Us Constitution: Budget Deficits And The Law

The US Constitution gives Congress the power to create a federal budget, determining how much money the government can spend in a fiscal year. The budget is a financial representation of the government's priorities, with spending on healthcare, retirement, and defense programs. A budget deficit occurs when the government spends more than it collects in revenue, and a surplus occurs when the government collects more than it spends. The US Constitution does not contain a balanced budget provision, and the federal government is not required to have a balanced budget. However, there have been discussions and attempts to introduce a balanced budget amendment to the US Constitution to reduce deficit spending and constrain irresponsible short-term spending decisions.

Explore related products

The Deficit Myth: Modern Monetary Theory and the Birth of the People's Economy

$11.99 $18.99

To reduce the budget deficit of the United States, and for other purposes.

$26.95

The Age of Deficits: Presidents and Unbalanced Budgets from Jimmy Carter to George W. Bush

$34.5 $59.99

The People's Money: How Voters Will Balance the Budget and Eliminate the Federal Debt

$14.56 $26

Budget deficit: Appendixes on outlook, implications, and choices : report to Congressional requesters

$10.99

Reconcilable Differences?: Congress, the Budget Process, and the Deficit

$85

The US Constitution and federal budget process

The US Constitution gives Congress the power to create a federal budget, outlining how much money the government can spend in the upcoming fiscal year. The Constitution makes clear that Congress holds the "power of the purse", giving it the authority to "lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises". It also specifies that ""No Money shall be drawn from the Treasury, but in Consequence of Appropriations made by law". Federal spending is classified into two categories: mandatory and discretionary. Mandatory spending includes funding for Social Security, Medicare, and veterans' benefits, while discretionary spending covers federal agency funding.

The federal budget process begins with the President's annual budget guidelines, which are then considered by Congress. Congress decides on the amount and type of discretionary spending and provides resources for mandatory spending. The Congressional Budget Act of 1974 established an internal process for Congress to formulate and enforce an annual plan for acting on budget legislation. However, Congress has often chosen to ignore this process in recent years.

The budget "reconciliation" process is an optional procedure outlined in the Congressional Budget Act to expedite the consideration of spending and tax legislation. It was envisioned as a deficit-reduction tool, but it has also been used to increase the deficit on several occasions. The reconciliation process allows Congress to use expedited procedures, such as directing committees to draft legislative language to fit specific budgetary outcomes and limiting the duration of debate on the Senate floor.

While there is no explicit requirement for a balanced budget in the US Constitution, the concept has been advocated in the past by the Republican Party. Balanced budget amendments are argued to reduce deficit spending and prevent irresponsible short-term spending decisions. However, economists generally agree that strict annual balanced budget amendments can have detrimental economic effects in the short term.

The size of the national deficit or surplus is influenced by the health of the economy and spending and revenue policies set by Congress and the President. A budget deficit occurs when government spending exceeds revenue, and a surplus occurs when revenue is greater than spending. The federal budget is intended to support the American public and fulfill the constitutional purpose of establishing justice, ensuring domestic tranquility, providing for the common defense, promoting general welfare, and securing liberty.

Budget deficit vs surplus

The US Constitution gives Congress the power to create a federal budget, which is then approved by the President. The budget outlines how much money the government can spend in the upcoming fiscal year. However, there is no balanced budget provision in the US Constitution, so the federal government is not required to have a balanced budget.

A budget deficit occurs when a government's expenditures exceed its income. This results in the government borrowing money and paying interest on the borrowed sum. Deficits are influenced by the health of the economy and spending and revenue policies set by Congress and the President. For instance, during the COVID-19 pandemic, revenue increased from approximately $3.5 trillion in 2019 to $4 trillion in 2021. However, increased government spending on unemployment and healthcare caused spikes in the deficit.

A budget surplus occurs when the government collects more revenue than it spends in a given year. A surplus is generally considered a good thing as the extra cash can be reinvested or used to pay off debts. However, if a surplus is a result of high taxes or reduced public services, it can negatively impact the economy. The US has rarely run a budget surplus, and experienced long periods of economic growth while running a budget deficit.

Keynesian economics theory suggests that governments should run a surplus during prosperous times and a deficit during a downcycle or depression. This allows the government to save money when it is well off and spend it on economic stimulus when the economy is struggling.

The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated that the budget deficit in fiscal year 2024 was around $2 trillion, or 7% of the economy as measured by gross domestic product (GDP). This was down from 9.8% during the Great Recession and 14.7% in 2020 at the peak of the COVID-19 shutdown.

Congress and budget responsibilities

Congress is responsible for creating the federal budget, determining how much money the government can spend in the upcoming fiscal year. The U.S. Constitution gives Congress the power to create a federal budget, a power often referred to as the "power of the purse". The budget is then approved by the President.

Congress decides on the amount and type of discretionary spending and provides resources for mandatory spending. The federal budget is divided into approximately 20 categories, known as budget functions, which are based on the purpose of the spending, such as National Defence, Transportation, and Health.

The Congressional Budget Office, established by the Budget Act, creates enforceable parameters within which Congress can consider legislation dealing with spending and revenue. The Budget Committee, also established by the Budget Act, is responsible for drafting budget plans for Congress and monitoring and enforcing rules surrounding spending, revenue, and the federal budget. The Committee also plays a role in the selection of the Director of the Congressional Budget Office.

The Budget Committee develops a concurrent resolution on the budget, which serves as a framework for congressional action on spending, revenue, and debt-limit legislation. The resolution is adopted by both the House and the Senate, but it does not become law as the President does not sign it.

The size of the national deficit or surplus is largely influenced by the spending and revenue policies set by Congress and the President. A budget deficit occurs when the government spends more than it collects in revenue, and a surplus occurs when the government collects more than it spends.

Explore related products

Deficit Politics in the United States (Europa Economic Perspectives)

$45.59 $56.99

The Budget Deficit and the National Debt (The Miller Center on the Budget Deficit and the National Debt)

$85

Working the Federal Budget: A Guide

$44.79 $55.99

Budget of the U.S. Government, Fiscal Year 2024 (Budget Of the United States Government)

$32

Fixing the Moral Deficit: A Balanced Way to Balance the Budget

$12.99

Red Ink: Inside the High-Stakes Politics of the Federal Budget

$13.99 $19

Balanced budget amendments

The US Constitution gives Congress the power to create a federal budget, determining how much the government can spend in a fiscal year. The US Constitution does not contain a balanced budget provision, so the federal government is not required to have a balanced budget, and Congress usually does not pass one.

A budget deficit occurs when the government spends more than it collects in revenue, and a surplus occurs when the opposite is true. The US Constitution's Preamble states that the purpose of the federal government is:

> "...to establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessies of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity."

These goals are achieved through government spending, which can be classified into two primary categories: mandatory and discretionary.

In the US, Senators Mike Lee and Chuck Grassley introduced an amendment to the US Constitution in 2023, requiring the federal government to balance its budget annually. This amendment would force Congress to balance its budget, limit spending to 18% of GDP, and require a supermajority vote to raise taxes or increase the debt ceiling. Senator Lee argued that a balanced budget amendment is necessary to eliminate deficits, reduce the national debt, and preserve the economy. However, some economists argue that strict annual balanced budget amendments can have harmful near-term economic effects, especially during recessions when deficit spending can be beneficial.

National deficit influences

The US Constitution gives Congress the power to create a federal budget, which is then approved by the President. The Constitution's Preamble states that the purpose of the federal government is "to establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity." These goals are achieved through government spending, which can be broken down into two primary categories: mandatory and discretionary.

The size of the national deficit or surplus is influenced by the health of the economy and spending and revenue policies set by Congress and the President. When the country's people and businesses are earning more money, the government collects more in taxes and other revenues, leading to a surplus. Conversely, when there is an economic downturn, government revenues decrease, potentially resulting in a deficit.

Legislative decisions that increase spending on Social Security, healthcare, and defense can also contribute to a budget deficit if they outpace revenue. For example, during the COVID-19 pandemic, government spending on unemployment benefits and healthcare caused spikes in the deficit, despite increased revenue due to widespread unemployment. Similarly, responses to the 2008 financial crisis, including bank bailouts and economic stimulus measures, grew the deficit.

In recent years, there have been discussions about introducing a balanced budget amendment to the US Constitution, which would require the federal government to maintain a balanced budget. Proponents argue that it would reduce deficit spending and prevent politicians from making irresponsible short-term spending decisions. However, economists generally agree that strict annual balanced budget amendments can have harmful near-term economic effects, particularly during recessions when deficit spending can help alleviate economic hardship.

In summary, national deficits are influenced by a combination of economic factors, legislative decisions, and the budgetary policies set by Congress and the President. While a balanced budget amendment has been proposed as a potential solution to deficit spending, it is controversial due to its potential negative economic impact.

Frequently asked questions