Patrick Henry's Constitution Stance: A Founding Father's View

Patrick Henry (1736–1799) was a firebrand speaker, a lawyer, and an ardent supporter of the American Revolution. He is best known for his famous declaration, Give me liberty or give me death, made during a speech before the Virginia Convention in 1775. Henry was an early opponent of the adoption of the U.S. Constitution, fearing a powerful central government and advocating for a bill of rights. He actively opposed the ratification of the Constitution and helped convince Federalists to agree to support a bill of rights, which paved the way for its adoption in 1788. Henry's critiques influenced the Bill of Rights and Democratic-Republican policy, and he is remembered as a founder of the republic who championed the cause of states' rights.

Explore related products

The Anti-Federalist Papers (Dover Thrift Editions: American History)

$10 $15.59

The Federalist & The Anti-Federalist Papers: Complete Collection: Including the U.S. Constitution, Declaration of Independence, Bill of Rights, Important Documents by the Founding Fathers & more

$0.99 $20.4

The Constitution of the United States (U.S. Heritage): with The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights and other Founding Documents with an ... by Constitutional Lawyer Alan Dershowitz

$34.99

How to Read the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence

$16.93 $14.95

The U.S. Constitution

$12.99

Benedictine Options: Learning to Live from the Sons and Daughters of Saints Benedict and Scholastica

$18.55 $19.95

Patrick Henry's opposition to the US Constitution

Patrick Henry (1736–1799) was a firebrand speaker, a passionate supporter of the American Revolution, and an early and staunch opponent of the adoption of the U.S. Constitution. He actively opposed the ratification of the United States Constitution, fearing a powerful central government and the absence of a Bill of Rights at the time. Henry's opposition influenced Federalists to support a bill of rights, which helped pave the way for the Constitution's adoption in 1788.

Henry's opposition to the Constitution stemmed from his belief in states' rights and his fear of a strong federal government. He viewed the Constitution as a threat to individual rights and states' rights, and his critiques influenced the eventual inclusion of a Bill of Rights. Henry's stance on states' rights was evident in his support for frontier interests against the aristocracy while serving in the House of Burgesses, the lower house of the Virginia legislature. He also helped establish committees of correspondence to open communication among the governments of the North American colonies.

Henry's influence extended beyond his political career. He is remembered for his oratory skills and his role in the fight for independence. He is best known for his declaration, "Give me liberty or give me death," made during a speech before the Virginia Convention in 1775. Henry's speeches filled a significant portion of the Convention's debates, and he played a crucial role in the passage of the Stamp Act Resolves, cementing his place among the leaders of the American Revolution.

Despite his opposition to the Constitution, Henry never rejected it after its adoption. In fact, he later joined the Federalist Party, supporting the development of a strong central government. He declined several offices under the federal government, including appointments as U.S. senator, Chief Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, secretary of state, and minister to France and Spain. Henry's complex political journey included a turnabout where he opposed the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions, which were secretly written by Jefferson and Madison to counter the Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798.

Henry's fear of a powerful central government

Patrick Henry was a prominent figure in the American Revolution, known for his powerful oratory and unwavering patriotism. However, his opinions and stances often diverged from those of his fellow founders, including Thomas Jefferson and James Madison. Henry actively opposed the ratification of the United States Constitution, fearing the concentration of power in a central government and the potential infringement on states' rights and individual liberties.

Henry's influence extended beyond his vocal opposition to the Constitution. He served as the first governor of the independent Commonwealth of Virginia, advocating for amnesty for British Loyalists and state support for religious teachers. Henry also played a pivotal role in the American Revolution, supporting frontier interests against the aristocracy and helping establish committees of correspondence among the North American colonies. Additionally, Henry was a delegate to the First Continental Congress and commanded the Virginia militia at the outset of the war.

Despite his initial opposition to the Constitution, Henry's views evolved over time. He eventually joined the Federalist Party, aligning himself with George Washington, and supported efforts to develop a strong central government. Henry's complex political journey demonstrates his commitment to adapting his beliefs according to the changing political landscape.

Henry's legacy is that of a passionate advocate for liberty and independence, even if his specific stances have sometimes been obscured or simplified in historical memory. His contributions to the founding of the American republic, both in terms of his political service and his influence on the Constitution, remain significant.

The absence of a Bill of Rights

Patrick Henry, a firebrand speaker, ardent supporter of the American Revolution, and early opponent of the adoption of the U.S. Constitution, played a significant role in shaping the country's political landscape. Henry's stance on the Constitution was influenced by his fear of a powerful central government and his belief in states' rights and individual liberties. Notably, one of the main reasons for his opposition to the Constitution was the absence of a Bill of Rights.

Henry, a strong Anti-Federalist, believed that the Constitution as it stood posed a threat to the rights of states and individuals. He argued that a powerful federal government could infringe upon the freedoms and autonomy that the colonies had fought for during the Revolution. Henry's concerns were shared by other Anti-Federalists, and their voices gained traction. As a result, the Federalists, who supported the Constitution, agreed to consider amendments after ratification, including the addition of a Bill of Rights. This promise played a crucial role in securing the adoption of the Constitution in 1788.

Henry's influence extended beyond his opposition to the Constitution. He was a skilled politician, lawyer, and orator, known for his powerful speeches. He served as the first governor of the independent Commonwealth of Virginia, a role to which he was re-elected multiple times. Henry also declined several prominent offices under the federal government, including appointments as U.S. senator, Chief Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, secretary of state, and minister to Spain and France.

Henry's legacy is complex. While he is remembered for his oratory and promotion of independence, his memory has also taken on a hazy, patriotic cast that fails to capture his fractious yet influential life. He has been branded a traitor and an apostate by some, while others, particularly Christian conservatives, view him as a hero due to his deep religious beliefs and defence of religious liberty.

Explore related products

The Anti-Federalist & The Federalist Papers: Complete Collection: The U.S. Constitution, Declaration of Independence, Bill of Rights, Works by the Founding Fathers…

$24.54

The Federalist & The Anti-Federalist Papers: Complete Collection: Including the U.S. Constitution, Declaration of Independence, Bill of Rights, Important Documents by the Founding Fathers & more

$0.99

Uncertain Justice: The Roberts Court and the Constitution

$13.23 $23.99

The Essential Debate on the Constitution: Federalist and Antifederalist Speeches and Writings

$15.96 $16.95

The Federalist vs. Anti-Federalist Dispute: The Original Arguments For Each

$0.99 $25.13

Presidential Candidate Patrick Anthony Ockander: Defending Our Constitution and Restoring Power to the People: Let Freedom Ring!

$5.47

Henry's influence on the Bill of Rights

Patrick Henry was an early opponent of the adoption of the U.S. Constitution, fearing a powerful central government and advocating for a bill of rights to protect states' rights and individual rights. Henry's opposition played a significant role in convincing Federalists to support the inclusion of a bill of rights in the Constitution, which ultimately helped pave the way for its adoption in 1788.

At the Virginia Ratifying Convention in 1788, Henry passionately argued against the ratification of the Constitution, deeming it a betrayal of the Revolutionary cause. He believed that the document concentrated too much power in the hands of a few and ignored the powers of the states. Henry's speeches filled nearly a quarter of the pages of the Richmond convention's debates, and his influence extended beyond the convention as well.

Henry's demands for a bill of rights were not just limited to his speeches at the convention. He actively pushed for a federal Bill of Rights, and his efforts were ultimately successful. The Federalists agreed to consider amendments, and Congress sent twelve constitutional amendments to the states. Virginia became the final state to ratify the ten amendments, known as the Bill of Rights, which reserved all rights not allotted to the federal government to the states or to the people.

In addition to his influence on the Bill of Rights, Henry also had an impact on the broader political landscape. He was a symbol of homeschooling and Christian conservatism, with his deep religious beliefs and writings in defense of religious liberty. Despite never holding national office, he was a founder of the republic and left a lasting legacy with his patriotic oratory and promotion of independence.

Henry's support for a strong central government

Patrick Henry was a prominent figure in the American Revolution, known for his powerful oratory and unwavering patriotism. He actively opposed the ratification of the United States Constitution, fearing a powerful central government and the absence of a Bill of Rights. However, towards the end of his life, Henry's stance shifted, and he reconciled with George Washington, whose strong Federalist leanings he had once opposed.

Henry eventually came to support the development of a strong central government, marking a significant evolution in his political beliefs. This change of heart was likely influenced by his fear of radicalism from the French Revolution spreading to the United States. He joined the Federalist Party and successfully ran for the Virginia legislature in 1799 at Washington's request, demonstrating his embrace of a stronger federal government.

Henry's influence extended beyond his political career. He was a skilled lawyer, and his arguments in court helped shape legal interpretations. Additionally, he was a strong advocate for religious liberty, and his deep religious beliefs made him a favourite among Christian conservatives. Henry's support for a strong central government, therefore, likely included a desire for the protection and preservation of religious freedoms on a national scale.

While Henry's opposition to the Constitution is well-documented, his eventual support for a strong central government should not be overlooked. His political evolution demonstrates his adaptability and commitment to what he believed was best for the nation. Henry's legacy is that of a complex and dynamic leader whose contributions to the foundation of the United States were significant.

Frequently asked questions