Republicanism: Constitutional Principle Explained

Republicanism is a theory of government that emphasizes the participation of citizens for the common good of the community. It is rooted in the political and civic ideas of classical antiquity, as they were expressed and practised in the city-communities of Greece and in the Republic of Rome. These ideas were revived during the Renaissance era in western Europe, particularly in the city-based republics of northern Italy, such as Florence, Genoa, and Venice. The term 'republicanism' is generally used in two different but closely related senses. In the first sense, it refers to a loose tradition or family of writers in the history of western political thought, including Machiavelli and his fifteenth-century Italian predecessors, the English republicans Milton, Harrington, and Sidney, among others. In the context of the United States constitution, republicanism does not refer to a political movement to abolish social class, but rather to the core values that citizenry in a republic have or ought to have. These values include liberty and inalienable individual rights, recognizing the sovereignty of the people as the source of all authority in law, rejecting monarchy, aristocracy, and hereditary political power, and vilification of corruption.

Explore related products

From Oligarchy to Republicanism: The Great Task of Reconstruction (Studies in Constitutional Democracy)

$50 $32

The Doctrine of State and the Principles of State Law

$21.99

The Doctrine of State and the Principles of State Law (Philosophy of Law)

$37.99

Commentaries On the Constitution of the United States of America: With That Constitution Prefixed, in Which Are Unfolded, the Principles of Free ... Advantages of Republicanism Demonstrated

$37.37

Madison's Metronome: The Constitution, Majority Rule, and the Tempo of American Politics (American Political Thought)

$29.99 $29.99

Emerging Conflicts of Principle: International Relations and the Clash between Cosmopolitanism and Republicanism (Ethics and Global Politics)

$69.99

Republicanism vs. Liberalism

Republicanism is a political ideology that encompasses a range of ideas, including civic virtue, political participation, the harms of corruption, the positives of a mixed constitution, and the rule of law. It emphasizes the idea of self-governance and can range from the rule of a representative minority or aristocracy to popular sovereignty. In the context of the United States, republicanism refers to the core values that citizens in a republic have or ought to have, such as liberty and inalienable individual rights, recognizing the sovereignty of the people as the source of all authority in law, and rejecting monarchy, aristocracy, and hereditary political power.

Liberalism, on the other hand, is based more on economics and individualism. It emphasizes the importance of private property and established positive law. While republicanism and liberalism are often seen as distinct, they both contributed to the democratic ideals of the modern world and share a rejection of absolute monarchy.

The debate between republicanism and liberalism came to prominence in the 1980s, with intellectual historians and political philosophers discussing their relative merits. This debate was particularly fierce regarding the understanding of eighteenth-century America. However, some argue that the binary nature of the debate is an artificial construction, and that the traditions of republicanism and liberalism are not as distinct as they are often portrayed.

The values and ideals of republicanism are foundational in the constitution and history of the United States. The Founding Fathers wanted republicanism because its principles guaranteed liberty, with opposing, limited powers offsetting one another. They were also afraid that a direct democracy would allow a majority of voters to trample the rights and liberties of the minority. This idea of majority tyranny has been a focus of much constitutional thought.

In conclusion, republicanism and liberalism are political ideologies that have both influenced modern democratic thought. While they have distinct features, they also share some similarities and have both contributed to the development of democratic ideals. The debate between republicanism and liberalism is ongoing, with historians and philosophers discussing their relative merits and attempting to understand their complex and interwoven nature.

Civic virtue and participation

Republicanism is a theory of government that emphasizes the participation of citizens for the common good of the community. It stresses the public rights and obligations of citizens to cooperate in support of their community. Civic virtue and participation are essential characteristics of republicanism.

Republicanism holds that the needs of the community are considered superior to the claims of the individual. Citizens are obligated to participate extensively and cooperatively in public affairs. Political and civic unity are valued more than diversity or pluralism in the community. Participation by citizens is the means to accountability in government and to personal fulfillment. Republicanism emphasizes that good government carries out the general will of the people. It holds that good republican government depends upon the continuous civic and political participation of virtuous citizens.

The Founding Fathers wanted republicanism because its principles guaranteed liberty, with opposing, limited powers offsetting one another. They thought change should occur slowly, as many were afraid that a "democracy" – by which they meant a direct democracy – would allow a majority of voters at any time to trample rights and liberties. The principles of republican government embedded in the Constitution represent an effort to ensure that the inalienable rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness would not be trampled by majorities.

In the late 18th century, there was a convergence of democracy and republicanism. Republicanism includes the key principles of rule by consent of the governed and sovereignty of the people. It emphasizes the importance of civic virtue and political participation, and the benefits of a mixed constitution and the rule of law.

Rule of law

Republicanism is a theory of government that emphasizes the participation of citizens for the common good of the community. The responsibilities and duties of citizens are paramount, and the exemplary citizen readily subordinates personal interests to public interests. It is rooted in the political and civic ideas of classical antiquity, as expressed and practised in the city-communities of Ancient Greece and the Republic of Rome. These ideas were revived during the Renaissance in Western Europe, particularly in the city-based republics of northern Italy, such as Florence, Genoa, and Venice.

Republicanism, as a constitutional principle, is founded on the idea that citizens govern themselves through institutions established by the constitution. It emphasizes the government of the individual by the individual. A well-functioning republican constitution requires virtuous citizens and virtuous officials. It is characterized by beliefs or assumptions about the relationships between individuals, the community, and the government. The needs of the community are considered superior to the claims of the individual, and citizens are obligated to participate extensively and cooperatively in public affairs.

The rule of law is a key principle of republicanism. It emphasizes that political freedom is constituted by rightly ordered laws, institutions, and norms. In the words of Pettit, "to enjoy such non-domination, after all, is just to be in a position where no one can interfere arbitrarily in your affairs, and you are in that position from the moment that the institutions are in place." This view holds that political freedom is most fully realized in a well-ordered, self-governing republic of equal citizens under the rule of law, where no one citizen is the master of any other. James Harrington famously described this ideal as an "empire of laws and not of men."

The classical republican concern is to protect citizens from the arbitrary or uncontrolled power of their government through good institutional design. The standard devices for achieving this aim include the rule of law, the separation of powers, federalism, and constitutionally entrenched basic rights. These devices have been adopted by liberals and others, but contemporary civic republicans recognize their limitations. While these devices are necessary, the functioning of government inevitably involves a degree of discretion on the part of public authorities.

In summary, the rule of law is a critical aspect of republicanism as a constitutional principle. It ensures that citizens are protected from arbitrary interference and that political freedom is upheld. Republicanism emphasizes the participation of citizens in governing themselves through constitutional institutions, with a focus on the common good and the virtue of justice as lawfulness.

Explore related products

The Federalist Papers (Signet Classics)

$8.12 $8.95

The Federalist Papers (Including Declaration of Independence & United States Constitution)

$1.99

Sharia Law for Non-Muslims (A Taste of Islam)

$3.38 $8.95

Great Political Theories V.1: A Comprehensive Selection of the Crucial Ideas in Political Philosophy from the Greeks to the Enlightenment (Harper Perennial Modern Thought)

$11.21 $19.99

Great Political Theories V.2: A Comprehensive Selection of the Crucial Ideas in Political Philosophy from the French Revolution to Modern Times (Harper Perennial Modern Thought)

$12.23 $19.99

Political Theory: An Introduction

$43.99 $46.75

Separation of powers

Republicanism is a system that replaces or accompanies inherited rule, emphasising liberty and rejecting corruption. It is founded on the belief that sovereignty lies with the people, who have the right to consent to the government that rules them.

The legislative power is vested in Congress, which has the authority to pass laws and the power to impeach and remove the President, Vice President, and civil officers. The executive power is held by the President, who can veto legislation passed by Congress, but Congress can overrule these vetoes with a supermajority vote. The judicial power is vested in the Supreme Court and any lower courts created by Congress, which interpret the laws and determine whether the actions of one branch infringe upon the core functions of another.

The separation of powers creates a system of checks and balances, where each branch has some control over the others. This system aims to protect individual liberty and prevent tyranny or autocracy by ensuring that no single branch or individual holds absolute power. The framers of the Constitution were influenced by their experiences with the British monarchy, which led them to believe that concentrating power in a single entity could lead to arbitrary and oppressive government action.

The separation of powers has been a crucial factor in shaping American history, with three notable moments where the system of checks and balances protected the American republic: the passage of the 14th Amendment during the Civil War era, which overruled the Dred Scott v. Sandford Supreme Court decision that ruled Black Americans were not citizens; the ruling that halted the executive's attempt to alter a law using a line-item veto; and the impeachment and removal of a President, demonstrating that even the highest executive power is subject to the other branches' oversight.

Checks and balances

Republicanism, in the context of constitutional principles, refers to a set of core values and ideals that underpin a republic. It emphasises the participation of citizens in the governance of their community, with a focus on the common good and the subordination of personal interests to public interests. This is in contrast to liberalism, which primarily concerns itself with individual rights and freedoms.

Republicanism values the sovereignty of the people, where citizens are seen as the true rulers, rather than kings or aristocracies. It promotes the idea that political power should be derived from the consent of the governed, and that the needs of the community take precedence over individual claims. Citizens are expected to participate actively and cooperatively in public affairs, with a shared sense of civic duty and responsibility.

One of the key principles of republicanism is the protection of citizens from the arbitrary or uncontrolled power of their government. This is achieved through various mechanisms, such as the rule of law, the separation of powers, federalism, and constitutionally entrenched rights. These checks and balances are designed to prevent the concentration of power in any single individual or entity, thus safeguarding citizens' liberties and ensuring that power is distributed and accountable.

In the United States, the Founding Fathers embraced republicanism as a means of guaranteeing liberty. They were cautious about the potential for "democracy" or majority rule to infringe on the rights of minorities. Hence, they established a system of checks and balances, with opposing and limited powers offsetting one another, to prevent the tyranny of the majority. This system, as outlined in the Constitution, includes the separation of powers between the executive, legislative, and judicial branches of government, each serving as a check on the power of the other.

The concept of checks and balances is also evident in the tension between federal and state powers in the US. The federal government, while possessing supreme authority in certain areas, is limited by the powers reserved for the states, as outlined in the Tenth Amendment. This distribution of powers acts as a check on the federal government's authority, preventing it from becoming overly centralised and infringing on the rights of individual states.

Additionally, the US Constitution's Bill of Rights provides further checks and balances by guaranteeing certain fundamental rights and freedoms of citizens, which cannot be infringed upon by the government. These rights serve as a limit on the power of the state, ensuring that individual liberties are protected and that the government remains accountable to the people.

Frequently asked questions