Journalists, Political Donations: Ethical Or Unethical?

In an era of hyper-partisan politics, journalists' political affiliations and activities are under more scrutiny than ever. While charitable donations are generally tax-deductible, any donations made to political organizations, candidates, or campaigns are not. Despite this, journalists and media professionals frequently donate money to federal political candidates, committees, and parties during election cycles. This has led to concerns about conflicts of interest and the appearance of impartiality, with most news organizations prohibiting contributions to political causes. However, some journalists defend their right to donate, arguing that it's nobody's business and that donating to a candidate is not the same as donating to a party or presidential candidate. With the politicization of various social causes and issues, journalists must navigate a complex landscape to avoid the perception of bias.

Explore related products

Words to Win By: The Slogans, Logos, and Designs of America's Presidential Elections

$13 $24.99

The Political Campaign Desk Reference: A Guide for Campaign Managers, Professionals and Candidates Running for Office

$16.45 $19.95

The Campaign Manager

$40.62 $62.99

Winning Local Elections: A Guide To Winning Local, County and Legislative Political Campaigns

$16.95

Fascism or Genocide: How a Decade of Political Disorder Broke American Politics

$17.21 $22.95

The Money Signal: How Fundraising Matters in American Politics (Chicago Studies in American Politics)

$32.5 $31.99

Journalists' donations to political campaigns are often taboo and prohibited by news companies

Journalists' donations to political campaigns are often considered taboo, and many news companies prohibit their employees from contributing to political candidates, parties, and campaigns. This is to avoid any potential conflicts of interest and the appearance of bias in their reporting. Despite this, some journalists still choose to donate to political campaigns, and their contributions can be traced through public records.

In the 2010 election cycle, for example, a Center for Responsive Politics analysis indicated that 235 people identifying as journalists or media professionals donated more than $469,900 to federal political candidates, committees, and parties. Notable examples include Christopher Hayes, the Washington, D.C. editor of the left-leaning news magazine, *The Nation*, who donated $250 to an Alabama Democrat's congressional campaign. Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Seymour Hersh also donated $1,000 to a Democratic representative during the same cycle.

While these donations are not illegal, they can raise ethical concerns about the neutrality and objectivity of journalists and the news organizations they represent. As a result, many news companies choose to prohibit these types of contributions to maintain their credibility and avoid any perceived or actual bias in their reporting.

However, the line between political and social causes has blurred in recent years, with some issues becoming politicized. This has made it challenging for journalists to navigate their donations or support for certain causes without potentially jeopardizing their positions. For instance, during the COVID-19 pandemic, donating money to produce masks could be seen as "taking a side" in a polarized political climate.

Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Seymour Hersh donated $1,000 to a political campaign

Journalism and political campaigns have a complex relationship. While journalists are supposed to remain neutral and unbiased, it is not uncommon for them to donate money to political campaigns. Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Seymour Hersh donated $1,000 to a political campaign, specifically to Rep. Walt Minnick (D-Idaho) during a campaign cycle. Hersh, a frequent contributor to the New Yorker, became famous for revealing the My Lai Massacre in 1969 and has since written numerous investigative pieces, including exposing elements of the Abu Ghraib prison scandal in 2004.

Hersh's donation is not an isolated incident. In fact, journalists and media professionals frequently donate to federal political candidates, committees, and parties during election cycles. According to a Center for Responsive Politics analysis, 235 people who identified themselves as journalists or employees of news organizations donated more than $469,900 during the 2010 election cycle. While some news organizations prohibit contributions to political candidates, parties, and campaigns, there is no industry-wide standard, and the decision is often left to individual journalists and their news organizations.

The ethics of journalists donating to political campaigns are complex. On the one hand, journalists are expected to remain unbiased and neutral, and donating to a political campaign could create the appearance of a conflict of interest. On the other hand, journalists are individuals with their own beliefs and values, and they have the same rights as anyone else to support political causes and candidates financially. Additionally, donating to a political campaign may not always indicate support for a particular candidate or party but could be a way for journalists to support a free press or a specific issue they are passionate about.

In the case of Seymour Hersh, he justified his donation by stating that he respected Rep. Walt Minnick, with whom he had worked during the Nixon administration. Hersh also mentioned that he had donated to a Washington state senatorial candidate, who was a Republican, further emphasizing his donations as support for individual candidates rather than a particular party.

Journalists are under more scrutiny than ever in these 'hyper-partisan' times

Journalists are under more scrutiny than ever in these hyper-partisan times, with the public and politicians alike watching their every move, particularly during election seasons. The actions of journalists are increasingly being put under the microscope, with their reporting and personal lives being analysed and criticised by those with differing political beliefs. This is especially true when it comes to political donations and campaign contributions.

Indeed, journalists' donations to political campaigns are a highly controversial topic. While journalists are generally free to donate money to political campaigns, it is often considered taboo and some news organisations even prohibit it. This is due to the potential for conflicts of interest, as journalists are expected to remain neutral and unbiased in their reporting. However, this expectation of neutrality is increasingly difficult to maintain in the current political climate.

In the lead-up to an election, journalists, like any other citizen, may feel passionate about a particular candidate or cause and want to contribute financially. This is not a new phenomenon, with journalists having donated to political campaigns in the past, such as the $1,000 Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Seymour Hersh donated to Rep. Walt Minnick during a campaign cycle. However, in today's highly polarised political landscape, these donations can be seen as taking sides, which may call into question the journalist's impartiality.

The scrutiny on journalists is intensified by the prevalence of social media and the 24-hour news cycle, where every action and opinion is amplified and scrutinised by the public. Additionally, with the rise of dark money" groups and super PACs, which can accept unlimited contributions from corporations and spend millions of dollars on elections without disclosing their sources of funding, the already murky waters of campaign financing have become even more opaque. This further complicates the issue of journalists' donations, as the public and their employers demand transparency and accountability from the media.

Explore related products

Campaign Boot Camp 2.0: Basic Training for Candidates, Staffers, Volunteers, and Nonprofits

$29.22 $33.99

The Invisible Election: How Dark Money and Shadow Campaigns Control Democracy (Dark Money: Unveiling Hidden Political and Financial Networks Book 3)

$7.99 $17.99

Quick! Before You Vote...

$7.99 $19.99

Political Turbulence: How Social Media Shape Collective Action

$31.37 $42

Notley Nation: How Alberta's Political Upheaval Swept the Country

$19.31 $19.99

Campaign And Party Finance In North America And Western Europe

$18 $55.99

Ethical considerations for journalists donating to social causes or charities

While journalists are generally free to donate to charities and social causes, they must remain vigilant about potential conflicts of interest. This is particularly important in an era of hyper-partisanship, where even the most innocuous issues and causes have become politicised. For instance, donating to a cause related to COVID-19, such as funding the production of masks, could be construed as "taking a side".

Journalists should also be mindful of the appearance of a conflict of interest, even if none exists. They must consider whether their donation could adversely affect their ability to report fairly and objectively. This is especially pertinent when the cause is related to issues or people they cover in their reporting. To avoid the perception of bias, journalists are advised not to use their employer's name and logo when sharing personal donations on social media.

News organisations themselves often prohibit contributions to political candidates, parties, and campaigns. However, this does not extend to charitable donations, and journalists are generally free to donate to non-partisan charities and social causes. Nevertheless, journalists should exercise caution and consider the nature of the cause to ensure their support does not create an actual or perceived conflict of interest.

To maintain ethical standards, journalists should also be transparent about their donations. While they can donate to support journalism and a free press, they must ensure that their actions do not create the appearance of endorsing one charity over another. This is crucial for maintaining the public's trust in the news organisation and the journalist's integrity.

Ultimately, journalists must carefully navigate the complex landscape of social causes and charities, ensuring that their donations do not compromise their objectivity, impartiality, and ethical standards.

Political contributions are not tax-deductible

The IRS is explicit that money given to a politician or political party cannot be deducted from your taxes. This is also true for businesses; they cannot deduct political contributions, donations, or payments on their tax returns. The IRS provides a Tax-Exempt Organisation Search Tool to clarify which organisations qualify as tax-exempt.

While charitable donations are typically tax-deductible, political contributions are not. This includes monetary donations, in-kind contributions, and volunteer expenses. Time spent and expenses incurred while volunteering for a political campaign are not deductible. This includes supplies, transportation to and from campaign events, and out-of-pocket expenses.

In the context of journalists donating to political campaigns, it is worth noting that many news organisations prohibit contributions to political candidates, parties, and campaigns. However, in these ""hyper-partisan"" times, it is increasingly common for journalists to be scrutinised for their donations to social causes, as these causes and issues have become politicised.

Frequently asked questions