Verbal Contracts: When Words Become Legally Binding

Verbal agreements, also known as oral contracts, are legally binding in many places. However, they can be difficult to enforce in a court of law due to the absence of physical evidence. Verbal contracts are typically used in fast-paced industries like hospitality and retail, where quick decisions are necessary to keep operations running smoothly. They are also common among freelancers, who often agree on terms and payment via phone or email. While oral agreements are valid, they may lead to legal issues if disputes arise over the specific terms of the contract. In such cases, witness testimony, circumstantial evidence, and records of subsequent actions are often used to uphold the agreement. To avoid credibility issues and costly legal battles, it is generally recommended to follow up with a written contract outlining the terms of the verbal agreement.

Explore related products

A Treatise On the Validity of Verbal Agreements

$44.95

A treatise on the validity of verbal agreements: as affected by the legislative enactments in England and the United States, commonly called the Statute of frauds.

$34.95

A Treatise On the Validity of Verbal Agreements: As Affected by the Legislative Enactments in England and the United States, Commonly Called the Statute of Frauds, Volume 1

$41.97

Basic Contract Law for Paralegals [Connected eBook with Study Center] (Aspen Paralegal Series)

$177.3 $218.95

Basic Contract Law for Paralegals [Connected eBook with Study Center] (Aspen Paralegal Series)

$162.59 $218.95

Contract Drafting and Negotiation for Entrepreneurs and Business Professionals

$19.65 $29.95

Verbal contracts are legally binding but challenging to prove

A verbal contract is an agreement between two or more parties that is spoken and not written down. It is made in person or over the phone. While verbal contracts are legally binding, they are challenging to prove and enforce in a court of law. This is because they often lack tangible evidence, making it difficult to prove the existence of the agreement and its specific terms.

To be legally binding, a verbal contract must fulfil certain elements. These include offer and acceptance, consideration, intention and capacity. Offer and acceptance mean a clear offer is made by one party and accepted by the other. Consideration refers to the exchange of something of value, such as money, goods or services. Intention means both parties must have the intention to enter into a legally binding agreement, and capacity means both parties must have the legal capacity to agree, i.e., they are of sound mind and not under duress.

When a verbal contract is disputed in court, both parties present evidence, including witness testimony and relevant documentation. The jury then evaluates the credibility of the witnesses and the strength of the evidence to make a decision. While this can be challenging, it is not impossible to prove a verbal contract. Witness testimony, documentary evidence, and circumstantial evidence can all help establish the terms of a verbal agreement.

However, it is always advisable to get a contract in writing. Written contracts are generally easier to prove and lead to fewer disputes as the terms are clearly outlined. They can also help prevent costly legal battles that may arise due to misunderstandings or breaches of verbal agreements. In some cases, certain types of contracts, such as those for the sale of goods over a certain price threshold, are legally required to be in writing.

Oral agreements are ideal for low-risk, simple scenarios

Oral agreements are typically free of charge as they do not require any formal documentation. They are also flexible and can be executed quickly, making them a convenient option when time is of the essence.

However, oral agreements may lead to legal issues at a later stage due to the difficulty of proving the precise contractual terms. They often lack tangible evidence, making them harder to prove in court. As a result, oral agreements may lead to disagreements when memories fade or become distorted.

To counter these potential issues, it is recommended to follow up with an email or written contract outlining the specific details of the agreement. This helps to avoid credibility issues and misinterpretations of the contract's terms.

While oral agreements can be legally binding, they are generally best suited for simple, low-risk scenarios where the relationship between the parties is based on trust.

Contracts that must be in writing include those for the sale of goods

Verbal contracts are legally binding and can be enforced in court. However, they are harder to enforce than written contracts and can lead to more misunderstandings and legal disputes. This is because oral agreements often lack tangible evidence, making them challenging to prove in court. As such, written contracts are generally considered more enforceable in a court of law.

Despite this, verbal contracts are still useful in certain situations. For example, they are ideal for risk-free and informal settings or when a quick decision needs to be made. They are also useful for simple scenarios that require swift results. Verbal contracts are common in fast-paced industries such as hospitality and retail, where quick decisions are needed to keep operations running smoothly.

However, there are certain instances where a written contract is required by law. These include:

• Contracts for the sale of goods: Any contract for the sale of goods over a certain value (usually $500, but this varies by jurisdiction) must be in writing.
• Real estate transactions: Contracts involving the sale, lease, or transfer of real estate must be in writing.
• Agreements not to be performed within one year: If the performance of a contract will take longer than one year from the date the contract is signed, it must be in writing.
• Promises to pay the debt of another: Any promise to pay another person's debt must be in writing.
• Marriage contracts: Agreements made in consideration of marriage, such as prenuptial or postnuptial agreements, must be in writing.

In these cases, a verbal agreement will not suffice, and a written contract is required to make the agreement legally binding.

Explore related products

The Tech Contracts Handbook: Cloud Computing Agreements, Software Licenses, and Other IT Contracts for Lawyers and Businesspeople, Third Edition

$39.93 $42.95

Working With Contracts: What Law School Doesn't Teach You, 2nd Edition (PLI's Corporate and Securities Law Library)

$34.95

Basic Contract Law (American Casebook Series)

$305

Contract Law For Dummies

$21.4 $29.99

Basic Contract Law (American Casebook Series)

$249.99 $305

Contract Basics: The Listing Contract

$25

Verbal contracts are prone to misunderstandings and recollection issues

Verbal contracts, also known as oral contracts or handshake agreements, are prone to misunderstandings and recollection issues due to the lack of a written record. Each party involved may have a different memory of the initial discussion, leading to disputes over the terms of the contract. Without a written document, there is no mechanism to address these conflicts, which can strain relationships and result in costly legal battles.

The absence of a written record makes it challenging to prove the existence of a verbal agreement and its specific terms. When a breach of contract occurs, enforcing the terms can be difficult as there is no clear evidence of the agreement. This can leave individuals vulnerable and without proper protection during disputes, as they face the burden of proving their version of the agreement in court.

To substantiate a verbal contract, witness testimony, circumstantial evidence, and records of subsequent actions are often relied upon. However, this can be ambiguous and may not be sufficient to convince a court without additional supporting evidence. Therefore, it is recommended to follow up a verbal agreement with written confirmation, such as an email or text message, to clarify the terms and provide a basic record.

Furthermore, oral agreements can be misinterpreted, and important details may be overlooked or forgotten. This is particularly true when memory starts to fade or becomes distorted over time. In such cases, it can be challenging to prove the credibility of the oral contract and what was originally agreed upon.

To mitigate the risks associated with verbal contracts, it is generally advised to convert verbal agreements into written contracts or, at the very least, summarize the agreed-upon terms in a written note or email. Additionally, documenting any actions based on the verbal agreement, such as payments or work performed, can help provide evidence of the agreement's existence and terms.

To prove a verbal contract, you may need witness testimony and documentation

A verbal contract is any agreement made between two or more people that is spoken and not written down. While verbal contracts are legally binding, they are often challenging to prove in court due to the lack of tangible evidence. However, with the right evidence, a verbal contract can be upheld in court.

When a verbal contract is disputed in court, the primary objective is to establish the existence and terms of the agreement. Both parties present evidence, including witness testimony and relevant documentation. The jury evaluates the credibility of the witnesses and the strength of the evidence to make a decision.

Witness testimony plays a crucial role in proving verbal contracts. Credible witnesses who were present during the meeting when the agreement was made can provide firsthand accounts of the discussion. These witnesses can include business partners, employees, or other observers who can attest to the negotiations and subsequent actions.

Documentation is another critical aspect of proving a verbal contract. Written notes, emails, letters, and text messages can support the existence and terms of the agreement. It is important to save any written communications related to the contract, as they can serve as evidence. Additionally, creating a timeline of events and saving payment records, meeting notes, and other relevant documents can help establish the terms and show a consistent pattern of behaviour by both parties.

While verbal contracts can be legally binding, certain types of contracts are required to be in writing by the Statute of Frauds. These include contracts for the sale of goods over a certain price, real estate transactions, agreements not to be performed within one year, promises to pay someone else's debt, and marriage contracts. Therefore, it is essential to understand the specific requirements for the type of contract in question.

Frequently asked questions