The Constitution's Dual Court System: Why Separate?

The U.S. Constitution establishes a federal system of government, wherein power is shared between the federal government and state governments, each with its own court systems. Article III of the Constitution establishes the judicial branch of the national government, with the first sentence of Article III stating that The judicial power of the United States, shall be vested in one Supreme Court, and in such inferior courts as the Congress may from time to time ordain and establish. This provision ensures the Supreme Court's separation from the legislative and executive branches, while granting Congress the authority to decide on the establishment of other federal courts. The federal court system, established through the Judiciary Act of 1789, marked one of the first acts of the new Congress, reflecting the founders' belief in the importance of a national judiciary.

Explore related products

Federal Court Basics: The Structure and Function of Federal and State Courts

$11.95

Federal Courts and the Law of Federal-State Relations (University Casebook Series)

$120.33 $305

Examples & Explanations for Federal Courts

$53 $76.95

Federal Court Interpreters Orientation Manual and Glossary

$12.95

Hart and Wechsler's The Federal Courts and the Federal System (University Casebook Series)

$305

Federal and State Court Systems: Analysis of History Making Legal Precedent

$77.83 $159.93

The US Constitution creates a federal system of government

The Constitution establishes a federal judiciary, with Article III creating the Supreme Court and authorizing Congress to establish lower courts. This three-level federal court system includes trial courts, courts of appeals, and the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court is the highest court in the US, with the power to decide the constitutionality of federal laws and resolve cases involving federal laws.

The federal court system was established by the Judiciary Act of 1789, which gave the Supreme Court original jurisdiction and granted it appellate jurisdiction in cases from federal circuit courts and state courts where federal claims were rejected. The Act also established the limited jurisdiction of district and circuit courts. This system has been largely maintained, with Congress continuing to interpret and build upon it.

The US Constitution thus provides for two separate court systems—federal and state—with the federal government and each state government having their own courts. This duality reflects the compromise between ensuring a unified nation under federal law while recognizing the significance of state loyalties and autonomy.

The federal and state governments have their own court systems

The US Constitution establishes a federal system of government, where power is shared between the federal and state governments. Both levels of government have their own court systems, each with distinct structures, methods of judicial selection, and types of cases heard.

Article III of the US Constitution created the Supreme Court, the highest court in the country, and authorized Congress to establish lower courts. The federal court system, established in 1789, consists of trial courts, courts of appeals, and the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court has original jurisdiction, while the courts of appeals review decisions made by lower courts or federal administrative agencies. The trial courts, or district courts, resolve disputes by determining facts and applying relevant laws.

The federal court system is designed to maintain a balance of power between the three branches of government: legislative, executive, and judicial. While each branch operates independently, they must also cooperate. For instance, federal laws are passed by Congress and signed by the President, but it is the judicial branch that decides on the constitutionality of these laws. Judges rely on the executive branch to enforce court decisions.

The state court systems, on the other hand, handle cases that primarily concern state laws and disputes within their respective states. They are the first point of contact for most legal disputes and are often structured similarly to the federal system, with trial courts, appeals courts, and a state supreme court.

The existence of separate federal and state court systems reflects the compromise made by the Constitution's framers, who wanted to ensure that the federal government did not overpower the states.

Article III of the Constitution establishes the judicial branch

Article III of the US Constitution establishes the judicial branch of the national government. It created the Supreme Court and authorised Congress to pass laws establishing a system of lower courts. Article III states that "The judicial power of the United States, shall be vested in one Supreme Court, and in such inferior courts as the Congress may from time to time ordain and establish".

The Constitution thus establishes that there will be a Supreme Court, and that this Court is separate from both the legislature (Congress) and the executive (the President). The judicial branch, as part of its role in the constitutional system of "checks and balances", has the authority to decide the constitutionality of federal laws and resolve other cases involving federal laws.

The Supreme Court is the highest court in the United States. There are 13 appellate courts that sit below it, and 94 district or trial courts. Congress has continued to build on the interpretation of the drafters of the first judiciary act in exercising a discretionary power to expand or restrict federal court jurisdiction.

The founders of the new nation believed that the establishment of a national judiciary was one of their most important tasks. However, at the time the Constitution was written, the federal government seemed almost like a foreign government to some people. Their main loyalty was to their states, and they did not feel they had much of a say in who ran the federal government. To these people, an extensive system of federal courts, staffed by judges appointed by the President, amounted to allowing the federal government to get its tentacles into every corner of the nation.

The compromise was that, just as the Constitution and federal laws would be the “supreme Law of the Land,” there would definitely be a Supreme Court—a court created by the federal government, with judges appointed by the President, that would get the last word in case state courts did something threatening to the new nation. However, the extent and shape of the rest of the federal court system would be hashed out in day-to-day politics.

Explore related products

Low and Jeffries’ Federal Courts and the Law of Federal-State Relations (University Casebook Series)

$305

The Business of the Supreme Court: A Study in the Federal Judicial System (Library of Liberal Thought)

$31.7 $63.99

Federal Courts in Context [Connected eBook](Aspen Casebook)

$272.2 $344

Federal-State Court Directory

$99

Representing Yourself in Federal Court: A Handbook for Pro Se Litigants

$19.99

Federal Courts: Cases and Materials [Connected Ebook] (Aspen Casebooks)

$244.98 $359

The judicial branch has authority over federal laws

The US Constitution establishes a federal system of government, where power is shared between the federal government and state governments. Both federal and state governments have their own court systems, each with its own structure, judicial selection process, and types of cases heard. The Constitution's Article III establishes and empowers the judicial branch of the national government, ensuring the separation of powers between the legislative, executive, and judicial branches.

Article III of the Constitution created the Supreme Court, which is the highest court in the United States and sits at the apex of the federal court system. The Supreme Court is separate from both the legislature (Congress) and the executive (the President). It has the authority to decide the constitutionality of federal laws and resolve cases involving federal laws. The Supreme Court also has original jurisdiction, as outlined in the Constitution, and appellate jurisdiction over cases from federal circuit courts and state courts where federal claims were rejected.

Below the Supreme Court are the 13 appellate courts, or courts of appeals, which determine whether the law was correctly applied in the trial court or federal administrative agency. The nation's 94 district or trial courts, called US district courts, resolve disputes by determining the facts and applying the law. There are also 90 US bankruptcy courts that help individuals and businesses manage their debts.

The judicial branch's authority over federal laws is a crucial aspect of the system of "checks and balances" established by the Constitution. While federal laws are passed by Congress and signed by the President, the judicial branch interprets and decides on the constitutionality of these laws, ensuring a balance of power between the branches of government.

The federal court system was established in 1789

Article III of the U.S. Constitution created the Supreme Court and authorized Congress to pass laws establishing a system of lower courts. The Supreme Court is the highest court in the United States and is separate from both the legislature (Congress) and the executive (the President). The Constitution grants the judicial branch the authority to decide the constitutionality of federal laws and resolve other cases involving federal laws.

The Judiciary Act of 1789 established a limited jurisdiction for the district and circuit courts, giving the Supreme Court original jurisdiction and appellate jurisdiction in cases from the federal circuit courts and state courts where federal claims were rejected. This act also recognized that a full-blown federal court system would not be accepted by the people of the United States at that time.

The federal court system established in 1789 closely resembles the system we have today, with minor adjustments made over time. The system consists of trial courts, courts of appeals, and the Supreme Court, with about 800 federal judges.

Frequently asked questions