The Constitution's Promise: Impartial Jury Of Peers

The Sixth Amendment to the US Constitution guarantees the right to a jury trial for criminal defendants in all criminal prosecutions. This right is limited to serious offenses and does not apply to petty crimes or juvenile proceedings. The jury trial provision in the Sixth Amendment ensures a fair and impartial criminal prosecution, protecting against unfounded charges and overzealous prosecution. The Seventh Amendment further preserves the right to a jury trial in civil cases, involving disputes over a certain monetary threshold, although this varies among states. The jury system has its roots in English common law and has evolved to become a fundamental aspect of the US justice system, ensuring a fair trial and safeguarding against potential abuses of power.

Explore related products

Common Law Petit Jury Handbook

$6.99

The Constitution of the United States and The Declaration of Independence

$1.99 $6.95

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights

$9.99 $9.99

Jury Duty, Jury Nullification and Surviving a Rigged Court Process

$0.99 $7.99

The Palladium of Justice: Origins of Trial by Jury

$18.31

Evolving Constitutional Rights: The Roberts Court and Criminal Justice (Perspectives on Crime and Justice)

$27.95

The Sixth Amendment

The right to a jury trial is deeply rooted in the history of the US legal system. It can be traced back to English common law, where it evolved as a method to resolve disputes. Initially, jurors acted as witnesses, but over time, they transitioned into a more neutral fact-finding role. By the time of the American Revolution, the right to a jury trial was enshrined in the constitutions of the original 13 states.

The US Supreme Court has provided further clarification on the Sixth Amendment. In 1968, the Court ruled that the right to a jury trial applied not only to federal courts but also to state courts. Additionally, the Court has held that a jury must be sufficiently large to promote deliberation and represent a cross-section of the community. While historically, juries consisted of 12 people, this number is not considered a requirement for a valid jury.

Criminal prosecutions

The Sixth Amendment to the US Constitution guarantees a criminal defendant the right to a jury trial in "all criminal prosecutions". This right is limited to serious offences, and petty offences are excluded from the guarantee of a jury trial. The Supreme Court has held that no offence can be deemed 'petty' if imprisonment for more than six months is authorised.

The Sixth Amendment also guarantees several other rights, including the right to a speedy and public trial, the right to an impartial jury, the right to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation, the right to confront witnesses, the right to obtain witnesses in their favour, and the right to assistance of counsel for their defence.

The right to a jury trial is important because it ensures a fair and impartial criminal prosecution. It acts as a safeguard against oppression by the government and unfounded criminal charges. The framers of the constitution wanted to protect against arbitrary action and overzealous prosecutors. The jury trial provisions reflect a profound judgment about the way in which law should be enforced and justice administered.

The right to a jury trial is waivable in certain instances, although this differs depending on the jurisdiction. In federal district court, defendants can ask to waive the jury, but the court and prosecutor must agree, and the waiver must be in writing and done knowingly and voluntarily. The right is generally not waivable when a defendant faces the possibility of the death penalty.

Civil jury trials

The Sixth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees criminal defendants the right to a jury trial and several other rights. The right to a jury trial is important because it ensures a fair and impartial criminal prosecution. The Sixth Amendment is phrased in terms of "all criminal prosecutions," but petty offenses are excluded from the guarantee of a jury trial in federal courts. The Supreme Court interprets this constitutional right to limit the right to a jury trial to instances where the criminal charges constitute "serious offenses."

The Seventh Amendment, on the other hand, preserves the defendant's right to a jury trial in civil cases. This amendment was ratified on December 15, 1791, and protects citizens' right to a jury trial in federal courts when the claim exceeds a certain dollar value. The exact text of the amendment is as follows: "In suits at common law, where the value in controversy shall exceed twenty dollars, the right of trial by jury shall be preserved, and no fact tried by a jury shall be otherwise re-examined in any court of the United States than according to the rules of common law."

The Seventh Amendment's provisions for a civil jury date back to traditional English common law. During the Middle Ages, English courts used juries composed of people inexperienced in legal affairs to make decisions. By the time of the American Revolution, many of the new states' constitutions specifically included the right to a jury in civil and criminal cases. The inclusion of civil juries in the Constitution was pushed for by Anti-Federalists, who believed they would serve as a defence against overreach and corruption from the legislative, executive, and judicial branches of the federal government.

While the Seventh Amendment guarantees the right to a civil jury trial at the federal level, it does not require states to do so. However, most states have included the right to a civil trial to some degree in their constitutions.

Explore related products

Perfecting the U.S. Constitution: 27 and Counting, The Amendments that Shaped America’s Future (Anthem Studies in Law Reform, 1)

$19.99 $90

Painting Constitutional Law Xavier Cortadas Images of Constitutional Rights (Legal History Library)

$157.28

The United States Constitution: What It Says, What It Means: A Hip Pocket Guide

$5.99

The Know Your Bill of Rights Workbook: Don't Lose Your Constitutional Rights--Learn Them!

$14.99

Constitution of the United States (Books of American Wisdom)

$9.25 $9.95

I, The Jury

$13.6

Jury size

The Sixth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees the right to a jury trial for criminal defendants in "all criminal prosecutions". However, the Supreme Court has interpreted this to only apply to serious offences, excluding petty crimes from the guarantee of a jury trial. The Sixth Amendment also guarantees several other rights, including the right to a speedy and public trial, the right to an impartial jury of the state and district where the crime was committed, the right to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation, the right to confront witnesses, the right to obtain witnesses for the defence, and the right to the assistance of counsel for the defence.

The Seventh Amendment, on the other hand, preserves the right to a jury trial in civil cases involving disputes over a certain monetary threshold. This amendment was ratified on December 15, 1791, and applies on the federal level. It protects citizens' right to a jury trial in federal courts for civil cases where the claim exceeds $20. While most states have included the right to a civil jury trial in their constitutions, they are not required to guarantee civil trials under the Seventh Amendment.

The exact number of jurors in a jury trial has been a subject of debate. Traditionally, juries consisted of 12 persons, and this number was considered firmly established when the Sixth Amendment was proposed and ratified. However, in Williams v. Florida, the Court held that fixing the jury size at 12 was a historical accident and not a necessary attribute of the jury system. The Court's decision in Apodaca v. Oregon also suggested that the framers of the Sixth Amendment did not intend to preserve the unanimity requirement within the term "jury".

Despite the reconsideration of the unanimity rule, the jury size must still be sufficiently large to promote deliberation and represent a cross-section of the community. A six-member jury has been upheld as constitutional, provided that it meets these criteria. The jury's role is crucial in determining any facts that may increase the penalty for a crime beyond the statutory maximum.

Unanimous verdicts

The Sixth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees criminal defendants the right to a jury trial and several other rights. The right to a jury trial is important because it ensures a fair and impartial criminal prosecution. The Sixth Amendment is phrased in terms of “all criminal prosecutions," but petty offenses are excluded from the guarantee of a jury trial. The Supreme Court's interpretation of this constitutional right limits the right to a jury trial to instances where the criminal charges constitute "serious offenses."

The right to a unanimous jury verdict has been a topic of debate and reconsideration. The Supreme Court previously held that the right to a jury trial included all essential elements as understood and applied at common law, including a unanimous verdict by a jury of 12 people. However, in Apodaca v. Oregon, a four-justice plurality concluded that the framers of the Sixth Amendment likely did not intend to preserve the unanimity requirement. They argued that unanimity did not materially affect the jury's role as a barrier against oppression or its ability to deliver commonsense judgments.

The Seventh Amendment, on the other hand, specifically addresses civil cases. It protects the right of citizens to have a jury trial in federal courts for civil cases exceeding a certain dollar value. This amendment was added due to the demands of Anti-Federalists, who believed that civil juries were necessary to defend against overreach and corruption from the legislative, executive, and judicial branches of the federal government. The Seventh Amendment's provisions for civil juries date back to traditional English common law, which influenced the American legal system.

While the Sixth Amendment guarantees the right to a jury trial in criminal cases, it does not specify the size of the jury. The Supreme Court has ruled that fixing the jury size at 12 is a historical accident and is not a requirement for a valid jury system. However, the jury must be sufficiently large to promote deliberation and represent a cross-section of the community.

In summary, the U.S. Constitution, through the Sixth and Seventh Amendments, guarantees the right to a jury trial in criminal and civil cases, respectively. The Sixth Amendment does not specify a jury size but ensures a unanimous verdict, while the Seventh Amendment addresses civil cases and is tied to the dollar value of the claim.

Frequently asked questions