European Reactions To The Ottoman Constitution Of 1876

The Ottoman Constitution of 1876 was the first written constitution in the Muslim world, and it had a significant impact on the country and its subjects. The constitution was the culmination of a series of nineteenth-century reforms aimed at modernizing the Ottoman Empire and securing its territorial integrity. It established all subjects as Ottomans, granting them equal rights and liberties, regardless of their religion. This move was influenced by pressure from European powers to address the discrimination of religious minorities within the Empire. The constitution also reaffirmed the sovereignty of the Sultan as the Padishah and Sovereign of all Ottomans and the protector of the Muslim religion. The document was translated into multiple languages, including Oriental-style and Western-style versions, and was officially published in various newspapers. The Ottoman Constitution of 1876 was put on hold after the Russo-Turkish War but was later restored during the Second Constitutional Era, which began with the Young Turk Revolution in 1908.

Explore related products

Reform in the Ottoman Empire, 1856-1876 (Princeton Legacy Library)

$39.41 $79

Negotiating the Ottoman Constitution 1839-1876 (Collection Turcica, 24)

$112

Nationalism: A World History

$25.99 $39.95

The Habsburg Empire: A New History

$28 $28

Constitution Ottomane: Promulguee Le 7 Zilhidje 1293, 11/23 Decembre 1876 (1898) (French Edition)

$21.95

Afghanistan Rising: Islamic Law and Statecraft between the Ottoman and British Empires

$36.77 $57

The Constitution's significance as the first written constitution in the Muslim world

The Ottoman Constitution of 1876 was the first written constitution in the Muslim world. It was in effect from 1876 to 1878, during the First Constitutional Era, and again from 1908 to 1922, in the Second Constitutional Era. The constitution was drafted by Western-educated Ottoman Armenian Krikor Odian, who was an advisor to Midhat Pasha. It was written during the reign of Sultan Abdul Hamid II, who pledged to uphold it.

The constitution was significant because it established the subjects of the Empire as "Ottomans" under the law, regardless of their religion. This meant that all subjects were guaranteed certain liberties, such as freedom of the press and free education. The constitution also reaffirmed the equality of all Ottoman subjects, including their right to serve in the new Chamber of Deputies. It was an assertion that the empire was capable of resolving its problems and had the right to remain intact.

The constitution was influenced by the Armenian National Constitution of 1863, which was drafted by Western-educated Armenians of the Ottoman Empire. The Ottoman Constitution of 1876 was also shaped by the ideals of the Young Ottomans, who dreamed of an empire in which "there would be neither Muslim nor non-Muslim but only Ottomans". This ideology led to the formation of groups advocating for real reform, such as the Committee of Union and Progress.

The constitution was published in multiple languages, including Ottoman Turkish, with translations targeting both adherents of Islam and Christians and Jews. It was officially published in various newspapers and reprinted by other publications. The constitution represented the influence of European political thought and the pressure from Europeans to address discrimination against religious minorities within the Ottoman Empire.

The Ottoman Constitution of 1876 was the first and only constitution of the Ottoman Empire. It was significant as the first written constitution in the Muslim world, establishing principles of equality, liberty, and representation for all subjects, regardless of their religious or ethnic background.

The influence of European powers on the Constitution

Secondly, the constitution itself was drafted with an awareness of European pressures on the issue of discrimination against religious minorities. The constitution reaffirmed the equality of all Ottoman subjects, regardless of religion, and their right to serve in the new Chamber of Deputies. This was a significant departure from previous religious-based discrimination and was likely influenced by European ideas of equality and religious freedom.

Thirdly, the Ottoman administration drafted the constitution with an uneven representational scheme that favored the European provinces by a 2:1 ratio. This suggests a direct influence of European powers on the political structure of the empire, indicating that European provinces were given greater representation to appease European powers and potentially reduce external pressure.

Furthermore, the constitution was translated into multiple languages, including Western-style versions for Christian and Jewish citizens and foreigners residing in the empire. This recognition of linguistic diversity and the need for translation, particularly for non-Muslim populations, demonstrates an accommodation towards European populations within the empire.

Lastly, the constitution's provisions regarding individual liberties, freedom of the press, and the protection of religious exercise reflect values that were prominent in Europe during this time. These provisions granted rights to all subjects, regardless of religion, which may have been influenced by European notions of individual rights and religious freedom.

In conclusion, the Constitution of the Ottoman Empire in 1876 was significantly influenced by European powers and ideas. It reflected a modernization effort, addressed religious discrimination, and incorporated principles of equality, individual liberties, and freedom of the press, which were prevalent in contemporary Europe. The constitution also recognized the influence of European provinces and populations within the empire, indicating a direct response to European pressures and the desire to maintain positive relations with neighboring powers.

The Constitution's role in the Ottoman Empire's modernisation

The Ottoman Constitution of 1876 was significant in the modernisation of the Ottoman Empire. It was the first written constitution in the Muslim world, marking the culmination of the nineteenth-century reforms. The constitution was a proclamation of Ottomanism and patriotism, asserting the empire's ability to resolve its issues and maintain its integrity. It established all subjects as "Ottomans", regardless of their religion, and granted them equal rights and liberties, such as freedom of the press and education.

The constitution played a crucial role in the empire's modernisation by introducing secularisation and replacing religious law. This move towards secularism also extended to the military, with the constitution leading to the modernisation and professionalisation of the Ottoman military according to Western European models. The constitution also brought about banking system reforms and the decriminalisation of homosexuality.

Additionally, the constitution contributed to the multi-party political landscape of the empire. It led to the formation of various political groups and parties, such as the Committee of Union and Progress (CUP). The Second Constitutional Era, which began with the restoration of the 1876 constitution after the Young Turk Revolution in 1908, brought multi-party politics and a two-stage electoral system to the empire.

The constitution also had an impact on the representation of different regions within the empire. To appease European powers, the Ottoman administration drafted an uneven representational scheme that favoured the European provinces. This reflected the external pressures and influences from European countries, with whom the empire had been forging alliances since the 19th century.

Overall, the Ottoman Constitution of 1876 was a significant step towards the modernisation of the Ottoman Empire. It brought about political, social, and legal reforms that moved the empire towards secularism, multi-party politics, and equal rights for its subjects, regardless of their religion.

Explore related products

Ottoman Civil Officialdom: A Social History (Princeton Studies on the Near East)

$71 $75

Formation of the Modern State: The Ottoman Empire, Sixteenth to Eighteenth Centuries (Suny the Social and Economic History of the Middle East)

$17.06 $19.95

The Present State of Turkey; or, A Description of the Political, Civil, and Religious Constitution, Government, and Laws, of the Ottoman Empire ... ... the Principalities of Moldavia and Wallachia

$39.95

The Present State of Turkey: Or, a Description of the Political, Civil, and Religious Constitution, Government, and Laws, of the Ottoman Empire; the ... and of the Liberal and Mechanical Arts

$39.95 $36.97

The Making of the Modern Chinese State: 1600–1950

$52.24 $54.99

The Present State Of Turkey, Or A Description Of The Political Civil And Religious Constitution Governmentand Laws Of The Ottoman Empire, 1

$40.95

How the Constitution addressed religious minorities

The Ottoman Empire was the most religiously diverse empire in Europe and Asia. Its treatment of religious minorities varied throughout its history. During the golden age of the empire, the millet system promised its Christian subjects better treatment than non-Christians experienced in Christian Europe. However, during the decline and fall of the empire, atrocities were committed against Christian minorities. Notable cases of persecution include the Constantinople massacre of 1821, the Chios massacre, the Destruction of Psara, the Batak massacre, the Hamidian massacres, the Adana massacre, the Thracian Bulgarian ethnic cleansing of 1913, the Great Famine of Mount Lebanon, and the Armenian, Greek, and Assyrian genocides.

The Ottoman Constitution of 1876 was written by members of the Young Ottomans, notably Midhat Pasha, who dreamed of an empire in which "there would be neither Muslim nor non-Muslim but only Ottomans". The constitution reaffirmed the equality of all Ottoman subjects, regardless of their religion, and established them as "Ottomans", with the Sultan titled as the "Padishah and Sovereign of all Ottomans", rather than "of the Turks". It also maintained the principle of protecting the free exercise of all religions recognised in the empire, granting religious privileges to different communities as long as no offence was committed against public order or good morals.

The constitution was preceded by the Nationality Law of 1869, which established a common and equal citizenship for all Ottomans, regardless of race or religion. The constitution built upon these ideas, focusing on keeping the state together. It created an elected Chamber of Deputies and an appointed Senate, but it only placed minimal restrictions on the Sultan's power. The constitution was in effect from 1876 to 1878 during the First Constitutional Era and was later reinstated from 1908 to 1922 during the Second Constitutional Era.

The constitution was well-received by reform-oriented groups, including the Young Turks (the CUP and liberals), the Armenians, the Zionist Yishuv, and American missionaries. These groups hoped that a constitutional Ottoman Empire would shape the future of the Middle East. However, as tensions increased, boycott movements and press campaigns against Ottoman Christians emerged.

The impact of the Constitution on the equality of Ottoman subjects

The Constitution of the Ottoman Empire, 1876, was the first written constitution in the Muslim world. It was preceded by the Nationality Law of 1869, which created equal citizenship for all Ottomans, regardless of race or religion. The 1876 Constitution further solidified this equality by making all subjects "Ottomans" under the law, granting them rights and liberties such as freedom of the press, freedom of religion, and free education. This was a significant step towards equality for all subjects of the Empire, regardless of their religious or ethnic background.

The Constitution also reaffirmed the equality of all Ottoman subjects, including their right to serve in the new Chamber of Deputies. It was more than just a political document; it was a proclamation of Ottomanism and patriotism, asserting the empire's capability to resolve its problems and its right to remain intact. The Constitution officially established the subjects of the Empire as "Ottomans," with the Sultan being titled "Padishah and Sovereign of all Ottomans," rather than just "of the Turks." This change in title symbolised the inclusive nature of the Ottoman Empire, recognising the diversity of its subjects.

The impact of the Constitution on equality was significant. Firstly, it granted all Ottomans individual liberty, provided that they did not infringe upon the liberty of others. This liberty was protected by law, and no one could be penalised except in cases determined and prescribed by law. The Constitution also protected the free exercise of all recognised religions within the Empire, as long as no offence was committed against public order or good morals. This provision ensured that people of different faiths could coexist peacefully and that their religious practices would not be hindered by the state.

Additionally, the Constitution provided for the freedom of the press within the limits of the law. This allowed for the open exchange of ideas and information, fostering a more informed and engaged populace. The Ottomans were also given the privilege to form commercial, industrial, or agricultural associations within the limits determined by the laws and regulations. This provision promoted economic development and empowered individuals to pursue their initiatives while ensuring compliance with legal frameworks.

The Constitution of 1876 had a lasting impact on the equality of Ottoman subjects. It established the principle of equality under the law, guaranteed individual liberties, and protected religious and associational freedoms. While there may have been variations in the practical implementation of these rights, the Constitution set a foundational framework for a more just and equitable society within the Ottoman Empire.

Frequently asked questions