stake. This control can be direct or indirect. Direct control is usually associated with a company determining the affairs of another company due to its shareholding, voting rights, or powers within the articles of association or other governing documents. Indirect control, on the other hand, refers to situations where companies are controlled by the same person or group of persons, resulting in an affiliation or association between them.

Multinational organisations often have complex structures, with subsidiaries, branches, joint ventures, and partnerships spread across different countries. Within these structures, related parties can include foreign subsidiaries, parent companies, and other associated enterprises. The degree of ownership or shareholding can vary, but a common threshold is a 10% interest in both the exporter and the ultimate consignee in global trade. This level of ownership or influence is considered significant enough to establish a relationship for related-party transactions.

Transfer pricing methods, such as the Comparable Uncontrolled Price method and the Cost-plus method, are used to determine appropriate pricing for related-party transactions. These methods aim to ensure that prices between related parties are comparable to those that would be charged to independent third parties in similar circumstances. By doing so, organisations can mitigate audit risks, satisfy tax authorities, and avoid penalties associated with administrative infractions.

It is important to note that regulations and requirements related to transfer pricing and related-party transactions can vary across different jurisdictions. While the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has promoted the "'arm's length principle'" as an international standard, specific tax laws and enforcement practices may differ from country to country. Therefore, understanding the specific laws and regulations in each relevant jurisdiction is crucial for compliance.

Intra-group transactions

Transfer pricing is a critical concept in intra-group transactions, allowing companies to establish prices for goods and services exchanged between their divisions. These transfer prices are typically based on market prices to determine the cost charged to another division, subsidiary, or holding company for services rendered. By charging above or below the market price, companies can strategically shift profits and costs to different divisions, thereby reducing their overall tax burden.

Multinational enterprises (MNEs) often engage in intra-group transactions, utilizing structures such as subsidiaries, branches, joint ventures, or partnerships across different countries. These cross-border operations can lead to complex tax considerations, as companies seek to optimize their tax liabilities by transferring prices to low-tax jurisdictions.

To ensure fair taxation, tax authorities generally require transfer prices between related enterprises to reflect the prices that would have been set in the open market under similar circumstances, also known as the "arm's length price." This principle, promoted by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), guides transfer pricing practices internationally.

The OECD provides guidelines and methods for valuing related-party transactions, such as the Comparable Uncontrolled Price method, which compares the price of goods or services in intercompany transactions with independent parties in similar circumstances. Other methods, such as the cost-plus method, involve adding the usual margin observed in similar transactions with independent customers. These methods help ensure that intra-group transactions are appropriately priced and comply with tax regulations.

Explore related products

Transfer Pricing in One Lesson: A Practical Guide to Applying the Arm’s Length Principle in Intercompany Transactions (Management for Professionals)

$38.57 $59.99

Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations: Travel Version 2001

$29.95 $68

Transfer Pricing in Manufacturing: An Analysis of the OECD Guidelines (Contributions to Finance and Accounting)

$130.15 $169.99

84 Pcs Jungle Safari Party Favors Set Wild Animals Set for Kids Birthday,Safari Birthday Decorations,Safari Party Decorations,Suitable For Holiday,Themed Parties And Other Related Parties(Animal)

$22.99

CHEERS & BEERS Balloons, Beer Themed Birthday Party Decorations with Beer Mug Banners Latex Balloons for Beer Birthday Wedding Decor

$16.99

200Pcs Halloween Bats Birthday Party Supplies Bloody Bat Paper Plates and Napkins Red and Black Disposable Tableware for Boy Girl Halloween Birthday Party Decorations Serves 50

$23.99

Tax implications

Transfer pricing is an accounting and tax concept that aims to capture the price paid in transactions between related parties, such as subsidiaries, affiliates, or commonly controlled companies that are part of the same larger enterprise. Transfer pricing can lead to tax savings for corporations, but tax authorities may contest their claims. Companies use transfer pricing to reduce the overall tax burden of the parent company. They charge a higher price to divisions in high-tax countries (reducing profit) and a lower price for divisions in low-tax countries (increasing profits).

The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has promoted the acceptance of the "arm's length principle" as the international standard to guide transfer pricing. The arm's length principle states that the conditions imposed between two affiliated enterprises in their commercial or financial relations should be the same as those that would be imposed between independent enterprises. The OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines are the most commonly used and are periodically revised. They set out transfer pricing methods that provide ways to set transfer prices that are arm's length, or to test the transfer price already in place.

There are five recognised OECD transfer pricing methods, divided into two categories: traditional methods and transactional methods. Traditional methods rely on actual transactions and directly compare the terms and conditions in the related-party transaction with those of third parties in comparable transactions. Transactional methods, on the other hand, are less direct and rely on profit levels to determine arm's length prices, measuring the net operating profits of related-party transactions and comparing them to those of independent companies in similar transactions.

The comparable uncontrolled price method is the most commonly used method. It involves comparing the price of the good or service in the intercompany transaction with the price of the same good or service in a transaction between independent parties in similar circumstances. The cost-plus method is another recognised approach, which requires adding the usual margin in similar transactions with independent customers to the acquisition value or production cost of the good or service.

In the day-to-day activity of a company, related-party transactions can include loans, acquisitions, or sales. These transactions have consequent obligations before the tax administration, and companies must provide documentation to justify the prices of these transactions. Local and Master Files are mandatory for all companies and permanent establishments that carry out related-party transactions, as long as certain criteria are met. The taxpayer is obliged to keep these files at their premises for the entire period for which there is a relevant obligation to keep the books and records of the respective fiscal year.

Multinational organisations can face significant compliance challenges with the regulations and administrative requirements around transfer pricing, as they differ from country to country. Customs authorities are also concerned with related-party transactions and any difference between the transaction value and the Customs valuation that might affect duties collected. Imported goods are appraised for the payment of duties, and in the case of non-related party transactions, the transaction value is typically used for this appraisal. However, in a related-party transaction, Customs authorities must determine the value of the goods on which to base import duties.

Comparable uncontrolled pricing

The CUP method compares the price charged for goods or services in a related-party transaction to that charged in a comparable third-party transaction. It is considered the most direct and reliable way to apply the arm's length principle when sufficient data is available. The arm's length principle states that the transfer price between associated enterprises should be equivalent to what the prices would have been in the open market in similar circumstances had the companies not been related.

The internal CUP method involves using comparable transactions within the same company. For instance, if a company sells a product to both related and unrelated parties, the price charged to the unrelated parties can serve as a benchmark for the related transactions. On the other hand, the external CUP method compares the controlled transaction with transactions between two independent entities. For example, a company with no internal comparable transactions can look at similar transactions in the market between unrelated parties.

The CUP method is particularly appropriate for commodity transactions where the same products are sold in both controlled and uncontrolled transactions. It is also suitable when reliable comparables data for uncontrolled transactions is available. By applying the CUP method, companies can ensure compliance with transfer pricing regulations and mitigate potential tax risks.

Frequently asked questions