The Constitution's Administrative Agencies Explained

Administrative agencies are bureaucratic institutions that implement, manage, and administer laws and public policies. They are created through their own organic statutes, which establish new laws, and in doing so, create the respective agencies to interpret, administer, and enforce those new laws. Congress can establish an agency through legislation, and the authority of federal administrative agencies stems from their organic statutes. The Administrative Procedure Act (APA) is the major source of federal administrative agency law, and it ensures that the rule-making and enforcement activities of agencies are conducted fairly and efficiently. Regulatory agencies are central to the process of implementing and enforcing laws, and they can be part of the executive branch or independent agencies.

Explore related products

Administrative Law: Bureaucracy in a Democracy

$213.39 $226.65

Inside Administrative Law: What Matters and Why (Inside Series)

$48 $67.95

Administrative Law (Examples & Explanations Series)

$47 $74.95

Examples & Explanations for Administrative Law

$75.95 $76.95

Understanding Administrative Law (Understanding Series)

$55 $55

Principles of Administrative Law (Concise Hornbook Series)

$70

Agencies are created through their own organic statutes

The authority of federal administrative agencies stems from their organic statutes and must be consistent with constitutional constraints and the scope of authority granted by statute. Federal administrative agencies, when granted the power to do so in a statutory grant of authority from Congress, may promulgate rules that have the force of law. Agencies legislate through rulemaking—the power to promulgate (or issue) regulations. Such regulations are codified in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) and published in the Federal Register. Rules of lesser effect are published in a host of forms, including manuals for agency staff and the public, circulars, bulletins, letter rulings, press releases, and more.

Agencies are created to protect the public interest rather than to vindicate private rights. They oversee and monitor activities in complex areas such as commercial aviation, medical device manufacturing, and securities markets. The APA is the major source for federal administrative agency law, while state agencies' administration and regulation are governed by comparable state acts. For example, under the federal APA and judicial interpretations of the APA, agencies must give notice of proposed rulemaking before adopting the final rule. The final rule must follow a logical outgrowth of the proposed rule and must display the agencies' consideration of all comments received and reviewed.

The APA is a remedial statute designed to ensure uniformity and openness in the procedures used by federal agencies. It is a comprehensive regulatory scheme governing regulations, adjudications, and rulemaking in general terms. The APA categorizes administrative functions into formal and informal rulemaking and adjudication, which have binding effects, as well as guidance, which has no binding effect. The APA further prescribes certain procedural rules by which the agencies need to follow before acting in one of the functions listed.

Agencies are created to protect public interest

While the US Constitution does not explicitly mention administrative agencies, their creation and function are governed by administrative law, which is a body of law encompassing statutes, rules, judicial precedents, and executive orders. These administrative laws define the powers and responsibilities of administrative agencies. Agencies are delegated power by Congress to carry out certain prerogatives, and they are created through their own organic statutes, which establish new laws for the agencies to interpret, administer, and enforce.

Agencies are generally created to protect the public interest rather than to vindicate private rights. They are tasked with overseeing and monitoring activities in complex areas such as commercial aviation, medical device manufacturing, and securities markets. For example, the Access Board is an independent federal agency that promotes equality for people with disabilities through accessible design standards. The Federal Trade Commission, Securities and Exchange Commission, and Environmental Protection Agency are other examples of agencies that protect the public interest by enacting and enforcing rules and regulations.

The Administrative Procedure Act (APA) is a key statute that provides for the roles and powers of agencies and the procedures they must follow. The APA categorizes administrative functions into formal and informal rulemaking and adjudication, both of which have binding effects. In its rulemaking function, an agency must give notice of proposed rulemaking and consider all comments received before adopting a final rule. Adjudication within an agency is often handled by an Administrative Law Judge, who is part of the agency but must remain independent from its officials.

Despite their important role in protecting the public interest, agencies face challenges in fulfilling their mandate. One issue is "agency capture," where industry representatives have disproportionate influence over agency decisions due to frequent appearances before the agency, while public interest groups are underrepresented. This can lead to regulatory delays or roadblocks that hinder the agency's ability to protect people and the environment. Another challenge is the potential for career staffers within agencies to develop a bias in favor of their agency's interests, which may conflict with the broader public interest.

Congress can establish an agency through legislation

The US Constitution does not establish administrative agencies or explicitly outline how they may be created. However, the Supreme Court has acknowledged that Congress has broad constitutional authority to establish and shape the federal bureaucracy. Congress can use its Article I lawmaking powers to create federal agencies and offices within those agencies. It can also design agencies' basic structures and operations and prescribe, within constitutional limits, how those holding agency offices are appointed and removed.

Congress's control over agency authority is not limited to initial decisions made when the agency is created. Instead, Congress can expand, narrow, or alter the authority delegated to an agency at any time. Congress may also revoke delegated authority, often using sunset provisions to terminate a delegation on a specified date.

The legislative process through which Congress establishes an agency typically involves both chambers of Congress—the House and the Senate. A bill is introduced and assigned to a committee, whose members will research, discuss, and make changes to the bill. The bill is then put before the first chamber to be voted on. If it passes, it goes through a similar process in the second chamber. Once both chambers pass the bill, they must agree on a single version. The bill is then presented to the President, who can approve or veto it. If the President vetoes the bill, Congress can override the veto, and the bill becomes law.

Explore related products

Administrative Law and Regulatory Policy: Problems, Text, and Cases (Aspen Casebook Series)

$200 $359

Federal Administrative Law, Cases and Materials (University Casebook Series)

$305

Administrative Law: Cases and Materials [Connected eBook with Study Center] (Aspen Casebook Series)

$190 $359

Administrative Law: Cases and Materials [Connected eBook with Study Center] (Aspen Casebook)

$41.05 $345

Administrative Law: A Lifecycle Approach [Connected eBook with Study Center] (Aspen Casebook) (Aspen Casebook Series)

$331.23 $332

Administrative Law for Public Managers

$26.41 $51.99

Agencies are bureaucratic institutions that implement and manage law and public policy

Agencies are bureaucratic institutions that implement, manage, and administer law and public policy. They are created through their own organic statutes, which establish new laws and, in turn, create the respective agencies to interpret, administer, and enforce those laws. Agencies are delegated power by Congress (or, in the case of a state agency, the state legislature) to take on the responsibility for carrying out certain prerogatives from Congress. Generally, administrative agencies are created to protect a public interest rather than to vindicate private rights.

The authority of federal administrative agencies stems from their organic statutes and must be consistent with constitutional constraints and the scope of authority granted by statute. Federal administrative agencies, when granted the power to do so in a statutory grant of authority from Congress, may promulgate rules that have the force of law. Agencies "legislate" through rulemaking—the power to promulgate (or issue) regulations. Such regulations are codified in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) and published in the Federal Register. Rules of lesser effect are published in various forms, including manuals for agency staff and the public, circulars, bulletins, letter rulings, press releases, and more.

The Administrative Procedure Act (APA) is the major source of federal administrative agency law, while state agencies' administration and regulation are governed by comparable state acts. The APA provides for the roles and powers of all the agencies and the procedures they must follow in their functions. It categorizes administrative functions into formal and informal rulemaking and adjudication, which have binding effects, as well as guidance, which has no binding effect. The APA further prescribes certain procedural rules that agencies must follow before acting.

Agencies operate under their interpretative rules. The law permits parties before the agency to argue alternative interpretations, and agencies are supposed to respond to these arguments. In its adjudicatory functions, agencies often have their own judicial body, known as an Administrative Law Judge, who is part of the agency but must remain independent from the agency officials involved in certain actions.

Regulatory agencies are pivotal in safeguarding the public interest

Regulatory agencies are essential in safeguarding the public interest, and their role is pivotal in upholding legislative intentions and adapting to the dynamic needs of the sectors they oversee. Administrative law, which governs the administration and regulation of federal and state government agencies, plays a crucial role in shaping public policies and safeguarding public health.

The authority of federal administrative agencies stems from their organic statutes and must adhere to constitutional constraints. These agencies are delegated power by Congress to carry out specific responsibilities, such as enforcing federal laws and regulations. For instance, agencies like OSHA ensure workplace safety and protect employee rights, while the EPA implements federal environmental laws that impact various industries.

The Administrative Procedure Act (APA) is a key statute that outlines the roles and powers of agencies and the procedures they must follow. APA categorizes administrative functions into formal and informal rulemaking and adjudication, ensuring uniformity and transparency in the decision-making process. The APA also provides for public participation, a vital aspect of democratic governance, allowing individuals and businesses to have a say in rule-making.

However, regulatory agencies face challenges, such as regulatory capture, where special interests may be prioritized over the general public's interests. This can occur when an industry gains influence over its regulating agency, as seen in the example of nuclear power regulation. To counter this, vigorous public scrutiny and Congressional oversight are necessary.

Overall, regulatory agencies are crucial in safeguarding the public interest by ensuring that laws are enforced fairly and efficiently, adapting to the changing needs of the sectors they regulate, and balancing the authority of government agencies with the rights of individuals and businesses.

Frequently asked questions