Direct Representation: Constitutional Amendments For The People

The 17th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, ratified in 1913, was a landmark legislation that modified Article I, Section 3, to allow for the direct election of senators by the people. Prior to this amendment, senators were chosen by state legislatures, which often led to deadlocks and long vacancies. The rise of the Populist Party and increasing calls for reform in the late 19th century added momentum to the movement for direct representation. Senator Joseph Bristow of Kansas played a key role in proposing a substitute amendment without the race rider, which was adopted by the Senate in 1911 and later approved by the House of Representatives.

Explore related products

The Constitution of the United States and The Declaration of Independence

$1.99 $6.95

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights

$9.99 $9.99

The Architecture of Constitutional Amendments: History, Law, Politics

$54.85 $60.95

The Constitution of the United States: And All Its Amendments

$6.97 $6.97

The Constitutional Amendments: 1789 To the Present

$98.39 $149

The Thirteenth Amendment and American Freedom: A Legal History (Constitutional Amendments)

$78 $78

The 17th Amendment (1913)

The 17th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, ratified in 1913, was a significant development in American political history, as it provided for the direct election of U.S. senators by the people. Before this amendment, senators were chosen by state legislatures, with each state legislature electing two senators to serve six-year terms. This process was outlined in Article I, Section 3 of the Constitution, which the 17th Amendment modified.

The push for direct election of senators had been building for some time. As early as 1826, resolutions calling for direct popular election appeared in the House of Representatives, but none succeeded. In the following decades, disputes over Senate elections led to deadlocks, leaving Senate seats vacant for extended periods. By the 1890s, support for direct election had grown significantly, and reformers advocated for change.

The 17th Amendment was first proposed by Senator Joseph Bristow of Kansas in 1911. It removed the phrase "chosen by the Legislature thereof" from Article I, Section 3, and replaced it with "elected by the people thereof." This change ensured that senators would be directly elected by the citizens of their states. The amendment also addressed the filling of Senate vacancies, allowing the governor or executive authority of a state to appoint a senator until a general election could be held.

The amendment was passed by Congress on May 13, 1912, and ratified on April 8, 1913, by three-quarters of state legislatures (36 states). The first senator elected under the 17th Amendment was Augustus Octavius Bacon of Georgia, who ran unopposed on July 15, 1913. The transition to direct election was gradual, with the process completed by March 4, 1919, when senators chosen in the 1918 election took office.

The 17th Amendment marked a shift towards greater democracy and direct representation in the United States, empowering citizens to have a more direct say in who represented them in the Senate. It was a notable departure from the original intentions of the framers of the Constitution, who had envisioned a different system for electing senators, but it reflected the evolving needs and demands of the American people.

Article I, Section 3 modified

Article I, Section 3 of the U.S. Constitution originally provided for the election of senators by state legislatures. This was modified by the Seventeenth Amendment, which was passed by Congress and ratified by the states in 1913. The amendment restates the first paragraph of Article I, Section 3, replacing the phrase "chosen by the Legislature thereof" with "elected by the people thereof". This change allowed for the direct election of senators by the people, rather than by state legislatures.

The push for direct election of senators began as early as 1826, with resolutions appearing in the House of Representatives, but none were successful at first. After the Civil War, disputes among state legislators over Senate elections resulted in many deadlocks, leaving Senate seats vacant for extended periods. By 1911, a growing number of senators were elected by their state's population, either as nominees of their party's primary or in a general election. These popularly elected senators advocated strongly for a direct election process.

Senator Joseph Bristow of Kansas proposed a Senate resolution to amend the Constitution in 1911, which was soon followed by other senators calling for reform. The amendment passed the Senate on June 12, 1911, and was then approved by the House of Representatives before being sent to the states for ratification. On April 8, 1913, Connecticut became the final state needed to give the amendment the required three-fourths majority for ratification.

The Seventeenth Amendment not only provided for the direct election of senators but also addressed vacancies. It allows the governor or executive authority of a state, if authorized by the state's legislature, to appoint a senator temporarily until a general election occurs. This ensures that Senate seats remain filled and functioning, even in the event of unexpected vacancies.

The modification of Article I, Section 3 through the Seventeenth Amendment was a significant shift from the original intent of the Constitution's framers. It empowered the people to directly elect their senators, moving away from the previous system where state legislatures held that power. This change towards greater direct representation in the Senate was a result of evolving political dynamics and the recognition of the importance of ensuring that all Senate seats remain filled through a timely election process.

Direct election of senators

The Seventeenth Amendment to the United States Constitution established the direct election of United States senators in each state. Before this amendment, senators were appointed by state legislatures, which led to corruption and electoral deadlocks.

The Seventeenth Amendment overrides Article I, Section 3, Clauses 1 and 2 of the original Constitution, which stated that senators were to be "chosen by the Legislature thereof". The amendment replaces this phrase with "elected by the people thereof". This change allows for senators to be elected directly by the voting public during elections.

Calls for a constitutional amendment regarding Senate elections started in the early 19th century, with Henry R. Storrs proposing an amendment for popular election in 1826. Similar amendments were introduced in 1829 and 1855, with the "most prominent" proponent being Andrew Johnson, who raised the issue in 1868. In the 1860s, there was a major congressional dispute over the issue, with the House and Senate voting to veto the appointment of John P. Stockton to the Senate due to his approval by a plurality of the New Jersey Legislature rather than a majority.

In 1892, the Populist Party's Omaha Platform called for the direct election of senators, and Oregon became the first state to conduct its senatorial elections by popular vote in 1908. In 1906, William Randolph Hearst hired novelist David Graham Phillips to write a series of articles on the Senate, which offered an unsympathetic account of senators as pawns of industrialists and financiers. Published in Cosmopolitan magazine, Phillips' series, "The Treason of the Senate," helped to increase support for direct election.

In 1911, Senator Joseph Bristow of Kansas offered a Senate resolution to amend the Constitution, and soon other senators called for reform. The final version of the proposed amendment was produced in 1912, and it was issued to the states for ratification. On April 8, 1913, the Seventeenth Amendment was ratified, and it was certified on May 31. Augustus Bacon of Georgia was the first senator directly elected under the terms of the Seventeenth Amendment, on July 15, 1913.

Explore related products

The Founders' Second Amendment: Origins of the Right to Bear Arms

$21.74 $28.95

The People’s Constitution: 200 Years, 27 Amendments, and the Promise of a More Perfect Union

$18.34 $45

The Second Amendment Primer: A Citizen's Guidebook to the History, Sources, and Authorities for the Constitutional Guarantee of the Right to Keep and Bear Arms

$12.99 $12.99

The Second Amendment: A Biography

$9.99 $18.99

Loaded: A Disarming History of the Second Amendment (City Lights Open Media)

$11.98 $16.95

The Constitution of the United States of America, with the Bill of Rights and all of the Amendments; The Declaration of Independence; and the Articles of Confederation

$4.5 $4.5

Removal of the 'race rider'

The 17th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which was passed in 1913, allows for the direct election of senators by the people. This amendment was the result of a long effort to reform the process of selecting senators, which previously relied on state legislatures.

The original Constitution, adopted in 1788, established the Senate as a body where each state would have equal representation, with senators chosen by their state legislatures. Over time, this system led to numerous issues, including deadlocks between state legislators, long periods of Senate vacancies, and the influence of special interests or political machines.

In the late 19th century, progressive reformers advocated for a direct election process to make the Senate more accountable to the people. The rise of the Populist Party during this period further emphasised the need for reform. While resolutions calling for direct election were introduced in the House of Representatives as early as 1826, they consistently faced opposition in the Senate.

In 1911, Senator Joseph L. Bristow of Kansas proposed a substitute amendment that removed the "race rider". The "race rider" was a provision in the original House Joint Resolution 39 that aimed to prevent Federal intervention in cases of racial discrimination among voters. Senator Bristow's amended resolution provided for the direct election of senators without this controversial clause.

The Senate adopted the amended joint resolution by a close vote in May 1911. After more than a year, the House accepted the change, and on April 8, 1913, the resolution became the 17th Amendment upon ratification by three-quarters of the states. This amendment modified Article I, Section 3 of the Constitution, replacing the phrase "chosen by the Legislature thereof" with "elected by the people thereof".

State legislature appointments

The Seventeenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, ratified in 1913, was a landmark legislation that significantly altered the process of electing senators, transitioning from state legislature appointments to direct elections. This amendment directly addressed Article I, Section 3 of the Constitution, which initially provided for the election of senators by state legislatures.

The idea of amending the Constitution to allow for direct elections of senators emerged as early as 1826, with the first proposal introduced in the House of Representatives. However, it wasn't until the late 19th century that this idea gained momentum due to several issues with Senate elections. Disputes among state legislators resulted in deadlocks, leaving Senate seats vacant for extended periods. Special interests and political machines also exerted control over state legislatures, leading to concerns about senators serving private interests rather than the people.

The rise of the People's Party, or the Populist Party, further fuelled the push for direct elections. Despite multiple resolutions passed by the House of Representatives, the Senate consistently refused to vote on a constitutional amendment. In response, many states invoked Article V of the Constitution, applying for conventions to propose amendments. As the number of applications approached the required two-thirds threshold, Congress was compelled to act.

Senator Joseph Bristow of Kansas played a pivotal role in this process, offering a Senate resolution in 1911 that led to other senators advocating for reform. The resolution proposed a direct election process, removing the "race rider" meant to prevent federal intervention in cases of racial discrimination among voters. The resolution passed the Senate in June 1911 and subsequently moved through the House of Representatives and on to the states for ratification.

The Seventeenth Amendment not only allowed voters to cast direct votes for senators but also provided for the governor or executive authority of each state to appoint a senator temporarily in the event of a vacancy until a general election could be held. This amendment marked a significant shift in representation, empowering citizens to directly elect their representatives and hold them accountable.

Frequently asked questions