Who Really Controls Diplomacy?

which agent controls diplomacy

Diplomacy is the main instrument of foreign policy, representing a state's broader goals and strategies in its interactions with the rest of the world. The term 'diplomacy' is derived from the 18th-century French term 'diplomate' ('diplomat' or 'diplomatist'), which is based on the ancient Greek 'diploma' ('folded in two'), reflecting the practice of protecting the privacy of official documents by folding them before sending. Today, diplomacy is conducted by accredited officials, such as envoys and ambassadors, through dedicated foreign affairs offices, consulates, and embassies. These diplomats are protected by diplomatic immunity, which ensures their safety and ability to perform their functions. The power to dispatch diplomatic agents and receive public ministers lies with the executive, such as the President in the United States, who can recognise or decline recognition of new states and governments.

Characteristics and Values of Diplomatic Agents

Characteristics Values
Communication by representatives of state, intergovernmental, or non-governmental institutions To influence events in the international system
Negotiate, maintain political, social, and economic relationships with other countries Exemption from all dues and taxes except for certain indirect taxes, taxes on private immovable property, estate/succession/inheritance duties, taxes on private income, charges for specific services, registration/court fees, and mortgage dues
Appointed by their own country to reside in another country Inviolability, i.e., not liable to arrest or detention, and the receiving state must take steps to prevent any attack on their person, freedom, or dignity
Exempt from all personal services, public services, and military obligations Immunity from the criminal jurisdiction of the receiving state
Perform consular functions such as registrations of births, deaths, and marriages, and issuing passports Not liable to present themselves in court or give evidence in a court of law
Carry out diplomatic negotiations and processes, including international treaties, agreements, and alliances ---
Help shape a state by advising government officials ---

cycivic

The President's role in diplomacy

The President of the United States is the Chief Diplomat of the country, as outlined in Article II, Section 2 of the Constitution. This means that the President has the power to negotiate with foreign governments, appoint ambassadors, and make binding treaties. The President's role in diplomacy is, therefore, a critical one, with the power to shape foreign policy and America's relationships with other nations.

The President's role as Chief Diplomat gives them the authority to represent the interests of the United States abroad. This can include negotiating treaties, resolving international conflicts, and promoting American values and goals, such as democracy and peace. For example, President Clinton played a diplomatic role in rallying world leaders to the cause of democracy and resolving "The Troubles" in Northern Ireland.

The President is also responsible for appointing the heads of federal agencies, including the Cabinet, which plays a significant role in foreign policy development and implementation. The Department of State, for instance, leads in executing the President's foreign policy and has major responsibilities, including United States representation abroad, foreign assistance, and facilitating foreign nationals seeking entrance to the country.

While the President has significant powers as Chief Diplomat, there are checks and balances in place. The Constitution stipulates that the President must seek the advice of senators and obtain the consent of two-thirds of the Senate to make binding treaties. This power-sharing arrangement ensures that the legislative branch has a say in foreign policy decisions and helps maintain a balance of power between the executive and legislative branches.

cycivic

Diplomatic agents' powers and privileges

Diplomatic agents are representatives of their home country, residing in a foreign country. They act as a link between the two countries, maintaining and establishing mutual relations, and carrying out legal and political transactions based on foreign policies.

Diplomatic agents have powers and privileges that allow them to effectively perform their functions. These include immunity from criminal, civil, and administrative jurisdiction in the host country, as well as inviolability, meaning they are not liable for any form of arrest or detention and are to be treated with due respect by the receiving state. This immunity also extends to their immediate family members and staff, who are also bound to respect the laws of the host country.

Diplomatic agents are also entitled to freedom of communication with their home state and the freedom to travel within the host country, except for prohibited areas. They are not bound to give evidence or present themselves in a court of law, either in their host country or their home country.

In the UK, for example, the Diplomatic Privileges Act of 1964 gives effect to the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations of 1961, providing diplomatic agents with immunity from criminal, civil, and administrative jurisdiction. This Act also grants immunity to diplomatic staff and their families, as outlined in the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations of 1963 and the Consular Relations Act of 1968.

It is important to note that diplomatic immunity is not absolute and there are exceptions. For instance, in the case of grave crimes, diplomatic agents and consular officers may be detained, but only with a waiver of immunity from the sending state. Additionally, if a diplomat violates the laws of the host country, that country can declare the diplomat persona non grata and request their removal.

cycivic

International treaties and agreements

Diplomacy is the main instrument of foreign policy, representing the broader goals and strategies that guide a state's interactions with the rest of the world. It is the communication by representatives of states, intergovernmental, or non-governmental institutions intended to influence events in the international system. Treaties and other international agreements are written agreements between sovereign states or between states and international organizations, governed by international law. The United States, for example, enters into more than 200 treaties and other international agreements each year. The subjects of treaties span the whole spectrum of international relations, including peace, trade, defense, territorial boundaries, human rights, law enforcement, and environmental matters.

The role of diplomats is crucial in the formation and implementation of international treaties and agreements. They help shape a state by advising government officials and facilitating negotiations between nations. Diplomats operate through diplomatic missions, most commonly consulates and embassies, and rely on a number of support staff. The term "diplomat" is applied broadly to diplomatic and consular personnel and foreign ministry officials.

The process of forming international treaties and agreements involves several steps. Firstly, the negotiation stage involves diplomats from different countries discussing and negotiating the terms of the agreement. Once the terms are agreed upon, the treaty or agreement enters into force when the specified conditions are met. Bilateral treaties, for example, usually enter into force when both parties agree to be bound as of a certain date.

The specific content and scope of international treaties and agreements can vary widely depending on the issues being addressed. Treaties may cover a range of topics, including peace, trade, defense, human rights, and environmental protection. For example, the United States entered into the Treaty with Tripoli in 1796 to protect its citizens from kidnapping and ransom by pirates in the Mediterranean Sea. More recently, in 2001, the United States agreed to a treaty on cybercrime.

cycivic

The role of spies in diplomacy

Diplomacy is the communication by representatives of state, intergovernmental, or non-governmental institutions intended to influence events in the international system. It is the main instrument of foreign policy, representing the broader goals and strategies that guide a state's interactions with the rest of the world. International treaties, agreements, alliances, and other manifestations of international relations are usually the result of diplomatic negotiations and processes.

Spies and diplomats are both integral to the world of international relations. However, there is a clear distinction between the two. Diplomats are meant to operate above the surface, in the light, while spies lurk below the surface, operating in the dark. The official and private correspondence of diplomats is "inviolable", protected against interference and prying from the host country, according to the 1961 Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations. This convention, ratified by most sovereign states, provides a framework for diplomatic procedures, methods, and conduct.

While diplomats are meant to cultivate relationships and build credibility with local interlocutors, spies are tasked with illegally gathering intelligence, often by coordinating spy rings of locals or other spies. Spies operating out of embassies tend to gather little intelligence themselves, and their identities are often known by the opposition. If discovered, these diplomats can be expelled from an embassy, but counter-intelligence agencies often prefer to keep these agents in place and under close monitoring. Spies play an increasingly important role in diplomacy, as the information they gather is crucial for arms-control treaties and monitoring compliance.

However, it is important to note that diplomats should not engage in spying. Doing so would be a breach of the trust and privileges granted to them by the host country. Governments may engage in spying on each other, but it is essential to maintain a clear boundary between the work of diplomats and spies.

cycivic

The US State Department's use of diplomacy

Diplomacy is the main instrument of foreign policy, representing a state's broader goals and strategies in its interactions with the rest of the world. In the United States, the Department of State is responsible for carrying out the President's foreign policies. The Department of State facilitates the entry of legitimate visitors to the United States while denying visas to those who do not qualify or may pose a threat. It also works to nurture common interests and values between the people of the United States and those of other countries.

The US State Department uses diplomacy to protect America and its interests. This includes fighting international terrorism through sound policies, a concerted US government effort, and international cooperation. The State Department also provides foreign policy oversight and guidance to the US. Additionally, the State Department uses diplomacy to promote regional stability, joining with other countries in international organizations to prevent local conflicts from becoming wider wars that may harm US interests.

The Department of State also promotes transformational diplomacy by advancing environmental stewardship, encouraging economic growth, and promoting social development around the globe. It works with international partners to address climate change and energy security, aiming for sustainable economic growth and increased energy security. The State Department also engages international audiences on issues of foreign policy, society, and values to foster an environment receptive to US national interests. This includes communicating with foreign opinion-makers and other publics through public diplomacy programs and using cutting-edge technologies to reach a global audience.

The US State Department's diplomatic efforts also extend to disaster response and relief. For example, the US Agency for International Development (USAID) deployed the Los Angeles County Fire Department to Nepal to assist with recovery efforts after a powerful earthquake in 2015. The National Museum of American Diplomacy, located in Washington, DC, showcases the history, practice, and challenges of American diplomacy. It inspires the American public to discover diplomacy and its impact on their lives.

Frequently asked questions

Diplomacy is the communication between representatives of state, intergovernmental, or non-governmental institutions intended to influence events in the international system.

Diplomats are the persons who negotiate, maintain political, social, and economic relationships with other countries and are appointed by their own country to reside in another country. They act as a link between the two countries.

Diplomats have the power of inviolability, freedom of communication for official purposes, and immunity from civil administrative jurisdiction. They are also exempt from all dues and taxes, personal services, and public services.

The executive has the power to receive and dispatch diplomatic agents, recognize new states, communities claiming the status of belligerency, and changes of government in established states.

AI agents are being used in diplomacy to develop strategies, write emails, schedule meetings, book travel, and more. They can provide a sense of an adversary's thinking and help users predict probable responses and counter-responses.

Written by
Reviewed by

Explore related products

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment