Compromises That Shaped The Constitution's Final Content

The US Constitution is often referred to as a bundle of compromises, as delegates representing 12 out of 13 original states had to make several concessions to create a government charter that was acceptable to all. The delegates met in Philadelphia in 1787 to revise the Articles of Confederation, which had been the governing document of the United States since the American Revolution. However, they soon realised that a more comprehensive overhaul was needed, and so they set out to create a new constitution. The major compromises that moulded the final content of the Constitution included the Great Compromise, the Three-Fifths Compromise, and agreements on taxation, tariffs, and slavery.

Explore related products

The Taming of Free Speech: America’s Civil Liberties Compromise

$53 $53

Constitutional Convention of 1787, The: A Reference Guide (Guides to Historic Events in America)

$15.86 $29.95

The Summer of 1787: The Men Who Invented the Constitution (The Simon & Schuster America Collection)

$11.29 $19.99

Justice Robert H. Jackson's Unpublished Opinion in Brown v. Board: Conflict, Compromise, and Constitutional Interpretation

$49.99 $54.99

Backlash Presidents: From Transformative to Reactionary Leaders in American History (Princeton Studies in American Politics)

$29.95 $29.95

The Union As It Is: Constitutional Unionism and Sectional Compromise, 1787-1861

$63.31 $50

The Great Compromise: a bicameral legislature with proportional representation in the House of Representatives and equal representation in the Senate

The Great Compromise, also known as the Connecticut Compromise, was a crucial agreement that addressed a fundamental disagreement over congressional representation during the Constitutional Convention. The delegates representing the 12 out of 13 original states had differing viewpoints, with smaller states advocating for equal representation and larger states arguing for representation based on population.

The Great Compromise combined two plans that emerged during the Constitutional Convention: the Virginia Plan and the Jersey Plan (also known as the New Jersey Plan). The Virginia Plan, supported by larger states, proposed representation based on each state's population. On the other hand, the Jersey Plan, favoured by smaller states, suggested equal representation for every state.

The Great Compromise established a bicameral legislature, which means it created two chambers within Congress: the House of Representatives and the Senate. The House of Representatives provided proportional representation, where representation was based on each state's population. In contrast, the Senate offered equal representation, ensuring that each state had an equal voice regardless of its size.

This compromise was essential in ensuring that all states had a say in the federal government and in balancing the interests and power dynamics between larger and smaller states. It laid the groundwork for the federal government's operations and contributed to shaping the current power relations between the states and the federal government. The Great Compromise played a pivotal role in the adoption of the United States Constitution and the establishment of the federal government as we know it today.

The Three-Fifths Compromise: slaves were counted as three-fifths of an individual when determining congressional representation

The Three-Fifths Compromise was a pivotal agreement between delegates from the Northern and Southern states at the 1787 Constitutional Convention. It was a resolution to the dispute over representation and taxation concerning enslaved individuals. The Southern delegates vehemently opposed the eradication of slavery and threatened to abandon the convention if enslaved individuals were not counted. On the other hand, Northern delegates advocated for ending the importation and sale of enslaved individuals.

The compromise, drafted by key figures like James Madison, Roger Sherman, and James Wilson, agreed that three-fifths of a state's enslaved population would be considered when determining representation in the House of Representatives and direct taxation. This resulted in the Southern states gaining greater representation in the House of Representatives and the Electoral College, giving them more political power compared to the North. This compromise, embedded in Article 1, Section 2, Clause 3 of the Constitution, showcases the moral dilemmas faced by the Founding Fathers, as it diminished enslaved individuals by treating them as a fraction of a person, denying their fundamental rights and humanity.

The Three-Fifths Compromise also had economic implications. While it increased the direct federal tax burden on slaveholding states, it also provided these states with perpetual overrepresentation in national politics. This overrepresentation was further exacerbated by the Fugitive Slave Law, which required Northern states to deport freedom seekers. Additionally, the compromise included a moratorium until 1808 on any congressional ban against the importation of slaves, although individual states retained the freedom to prohibit such imports.

The Three-Fifths Compromise was a pivotal agreement that addressed the contentious issue of slavery and its impact on representation and taxation. It reflected the complexity of the political landscape during the Constitutional Convention, where maintaining unity and ratifying the Constitution took precedence over the eradication of slavery.

The Electoral College: electors are roughly proportional to population, citizens vote for electors who then vote for the president

The United States Constitution is often referred to as a "bundle of compromises", as delegates from 12 of the 13 original states had to agree on several key points to create a government charter acceptable to each state. One of the most significant compromises was the creation of the Electoral College, which was established to elect the president.

The Electoral College is a group of electors who cast the state votes for the president. The number of electors in each state is roughly proportional to the state's population. For example, California, a highly populated state, has 54 electors, while sparsely populated states like Wyoming, Alaska, and North Dakota have the minimum of three. These electors are selected by political parties at the state level and are, in many cases, bound by law to vote in a way that is consistent with the results of the popular vote.

The Electoral College system was created because a national popular vote to elect a president was considered impractical in 1787 due to the size of the country and the lack of reliable communication methods. The delegates considered several alternatives, including direct election by the people, by state legislatures, by state governors, and by the national legislature. Ultimately, the delegates agreed on the Electoral College as a compromise solution.

The Electoral College process begins with American voters going to the polls on the Tuesday following the first Monday in November. However, the ballots cast by voters do not directly elect the president. Instead, the voters' will is reflected in the actions of the state electors. After the November election, the electors meet in their respective state capitals on the first Monday following the second Wednesday in December to cast their ballots. If a candidate receives 270 or more electoral votes, the sitting vice president declares that person the president-elect. If no candidate wins at least 270 electoral votes, the House of Representatives elects the president by a simple majority vote.

Explore related products

Noble Undertaking: Volume 1: The Continental Congress and the American Revolution, 1774–78

$12.1 $39.95

Slavery's Constitution: From Revolution to Ratification

$17.1 $19.99

The Original Compromise: What the Constitution's Framers Were Really Thinking

$18.89 $47.99

The Presidents and the Constitution: A Living History

$23.07 $50

The Constitutional Convention Of 1787: The Drafting Of The U.S. Constitution

$9.99

The constitutional and political history of the United States

$9.9 $18.12

Import tariffs: the federal government could impose tariffs on imports but not exports

The US Constitution is sometimes referred to as a "bundle of compromises" due to the numerous concessions made by delegates to create a government charter that was acceptable to each of the 13 states. One of the key compromises that moulded the final content of the Constitution was the agreement that the federal government could impose tariffs on imports but not exports.

At the time of the Constitutional Convention, the North and South had opposing economic interests. The North was industrialised and produced many finished goods, while the South had an agricultural economy and imported many finished goods from Britain. The Northern states wanted the federal government to be able to impose import tariffs on finished products to protect against foreign competition and encourage the South to buy goods made in the North. They also wanted to impose export tariffs on raw goods to increase revenue for the United States. However, the Southern states relied heavily on trade and feared that export tariffs on their raw goods would hurt their economy.

The compromise mandated that tariffs could only be imposed on imports from foreign countries and not on exports from the US. This compromise also dictated that the federal government would regulate interstate commerce and that all commerce legislation had to be passed by a two-thirds majority in the Senate, giving more power to the South.

The Constitution grants Congress the power to "lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts, and Excises". While Congress has ceded much of this authority to the president, it may reassert its rights to regulate international trade. The imposition of tariffs can be a powerful policy tool, but experts disagree on their costs and benefits. While some argue that tariffs help bring manufacturing and jobs back to the US, others contend that they drive up prices for consumers and disrupt supply chains.

Slavery: Northern states agreed to wait until 1808 to ban the slave trade

The United States Constitution was created through a series of compromises among the delegates to the Constitutional Convention of 1787. The delegates, representing 12 of the 13 original states, met in Philadelphia to revise the Articles of Confederation, which had been the governing document of the United States since the American Revolution. The Constitution is sometimes called a "bundle of compromises" because delegates had to give ground on numerous key points to create a government charter acceptable to each of the 13 states.

One of the key compromises that molded the final content of the Constitution was the agreement by Northern states to wait until 1808 to ban the slave trade. At the time of the Constitutional Convention, the Northern and Southern states had strong opposing views on the issue of slavery. The Northern states, which had an industrialized economy, wanted to end the importation and sale of enslaved people. On the other hand, the Southern states, which had an agricultural economy, felt that slavery was vital to their economy and did not want government interference.

The Northern states agreed to a compromise to delay the ban on the slave trade until 1808 to keep the Union intact. This compromise was reflected in the Act Prohibiting Importation of Slaves of 1807, which was signed into law by President Thomas Jefferson on March 2, 1807, and took effect on January 1, 1808. The act prohibited the importation of slaves into the United States, but it did not end slavery in the country.

The issue of slavery continued to be a source of tension between the North and the South, eventually leading to the Civil War. Despite the efforts of some slave owners in the North to free their slaves or create indenture-type agreements, slavery officially persisted in the region. The demise of slavery in the North was a gradual and complicated process, with some states passing bills banning slavery as late as 1848, and the illegal importation of slaves continuing even after 1808.

Frequently asked questions