The Constitution's Singularly Defined Crime

Treason is the only crime that is specifically defined in the US Constitution. Article III, Section 3 of the Constitution outlines the definition of treason, the requirements for conviction, and the significance of protecting individuals from unjust charges. This section states that treason consists of levying war against the United States or providing aid and comfort to its enemies. The Framers of the Constitution intended to create a restrictive concept of treason, narrowing its definition and making it challenging to establish. The inclusion of treason as the only defined crime in the Constitution underscores its importance in legal and political contexts.

Explore related products

The U.S. Constitution for Everyone: Features All 27 Amendments (Perigee Book)

$11 $24

Pardon Power: How The Pardon System Works—And Why

$9.99 $22.95

The Spy Who Couldn't Spell: A Dyslexic Traitor, an Unbreakable Code, and the FBI's Hunt for America's Stolen Secrets

$20.55 $27

High Crimes and Misdemeanors: The Case Against Bill Clinton

$8.3 $24.95

Constitutional Law for Criminal Justice

$115.06 $170

Legal Guide for Police: Constitutional Issues

$31.86 $54.95

Treason's definition

Treason is the only crime that is clearly defined in the US Constitution. This definition is outlined in Article III, Section 3, which also details the requirements for conviction and the importance of protecting individuals from unjust charges.

Treason is a crime committed by an individual who owes allegiance to a sovereign or country but acts to betray them. This could include attempting to overthrow the government, kill or personally injure the sovereign, or levy war against the country. The Latin root of the word "treason", "tradere", means "to hand over" or "surrender".

In the US, treason is defined as "levying war against the United States or providing aid to its enemies". This definition does not contain a territorial limitation, meaning American citizens can be found guilty of treason abroad, even if they are dual citizens. The Constitution restricts the definition of treason and permits Congress to create offences related to treason, as well as restrict punishment for treason to only the convicted.

Historically, treason has been used as a political epithet, with the term "traitor" used as a slur against political dissidents or officials who are perceived as failing their constituents. The accusation of treason has also been used as a unifying political message.

Requirements for conviction

Treason is the only crime that is clearly defined in the US Constitution. The requirements for conviction for treason are outlined in Article III, Section 3 of the US Constitution. This section also highlights the importance of protecting individuals from unjust charges.

To be convicted of treason, the crime must meet the definition outlined in the Constitution, which is: "Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort." The term "levying war" refers to the assembly of armed people with the aim of overthrowing the government or resisting its laws. "Enemies" are subjects of a foreign government that is in open hostility with the United States.

Additionally, the Constitution requires the testimony of two witnesses to the same overt act, or a confession in open court for a conviction. This requirement originates from the British Treason Trials Act of 1695. The witnesses must attest to the same overt act, indicating a treasonous intent. It's important to note that words alone typically don't constitute treason, but they can serve as proof of treasonous intent.

The penalty for treason is death or a minimum of five years' imprisonment, along with a minimum fine of $10,000 if not sentenced to death. A conviction also results in the forfeiture of the right to hold public office in the United States. While treason prosecutions are rare, they carry significant weight and penalties.

Protection from unjust charges

Treason is the only crime that is specifically defined in the US Constitution. According to Article III, Section 3, Clause 1, treason is defined as levying war against the United States or providing aid and comfort to its enemies. This section also outlines the requirements for a conviction and the protection of individuals from unjust charges.

The Framers of the US Constitution intended to create a narrow definition of treason, in contrast to the broader English law of treason, which could be used to cover many actions against the Crown. They were wary of vesting the power to declare and punish treason in Congress, having witnessed how the English kings and British Parliament had used treason charges to eliminate political dissidents. By including a specific definition of treason in the Constitution, the Framers restricted Congress's ability to change the definition of the crime or the proof needed to secure a conviction.

To protect individuals from unjust charges of treason, the Constitution requires that a conviction must be based on either a confession in open court or the testimony of two witnesses to the same overt act. This standard of proof makes it challenging to establish that someone has committed treason and helps to prevent the abuse of treason charges for political purposes.

The Supreme Court has also played a role in interpreting and clarifying the definition of treason. While there have been relatively few treason cases in American history, the Supreme Court has provided guidance on what it means to "levy war" and provide "aid and comfort" to enemies. This further contributes to the protection of individuals from unjust charges by ensuring a consistent and narrow interpretation of treason.

In summary, the US Constitution's explicit definition of treason and its requirements for conviction provide important safeguards against unjust charges. By restricting Congress's power and establishing a high standard of proof, the Constitution helps to ensure that treason charges are not misused or politically motivated. The Supreme Court's interpretation of treason also contributes to a consistent and narrow understanding of the crime. These protections underscore the importance of safeguarding individuals' rights and freedoms in the legal and political context of treason.

Explore related products

Constitutional Law for Criminal Justice

$91.4 $160

When Speech Becomes a Crime

$14.95 $14.95

Judicial Insurrection: One Woman's Pursuit for Constitutional Justice

$9.99 $22.22

We Charge Genocide: The Historic Petition to the United Nations for Relief From a Crime of the United States Government Against the Negro People

$19.59

Constitutional Law and Criminal Justice

$120 $300

Evolving Constitutional Rights: The Roberts Court and Criminal Justice (Perspectives on Crime and Justice)

$27.95

English law of treason

Treason is the only crime that is clearly defined in the US Constitution. The relevant section can be found in Article III, Section 3, which outlines the definition of treason, the requirements for conviction, and the significance of protecting individuals from unjust charges.

In English law, treason has a long and complex history. Prior to the Treason Act of 1351, treason was defined by the common law, with the king's judges interpreting an "assortment of royal power" as treason. This led to concerns about overreach, and in 1348, Edward III was pressured to restrict the definition of treason through an Act of Parliament. The Treason Act of 1351 established two varieties of treason: high treason and petty treason. High treason was considered a crime against the sovereign and included offences such as conspiracy to kill the sovereign, violating the royal bloodline, and fighting against the sovereign within their kingdoms. Petty treason, on the other hand, was disloyalty to a subject and included instances where a murderer owed particular "faith and obedience" to their victim, such as a servant killing their master or a wife killing her husband.

Over the centuries, various Treason Acts were passed, modifying the law. For example, in 1553, Mary I passed the Treason Act, abolishing all treasons created since 1351, but later that year, she made it high treason to forge the Sovereign's signet or counterfeiting foreign money. In 1708, following the Union of England and Scotland, Queen Anne signed the Treason Act, which replaced Scottish treason laws with English ones, making it treason to counterfeit the Great Seal of Scotland or kill Scottish judges.

Treason remained a capital offence in England until the Crime and Disorder Act of 1998, which replaced the death penalty with life imprisonment. While the definition of treason has evolved, it continues to be a serious offence, underscoring its importance in the legal and political context.

Congress's power

Treason is the only crime that is explicitly defined in the US Constitution. The Framers of the Constitution, having just gained independence from Great Britain, were wary of giving Congress too much power in defining treason, as they had seen the British monarchy use treason charges to eliminate political dissidents.

Article III, Section 3, Clause 1 of the US Constitution states:

> "Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort. No Person shall be convicted of Treason unless on the testimony of two Witnesses to the same overt Act, or on Confession in open Court."

The Framers adapted parts of the English Statute of Treason when formulating the treason clause, but they specifically omitted the phrase defining treason as "the 'compassing or imagining the death of our lord the King'". This was to prevent the expansion of treason laws, as had happened in England. The Framers intended to create a restrictive concept of the crime of treason, making it challenging to establish that someone had committed treason.

By defining treason in the Constitution, the Framers restricted Congress's power to change the definition of the crime and the evidence required to establish charges. The treason clause protects against a corrupt Congress or executive from easily expanding the definition of treason or altering the standard of proof required for conviction. The Supreme Court has clarified what it means to "levy war" and provide "aid and comfort" to enemies, and only 30 treason charges have been brought by Congress since the Constitution's ratification.

Frequently asked questions