Buchanan's Stance On Lecompton Constitution: A Historical Perspective

The Lecompton Constitution was the second of four proposed state constitutions of Kansas. It was drafted in 1857 by pro-slavery advocates and included provisions to protect slavery in the state and exclude free Black people from its bill of rights. The document was written in response to the anti-slavery position of the 1855 Topeka Constitution. Free-state supporters boycotted the vote, and the Lecompton Constitution was approved in a rigged election in December 1857. Despite evidence that the Lecompton Constitution was only supported by a small minority of Kansans, President James Buchanan endorsed it before Congress, asking them to admit Kansas as a slave state. Buchanan's support for the Lecompton Constitution alienated many Democrats, including Stephen Douglas, who felt it violated popular sovereignty.

Explore related products

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights

$9.99 $9.99

The Presidency of James Buchanan (American Presidency Series)

$54.98

Message from the President of the United States to the two houses of Congress : communicating a certified copy of the constitution of Kansas, framed by the convention recently assembled at Lecompton

$10.65

The Constitutional and Political History of the United States, Vol. 6: 1856-1859; Buchanan's Election End of 35th Congress (Classic Reprint)

$34.97

The Democratic Collapse: How Gender Politics Broke a Party and a Nation, 1856-1861 (Civil War America)

$22.99 $27.95

Northern Men with Southern Loyalties: The Democratic Party and the Sectional Crisis

$14.99 $30.95

James Buchanan endorsed the Lecompton Constitution

James Buchanan, the 15th President of the United States, endorsed the Lecompton Constitution. The Lecompton Constitution was the second of four proposed state constitutions of Kansas, drafted in 1857 and strongly pro-slavery. It was written in response to the anti-slavery position of the 1855 Topeka Constitution. The document enshrined slavery in the proposed state and protected the rights of enslavers. It prevented the legislature from emancipating enslaved people without their enslavers' consent and full compensation.

Free-state supporters boycotted the vote, and the Lecompton Constitution was approved in a rigged election in December 1857. However, it was overwhelmingly defeated in a second vote in January 1858 by a majority of voters in the Kansas Territory. Despite this, Buchanan supported the pro-slavery vote and asked Congress to admit Kansas as a slave state. He submitted the Lecompton Constitution to Congress for approval, endorsing it before Congress. Buchanan's support for the Lecompton Constitution was unwavering, and he staked his administration on the passage of the Kansas statehood bill under this document.

Buchanan's position on the Lecompton Constitution was influenced by his belief that the Dred Scott decision would not expand slavery. He also argued that supporting slavery was necessary to prevent Southern secession and preserve the Union. However, his endorsement of the Lecompton Constitution alienated many Democrats, including Stephen Douglas, who felt it violated popular sovereignty. The debate over the proposed constitution ripped apart the Democratic Party.

Despite the opposition, the Kansas statehood bill passed the Senate in March 1858. However, Northern anti-Lecompton Democrats and Republicans blocked the passage of the bill in the House, causing a stalemate. A compromise was offered, proposing that the Lecompton Constitution be sent back to Kansas for another vote, which Buchanan rejected. Kansas voters overwhelmingly rejected the Lecompton Constitution in a referendum in August 1858 and were admitted to the Union as a free state.

He supported the pro-slavery vote

President James Buchanan supported the pro-slavery vote on the Lecompton Constitution in Kansas over the free-state vote. The Lecompton Constitution was drafted by pro-slavery advocates and included provisions to protect slavery in the state and to exclude free people of colour from its bill of rights. It prevented the legislature from emancipating enslaved people without their enslavers' consent and full compensation.

The Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 required people to decide on the issue of slavery through their vote for a constitution for any new territory which desired to become a state. This led to a series of events in Kansas and Missouri that culminated in violence and became known as "Bleeding Kansas". One of the most controversial events was the writing, voting on, and submission to Congress of the Lecompton Constitution by pro-slavery advocates in Lecompton, Kansas, in 1857.

The Lecompton Constitution was drafted by a pro-slavery convention, which was boycotted by free-state supporters. The convention presented voters with a pro-slavery constitution, and when the anti-slavery faction refused to participate in the election, the pro-slavery constitution was sent to Buchanan for congressional approval. Despite the clear majority opposing the Lecompton Constitution, Buchanan demanded that Congress approve it and admit Kansas as a slave state. His support for the constitution alienated many Democrats, including Stephen Douglas, who felt it violated popular sovereignty.

Buchanan's decision to support the pro-slavery vote on the Lecompton Constitution was based on his belief that it was necessary to preserve the Union and prevent Southern secession. He also believed that the Dred Scott decision would not expand slavery, but he rejected an opportunity to prove this to his northern critics. Instead, he supported the admission of Kansas as a slave state under the Lecompton Constitution, despite evidence that it was acceptable only to a small minority of Kansans.

This alienated many Democrats

The Lecompton Constitution was drafted in 1857 by pro-slavery advocates and included provisions to protect slavery in the state of Kansas and exclude free people of colour from its bill of rights. It was submitted to Congress by President James Buchanan in February 1858.

Despite the fact that the majority of Kansans opposed the Lecompton Constitution, Buchanan demanded that Congress approve it and admit Kansas as a slave state. This stance alienated many Democrats, including Stephen Douglas, who felt that the constitution violated popular sovereignty. Douglas, a noted Kansas Free State politician, led the opposition to the Lecompton Constitution, which was becoming increasingly difficult to sell to his northern constituents. To these northern citizens, Buchanan's insistence that Kansas be admitted as a slave state was a clear indication of the slave power manipulating northern Democrat politicians.

Douglas broke with Buchanan and joined with the Republicans in trying to block the Kansas statehood bill. This represented a growing trend among Northern Democrats in the late 1850s, who were finding it increasingly difficult to defend slavery to their constituents. Buchanan's support for the Lecompton Constitution, despite the clear majority of Kansans who opposed it, highlighted the irregular and fraudulent voting practices that had marked earlier efforts.

The debate over the proposed constitution ripped apart the Democratic Party, with Northern Democrats siding with Republicans in opposition to the Southern Democrats who supported Buchanan. The Kansas statehood bill passed the Senate in March 1858, thanks to the support of Southern Democrats. However, Northern anti-Lecompton Democrats and Republicans successfully blocked the passage of the bill in the House, causing a stalemate. Anti-Lecompton Democrats offered Buchanan a compromise to break the stalemate, but he rejected it for unknown reasons.

Explore related products

IDEAL INDUSTRIES INC. C24 Four-Way Crimp Tool – Spring Loaded, Fingertip Adjustment Wire Crimper for Two Connector Sizes

$77.03

The Death of the West: How Dying Populations and Immigrant Invasions Imperil Our Country and Civilization

$12.99 $22.99

Buchanan Clan Scottish Name Coat Of Arms Tartan Family T-Shirt

$17.99

Buchanan Scottish Clan Badge & Tartan T-Shirt

$18.99

Churchill, Hitler, and "The Unnecessary War": How Britain Lost Its Empire and the West Lost the World

$16.87 $22

Buchanan-Smith’s Axe Handbook: Knowing, Buying, Using, Hanging, Restoring & Adorning

$13.14 $24.99

He ignored the pleas of his own appointed Kansas governor

The Lecompton Constitution was drafted in 1857 by pro-slavery advocates and included provisions to protect slavery in the state of Kansas and exclude free people of colour from its bill of rights. It was strongly pro-slavery and prevented the legislature from emancipating enslaved people without their enslavers' consent and full compensation.

The document was written in response to the anti-slavery position of the 1855 Topeka Constitution. When voters met at Lecompton to write a state constitution, free-soil Kansans boycotted the registration and delegate election process, resulting in the election of a pro-slavery convention. When only a pro-slavery constitution was presented to voters, the anti-slavery faction again refused to participate in the election, and the pro-slavery constitution was sent to President James Buchanan for congressional approval.

President Buchanan's appointee as territorial governor of Kansas, Robert J. Walker, was a strong defender of slavery. However, he opposed the blatant injustice of the Lecompton Constitution and resigned rather than implement it. Walker warned Buchanan that the Lecompton Constitution did not fulfil the promise of popular sovereignty and that blood may be shed over it. Despite these pleas from his own appointed Kansas governor, Buchanan ignored Walker and asked Congress to admit Kansas as a slave state.

Buchanan's support for the Lecompton Constitution never wavered, and it became clear that he would stake his administration on the passage of the Kansas statehood bill under this document. He demanded that Congress approve it, even though a clear majority of Kansans did not approve of it. His unrelenting support for the constitution alienated many Democrats, including Stephen Douglas, who felt it violated popular sovereignty.

In February 1858, Buchanan submitted the pro-slavery Lecompton Constitution to Congress, and he subsequently recommended statehood for Kansas under its provisions. Congress balked, and a compromise was offered, calling for the resubmission of the constitution to the territory's voters. Kansas rejected it in August 1858 and was admitted to the Union as a free state in January.

He believed it necessary to prevent Southern secession

President James Buchanan endorsed the Lecompton Constitution before Congress, believing that supporting enslaver rights was necessary to prevent Southern secession and preserve the Union. The Lecompton Constitution was drafted by pro-slavery advocates and included provisions to protect slavery in Kansas and exclude free people of colour from its bill of rights. It prevented the legislature from emancipating enslaved people without their enslavers' consent and compensation.

Buchanan's support for the Lecompton Constitution was influenced by his belief that it was essential to prevent Southern secession. He feared that failing to uphold enslaver rights would lead to the South breaking away from the Union. This stance, however, alienated many Democrats, including Stephen Douglas, who felt that the constitution violated popular sovereignty. Douglas argued that the people of Kansas should have the right to accept or reject any constitution through a fair election, which was not the case with the Lecompton Constitution.

The debate over the Lecompton Constitution highlighted the deep divisions within the Democratic Party, with Southern Democrats supporting Buchanan and Northern Democrats siding with the Republicans in opposition to the constitution. Despite these objections, Buchanan remained steadfast in his support for the Lecompton Constitution, prioritising his belief in preventing Southern secession over the concerns of his own party members.

Buchanan's actions had significant consequences. The controversy surrounding the Lecompton Constitution and his insistence on admitting Kansas as a slave state, despite clear opposition from a majority of Kansans, indicated to many Northern politicians that the slave power was manipulating Northern Democrat politicians. This perception contributed to the growing tensions between the North and the South, further exacerbating the divide and pushing the country closer to the Civil War.

In conclusion, President James Buchanan's endorsement of the Lecompton Constitution was motivated by his belief in the necessity of upholding enslaver rights to prevent Southern secession. His actions, however, had far-reaching implications, alienating allies, deepening political divisions, and ultimately failing to prevent the country's descent into civil war.

Frequently asked questions