Common Sense's Influence On The Us Constitution

Thomas Paine's Common Sense, a 47-page pamphlet published in 1776, played a pivotal role in shaping the course of American history and the creation of the US Constitution. With its accessible language and compelling arguments, Common Sense ignited a revolutionary fervor among the colonists, advocating for independence from British rule and a new form of government rooted in freedom and self-rule. The pamphlet's critique of monarchy and its vision of an independent and just society struck a chord with people from all walks of life, fostering a sense of unity and shared purpose. Common Sense not only influenced public opinion but also inspired the Continental Congress to instruct each colony to draft new state constitutions, setting the stage for the declaration of independence and the formation of a new nation.

Explore related products

The Constitution of the United States and The Declaration of Independence

$1.99 $6.95

Common Sense - Pocket Edition with US Constitution, Declaration, Famous Quotes

$7.95 $7.95

Common Sense: The Origin and Design of Government

$9.99 $9.99

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights

$9.99 $9.99

Common Sense (Books of American Wisdom)

$10 $12.95

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights, Common Sense, and The Federalist Papers (Royal ... (Case Laminate Hardcover with Jacket)

$51.15 $59.95

Thomas Paine's critique of the monarchy

Thomas Paine's 47-page pamphlet, "Common Sense", published in 1776, was a scathing critique of the British monarchy and a powerful argument for American independence. Paine's writing was accessible, using straightforward language to articulate complex philosophical arguments. This democratic approach to knowledge allowed his ideas to reach a wide colonial audience, creating a shared sense of purpose and fuelling revolutionary fervour.

Paine's critique of the monarchy was twofold: he attacked the notion of hereditary power and the inherent flaws of the royal system. Paine wrote that "There is something exceedingly ridiculous in the composition of monarchy", highlighting the absurdity of a system that grants power based on birthright rather than merit. He argued that the notion of political sovereignty being passed down through bloodlines contradicted the principles of natural equality and the inalienable rights of man. Paine believed that a monarch's authority was not justifiable based on equal rights or scripture. He pointed to the story of Gideon in the Bible, where the Almighty disapproved of government by kings, and the Jews were without a king.

Paine also critiqued the pageantry and idolatrous homage associated with royalty, arguing that it masked the injustice and oppression of monarchical rule. He described the monarchical system as a "levelling system", where any species of character could attain the same authority, regardless of their moral character or skills. This, he argued, resulted in an inconsistent and unstable form of government, subject to the passions and accidents of each individual ruler. Paine believed that the British system gave too much power to the monarchy and nobles, hindering the ability of the government to be responsive to the people's needs.

Paine's critique of the monarchy was not limited to the British context. He also turned his attention to the French Revolution, distinguishing between the "representative" government of North America and the "hereditary" system that prevailed in France. Paine's ideas about monarchy were shaped by his belief in the importance of individual rights and religious freedom. He envisioned a strong central government for the new American nation, with a constitution protecting these rights and freedoms.

Overall, Thomas Paine's critique of the monarchy formed a crucial part of his argument for American independence. By exposing the flaws and injustices of monarchical rule, Paine helped to unify the colonies and inspire a revolutionary consciousness among the colonists.

The economic benefits of independence

Thomas Paine's "Common Sense", published on January 10, 1776, was a 47-page pamphlet that played a crucial role in shaping the ideas and sentiments that led to the American Revolution and the creation of a new nation. Its accessible language and compelling arguments against monarchy and for independence struck a chord with the populace, rapidly spreading and influencing both informal discussions and formal political debates. One of the key aspects of "Common Sense" was its discussion of the economic benefits of independence, which provided a tangible reason for ordinary colonists to support the cause.

Paine argued that America's economic potential was hampered by British policies and that independence would allow the colonies to thrive. He pointed out that the colonies had the raw materials and skills needed to build and equip an army and navy for defence. The individual colonies also had the potential to unite and form a powerful nation, but it was essential to act quickly before new divisions emerged. This pragmatic perspective, presented with conviction and urgency, reflected the revolutionary spirit of the time and helped unify the colonies in their aspirations for independence.

• Removal of Trade Restrictions: Under British rule, the colonies were subject to trade restrictions and interference. The Navigation Acts, for example, increased the cost of shipment by requiring the use of English ports as an entrepôt, affecting both imports and exports. Independence would allow the colonies to freely engage in trade with other nations, reducing these costs and potentially increasing colonial GNP.
• Increased Economic Self-Governance: The colonies had limited sovereignty over their trade policies under British mercantilism. Independence would grant them greater control over their economic destiny, allowing them to make decisions that benefited their own economy rather than primarily serving the interests of the British Empire.
• Reduction of Economic Burdens: The net burdens of the mercantilist relationship between Britain and the colonies resulted in an estimated loss of 0.4% per capita income for the colonists. Independence would eliminate these economic burdens, leading to a potential increase in per capita income.
• Development of Domestic Industries: Independence would encourage the development of domestic industries and production. The colonies had the resources and skills necessary for economic growth, and by freeing themselves from British economic policies, they could foster their industrial and economic advancement.
• Elimination of Opportunity Costs: By remaining under British rule, the colonies potentially forfeited opportunities for economic growth and diversification. Independence would allow them to explore new economic avenues, invest in their infrastructure, and promote economic policies that aligned with their specific needs and goals.
• Military and Strategic Advantages: The colonies had the raw materials and capabilities necessary to build and maintain a strong military force, including an army and navy. Independence would grant them greater autonomy in defence strategies and ensure that their economic resources were primarily dedicated to their own protection and advancement rather than being subjected to the demands and conflicts of a distant empire.

In conclusion, the economic benefits of independence, as outlined by Paine in "Common Sense" and supported by economic analyses, provided a compelling rationale for the colonists to pursue independence. The potential for economic growth, self-governance, and the removal of trade restrictions were key factors in shaping the revolutionary sentiment that ultimately led to the creation of a new nation.

Religious freedom

Thomas Paine's pamphlet, 'Common Sense', is considered to have played a significant role in inspiring the American Revolution and shaping the ideals that would be reflected in the US Constitution. One of the key aspects of 'Common Sense' was its advocacy for religious freedom, which would later be enshrined in the Constitution.

Paine's ideas on religious freedom were influenced by his critique of the English constitution and the monarchy. He argued that since all men are created equal, the distinction between kings and subjects is false. Paine further challenged the divine right of kings by quoting biblical passages. He believed that the concentration of power in the hands of the monarch allowed them to transcend any limitations, making the constitutional monarchy's supposed checks on monarchical power insufficient.

In 'Common Sense', Paine envisioned a new nation with a strong central government and a constitution that protected individual rights, including religious freedom. This vision resonated with many Americans who resented being forced to pay tithes to churches they did not belong to. Paine's espousal of religious freedom contributed to unifying Americans and winning them over to the cause of independence.

The US Constitution, adopted in 1787, included limited references to religion. Article VI stated that "no religious Test shall ever be required as Qualification" for federal officeholders. This provision was included to defuse controversy and prevent claims of religious discrimination in eligibility for public office. However, the Constitution's reticence on religion disappointed some Americans, who felt it slighted God and failed to give faith a prominent role in the government.

To address these concerns, the First Amendment to the Constitution was ratified in 1791. The First Amendment included the Establishment Clause and the Free Exercise Clause, which together form the basis for religious freedom in the US. The Establishment Clause forbids Congress from making any law "respecting an establishment of religion," thus ensuring separation of church and state. The Free Exercise Clause guarantees the right to "the free exercise of religion," protecting individuals' ability to live according to their beliefs and act on their religiously informed moral judgments in public life and policy debates.

In conclusion, Thomas Paine's 'Common Sense', with its advocacy for religious freedom, helped lay the groundwork for the religious freedom provisions in the US Constitution and its amendments. Paine's ideas on religious freedom, along with the subsequent efforts to include explicit protections in the Constitution, ensured that individuals in the US could practice their faith without government interference and participate in public life guided by their religious beliefs.

Explore related products

A Return to Common Sense: How to Fix America Before We Really Blow It

$10.51 $29.99

The Constitution, Declaration of Independence, and Common Sense: A Pocketbook Collection of The Constitution of the United States of America, The ... Sense (American and French Revolution Books)

$6.24

Common Sense (Dover Thrift Editions) (Dover Thrift Editions: Political Science)

$5.5 $5.5

Common Sense: and The American Crisis I (Penguin Classics)

$13 $13

Common Sense (Hourglass Edition): Abridged and Annotated with Definitions and Historical Context

$7.99 $7.99

Common Sense

$9.99

Persuasion and propaganda

Thomas Paine's "Common Sense" was a 47-page pamphlet that played a crucial role in shaping public opinion and fuelling revolutionary fervour in the American colonies. Published on January 10, 1776, just months before the first battles of the Revolutionary War, the pamphlet's accessible language and compelling arguments reached a wide audience, including individuals across different social strata.

Paine's persuasive writing style and propaganda techniques were key to the impact of "Common Sense". He presented complex philosophical concepts in plain language, making his ideas relatable and understandable to the colonial populace. Paine's critique of monarchy and his vision of an independent and just society resonated deeply with the people, awakening a revolutionary consciousness. He argued that the British system, with its concentration of power in the monarchy and nobles, failed to serve the people effectively. Paine's advocacy for religious freedom and his espousal of a strong central government with a written constitution that protected individual rights also appealed to a broad spectrum of colonists.

The pamphlet's widespread distribution and discussion unified the colonies in their aspirations for independence and created a shared sense of purpose and direction. It sold an estimated 500,000 copies, an extraordinary feat at the time. The impact of "Common Sense" was such that John Adams, one of the Founding Fathers of the United States, declared that "without the pen of the author of Common Sense, the sword of Washington would have been raised in vain." Paine's words influenced not only the general populace but also influential figures like George Washington, helping to shape their political ideologies.

Paine's skills in persuasion and propaganda were evident in his ability to convey his ideas with conviction and urgency, tapping into the revolutionary spirit of the time. He understood the power of language and used straightforward, dramatic, and relatable writing to ensure his message was accessible to all. Paine's talent for persuasion extended beyond the content of his writing; he also strategically utilised tools such as asserting his Christianity, despite being a Deist, to further enhance the appeal of his message.

In conclusion, Thomas Paine's "Common Sense" was a powerful tool of persuasion and propaganda that played a significant role in shaping public opinion and inspiring revolutionary change in the American colonies. Its influence extended beyond the pages of the pamphlet, unifying the colonies and laying the foundation for colonial unity and the eventual declaration of independence.

The founding of American democracy

Thomas Paine's "Common Sense" was a 47-page pamphlet published on January 10, 1776, that played a significant role in shaping the founding of American democracy. Paine's writing was accessible and compelling, resonating with a broad spectrum of colonial Americans and fuelling revolutionary fervour.

Paine critiqued the British monarchy and the English Constitution, arguing that the system of hereditary monarchy was inherently flawed and contrary to the principles of natural equality. He advocated for complete independence from Great Britain and the establishment of a democratic government with a written constitution. Paine's ideas contributed to spreading enthusiasm for independence and unifying the colonies in their revolutionary aspirations.

One of the most notable aspects of "Common Sense" was its accessibility. Paine wrote in straightforward language, articulating complex philosophical arguments in a manner that was easy to understand. This linguistic accessibility democratized his ideas, allowing them to reach individuals across different social strata, from the elite to the common masses. The pamphlet's arguments struck a chord with the populace, leading to rapid sales and widespread discussion.

In addition to his critique of monarchy, Paine addressed practical matters such as the economic benefits of independence. He argued that American economic fortunes were hampered by British policies and that liberation from these constraints would allow the colonies to thrive. This pragmatic perspective provided a tangible reason for ordinary colonists to support the cause of independence.

Paine also envisioned a strong central government for the new nation, with a constitution that protected individual rights, including freedom of religion. He believed that government existed to serve the people and needed to be responsive to their needs. Paine's espousal of religious freedom appealed to those who resented being forced to pay tithes to churches they didn't belong to.

The impact of "Common Sense" was profound. Within a few months of its publication, the Continental Congress instructed each colony to draft new state constitutions, setting the colonies firmly on the path to declaring independence. Paine's pamphlet unified Americans and won converts to the cause of independence, with some even considering it the true revolutionary document, not the Declaration of Independence.

Frequently asked questions