Constitutionalism Vs. Ethnic Nationalism: Key Differences Explained

Constitutional patriotism is the idea that people should form a political attachment to the norms and values of a pluralistic liberal democratic constitution rather than to a national culture or cosmopolitan society. It is associated with post-nationalist identity, and while it is similar to nationalism, the attachment is based on the constitution rather than on a national culture. Ethnic nationalism, on the other hand, is a form of nationalism where the nation and nationality are defined in terms of ethnicity, with an emphasis on an ethnocentric approach to various political issues. Civic nationalism, which is frequently contrasted with ethnic nationalism, defines nation and its membership by living on common territory, common values and beliefs, and a common history.

Explore related products

Constitutionalism in Ireland, 1932–1938: National, Commonwealth, and International Perspectives (Palgrave Modern Legal History)

$92.5 $109

Ethnic Nationalism: The Tragic Death of Yugoslavia

$27.5

Modi's India: Hindu Nationalism and the Rise of Ethnic Democracy

$21.49 $35

Ethnic Nationalism and the Fall of Empires: Central Europe, the Middle East and Russia, 1914-23

$182.59 $64.99

The Affirmative Action Empire: Nations and Nationalism in the Soviet Union, 1923–1939 (The Wilder House Series in Politics, History and Culture)

$37.08 $42.95

The Golden Age of Black Nationalism, 1850-1925

$55.49

Civic nationalism is inclusive, ethnic nationalism is exclusive

Civic nationalism is inclusive, while ethnic nationalism is exclusive. Civic nationalism is often associated with Western nations and is based on the principles of citizenship, political participation, and shared values. It emphasizes a collective identity that transcends ethnic, cultural, or religious differences. Anyone who subscribes to the country's values and participates in its political life can be considered a part of the nation. For example, the American identity is built around the ideals of liberty, justice, and the pursuit of happiness, rather than a specific ethnic or cultural background.

Ethnic nationalism, on the other hand, emphasizes shared heritage, language, and cultural ties. It is rooted in the belief that a nation is defined by common ancestry and cultural identity. Ethnic nationalists argue that a nation is a natural community bound together by historical and cultural connections. They consider those of other ethnicities as outsiders or even second-class citizens. Ethnic nationalism tends to focus on a specific ethnic or cultural group and its heritage, excluding others.

The distinction between civic and ethnic nationalism can be blurry, and they may overlap in some aspects. Civic nationalism, for instance, still emphasizes a shared history and common territory, which can be inclusive or exclusive depending on the context. Similarly, ethnic nationalism can develop among minority ethnic groups who feel threatened by assimilation and seek to preserve their cultural identity.

Civic nationalism is often associated with long-established states that encompass multiple distinct territories and populations with diverse linguistic and cultural backgrounds. It provides a common purpose and identity that unite individuals within the state, even if they have little obvious common ground. Civic nationalism influenced the development of representative democracy in multiethnic countries.

Ethnic nationalism, also known as ethnonationalism, has traditionally been prominent in Eastern Europe and multi-ethnic empires such as the Russian, Austrian-Hungarian, or Ottoman Empires. It can lead to the desire for a separate state for one's ethnicity or the assimilation of minority groups into the dominant ethnic group.

Civic nationalism is associated with Western nations

Civic nationalism is frequently contrasted with ethnic nationalism. According to Donald Ipperciel, civic nationalism played a crucial role in the development of modern constitutional and democratic states. Civic nationalism is associated with Western nations, as it is considered more democratic and peaceful than ethnic nationalism, which has been linked to authoritarian rule and even dictatorship.

Civic nationalism is often associated with long-established states with stable boundaries that encompass multiple distinct territories and populations with diverse linguistic and cultural backgrounds. It emphasizes the idea of a voluntary partnership for a common endeavor, where individuals are united by a shared territory, history, values, and beliefs rather than a specific ethnicity. Civic nationalism is supposed to be non-xenophobic and inclusive, promoting ideals such as representative democracy, civic liberties, and tolerance. Western democracies like the United States, the United Kingdom, and France are often cited as examples of civic nations.

However, critics argue that the distinction between ethnic and civic nationalism is blurred. Yael Tamir, a former Israeli minister, claims that Western democracies use civic nationalism to foster an image of inclusivity while failing to address internal conflicts and racial tensions. Moreover, some scholars, such as Bernard Yack and Umut Özkırımlı, reject the notion of voluntary civic nationality, arguing that cultural memories and ethnic concepts of national belonging inevitably play a role in any form of nationalism.

While civic nationalism is associated with Western nations and democratic values, it is important to recognize that ethnic nationalism has also influenced Western countries. For example, the United States historically banned Chinese immigrants in the 19th century due to xenophobic sentiments, and similar concerns have been raised about the treatment of Islamic populations in Western nations in the 21st century.

In summary, civic nationalism is associated with Western nations due to its correlation with democratic ideals, liberal principles, and a voluntary partnership that transcends ethnic boundaries. However, the distinction between civic and ethnic nationalism is not always clear-cut, and Western nations have also grappled with ethnic nationalism and xenophobic tendencies at various points in their histories.

Civic nationalism is based on citizenship, political participation, and shared values

Civic nationalism is a concept that is often associated with Western nations. It is based on the principles of citizenship, political participation, and shared values. Civic nationalism emphasizes that anyone who subscribes to the country's values and actively participates in its political processes can be considered a member of the nation, regardless of their cultural background or ethnicity. This form of nationalism is inclusive and values the participation of individuals from diverse backgrounds, as long as they embrace the nation's values and principles.

The foundation of civic nationalism lies in a shared set of values, such as democracy, freedom, and equality. It promotes the idea of a collective identity that transcends ethnic, cultural, or religious differences. Citizenship plays a pivotal role in defining membership in a civic nation, and individuals are united by their commitment to democratic values and principles enshrined in the country's constitution. For instance, the American identity is built around ideals such as liberty, justice, and the pursuit of happiness, rather than a specific ethnic or cultural heritage.

Political participation is another cornerstone of civic nationalism. It emphasizes the importance of active engagement in the political process, including voting and public discourse. Civic nationalists believe that participation in the political life of the nation is essential for fostering a sense of belonging and shared purpose. This participation allows individuals to shape the direction of the nation and ensure that their voices are heard in the decision-making process.

Shared values are also fundamental to civic nationalism. Civic nationalists believe in a common set of values that unite the citizens of the nation. These values may include democracy, freedom of speech and religion, equality before the law, and respect for human rights. By embracing these shared values, individuals from diverse backgrounds can find common ground and work together for the betterment of the nation.

In contrast to ethnic nationalism, which emphasizes common descent, language, and cultural ties, civic nationalism focuses on the shared values and beliefs of its citizens. It is based on the idea that individuals from different backgrounds can come together under a shared sense of belonging and a commitment to a common set of principles. Civic nationalism has played a significant role in the development of modern constitutional and democratic states, promoting inclusivity and fostering a sense of unity among diverse populations.

Explore related products

The Ethnic Origins of Nations

$58.98 $71.95

Ethnicity and Nationalism: Anthropological Perspectives (Anthropology, Culture and Society)

$27 $24.19

Ethnic Nationalism in Korea: Genealogy, Politics, and Legacy (Studies of the Walter H. Shorenstein Asia-Pacific Research Center)

$21.71 $30

Legitimating Nationalism: Political Identity in Russia's Ethnic Republics

$64.84 $89.95

Nationalism and Ethnic Conflict - revised edition (International Security Readers)

$21.99 $40

Black Nationalism: The Search for an Identity

$26.59 $28

Ethnic nationalism is more common in Eastern contexts

Ethnic nationalism is a form of nationalism that defines a nation and its membership in terms of ethnicity, with an emphasis on an ethnocentric approach to various political issues. It is often associated with Eastern contexts and traditionally served as the determinant type of nationalism in Eastern Europe. It is rooted in the belief that a nation is defined by a shared heritage, language, and cultural identity, bound together by historical and cultural connections. This idea of a “natural community” is in contrast to civic nationalism, which is more inclusive and based on principles of citizenship, political participation, and shared values. Civic nationalism is more commonly associated with Western nations and emphasizes a collective identity that transcends ethnic, cultural, or religious differences.

The differences between ethnic and civic nationalism can be nuanced and blurred. Both aim to foster a sense of unity, but through different means. Ethnic nationalism emphasizes a shared ancestry, language, and cultural ties, while civic nationalism focuses on common territory, values, and beliefs. Ethnic nationalism traditionally developed among ethnic groups whose survival was threatened by assimilation or those living across several states, leading to a desire for a separate state to ensure cultural survival. Civic nationalism, on the other hand, tends to emerge in long-established states with diverse populations, serving as a way to explain heterogeneity and provide a common purpose.

The resurgence of ethnic nationalism can be attributed to the failure of modern nation-states to adequately address the needs of their minority populations, particularly in terms of equitable resource distribution and political representation. Economic deprivation, denial of cultural and political rights, and a lack of power-sharing for minority groups through constitutional means can fuel nationalist sentiments. This can lead to inter-ethnic tensions within and between states, challenging the state's claim to represent the interests of all its citizens.

Ethnic nationalism has historically played a significant role in various regions, including 19th-century Europe, where it was affirmed by liberal movements to topple classical conservatism. During the Cold War, the independence movements in former European colonies in Asia and Africa also reinvigorated research into ethnic identities and their interactions with statehood. More recently, increased international migration and globalization have given rise to "ethno-national" movements, including xenophobic and racist groups focused on exclusionary identity politics, particularly in the developed world.

In summary, ethnic nationalism is more common in Eastern contexts, emphasizing shared heritage and cultural ties. It has historically served as a response to assimilation threats or as a means to ensure cultural survival among ethnic groups living across multiple states. While civic nationalism is more inclusive and associated with Western nations, the resurgence of ethnic nationalism in various regions highlights the complex and evolving nature of nationalist ideologies.

Civic nationalism defines nation and membership by territory, values, and history; ethnic nationalism by shared heritage, language, and cultural ties

Civic nationalism and ethnic nationalism are two contrasting ideologies that define a nation and its membership. Civic nationalism defines a nation by its territory, values, and history, whereas ethnic nationalism defines a nation by its shared heritage, language, and cultural ties.

Civic nationalism, often associated with Western nations, is based on the principles of citizenship, political participation, and shared values. It emphasizes a collective identity that transcends ethnic, cultural, or religious differences. In a civic nation, anyone who subscribes to the country's values and participates in its political life can be considered a member of the nation, regardless of their cultural or ethnic background. This inclusivity is a defining feature of civic nationalism. It promotes the idea that a nation is defined by its shared values, such as democracy, freedom, and equality, rather than a specific ethnic or cultural identity. The concept of citizenship and a shared commitment to democratic values play a crucial role in shaping the national identity of a civic nation. For example, the American identity is built around ideals such as liberty, justice, and the pursuit of happiness, which transcend ethnic or cultural boundaries.

Ethnic nationalism, on the other hand, emphasizes a shared heritage, common language, and cultural ties. It is rooted in the belief that a nation is defined by a common ancestry and cultural identity. Ethnic nationalists view the nation as a natural community, bound together by historical and cultural connections. Ethnic nationalism tends to be more exclusive, focusing on a specific ethnic or cultural group and its heritage. It bases membership in the nation on descent or heredity, often articulated in terms of common blood or kinship. This emphasis on common ancestry and ethnicity can lead to the assimilation of minority ethnic groups into the dominant group, as seen in historical examples such as Italianisation and Germanisation.

While civic nationalism fosters unity through shared values and political participation, ethnic nationalism achieves it through a shared heritage and cultural lineage. These two ideologies represent different ways of defining a nation's identity and membership, with civic nationalism emphasizing inclusivity and shared values, while ethnic nationalism focuses on exclusivity and shared ethnicity.

Frequently asked questions