Federalists Concerned About Constitution's Lack Of Protections

The Constitution of the United States was criticised for lacking protections for individual liberties, with several state legislatures expressing concern during the ratification process. The original text contained very few provisions protecting individual rights, with some framers believing that the central government they had created would not have the authority to violate individual rights. The Bill of Rights was added to the Constitution to address this issue, but it was written in broad language that excluded whole groups, including women and Native Americans.

Explore related products

The Anti-Federalist Papers and the Constitutional Convention Debates (Signet Classics)

$8.32 $8.95

The Anti-Federalist Papers (Dover Thrift Editions: American History)

$10

The Federalist & The Anti-Federalist Papers: Complete Collection: Including the U.S. Constitution, Declaration of Independence, Bill of Rights, Important Documents by the Founding Fathers & more

$0.99 $20.4

Documents of Revolution: Common Sense, The Complete Federalist and Anti-Federalist Papers, The Articles of Confederation, The Articles of Confederation, The U. S. Constitution, The Bill of Rights

$26.99

The Anti-Federalist: Writings by the Opponents of the Constitution

$33

The Essential Federalist and Anti-Federalist Papers (Hackett Classics)

$11

State legislatures

Several state legislatures expressed concern over the lack of protection of individual liberties in the Constitution. The original text of the Constitution contained very few provisions protecting individual rights. This was likely due to the belief that the framers had created a central government with limited powers that would not have the authority to violate individual rights. However, it is important to note that the Constitution itself does not provide the main protections of individual liberties. Instead, these protections are found in the first ten amendments, known as the Bill of Rights.

The Bill of Rights was added to the Constitution to address the lack of limits on government power. It includes the First Amendment, which protects the freedom of speech and religion, and the Fourth Amendment, which safeguards citizens' right to privacy by requiring a warrant for government intrusion into their homes. Over time, the Bill of Rights has evolved from a "parchment barrier" to a protective wall that shields individuals' unalienable rights from government overreach.

Despite the broad language of the Bill of Rights, it is important to note that it did not initially protect all people equally. Women, for example, were considered second-class citizens and were unable to vote until the passage of the 19th Amendment in 1920. Native Americans were also excluded from the constitutional system, defined as alien people in their own land.

Women

The original text of the Constitution contained very few provisions protecting individual rights. During the ratification process, several state legislatures expressed concern over the lack of protection of individual liberties. The Bill of Rights was added to the Constitution to address this, but it was written in broad language that excluded whole groups, including women.

The Founders saw the ability to speak and worship freely as a natural right protected by the First Amendment, and Congress is prohibited from making laws establishing religion or abridging freedom of speech. The Fourth Amendment safeguards citizens' right to be free from unreasonable government intrusion in their homes, requiring a warrant for any searches or seizures. These protections were meant to limit the power of the government and ensure the rights of individuals.

Gradually, the Bill of Rights was transformed from a "parchment barrier" to a protective wall that shielded each individual's unalienable rights from the reach of government. This transformation ensured that the rights and liberties of all citizens, including women, were protected and upheld by the Constitution.

Native Americans

The extra-constitutional status of Indigenous peoples within the US has always been both a blessing and a curse. Native nations have managed to fend off centuries of attempts at eradication and assimilation, retaining inherent sovereignty and governmental capacity. However, this also means that Indigenous peoples may be legally terminated, as a number were in the 1950s and 1960s.

The lack of constitutional protections for Native Americans has also resulted in the denial of rights protected by the First Amendment. For example, Indian religious beliefs have sometimes posed dilemmas for the application of such freedoms. Additionally, the idea of individual property ownership brought by Europeans has conflicted with the traditional Native American view of land as belonging to everyone.

Explore related products

The Anti-Federalist Papers

$10.95

The Anti-Federalist Papers Publisher: Signet Classics

$11.53 $24.99

The Anti-Federalist Papers

$0.99 $15.99

The Federalist Papers, Extended Edition: An Essential Collection of The Original, Unabridged Text (1787–88) With Detailed Commentary on Each Essay to Guide you Through America's Founding Ideas

$24.95

The Federalist Papers (Dover Thrift Editions: American History)

$7.14 $8

The Complete Federalist and The Anti-Federalist Papers: The Articles of Confederation, The Constitution of Declaration, All Bill Of Rights & Amendments (Part 4)

$7.49

First Amendment freedoms

The First Amendment freedoms are a set of rights that were added to the US Constitution through the Bill of Rights. The First Amendment protects the freedom of speech and religion, prohibiting Congress from making laws that establish a religion or restrict free speech.

The First Amendment was added to the Constitution because the original text lacked protections for individual rights and liberties. During the ratification process, several state legislatures expressed concern over this lack of protection. The framers of the Constitution believed that they had created a central government with limited powers that would not have the authority to violate individual rights. However, this belief proved to be incorrect, as the government began to intrude on citizens' rights, particularly their privacy and freedom of speech.

The Bill of Rights was intended to address these concerns and provide explicit protections for individual liberties. It transformed the Constitution from a "`parchment barrier`" to a protective wall that shielded each individual's unalienable rights from government overreach. The Bill of Rights ensured that the government could not violate citizens' privacy, freedom of speech, and freedom of religion.

Despite the intentions behind the Bill of Rights, it is important to note that it did not protect all people equally. Women and Native Americans, for example, were excluded from many of the rights and freedoms outlined in the First Amendment. Women were considered second-class citizens, unable to vote until the passage of the 19th Amendment in 1920. Native Americans, on the other hand, were entirely outside the constitutional system, defined as alien people in their own land.

Privacy rights

The original text of the Constitution contained very few provisions protecting individual rights. During the ratification process, several state legislatures expressed concern over the lack of protection of individual liberties. The Bill of Rights was added to the Constitution to address this issue, as the Constitution lacked limits on government power.

The Bill of Rights seemed to be written in broad language that excluded no one, but in fact, it was not intended to protect all people. Whole groups were left out, including women, who were essentially the property of their husbands and unable to vote until 1920, and Native Americans, who were entirely outside the constitutional system.

The Bill of Rights provided the missing ingredient that made the constitutional system work. It created a body of law that made First Amendment freedoms, privacy rights, and the principles of equality and fundamental fairness come alive. The Fourth Amendment, for example, safeguards citizens' right to be free from unreasonable government intrusion in their homes through the requirement of a warrant.

Gradually, the Bill of Rights transformed from a "parchment barrier" to a protective wall that increasingly shielded each individual's unalienable rights from the reach of government.

Frequently asked questions