Schumer's Constitution: What Did He Really Say?

did senator chuck schumer really this about the constitution

Chuck Schumer is a US Senator who has served in the Senate for many years and is known for focusing on local issues important to average New Yorkers. He has made several notable remarks and statements during his time in office, including those regarding the Constitution. In 2002, Schumer criticised the Bush administration's Middle East policy, and some considered him indifferent to the administration's war on the Constitution. In 2017, he expressed concerns about William Pryor's views, stating that his 'incredibly strong ideology' placed him outside the mainstream. In 2018, he spoke about the constitutional duty of the Senate to advise and consent regarding Justice Kennedy's successor. In 2021, he gave a speech emphasising the need to support and defend the Constitution.

Characteristics Values
Date 6th January 2021
Topic The need to support and defend the Constitution
Context The outcome of the 2020 election
Main Points The importance of accepting election results, defending democracy, and upholding the Constitution; Criticism of the Republican Party for endorsing an attempted coup; Emphasis on the role of the Senate in maintaining checks and balances
Related Topics Supreme Court, Justice Kennedy's retirement, health care law, Roe v. Wade

cycivic

Defending the Constitution

Senator Chuck Schumer has been a vocal advocate for upholding and defending the Constitution of the United States. In his Senate floor remarks, he emphasized the importance of supporting the Constitution and the rule of law. He reminded his colleagues that they had sworn an oath to defend the Constitution against all enemies, foreign and domestic. Schumer highlighted the significance of true faith and allegiance to the country and its Constitution, especially in light of the recent insurrection and attempts to undermine democratic values.

Schumer has also been critical of President Trump's actions, which he believes push the country towards authoritarianism and threaten the foundations of American democracy. He has drawn a red line, stating that if Trump defies a Supreme Court order, it would be a "quantum leap" and that extraordinary action would be necessary. This red line was crossed when Trump refused to comply with a Supreme Court order to return Kilmar Abrego Garcia from El Salvador, with Schumer's office calling it a "threat to all."

In addition, Schumer has expressed concerns about Trump's influence on the Supreme Court and the potential impact on laws and citizens' rights. He warned that Trump's nominees could threaten healthcare protections and Roe v. Wade, as well as roll back healthcare protections for millions of Americans. Schumer's comments highlight his commitment to defending the Constitution and ensuring that the country remains a shining example of democracy.

Furthermore, Senator Schumer has spoken in defense of the filibuster, referencing the Constitution's spirit and rule. He argued that the Founding Fathers intended the Senate to be a repository of checks and balances, where important issues should not be governed by a slim majority. He cautioned against turning the "cooling saucer of democracy" into the "rubber stamp of dictatorship."

In conclusion, Senator Chuck Schumer's remarks and actions demonstrate his commitment to defending the Constitution. He has raised concerns about threats to democratic values, emphasized the importance of upholding the rule of law, and spoken out against attempts to undermine the foundations of American democracy. His statements serve as a reminder of the duty to protect the Constitution and ensure that the country upholds its democratic ideals.

cycivic

The role of the Senate

The United States Senate is the upper chamber of Congress. Each state elects two senators to serve six-year terms, making up the 100 members of the Senate. The Senate is governed by the Constitution, a set of standing rules, and precedents established during the legislative process.

The Senate has a unique role in the US political system, serving as a "cooling saucer of democracy" to balance the more majoritarian House of Representatives. The Founding Fathers intended for the Senate to act as a check on the power of the majority, ensuring that important issues are not governed solely by the slimmest majority.

One of the key powers of the Senate is its role in the impeachment process. The Senate has the sole power to conduct impeachment trials, serving as both jury and judge. Since 1789, the Senate has tried 20 federal officials, including three presidents. The Senate also has the power to convict an executive or judicial official with a two-thirds vote in an impeachment trial.

Additionally, the Senate plays a crucial role in approving treaties and presidential appointees. The Senate has the power to approve, by a two-thirds vote, treaties made by the executive branch. While the president can enter into executive agreements without Senate approval, the Senate carefully guards its power to review and approve or reject presidential appointees to executive and judicial branch posts.

The Senate also has the power to propose legislation, draft or amend bills, and oversee the federal budget and the executive branch. Senators can use the filibuster to delay or block legislation through prolonged debate, a practice protected by Senate rules and traditions.

In his remarks on the Senate floor, Senator Chuck Schumer emphasized the duty of senators to support and defend the Constitution. He highlighted the importance of accepting election results and upholding democratic values, stating that the world looks to the US as a shining example of democracy.

cycivic

The Supreme Court

In 2018, Senator Chuck Schumer spoke on the Senate floor about the vacancy on the Supreme Court following Justice Anthony Kennedy's retirement. He expressed concern that the next justice appointed by President Trump would overturn healthcare protections and Roe v. Wade, impacting the laws of the United States and the rights of its citizens for generations. Schumer emphasised the importance of the Senate's role in providing checks and balances, as envisioned by the Founding Fathers, to prevent the country from becoming a "banana republic".

Schumer has also been vocal about his expectations of Supreme Court nominees, expressing misgivings about William Pryor's and John Ashcroft's nominations due to their strong ideologies. He clarified that his concerns were not religious but centred around women's rights, abortion rights, LGBT rights, and the separation of church and state.

In 2025, Schumer faced criticism from some Democrats for his decision to vote for a GOP spending bill, which granted President Trump and Elon Musk expanded powers over federal spending. However, he defended his vote, stating that he did not believe American democracy was at risk at the time. Schumer drew a red line and asserted that he would consider American democracy at stake if Trump defied the Supreme Court. This scenario unfolded when the Supreme Court ordered the Trump administration to facilitate the return of Kilmar Abrego Garcia from El Salvador, which Trump refused to do. In response, Schumer's office issued a statement emphasising the importance of due process and the rule of law, stating that "a threat to one is a threat to all."

In a speech on the Senate floor, Schumer emphasised the duty of senators to support and defend the Constitution of the United States. He reflected on the significance of accepting election results and upholding democratic values, sending a message to fledgling democracies and countries where human rights are under assault.

cycivic

The Republican Party

The party's first elected president was Abraham Lincoln, who took office in 1861. Lincoln, along with a Republican Congress, led the Union to victory in the Civil War, preserving the Union and abolishing slavery. The Republican Party largely dominated national politics until the Great Depression in the 1930s, when it lost its congressional majorities.

In the 20th and 21st centuries, the party became associated with laissez-faire capitalism, low taxes, and conservative social policies. Republicans typically support states' rights against the power of the federal government and advocate for limited government intervention in the economy, opposing extensive government regulation, government-funded social programs, and affirmative action. They support a strong national defense and the aggressive pursuit of U.S. national security interests.

On economic issues, the Republican Party has maintained a pro-business stance, advocating for reduced taxes and deregulation. They oppose socialism, labor unions, and public health insurance options. In terms of social issues, Republicans generally support restricting abortion, tough-on-crime policies, capital punishment, and gun ownership rights.

In recent years, the party has experienced significant factionalism and has shifted towards right-wing populism, with the election of Donald Trump in 2016 leading to a pivot towards Trumpism. The Republican Party currently finds its strongest support among rural voters, White Southerners, evangelical Christians, men, senior citizens, and voters without college degrees.

cycivic

The GOP spending bill

In April 2025, Senate minority leader Chuck Schumer faced criticism from fellow Democrats for voting for a GOP spending bill to continue funding the government. The bill, referred to as a "big, beautiful bill" by Donald Trump, aimed to turn his campaign promises into reality.

The bill was expected to extend tax cuts from Trump's first term, fund increased border security and mass deportations of undocumented immigrants, and potentially end the taxation of tips, overtime, and social security payments. To fund these initiatives, the GOP targeted significant reductions in government spending, including social safety net programs such as Medicaid and the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (Snap).

The spending bill encountered opposition from Democrats and highlighted divisions within the GOP. Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., faced the challenge of shepherding the bill through Congress. The bill's framework outlined separate targets for spending and cuts in the House and Senate, indicating a lack of unity within the party.

Despite the criticism he faced, Schumer's decision to support the bill may have been influenced by the need to avoid a government shutdown. However, his office did not immediately provide a comment in response to the backlash.

Several Groups of 52 Cards Fit in 5,148

You may want to see also

Frequently asked questions

Yes, Senator Chuck Schumer has made several remarks about the Constitution. In 2021, he spoke on the Senate floor about the need to support and defend the Constitution, emphasising the role of the Senate in upholding the democratic process and the importance of accepting election results. He also highlighted the significance of the Constitution in maintaining checks and balances within the government, specifically regarding the Supreme Court and Congress's authority.

Here are a few notable quotes attributed to Senator Chuck Schumer:

- "We each swore an oath... that we would defend and support the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic."

- "The Congress does not determine the outcome of elections, the People do."

- "The Senate is not a majoritarian body."

- "No democracy can hope to survive if it cannot ensure accountability."

Senator Chuck Schumer's remarks about the Constitution were made in various contexts, including:

- Defending the Senate's rules, traditions, and the importance of upholding the Constitution during a debate about the filibuster.

- Speaking on the Senate floor about the need to support and defend the Constitution following the 2020 election and the Capitol riots.

- Addressing the Supreme Court's accountability and Congress's constitutional authority to exercise checks on the judiciary.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment