Developing Nations: Constitutionalism's Challenge

Constitutionalism is a widely embraced concept that refers to the idea that a government's authority is derived from and limited by a body of fundamental law. It is a set of norms that prevents the state from abusing its power and ensures that people have liberty and justice. However, implementing constitutionalism in developing countries comes with its own set of challenges. For example, in African countries, the legacy of colonialism and neocolonial conditions of social organization have restricted the capacity of civil society, making the notion of legal rights against the state ephemeral. Additionally, the lack of a fixed meaning of constitutionalism generates space for contentious debate, with critics arguing that constitutions may not effectively protect individuals against oppressive governments.

Explore related products

Public Spaces, Marketplaces, and the Constitution: Shopping Malls and the First Amendment (SUNY series in American Constitutionalism)

$35.1 $36.95

Public Participation in African Constitutionalism (Routledge Global Cooperation Series)

$54.95 $68.99

City, State: Constitutionalism and the Megacity (Oxford Comparative Constitutionalism)

$21.59 $29.99

The Madisonian Constitution (The Johns Hopkins Series in Constitutional Thought)

$54.15 $57

Constitutionalism and Society in Africa (Contemporary Perspectives on Developing Societies)

$203.58

The Politics of War Powers: The Theory and History of Presidential Unilateralism (American Political Thought)

$59.99

Colonial legacy and post-colonial conditions

Colonialism has had a significant impact on the challenges faced by developing countries in their pursuit of constitutionalism. The legacy of colonialism has left many countries with constitutions that lack ownership, legitimacy, and relevance to the specific contexts of these nations. This is particularly evident in African countries, where constitutions are often seen as a product of colonial rule, imposed by former colonial powers without considering the unique needs and aspirations of the people.

The process of European colonisation in Africa and Asia, often referred to as exploitation colonialism, involved the extraction of natural resources and labour for the benefit of the colonising metropole. This form of colonialism created a dynamic where the colonised were ""othered"" and perceived as separate and inferior to the societal norms of the colonisers. The impact of this "othering" has been a division between Eastern and Western cultures, with a dynamic of dominance and subordination. As a result, the legal and political systems imposed during colonisation may not align with the traditional values and practices of the colonised nations, creating a disconnect between the constitution and the people it governs.

Additionally, the economic expansion that accompanied colonialism has led to variations in economic development, regime types, and state capacity in post-colonial countries. The wealth generated through trade routes and the exploitation of resources often benefited the colonising powers, creating economic disparities that persist even after independence. This has resulted in stagnated economic development, widespread poverty, and social inequality, as seen in Kenya, where 60% of the population now lives below the poverty line despite initial economic potential at independence.

Furthermore, the colonial legacy has contributed to ethnic tensions and conflicts in post-colonial states. In Kenya, for example, ethnic violence stemming from a disputed presidential election in 2008 resulted in the loss of lives and the displacement of hundreds of thousands of people. Similar occurrences in other African countries, such as Zimbabwe, Uganda, and Nigeria, have raised questions about the fragility of the African post-colonial state and the challenges of constitutionalism in multi-ethnic communities. The lack of ethnic and regional inclusiveness in constitutional frameworks can exacerbate these tensions and hinder the development of stable, democratic societies.

The transition from authoritarian rule to democracy in some post-colonial countries, such as South Africa, has also been challenging. While South Africa adopted a constitution to consolidate its young democracy, the process of de-colonisation and addressing the legacies of modernity and coloniality remain crucial for the country's ongoing transformation. This includes extending political rights, addressing inequality, and reconciling historical injustices to create a more inclusive and democratic society.

Lack of land tenure security

Constitutionalism is a challenge for many developing countries due to various reasons, one of which is the lack of land tenure security. Land tenure security is essential for economic development and social inclusion, as it enables people to invest in improved homes and livelihoods. However, millions of people worldwide still lack secure land tenure and property rights. This issue is particularly prevalent in developing countries, where 90% of landholdings are undocumented, unprotected, or not administered.

The lack of land tenure security in developing countries can be attributed to several factors. One factor is the legacy of colonial land administration systems that failed to recognize traditional land ownership and usage rights, leading to overlapping rights and claims. This has resulted in complex land issues that are difficult to resolve. Additionally, urbanization is putting increasing pressure on land, with the population in cities expected to grow by 175% by 2030, further complicating land tenure security.

Another factor contributing to the lack of land tenure security is the limited access to and control over land for certain groups, such as women and youth. This disparity affects their ability to invest in their homes and livelihoods and contributes to their social and economic marginalization. Furthermore, the insufficient number of police personnel relative to civilians has led to widespread insecurity in both urban and rural areas, exacerbating the challenges of land tenure security.

To address these challenges, countries have implemented various initiatives, such as the Global Land Tool Network, which has improved security of tenure for households in Uganda, Zambia, and the Philippines. Additionally, countries have restructured their legal and regulatory frameworks related to land, attempting to harmonize modern statutory law with customary practices. However, the complexity of land issues and the need to protect traditional land rights while accommodating urbanization pressures persist, requiring continued efforts to enhance land tenure security in developing countries.

Ethnic and religious diversity

The relationship between ethnic and religious diversity and economic development is complex. While diversity can bring about social tolerance and improved economic conditions, it can also lead to conflict and social exclusion, especially when different ethnic and religious groups compete for resources and power. This conflict can be mitigated by sound institutional functioning, including good governance and democracy. However, this requires active engagement from academics and policymakers to ensure that constitutionalism is relevant to the specific context of the country or region.

In the case of Africa, the legacy of the colonial state has had a significant impact on the development of constitutionalism. The underlying colonial and neocolonial conditions of social organization, including the dual legal system and lack of land tenure security, restrict the capacity of civil society. This has resulted in a struggle for democracy and interethnic strife, which has fueled a continual search for understanding the place constitutionalism may play in the reconstruction of postcolonial states.

To address the challenges posed by ethnic and religious diversity, it is crucial to redefine constitutionalism to ensure the redistribution of political power and ethnic and regional inclusiveness. This includes moulding civic values and the behaviour of key political actors to generate a state capable of sound social policies and fair and honest administration. Additionally, understanding the historical and geographical trends in religious diversity can provide valuable insights. For example, the increase in religious diversity after WWII and the significant increase in Latin America and Sub-Saharan Africa.

Overall, ethnic and religious diversity presents a complex set of challenges for developing countries, requiring context-specific solutions that promote inclusiveness, sound institutional functioning, and active engagement with academics and policymakers.

Explore related products

States in American Constitutionalism: Interpretation, Authority, and Politics (Law, Courts and Politics)

$42.55 $55.99

Peacebuilding, Constitutionalism and the Global South: The Case for Cognitive Justice Plurinationalism (Routledge Research in Constitutional Law)

$42.55 $55.99

The Constitutional Development of Japan 1853-1881

$4.95 $7.55

The Quest for Constitutionalism: South Africa since 1994

$53.19 $55.99

Political Change and Constitutionalism in Africa (African Governance)

$190 $55.99

Military, Politics and Democratization in Southern Africa: The Quest for Political Transition (Advances in African Economic, Social and Political Development)

$129 $139.99

Economic and social context

The economic and social context of constitutionalism in developing countries is a critical aspect that requires careful consideration. It involves understanding the unique conditions and challenges faced by these nations as they strive to establish and uphold democratic ideals and principles.

One key economic and social context challenge is the legacy of colonialism and neocolonialism, particularly in African countries. The underlying conditions of social organization, including the dual legal system and lack of land tenure security, restrict civil society's capacity. Without addressing these issues, the notion of legal rights against the state and restraints on state power remain elusive. This challenge has fuelled a continuous search for understanding the role of constitutionalism in reconstructing postcolonial states.

The economic and social context also encompasses the struggle for democracy and interethnic strife. Many developing countries face challenges in adapting constitutional forms to local circumstances, especially in ethnically and religiously diverse societies. The question of national identity formation, arising from these diverse backgrounds, plays a crucial role in shaping the constitutional landscape.

Additionally, economic underdevelopment and stagnation, coupled with widespread disenchantment, pose significant challenges to constitutionalism in developing countries. It underscores the importance of effective governance and the need for constitutional frameworks that promote economic growth and address societal issues.

Furthermore, the economic and social context of constitutionalism in developing countries is marked by the quest for equality and social justice. Constitutionalism, in this context, aims to ensure equal rights for all, regardless of ethnicity, religion, or other factors. It seeks to establish fair and honest administration, promoting civic values and ensuring the welfare of all citizens.

The economic and social context of constitutionalism in developing countries is complex and multifaceted. It involves grappling with historical legacies, diverse social fabrics, economic challenges, and the desire for equality and justice. Addressing these issues is essential for the successful implementation of constitutionalism and the establishment of robust democratic societies in developing nations.

Judicial independence

Secondly, there is the issue of state corruption, which can impede economic growth and development. In transitional and developing countries, the executive branch may control spending on the judiciary, creating financial dependence and undermining judicial independence. This can lead to a judiciary that is not truly independent and able to make fair decisions.

Thirdly, the selection of judges and their independence are crucial. Judges should be individuals of integrity and ability, with the appropriate legal qualifications and training. They should be free from any improper influences or restrictions and should have freedom of expression, belief, association, and assembly. However, in some countries, judges are appointed for improper motives, and their decisions may be influenced by self-interest, ideological dedication, or even corruption.

Finally, the implementation of international principles of judicial independence in national law is a challenge. While countries like the United Kingdom, Canada, and India have well-established judicial independence, other countries are still working towards this goal. The European Court of Human Rights has influenced the development of judicial independence in Europe, and international human rights constitutional documents are now impacting British domestic law.

In conclusion, judicial independence is a complex and challenging issue for developing countries due to historical, social, political, and economic factors. It is a process that requires active engagement and a continuous striving for improvement.

Frequently asked questions