Tennessee's First Constitution: What Went Wrong?

why did the first tennessee constitution fail

The first Tennessee Constitution was adopted in 1796, the same year Tennessee became a state. The constitution was drafted by 55 delegates in Knoxville and was based on the United States Constitution, as well as the constitutions of North Carolina and Pennsylvania. While the original constitution was never submitted to voters, it was approved by Congress and President Washington. However, by 1834, the constitution was revised to update the court system and address the problems of a growing and urbanizing state. This was the second version of the constitution, and it was followed by a third constitution in 1870, which is still in use today with amendments.

Characteristics Values
Year of Adoption 1796
Drafting Location Knoxville
Number of Delegates 55
Review Location Washington City
Date of Effect June 1, 1796
Basis for Legislative Representation Population
Population in 1796 N/A
Population in 1834 700,000
Date of Revision 1834
Focus of Revision Taxation, Courts, Urbanization
Date of Second Revision 1870
Reason for Second Revision Abolition of Slavery, Reaction to Governor William G. Brownlow
Current Status of 1870 Constitution Still in Use
Number of Amendments to 1870 Constitution 11
Last Amendment Date November 8, 2022

cycivic

It was never submitted to voters for approval

The original Tennessee state constitution, which came into effect on June 1, 1796, was never submitted to the voters for approval. Instead, it was approved by US Congress, along with the resolution admitting Tennessee as a state. This was because Congress required a constitution before it would grant statehood. The state constitution was based on the United States Constitution, with most of the provisions regarding declarations of rights, taxes, and legislative authority drawn from the North Carolina and Pennsylvania constitutions.

The original Tennessee state constitution was drafted in Knoxville by a convention of 55 delegates. Once it was completed, the delegates sent the Constitution to Washington City for review by the Congress before it adjourned. President Washington signed the bill giving Tennessee immediate statehood on June 1, 1796.

The Tennessee Constitution defines the form, structure, activities, character, and fundamental rules (and means for changing them) of the US State of Tennessee. The original constitution of Tennessee is kept at the Tennessee State Library and Archives. The constitution was revised in 1834 to update the court system and address some of the problems in the original constitution. A second version of the constitution was adopted in 1835, and a third in 1870, which is the one still in use today, with subsequent amendments.

The current Tennessee Constitution has been amended 11 times since 2006, with voters last approving four amendments on November 8, 2022. The constitution is the fundamental document that outlines a state's framework for governance, including the powers, structure, and limitations of the state government, individual and civil rights, and other matters.

cycivic

It was based on the North Carolina and Pennsylvania constitutions

The first Tennessee Constitution was drafted in 1796 by a convention of 55 delegates in Knoxville. It was based on the North Carolina and Pennsylvania constitutions, from which most of the provisions regarding declarations of rights, taxes, and legislative authority were drawn. The constitution was also based on the United States Constitution.

The original Tennessee Constitution was not submitted to the voters for approval but was instead approved by the US Congress, in conjunction with the resolution admitting Tennessee as a state. It went into effect on June 1, 1796, when Tennessee officially became a state. President Washington signed the bill, and Thomas Jefferson described the constitution as the "least imperfect and most republican of the state constitutions."

However, by 1834, Tennessee's population had grown significantly, and the state had become more urbanized. As a result, the constitution was revised to update the court system and address issues with the original document, particularly regarding taxation and governance in a changing societal landscape. This resulted in a second version of the constitution being adopted in 1835.

The Tennessee Constitution continued to evolve, with a third constitution being adopted in 1870 after the Civil War. This version permanently abolished slavery in the state and addressed the overreaching actions of Governor William G. Brownlow. The 1870 Constitution remains the fundamental charter for Tennessee today, although it has been amended multiple times since its inception.

cycivic

It failed to address issues with the court system

The first Tennessee Constitution was drafted in 1796, and it came into effect on June 1, 1796, concurrent with the state's admission to the Union. It was drafted by a convention of 55 delegates in Knoxville, Tennessee, and was based on the United States Constitution. The original constitution was not submitted to the voters for approval but was approved by US Congress and President Washington, who signed the bill giving Tennessee immediate statehood.

The first Tennessee Constitution was revised in 1834 to address problems in the original document, including issues with the court system. By this time, Tennessee's population had grown significantly, and the state was becoming more urban. The 1834 revision focused on taxation, the courts, and how to govern this changing state effectively.

The specific changes made to the court system in the 1834 revision are not detailed in the sources available. However, it is clear that the original 1796 constitution did not adequately address the needs of the evolving state, particularly regarding the court system. This oversight was likely a significant factor in the need for a constitutional revision just a few decades after the original was adopted.

The 1834 revision was not the last change to Tennessee's constitution. The state has had three constitutions in total, with the current one being adopted in 1870 after the Civil War. The 1870 constitution is still in use today and has been amended numerous times to reflect the changing needs and values of the state.

cycivic

It did not account for the state's growing urban population

The first Tennessee Constitution was drafted in 1796 by a convention of 55 delegates in Knoxville. It was approved by US Congress and came into effect on June 1, 1796, when Tennessee officially became a state. The constitution was based on the United States Constitution and modelled after the North Carolina and Pennsylvania constitutions.

By 1834, Tennessee's population had grown to almost 700,000 people, more than six times the population in 1796. This rapid urbanization highlighted the shortcomings of the original constitution, which was primarily designed for a rural state. As a result, the constitution was revised in 1834 to address the changing demographics and needs of the state. The 1834 revision focused on taxation, the court system, and the challenges of governing an increasingly urbanized state.

The failure of the first Tennessee Constitution to account for the state's growing urban population reflected a lack of foresight in anticipating the state's rapid development and urbanization. This oversight likely stemmed from the state's rural roots and the limited scope of the original constitution, which may have been adequate for a less populous and more agrarian Tennessee. However, as the state's population expanded and urban centres emerged, the need for an updated constitution that reflected the diverse needs and interests of a more complex society became evident.

The 1834 revision of the Tennessee Constitution sought to address this shortcoming by adapting to the state's evolving demographics. It focused on issues such as taxation, which became increasingly important in a more urbanized economy, and the court system, which needed to adapt to the changing social and economic landscape. The revision also acknowledged the shift in power dynamics and the need for a governance structure that could effectively represent and serve a diverse and dispersed urban population.

In conclusion, the failure of the first Tennessee Constitution to account for the state's growing urban population was a significant factor in its eventual revision. This oversight highlighted the challenges of governing a rapidly changing state and the importance of creating a constitution that is flexible and responsive to the evolving needs of its citizens. By revising the constitution in 1834, Tennessee took a crucial step towards ensuring that its governing document remained relevant and effective in the face of urbanization and societal transformation.

cycivic

It was not designed to accommodate future amendments

The first Tennessee Constitution, which came into effect on June 1, 1796, concurrent with the state's admission to the Union, was not designed to accommodate future amendments. It was the product of a constitutional convention held in Knoxville, Tennessee, with 55 delegates drafting the constitution. This original constitution was never submitted to the voters for approval but was instead approved by Congress as a prerequisite for Tennessee's statehood.

The Tennessee Constitution has since undergone several revisions, with the second version adopted in 1834-1835 and the third and current version adopted in 1870. The 1796 Constitution was revised to address problems and update the court system to reflect the state's changing demographics, as Tennessee's population had grown significantly by 1834. The 1870 Constitution, which remains the fundamental charter for the state, included the permanent abolition of slavery and served as a reaction against the overreaching actions of Governor William G. Brownlow.

The process of amending the Tennessee Constitution involves the state legislature passing a constitutional amendment during two successive legislative sessions with an election in between. While a simple majority vote is required in both legislative chambers during the first session, a two-thirds vote is mandated in the second session. Amendments are then placed on general election ballots, and voters can approve or reject the proposed changes. For instance, in 1978, voters approved amendments regarding the governor's terms and metropolitan government but rejected a judicial amendment.

The Tennessee Constitution has been amended numerous times since its inception, with the most recent amendments approved by voters on November 8, 2022. These amendments are essential to ensure the document remains relevant and adaptable to the evolving needs and circumstances of the state and its populace.

Frequently asked questions

The first Tennessee constitution came into effect on June 1, 1796, concurrent with the state's admission to the Union. It was drafted in Knoxville by a convention of 55 delegates and was based on the United States Constitution.

The first Tennessee constitution was revised in 1834 to update the court system and address some of the problems in the original constitution. By 1834, Tennessee's population was more than six times greater than it had been in 1796, and the state was becoming less rural and more urban.

The second version of the Tennessee constitution was adopted in 1835, and a third constitution was adopted in 1870, after the Civil War. The 1870 constitution is still the fundamental charter for the State of Tennessee today, with some amendments.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment