Who Drafted Japan's Postwar Constitution?

Following World War II, Japan underwent a period of Allied occupation and rehabilitation led by U.S. General Douglas MacArthur, the Supreme Commander for the Allied Powers. During this time, a new constitution was drafted for Japan, primarily by American civilian officials. This constitution, written in 1946 and adopted in 1947, replaced the Meiji Constitution of 1889 and included key principles such as popular sovereignty, pacifism, and the protection of individual rights. While the exact number of individuals involved in the drafting process is unclear, it is known that MacArthur played a significant role and was supported by a team of young American staff members.

Explore related products

The Constitution of Japan: A Contextual Analysis (Constitutional Systems of the World)

$44.95

The Constitution of Japan: With the Laws Pertaining Thereto, and the Imperial Oath and Speech; Promulgated at the Imperial Palace, February 11th, 1889 (Classic Reprint)

$29.72

Bilingual United States Constitution (2002) ISBN: 487791112X [Japanese Import]

$37.36

Embracing Defeat: Japan in the Wake of World War II

$21.33 $23.99

The Constitution of the Empire of Japan: With the Speeches Addressed to Students of Political Science in the Johns Hopkins University (Classic Reprint)

$29.72 $23.97

The Quest for Japan's New Constitution: An Analysis of Visions and Constitutional Reform Proposals 1980-2009 (Routledge Contemporary Japan Series)

$65.54 $68.99

The US-led Allied occupation of Japan

The occupation can be divided into three phases. The initial phase focused on punishing and reforming Japan for its past militarism and expansionism. War crimes trials were held in Tokyo, the Japanese army was dismantled, and former military officers were banned from political leadership positions. Additionally, the expression of patriotism was eliminated from schools and public life, and Shinto was abolished as the state religion.

The second phase, beginning in 1947, shifted towards economic rehabilitation and suppressing dissent. The Allies introduced land reforms to benefit tenant farmers and reduce the power of wealthy landowners. They also attempted to break up large business conglomerates, or zaibatsu, to further democratize economic power and create competition. However, this reform was not fully implemented due to concerns about hindering Japan's economic recovery. During this time, the emergence of an economic crisis and the spread of communism led to a reconsideration of occupation policies.

The third phase, starting in 1950, focused on securing a formal peace treaty to end the war and the occupation. By this time, the perception of international threats had shifted, and the idea of a re-armed Japan was no longer seen as a concern. Instead, the focus turned towards the threat of communism, particularly in Asia. The final agreement allowed the United States to maintain its military bases in Japan, and a bilateral security pact was established between the two countries.

During the occupation, Japan also adopted a new constitution, known as the MacArthur Constitution due to the significant influence of General MacArthur in its drafting. This constitution downgraded the emperor's status to a symbolic role without political control and emphasized popular sovereignty, pacifism, and the protection of civil and human rights. It also included a renunciation of war, eliminating all non-defensive armed forces. The constitution was adopted on November 3, 1946, and came into effect on May 3, 1947, replacing the Meiji Constitution of 1889.

General Douglas MacArthur's role

General Douglas MacArthur played a significant role in shaping post-war Japan and its constitution. As the Supreme Commander for the Allied Powers, he directed the Japanese Prime Minister, Kijūrō Shidehara, to draft a new constitution for Japan after its surrender in 1945. MacArthur's primary objective was to transform Japan from a militarist, feudal society into a pro-Western modern democracy. To achieve this, he implemented widespread military, political, economic, and social reforms.

MacArthur believed that retaining Emperor Hirohito as a constitutional figurehead was crucial to maintaining control over the population and ensuring a peaceful transition. He shielded the Emperor from war crimes and carefully managed his image to distance him from the militarists. MacArthur's plan, code-named Operation Blacklist, was designed to use the Emperor to retain control over Japan and help the US achieve its objectives.

MacArthur also oversaw the demilitarization and democratization of Japan. He dismantled the Japanese Army, banned former military officers from political leadership, and introduced women's rights, labour unions, land reform, and civil liberties. MacArthur's staff helped draft the new constitution, which included a symbolic role for the Emperor, guarantees of civil and human rights, and a renunciation of war—a clause that would have an enormous impact on Japan's postwar history.

The constitution-drafting process involved collaboration between MacArthur's team and a committee of Japanese scholars. The MacArthur draft initially proposed a unicameral legislature, but this was changed to a bicameral system at the insistence of the Japanese. The final draft, adopted on 3 November 1946, reflected MacArthur's influence and set the framework for Japan's postwar governance.

The Meiji Constitution's flaws

Following the Second World War, the Japanese constitution was drafted by a committee of primarily American scholars and lawyers, with input from a small number of Japanese scholars. This group, often referred to as the "GHQ drafters," consisted of around 25 individuals, including a core group of about half a dozen key members who played the most active roles. Among the better-known members were Arthur E. Sutherland, a law professor from Yale University, and Courtney Whitney, a lawyer and close aide to General MacArthur. The process of drafting the constitution began in early 1946 and it was promulgated on November 3 of that year.

Now, here is the response to your question about the flaws of the Meiji Constitution:

The Meiji Constitution, enacted in 1889 and in force until 1947, was Japan's first modern constitution. While it established a constitutional monarchy and introduced Western-style political institutions, it had several inherent flaws that contributed to Japan's political and military trajectory in the first half of the 20th century.

One of the primary flaws was the concentration of power in the hands of the Emperor and the executive branch, particularly the Cabinet. The Meiji Constitution vested supreme authority in the Emperor, defining him as "sacred and inviolable," with the power to exercise "supreme command of the Army and Navy." While the Cabinet was responsible to the Imperial Diet (Japan's parliament), the Diet had limited powers and the Cabinet was not directly accountable to it. This lack of effective checks and balances allowed the military to exert significant influence over the government and pursue aggressive foreign policies with minimal oversight.

Another flaw was the limited franchise and the unequal distribution of voting power. The Meiji Constitution established a bicameral legislature with a directly elected House of Representatives and a House of Peers composed of appointed and hereditary members. However, the voting requirements were restrictive, with only male citizens over 25 years old who paid a certain amount in taxes eligible to vote. This excluded a large portion of the population from the political process, particularly the working class and women. As a result, the government was not fully representative of the people, and policies tended to favor the interests of the elite.

Additionally, the Meiji Constitution lacked a clear commitment to individual rights and liberties. While it included provisions for freedom of speech, assembly, and religion, these rights were not strongly protected and could be easily overridden by the government in the name of public order or state security. The lack of an independent judiciary to uphold these rights further weakened their effectiveness.

Finally, the Meiji Constitution failed to provide a mechanism for its own amendment and revision. It was designed to be a rigid document, difficult to change, which made it increasingly outdated and ineffective as social and political conditions in Japan evolved. This rigidity contributed to the rise of extra-constitutional means of policy-making, such as the use of secret agreements and the influence of military factions, further undermining democratic principles.

In conclusion, the flaws in the Meiji Constitution included the concentration of power in the executive, limited franchise and unequal voting rights, inadequate protection of individual liberties, and a lack of provision for constitutional amendment. These flaws had significant consequences for Japan's political development and contributed to the rise of militarism and authoritarianism in the lead-up to World War II. The post-war constitution, drafted by the GHQ, sought to address these issues by establishing a more democratic and peaceful framework for Japan's governance.

Explore related products

The Constitution of the United States and The Declaration of Independence

$1.99 $6.95

The Birth Of Japan's Postwar Constitution

$56.99 $74.99

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights

$9.99 $9.99

Eight Days at Yalta: How Churchill, Roosevelt, and Stalin Shaped the Post-War World

$23.47 $28

Enduring Alliance: A History of NATO and the Postwar Global Order

$19.34 $34.95

Australia's Constitution after Whitlam (Cambridge Studies in Constitutional Law, Series Number 17)

$28.3 $45

The Potsdam Declaration

The Constitution of Japan, the country's supreme law, was primarily written by American civilian officials during the occupation of Japan after World War II. It was adopted on November 3, 1946, and came into effect on May 3, 1947, replacing the Meiji Constitution of 1889. The constitution was drafted by a committee of Japanese scholars formed by Prime Minister Kijūrō Shidehara, per the directive of U.S. General Douglas MacArthur, the Supreme Commander for the Allied Powers. MacArthur later reversed course and presented his own draft, which was reviewed and modified by the scholars before its adoption.

Now, onto the Potsdam Declaration:

The declaration was released to the press in Potsdam and simultaneously transmitted to the Office of War Information (OWI) in Washington. It was broadcast in English and Japanese, and leaflets describing the declaration were dropped over Japan by American bombers. The Japanese Prime Minister Suzuki Kantarō's response to the ultimatum was "mokusatsu," which was debated in translation but generally interpreted as a refusal or ignoring of the declaration.

The impact on Japan's postwar history

The Constitution of Japan was written primarily by American civilian officials during the US-led Allied occupation of Japan after World War II. It was adopted on November 3, 1946, and came into effect on May 3, 1947, replacing the Meiji Constitution of 1889. The constitution was drafted at the direction of US General Douglas MacArthur, the Supreme Commander for the Allied Powers, and was based on the principles of popular sovereignty, pacifism, the renunciation of war, and individual rights.

The impact of the postwar constitution on Japan's history has been significant, particularly in terms of demilitarization, political reform, and the role of the Emperor. Firstly, the constitution's explicit renunciation of war and prohibition on maintaining military forces have had a profound impact on Japan's security policies and international relations. Article 9 of the constitution, which states that "the Japanese people forever renounce war as a sovereign right of the nation and the threat or use of force as means of settling international disputes", has guided Japan's commitment to pacifism and non-militarization in the postwar era. This has contributed to Japan's focus on economic development and soft power, rather than military power, in the international arena.

However, the interpretation and potential revision of Article 9 have also been a source of debate in Japan's postwar history. The retention of a de facto military, known as the Self-Defense Forces, and the hosting of US military bases have led to discussions about the true extent of Japan's demilitarization. In the 2010s, then-prime minister Shinzo Abe attempted to revise Article 9 to explicitly recognize the existence of the Self-Defense Forces, but his efforts were unsuccessful. The debate around this issue highlights the ongoing impact of the postwar constitution on Japan's security policies and the continued commitment to pacifism by a majority of the Japanese people.

Secondly, the postwar constitution brought about significant political reforms in Japan. It established a parliamentary system with three branches of government: the National Diet (legislative), the Cabinet led by a Prime Minister (executive), and the Supreme Court (judicial). This system decentralized power away from the Emperor and placed more power in the hands of elected officials, reflecting a shift towards popular sovereignty. The constitution also guaranteed individual rights, including legal equality, freedom of assembly, association, and speech, due process, and the right to a fair trial. These political reforms contributed to the development of a more democratic and rights-respecting political system in Japan.

Lastly, the postwar constitution significantly altered the role of the Emperor in Japan. Under the Meiji Constitution, the Emperor was the supreme leader and held supreme political power. In contrast, the postwar constitution limited the Emperor's role to matters of state delineated in the constitution and reduced his status to a symbolic figurehead. The Emperor became "the symbol of the State and of the unity of the people" but carried out only ceremonial duties, with the potential to delegate these duties as provided by law. This change in the Emperor's role reflected a break from the past and a move towards a more democratic and modern political system in Japan.

In conclusion, the postwar constitution of Japan, written under the direction of American civilian officials, has had a profound impact on the country's history. It led to demilitarization and a commitment to pacifism, brought about political reforms and the establishment of a parliamentary system, and altered the role of the Emperor. These changes have shaped Japan's domestic politics, international relations, and societal norms in the postwar era, contributing to the development of a more democratic and peaceful nation.

Frequently asked questions