A Rigid Constitution: Australia's Challenge To Amend

The Australian Constitution has been designed to be difficult to amend. Since 1901, 20 referendums proposing 45 changes to the Constitution have been held, but only 8 of these changes have been agreed to by the Australian people. The Australian Constitution can only be changed through a referendum, which requires a majority of voters in a majority of states, as well as a majority of voters across the nation as a whole. This is to ensure that the Constitution cannot be amended at the behest of one level of government, preserving the federal system.

Explore related products

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights

$9.99 $9.99

Understanding State Constitutions

$28.04 $45

A New Constitution for Australia (Australian S)

$42.55 $55.99

The Annotated Constitution Of The Australian Commonwealth Part 2 (1901)

$51.94

The Legislative Powers of the Commonwealth and the States of Australia, With Proposed Amendments

$39.95

On Equal Terms: The Constitutional Politics of Educational Opportunity

$28.67 $47

The Australian Constitution can only be amended through a referendum

The Australian Constitution was designed to be difficult to amend. The only way to change it is through a referendum—a vote by Australians to decide whether to support or reject a bill that proposes a change to the Constitution. This process ensures that the power to modify the Constitution rests with the Australian people.

The referendum process in Australia has several requirements that must be met for a successful amendment. Firstly, the amendment must be approved by an absolute majority of each house of parliament or passed twice by an absolute majority of one house, with a three-month interval between votes. This gives the federal government control over what goes to a referendum, as the governor-general can decide whether to put it to a vote, even if only one house approves.

Secondly, once a constitutional amendment is put to a referendum, it must be passed by a majority of all electors who vote, including those in the territories since 1977. Thirdly, the referendum must also be approved by a majority of voters in a majority of the states, i.e., there must be a "yes" vote in at least four of the six states.

There are also special requirements if the proposed constitutional change would affect the proportionate or minimum parliamentary representation of a state or its borders. In such cases, the approval of a majority of electors in the affected state is required. These legal and constitutional hurdles reflect the intention to make the Constitution rigid and entrenched, protecting it from frequent changes based on temporary fluctuations in public opinion or crises.

Since 1901, there have been 20 referendums proposing 45 changes to the Constitution, but only 8 of these changes have been agreed upon by the Australian people. The last successful referendum was in 1977. The low success rate highlights the challenging nature of amending Australia's founding document.

Amendments require approval from an absolute majority of each house of parliament

The Australian Constitution was always meant to be difficult to amend. The British government inserted an overriding provision in the statute that approved the NSW Constitution, allowing it to be amended by ordinary legislation passed by the NSW parliament. However, this flexibility was not possible for the Australian federation. A federal constitution confers different powers at the federal and state levels, and amendments must consider the balance of power between them.

Amending the Australian Constitution requires navigating several legal and constitutional hurdles. One of the critical requirements is that any proposed amendment must secure the approval of an absolute majority in each house of parliament. This means that the amendment must be passed by a majority of votes in both the House of Representatives and the Senate, the two chambers that comprise the Australian parliament.

This requirement ensures that any changes to the constitution have broad support across the political spectrum and among the representatives of different states and territories. It also gives the federal government significant control over what amendments are put forward to the Australian people in a referendum.

The Australian Constitution is considered "rigid" or "entrenched," meaning it cannot be amended easily or at the behest of a single level of government. This design was intentional to prevent any temporary fluctuations in public opinion or short-term crises from leading to hasty changes in the nation's foundational document.

The requirement for approval from an absolute majority in each house of parliament is a crucial step in the amendment process, ensuring that any changes to the constitution are carefully considered and broadly supported by Australia's elected representatives.

A majority of all electors who vote must pass the amendment

The Australian Constitution was always meant to be difficult to amend. The British government inserted an overriding provision in the statute that approved the NSW Constitution, allowing it to be amended by ordinary legislation passed by the NSW parliament. This flexibility was not possible for the Australian federation, as it would give the federal parliament the power to change it at will, removing all protections of the states and destroying the federal system.

For this reason, a "rigid" or "entrenched" constitution was needed, which could not be amended by the whim of one level of government. This means that any changes to the constitution must be approved by an absolute majority of each house of parliament, or passed twice by an absolute majority of one house, with an interval of three months between votes.

Once a constitutional amendment is put to a referendum, it must be passed by a majority of all electors who vote. This is the second step in the process of amending the constitution. The first step involves the amendment being approved by parliament, as described above. The third step requires that the referendum is approved by a majority of voters in a majority of the states. This means that there must be a majority 'yes' vote in four of the six states.

The Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) is responsible for running votes on referendums. The vote must take place no sooner than two months and no later than six months after the bill is passed by parliament. Since 1901, 20 referendums proposing 45 changes to the constitution have been held, with only eight of these changes being agreed to by the Australian people. The last successful referendum was in 1977.

Explore related products

The Constitution of Western Australia: An Exploration

$139.81 $169.99

The Secessionist States of America: The Blueprint for Creating a Traditional Values Country . . . Now

$15.99 $19.95

Quasi-Constitutionality and Constitutional Statutes: Forms, Functions, Applications (Comparative Constitutional Change)

$190 $58.99

Protecting Rights Without a Bill of Rights: Institutional Performance and Reform in Australia

$27.54 $28.99

The Changing Constitution: Constitutional Law in the Trump-Era Supreme Court

$36.01 $39.99

The Changing Constitution

$49.74 $54

A majority of voters in a majority of states is also required

The Australian Constitution was always intended to be difficult to amend. The British government inserted a provision in the statute that approved the NSW Constitution, allowing it to be amended by ordinary legislation passed by the NSW parliament. However, for an Australian federation, such flexibility was not feasible. A federal constitution confers different powers at the federal and state levels, and it was important to protect the federal system. Therefore, a "rigid" or "entrenched" constitution was required—one that could not be easily changed by a single level of government.

Amending the Australian Constitution requires a referendum, which is a vote by Australians to decide whether to support or reject a bill proposing a constitutional change. The referendum process ensures that any changes to the Constitution reflect the will of the Australian people. To pass, a referendum requires a majority of voters in a majority of states, known as a "double majority." This means that a "yes" vote must be achieved in at least four out of six states, in addition to a majority of voters nationwide.

The requirement for a majority of voters in a majority of states adds an extra layer of complexity to the amendment process. It ensures that any changes to the Constitution have broad support across the country and are not solely driven by the will of a single state or region. This safeguard helps maintain the integrity and stability of the Constitution by preventing amendments that may favour a specific state or region over others.

The double majority requirement also encourages a more inclusive and consensus-building approach to constitutional reform. It incentivises proponents of constitutional change to engage with a diverse range of communities and seek support from multiple states. This process helps to ensure that the interests and perspectives of various regions are considered and addressed in any proposed amendments.

The Australian Constitution's amendment process, including the requirement for a majority of voters in a majority of states, reflects the founders' intention to create a robust and stable framework of government. While this process makes amendments challenging, it also ensures that any changes are carefully considered and broadly supported by the Australian people, protecting the integrity of the Constitution and promoting long-term stability.

The federal government has control over what goes to a referendum

The Australian Constitution is difficult to amend because it was designed to be that way. It was intended to be challenging but not "absolutely impossible" to change. The Constitution confers different powers at the federal and state levels, and a ""rigid" or "entrenched" constitution was needed to prevent one level of government from making changes at will.

The federal government effectively controls what goes to a referendum. For a referendum to be successful, it must be supported by a majority of voters in a majority of states (at least four out of six states) and by a majority of voters across the nation. This is known as a "double majority". The referendum process is as follows:

• Ideas for changes to the Constitution can be proposed by members of parliament, interest groups, or individuals.
• If the idea gains support, a referendum may be initiated.
• The proposed change must first be passed by an absolute majority in both houses of parliament or twice by an absolute majority of one house, with a three-month interval between votes.
• If the proposal passes this stage, the governor-general decides whether to put it to a referendum.
• The referendum must be held between two and six months after the bill is passed by parliament.
• The Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) is responsible for conducting the referendum.
• Voters indicate their support or rejection of the proposed change by writing "yes" or "no" on their ballot papers.

Since 1901, there have been 20 referendums proposing 45 changes to the Constitution, but only eight of these changes have been approved by the Australian people. The last successful referendum was in 1977.

Frequently asked questions