Congressional Committees: Constitutional Or Not?

The United States Constitution does not mention or provide for committees in Congress. However, both the House of Representatives and the Senate have utilized them since the very first Congress. Congressional committees are legislative sub-organizations that handle specific duties, allowing members to develop specialized knowledge of the matters under their jurisdiction. They are essential to the effective operation of the Senate and play a crucial role in the legislative process.

Explore related products

Turf Wars: How Congressional Committees Claim Jurisdiction (American Politics and Political Economy Series)

$31.1 $33

Congressional Committees: A Study of the Origins and Development of Our National and Local Legislative Methods (Classic Reprint)

$36.72 $36.97

The Congressional Endgame: Interchamber Bargaining and Compromise

$35 $34.99

Competing Principals: Committees, Parties, and the Organization of Congress

$89.95

American Government 101: From the Continental Congress to the Iowa Caucus, Everything You Need to Know About US Politics (Adams 101 Series)

$10.99 $16.99

The right to keep and bear arms: Report of the Subcommittee on the Constitution of the Committee on the Judiciary, United States Senate, Ninety-seventh Congress, second session

$16.99

The US Constitution does not mention congressional committees

The first Senate committee was established on April 7, 1789, to draw up Senate rules of procedure. In the early days of the Senate, temporary select committees were the norm. These committees were responsive to the entire Senate, with the full Senate selecting their jurisdiction and membership. The early committees generally consisted of three members for routine business and five members for more important issues.

By the first decade of the 19th century, the Senate had only four standing or permanent committees, responsible for "housekeeping" tasks. Two of these were joint committees with the House: one on enrolled bills and the other on the Library of Congress. The other two were the Committee on Engrossed Bills and the Committee to Audit and Control the Contingent Expenses of the Senate.

The number of committees grew significantly over time. By 1906, the Senate maintained 66 standing and select committees, and by 1920, the Congressional Directory listed nearly 80 committees. This large number of committees led to concerns about government spending, and in 1921, the Republican majority abolished 41 committees. The expansion of federal government activity during the Great Depression and World War II also led to reforms of the committee system, with the 1946 Legislative Reorganization Act reducing the number of committees from 33 to 15.

Today, the Senate has 24 committees, including 16 standing committees, four special or select committees, and four joint committees. Committees are essential to the effective operation of the Senate, as they gather information, evaluate presidential nominees, and provide oversight of federal government operations. They also play a crucial role in the legislative process, drafting and considering bills before they reach the Senate floor.

Committees are essential to the effective operation of the Senate

During the first decades of the 19th century, the Senate created some semi-permanent legislative committees that remained active throughout a session. In 1806, the Senate adopted a rule to allow legislation to be referred to already created select committees that were dealing with similar topics. The Senate also began dividing the president's annual message (later the State of the Union Address) into sections by subject matter and referring each section to a different select committee. These committees did not always disband but continued in operation throughout the session. During the War of 1812, there was a rise in the number of select committees due to a surge in legislative business.

Committees enable members to develop specialized knowledge of the matters under their jurisdiction. They gather information on national and international problems through investigations and hearings, allowing them to draft, consider, and recommend legislation to the full membership of the Senate. Committees also evaluate presidential nominees for executive and judicial posts and provide oversight of federal government operations. The Senate currently has 16 standing committees, four special or select committees, and four joint committees. Standing committees are permanent bodies with specific responsibilities and jurisdictions defined in the Senate's rules. The four joint committees, composed of senators and representatives, provide administrative coordination between the House and Senate and conduct studies for the benefit of both houses.

The role of committees in the legislative process

The United States Constitution does not mention or provide for committees in Congress. However, both the House of Representatives and the Senate have utilized them since the very first Congress. Congressional committees are legislative sub-organizations that handle specific duties, acting as "little legislatures". They are essential to the effective operation of the Senate.

Committees draft, consider, and recommend legislation to the full membership of the Senate. They transform the broad objectives of proposed legislation into specific bill text. In the 1790s, select committees were also appointed to consider bills already passed by the House. Committees can also be authorized to review and recommend ways to improve the committee system itself.

The Senate currently has 24 committees: 16 standing committees, four special or select committees, and four joint committees. Standing committees are permanent bodies with specific responsibilities and jurisdictions defined in the Senate's rules. Special or select committees are also permanent and were created for specific purposes. Joint committees, composed of senators and representatives, provide administrative coordination between the House and Senate and conduct studies for both houses.

Explore related products

The Rise of the President's Permanent Campaign

$14.37 $29.99

The Right to Keep and Bear Arms - Report of the Subcommittee on the Constitution of the Committee on the Judiciary - United States Senate - Ninety-Seventh Congress - Second Session - February 1982

$0.99

Speech of Hon. Lyman Trumbull, of Illinois, on Amending the Constitution to Prohibit Slavery: Delivered in the Senate of the United States, March 28, 1864 (Classic Reprint)

$22.72

Congressional Constraint and Judicial Responses: Examining Judiciary Committee Court Curbing and Court Structuring Bills

$52.24 $54.99

Senate Consideration of Presidential Nominations: Committee and Floor Procedure

$0.99

The Constitution upheld and maintained

$10.65

The history of congressional committees

The United States Constitution did not mention nor provide for committees in Congress. However, both the House of Representatives and the Senate utilized them from the very first Congress in 1789. The first Senate committee was established on April 7, 1789, to draw up Senate rules of procedure. During the First Congress (1789–1791), Senator Oliver Ellsworth of Connecticut served on 22 committees in the first session and 36 committees in the second session. In the 1790s, many select committees were also appointed to consider bills already passed by the House.

By the first decade of the 19th century, the Senate referred legislation to 100 or more temporary committees each Congress. The Senate had only four standing, or permanent, committees, which were responsible for “housekeeping” tasks: two joint committees with the House (on enrolled bills and the Library of Congress), a committee on engrossed bills, and the Committee to Audit and Control the Contingent Expenses of the Senate. During the era of select, or temporary, committees, the Senate first met to discuss legislation as a “Committee of the Whole,” which relaxed the rules of the Senate and facilitated debate on legislation.

In 1920, the Congressional Directory listed nearly 80 committees, including the Committee on the Disposition of Useless Papers in the Executive Departments. In 1921, as part of the party’s commitment to reducing government spending, the Republican majority abolished 41 committees. The expansion of federal government activity during the Great Depression and World War II led to another reform of the committee system. The 1946 Legislative Reorganization Act further reduced the number of committees from 33 to 15, limited the number of seats on each committee, and redefined jurisdictions.

Today, the Senate is home to 24 committees: 16 standing committees, four special or select committees, and four joint committees. Standing committees are permanent bodies with specific responsibilities and jurisdictions that are defined in the Senate's rules. The four joint committees, made up of senators and representatives, provide administrative coordination between the House and Senate and conduct studies for the benefit of both houses.

The future of congressional committees

Although the United States Constitution does not mention or provide for committees in Congress, both the House of Representatives and the Senate have utilized them since the very first Congress. Congressional committees are essential to the effective operation of the Senate. They gather information on national and international issues within their jurisdiction, draft and consider legislation, and recommend bills to the full Senate. Committees also evaluate presidential nominees for executive and judicial posts and oversee federal government operations.

Technological advancements and the availability of information may also influence the future of congressional committees. In the past, committees relied primarily on executive branch agencies and advocacy groups for substantive policy information. Now, with access to advanced research tools and data analytics, committees can independently analyze and assess information. This may lead to more informed decision-making and evidence-based policy formulation.

Additionally, the changing nature of politics and increasing partisanship could impact the future of congressional committees. Committees have traditionally been a venue for bipartisan cooperation and compromise, with members from different parties working together to draft and negotiate legislation. However, with the rise of polarized politics, there may be a shift in the dynamics within committees, potentially affecting their effectiveness in reaching consensus.

Moreover, public expectations for transparency and accountability in government are likely to shape the future of congressional committees. Committees may be subject to increased scrutiny and pressure to provide more accessible information about their activities and decision-making processes. This could lead to enhanced transparency measures, such as public hearings, the publication of committee reports, and the disclosure of committee memberships.

In conclusion, the future of congressional committees will likely be characterized by adaptability and responsiveness to the evolving needs and challenges of governing a dynamic nation. By updating their structures, utilizing technological advancements, and maintaining a focus on effective governance, congressional committees will continue to play a crucial role in the legislative process and oversight functions of the Senate.

Frequently asked questions