Solon And Cleisthenes: Contrasting Constitutional Reforms

Solon was an Athenian statesman, lawmaker, political philosopher, and poet who lived between 630 and 560 BC. He is credited with laying the foundations for Athenian democracy through his constitutional reforms, which replaced a hereditary aristocracy with a system based on wealth. Solon established a constitutional order with a single chief consultative body, the Council of the Four Hundred, and a single administrative body, the Areopagus. He also implemented economic reforms, such as debt relief for poor farmers, later known as the seisachtheia or shaking off of burdens. Cleisthenes, on the other hand, was a statesman who came after Solon and built upon his reforms to establish Classical Athenian democracy. While Solon's constitution aimed to balance rival factions and create a mixed form of government, Cleisthenes' reforms fully embraced democracy and gave all Athenians the right to participate in the assembly.

Differences between Solon's Constitution and Cleisthenes' reforms:

Explore related products

The Athenian Constitution (World Classics)

$2.99 $4.99

Athenian Democracy (Lancaster Pamphlets in Ancient History)

$28.91 $52.99

The Growth of the Athenian Economy (Economic History)

$270.32

Solon the Athenian

$29.95

The Athenian Option (Sortition and Public Policy Book 5)

$11.99

From Solon to Socrates: Greek History and Civilization During the 6th and 5th Centuries BC (Routledge Classics)

$23.99 $29.99

Solon's constitution reduced aristocratic power, with wealth determining political position

Solon, an archaic Athenian statesman, lawmaker, political philosopher, and poet, is credited with laying the foundations for Athenian democracy through his constitutional reforms. Solon's constitution aimed to reduce the power of the old aristocracy and shift the criterion for holding political positions from birth to wealth, a system called timocracy.

Solon divided citizens into four classes based on their land production and income: the pentacosiomedimnoi, the hippeis or knights, the zeugitae or hoplite-class, and the thetes or lowest class. Most offices were restricted to the upper classes, as the lowest class had little to no official role due to their inability to afford time off for public service. Despite these divisions, Solon believed that all classes were interconnected. He considered any disservice against one member of society to be an indirect disservice against every member.

Solon's reforms also included debt relief, later celebrated by Athenians as the seisachtheia, or "shaking off of burdens." He abolished all debts, freed debt-slaves, and eliminated the status of hectemoroi, who farmed under an early form of serfdom. Aristotle described Solon as "the first people's champion" in the Athenian Constitution.

While Solon's constitution marked a significant step towards democracy, it did not fully eradicate aristocratic power. Solon himself was fundamentally aristocratic, and his reforms primarily benefited the upper classes. The lowest class, the thetes, remained largely excluded from political participation due to their economic status.

Cleisthenes, an Alcmaeonid, further advanced democracy by ousting the tyrant Hippias with Sparta's help and implementing a series of reforms. While Cleisthenes contributed significantly to Athenian democracy, Athenians increasingly ignored him and portrayed Solon and Theseus as their primary democratic founders.

Solon's reforms abolished debts and freed debt slaves

Solon was an Athenian statesman, lawmaker, political philosopher, and poet. He is credited with laying the foundations for Athenian democracy and is considered one of the Seven Sages of Greece. Solon's constitutional reforms aimed to address the economic and social instability in Athens, caused by the accumulation of debt and the enslavement of debtors.

The abolition of debt slavery had a significant and lasting impact on Athenian society. It addressed the power imbalance between creditors and debtors, where debtors and their families could be compelled to work for creditors or be sold into slavery. By abolishing debt slavery, Solon's reforms provided economic relief to the most oppressed groups and ensured that individuals could not be enslaved by their countrymen over debt obligations.

Solon's broader constitutional reforms aimed to reduce the power of the old aristocracy and create a timocracy, where wealth, rather than birth, determined eligibility for political positions. Solon divided citizens into four classes based on land ownership and agricultural production: the pentacosiomedimnoi, the hippeis, the zeugitae, and the thetes. While Solon's reforms granted political rights to the upper three classes, the lowest class, the thetes, had little official role and were largely excluded from political power.

While Solon's reforms were intended to address the social and economic crises in Athens, they were not without criticism or controversy. Some scholars interpret Solon's reforms as a cancellation of debts, while others view them as the abolition of a feudal relationship between debtors and creditors. Additionally, Solon's reform may have unintentionally removed the ordinary farmer's means of obtaining credit by abolishing debt slavery. Despite these debates and limitations, Solon's reforms are celebrated by Athenians as a "shaking off of burdens," demonstrating their significance and impact on Athenian society.

Cleisthenes furthered democracy by ousting Hippias and implementing reforms

Cleisthenes is regarded as the founder of Athenian democracy. He was an Athenian statesman who reformed the political structure and processes of Athens at the end of the 6th century BCE. He is credited with creating a celebrated system of democracy, which allowed all citizens to actively and directly participate in government.

Cleisthenes was born into the aristocratic Alcmaeonid family of Athens in the late 570s BCE. His father, Megacles, was a powerful figure in Athenian politics. Cleisthenes first came to political prominence when he was made archon, a high administrative official, in 525 BCE during the reign of the tyrant Hippias, son of Peisistratus. In 510 BCE, with the help of Spartan troops, the Athenians overthrew Hippias and established a pro-Spartan oligarchy headed by Isagoras.

After the overthrow of Hippias, Cleisthenes began to reform the government of Athens. He changed the political organization from the four traditional tribes, which were based on family relations, to ten tribes according to their area of residence (deme). This reform reduced the power of the nobility and fostered unity among citizens, creating a new democratic power structure.

Cleisthenes also increased the power of the Athenian citizens' assembly and reduced the influence of the nobility in Athenian politics. He may have introduced ostracism, a process whereby a vote by at least 6,000 citizens would exile a citizen for ten years if they were deemed a threat to democracy or had too much power in the city. This further ensured the power of the citizens in the democratic system.

Explore related products

The Ancient Greeks

$44.96 $63.99

Economic Analysis of Institutional Change in Ancient Greece: Politics, Taxation and Rational Behaviour (Routledge Explorations in Economic History)

$200 $72.99

The Birth of the Athenian Community: From Solon to Cleisthenes

$56.99 $56.99

Cornell studies in classical philology; No. IV; The Development of the Athenian Constitution

$18.45

Aspects of Greek History 750-323BC: A Source-Based Approach (Aspects of Classical Civilization)

$45.59 $59.99

From Popular Sovereignty to the Sovereignty of Law: Law, Society, and Politics in Fifth-Century Athens

$31.95 $52.95

Solon's constitution divided citizens into four classes based on land production

Solon, an archaic Athenian statesman, lawmaker, political philosopher, and poet, is credited with laying the foundations for Athenian democracy through his constitutional reforms. His constitution, known as the Solonian constitution, divided citizens into four classes based on land production. These classes were: pentacosiomedimnoi, hippeis (or Knights), zeugitae (or hoplite-class), and thetes (the lowest class).

The pentacosiomedimnoi were the richest class, followed by the hippeis, who were composed of men with at least 300 medimnoi or its equivalent as yearly income. The zeugitae were the hoplite-class, and the thetes were the lowest class, with virtually no official role in government.

Solon's constitution reduced the power of the old aristocracy by making wealth, rather than birth, the criterion for holding political positions. This system was called timokratia or timocracy. While Solon's constitution maintained a division between classes and citizens, he believed that all members of society were connected as one. He felt that a disservice against any member of society would indirectly be a disservice against every member.

Solon's reforms also included debt relief, later celebrated among Athenians as the seisachtheia or "shaking off of burdens." He abolished all debts and freed debt-slaves, as well as improving the status of the hectemoroi, who farmed in an early form of serfdom. Through his reforms, Solon helped to legislate against political, economic, and moral decline in Athens, although it would be inaccurate to call him a democrat as he was fundamentally aristocratic.

Cleisthenes, on the other hand, furthered democracy by ousting the Pisistratid tyrant Hippias with the help of Sparta and implementing a series of reforms. While Solon's laws were considered longstanding, Cleisthenes' laws may not have stood the test of time in the same way. Over time, Cleisthenes was increasingly ignored by Athenians, who came to portray Theseus and Solon as their democratic founders.

Cleisthenes was ignored by Athenians, who saw Solon as a democratic founder

Solon was an Athenian statesman, lawmaker, political philosopher, and poet who lived between 630 and 560 BC. He is credited with laying the foundations for Athenian democracy through his constitutional reforms, which overturned most of Draco's laws. Solon's constitution reduced the power of the old aristocracy by introducing a system called timokratia (timocracy), where wealth, rather than birth, was the criterion for holding political positions. He divided citizens into four classes based on land production and income: the pentacosiomedimnoi (the rich), the hippeis or knights (the second-highest class), the zeugitae or hoplite-class, and the thetes or the lowest class. Despite these divisions, Solon believed that all classes were connected as one and that any disservice against one member of society would indirectly be a disservice against every member.

Solon's reforms also included debt relief, later celebrated by Athenians as the seisachtheia or "shaking off of burdens". He abolished all debts and freed debt-slaves, as well as improving the status of hectemoroi, who farmed in an early form of serfdom. Solon is described by Aristotle in the Athenian Constitution as "the first people's champion". However, it would be inaccurate to call Solon a democrat as he was fundamentally aristocratic. Most offices were restricted to the upper classes, and the lowest class, the thetes, had virtually no official role due to their lack of wealth.

Cleisthenes, on the other hand, was an Alcmaeonid who furthered democracy by ousting the Pisistratid tyrant Hippias with the help of Sparta and implementing a series of reforms. While Solon had divided citizens into classes, Cleisthenes united them by creating a council composed of citizens from all classes. Over time, however, Cleisthenes was increasingly ignored by Athenians, who saw Solon as one of their democratic founders, along with Theseus.

The basic outline of the development of Athenian democracy can be traced from Solon to Cleisthenes, with the former laying the foundations and the latter building upon them. While Solon is credited with establishing the principles of democracy, Cleisthenes' contributions were no less significant, as he implemented reforms that furthered democratic ideals. Despite this, it is Solon who is more often remembered and revered by the Athenians as a champion of the people.

Frequently asked questions