The First Modern Political Campaign: Who Revolutionized Elections?

The first modern political campaign is a topic that is often debated, with many attributing the title to William McKinley's 1896 presidential campaign. McKinley, a Republican and former Governor of Ohio, worked with his friend and political manager, Mark Hanna, to create a systematic nationwide effort to seek the support of Republican delegates. They campaigned under the slogan The People Against the Bosses, emphasising McKinley's refusal to broker deals with political bosses. McKinley's campaign is considered the first modern campaign due to its organised, systematic, and exemplary use of campaign tactics, including modern technology, to reach a wide audience and create a lasting impression with voters. However, some sources cite William Ewart Gladstone's Midlothian campaign in the 1880s as the first modern campaign, with potentially earlier examples from the 19th century.

Explore related products

The Victory Lab: The Secret Science of Winning Campaigns

$10.06 $19

Words to Win By: The Slogans, Logos, and Designs of America's Presidential Elections

$13 $24.99

The Campaign Manager

$40.62 $62.99

The Political Campaign Desk Reference: A Guide for Campaign Managers, Operatives, and Candidates Running for Political Office

$18.9

Identity Crisis: The 2016 Presidential Campaign and the Battle for the Meaning of America

$9.49 $17.95

The Greatest Comeback Ever: Inside Trump's Big Beautiful Campaign

$13.99 $32.99

William Ewart Gladstone's Midlothian campaign in 1878–1880

The first modern political campaign is often described as William Ewart Gladstone's Midlothian campaign in 1878–1880, although there may be earlier, recognisably modern examples from the 19th century. The campaign was an early example of many modern political campaigning techniques and created a momentum that carried the Liberals to power in the 1880 election.

Gladstone's Midlothian campaign was a political comeback after his Liberal government suffered defeat in the 1874 general election. The campaign was based on opposition to the Ottoman Empire's reaction to the Bulgarian April Uprising. Gladstone's interest in the issue was sparked by young journalist W. T. Stead, who pressed him to join the protest. Gladstone published a pamphlet titled "The Bulgarian Horrors and the Question of the East", which sold over 200,000 copies in a month.

The constituency of Midlothian, or Edinburghshire, was small, with only 3620 voters. However, it offered a sophisticated, metropolitan environment steeped in the tradition of the Scottish Enlightenment. It was also a battleground for influence between two powerful Scottish aristocratic families: The Duke of Buccleuch and the Earl of Rosebery. Rosebery, one of the richest landowners, became Gladstone's campaign manager and promised to pay all arising costs.

Gladstone's fiery, emotive, and logically structured speeches during the campaign are credited with swaying a large number of undecided voters to the Liberals. In the general election of 1880, Gladstone gave several speeches, some up to five hours long, which were widely reported and attended by thousands. Gladstone's campaign also benefited from the widespread reporting of his speeches and the public's interest in his ideas.

While Gladstone's Midlothian campaign is considered the first modern political campaign, the 1896 William McKinley presidential campaign is also notable for laying the groundwork for modern campaigns. McKinley's campaign, managed by Mark Hanna, is regarded as "the first modern presidential primary campaign" due to its organised, systematic, and exemplary use of campaign tactics.

Mark Hanna's role in McKinley's campaign

Mark Hanna, a businessman from Cleveland, played a crucial role in McKinley's 1896 presidential campaign, widely regarded as the first "modern" campaign in history. Hanna left his business career in 1895 to dedicate himself entirely to McKinley's bid for the presidency. He used his wealth and political connections to support McKinley's campaign financially and strategically.

Hanna and McKinley embarked on a systematic nationwide effort to secure the support of Republican delegates, campaigning under the slogan "The People Against the Bosses." This slogan emphasised McKinley's refusal to make deals with political bosses, positioning him as a candidate seeking the nomination without any strings attached. Hanna's fundraising efforts broke records, and his financial backing was instrumental in getting McKinley's message out to the voters.

Hanna also played a key role in shaping the campaign's strategy and messaging. He recognised the initial popularity of William Jennings Bryan's "Free Silver" platform, the Democratic nominee, but was confident that support would wane. Hanna's prediction proved correct, and Bryan's campaign struggled to regain momentum. Meanwhile, McKinley promoted his "sound money" campaign, emphasising the importance of a strong economy and stable currency.

Hanna's influence extended beyond the campaign trail. He declined a cabinet position in McKinley's administration, opting instead for a seat in the Senate. As a senator, he focused on issues of commerce and business-labour relations, and he played a pivotal role in advancing the proposed Central American canal, which became affectionately known as the "Hannama Canal" due to his strong support.

Hanna's political genius and savvy were evident in McKinley's successful 1896 campaign, and he continued to play a role in politics, even chairing McKinley's reelection campaign in 1900. McKinley's victory in 1896 paved the way for Republican dominance for nearly four decades, and Hanna's contributions laid the groundwork for modern campaigning, earning him a place in the history of American politics.

McKinley's campaign message

William McKinley's 1896 presidential campaign is regarded as the first modern campaign in history. It laid the groundwork for future campaigns, with McKinley's approach to campaigning continuing to influence campaigns over a century later. McKinley's campaign message was focused on several key themes and talking points, which are outlined below:

Unity and Reconciliation

McKinley emphasised the idea of post-Civil War America as one unified country with a common destiny. He quoted George Washington, saying, "There should be no North, no South, no East, no West — but a common country." By portraying himself as a unifier, McKinley's message was one of optimism and national unity, which helped broaden his electoral support base.

Opposition to Political Bosses

McKinley and his campaign manager, Mark Hanna, emphasised McKinley's decision to not broker deals with political bosses of the era, such as Pennsylvania Senator Matthew Quay and New York's Thomas C. Platt. They campaigned under the slogan, "The People Against the Bosses," presenting McKinley as seeking the presidential nomination without any strings attached.

Protectionism and Tariffs

As a noted protectionist, McKinley was confident in his stance on protectionism and tariffs. He believed that these policies would restore prosperity to the country. McKinley's campaign raised and spent millions of dollars on pamphlets, postcards, and other campaign documents to promote their policies and platform.

Economic Issues

McKinley effectively campaigned on economic issues, particularly in contrast to his opponent, Bryan. McKinley's supporters included well-to-do urban dwellers and prosperous farmers, and he was able to paint Bryan as a radical, a demagogue, and a socialist. McKinley's victory was attributed to his strong performance on economic issues and his ability to reach voters through newspaper coverage of his speeches.

Foreign Policy

McKinley's campaign also addressed foreign policy issues, such as America's interests in foreign markets. The Republicans, including McKinley, advocated for expanding ties with China and protectorate status for the Philippines. They also promoted an antitrust policy that condemned monopolies while approving the "honest cooperation of capital to meet new business conditions."

Explore related products

Buying the Vote: A History of Campaign Finance Reform

$23.87 $51

A History of Political Conflict: Elections and Social Inequalities in France, 1789–2022

$72.55

Quest for the Presidency: The Storied and Surprising History of Presidential Campaigns in America

$15.43 $36.95

Campaigns Inc.: Leone Baxter, Clem Whitaker, and the Invention of Political Consulting (Women in American Political History)

$108 $120

A People's History of the United States

$18.69 $23.99

The Evolution of Political Parties, Campaigns, and Elections: Landmark Documents, 1787-2007

$59.2 $74

The campaign's structure and strategy

The campaign structure and strategy of the first modern political campaign, the 1896 William McKinley presidential campaign, were characterised by a systematic and organised approach, utilising various techniques to effectively reach and influence voters.

The campaign was managed by Mark Hanna, a Cleveland businessman and Republican power broker. Hanna played a crucial role in building a large and efficient campaign organisation, overcoming obstacles such as opposition from eastern bosses like Thomas Platt and Matthew Quay. He travelled across the country, seeking support from Republican delegates and emphasising McKinley's independence from political bosses.

The campaign effectively utilised a combination of modern technology, messaging, and financial resources. McKinley's front porch campaign attracted 750,000 visitors to his small hometown and disseminated his message nationwide. The campaign focused on specific themes and talking points, such as "The People Against the Bosses" and the moral argument against debasing the currency, which appealed to crucial voter blocs.

McKinley's campaign also emphasised optimism, national unity, and reconciliation, portraying him as a unifier. This strategy was particularly effective in post-Civil War America, where the message of a common destiny resonated with voters. McKinley's campaign laid the groundwork for modern campaigns, influencing future electoral strategies.

In terms of structure, a campaign team, regardless of size, must consider effective communication of the campaign message, recruitment of volunteers, and fundraising. The campaign plan, a formal strategy, encompasses the campaign's goals, messages, target audience, and available resources. Political consultants play a vital role in advising campaigns on various aspects, including research and field strategy. Activists and volunteers are essential for promoting the campaign through activities such as canvassing and phone calls.

The campaign's impact and legacy

The impact of William McKinley's 1896 presidential campaign, often regarded as the first modern political campaign, was significant and far-reaching. It set a new standard for political campaigns, with its systematic and organised use of campaign tactics, which continue to influence modern campaigns.

McKinley's campaign modernised the art of political campaigning, and its legacy can be seen in the emergence of a new approach, dubbed the "educational or merchandising style" by Williams. This style emphasises the importance of a clear and consistent message, effective use of resources, and a focus on reaching and persuading voters. McKinley's campaign also laid the groundwork for modern campaigns by creating a larger and more structured campaign organisation than previously seen. This included the use of talented individuals to run state organisations and locals to ensure victory at the conventions. The campaign's emphasis on unity and optimism also linked the Republicans with positive associations, which broadened McKinley's support base and increased political involvement.

The success of McKinley's campaign, resulting in a decisive victory and nearly four decades of Republican dominance, highlighted the effectiveness of modern campaigning techniques. This led to a shift in how campaigns were conducted, with a greater emphasis on strategy, organisation, and the use of resources. The campaign's impact extended beyond the immediate election, shaping the future of American politics and influencing how candidates approach the challenge of getting elected to public office.

The first modern campaign also set a precedent for the role of political consultants, who advise on various aspects of the campaign, including research and field strategy. Additionally, it demonstrated the importance of understanding and targeting specific voter blocs, such as immigrants and urban factory workers, to achieve electoral success. The campaign's use of a consistent theme and talking points about policy issues created a lasting impression on voters, influencing how campaigns craft and deliver their messages today.

Furthermore, the 1896 McKinley campaign highlighted the importance of nationwide efforts and the support of delegates in securing a party's nomination. This led to a more systematic and organised approach to campaigning, with a focus on building efficient campaign organisations and utilising resources effectively. The campaign's impact on the Republican Party's ascendancy and the realignment of voting patterns further emphasised the power of modern campaigning methods in shaping electoral outcomes and the political landscape.

Frequently asked questions