Campaign Ads: Political Strategy Or Propaganda?

what is a political campaign ad

Political campaign ads are a form of propaganda through the media to influence a political debate and, ultimately, voting. They can take many forms, from traditional print advertisements to online strategies. Cable television is one of the most expensive types of advertising to buy, but it is still very effective, with broadcast television representing 50% of all political ad spending. Other types of political campaign ads include radio, social media, and connected TV (CTV) ads. The period over which political campaign advertising is possible varies from country to country, with campaigns in the United States lasting a year or more, while in the UK and Ireland, advertising is restricted by law to just a few weeks before the election.

Characteristics Values
Purpose To influence a political debate and, ultimately, voting
Creators Political consultants and political campaign staff
Types Cable television, campaign videos, CTV, digital advertising, print, radio, social media, podcasts, broadcast television, Google search ads, billboards, signs, brochures, articles, tabloids, flyers, letters, presentations, emails, text messages, websites, and more
Requirements Must include a message that explains who paid for it (sponsor identification) and whether it was endorsed by the candidate
Regulations Vary depending on the country and state; some countries restrict the use of broadcast media to broadcast political messages; disclaimer requirements vary by state and platform
Effectiveness Campaign videos are better at holding audiences' attention than written ads; audio ads are an exciting opportunity for political campaigns but are often not prioritized

cycivic

Types of political campaign ads

Political campaign ads are a type of propaganda through the media, designed by political consultants and campaign staff to influence a political debate and, ultimately, voting. The types of political campaign ads can be broadly categorized into positive, negative, and comparative ads. Here are some specific types of political campaign ads:

Positive Ads

Positive ads usually start at the beginning of a campaign and aim to introduce or reintroduce a candidate by reinforcing their positive image and qualities. These ads focus on the candidate's character and personal qualities rather than their political identity.

Negative Ads or Attack Ads

Negative ads or attack ads present the "worst-case scenario," aiming to inspire action through voter fear. These ads are tough, critical, and compellingly urgent, often presenting the potential negative consequences of an opponent's policies or actions.

Citizen Testimonial or First-Person Ads

These ads are designed to connect with undecided voters through a conversational and neighborly approach. They often feature personal stories and aim to persuade voters by eliciting empathy for the candidate or cause.

Endorsement Ads

Endorsement ads are similar to citizen testimonial ads but with a celebrity or social influencer spin. They leverage the popularity and influence of public figures to boost a candidate or ballot initiative.

Single-Issue Ads

Single-issue ads focus on raising awareness about a specific issue and typically call for action or support. For example, "End Gerrymandering!" or "Protect Our Water!"

PAC Ads (Political Action Committee Ads)

PAC ads are third-party ads created by independent, outside organizations, typically representing business, labor, or partisan interests. These ads are designed to help elect or defeat specific candidates or promote particular causes.

It is important to note that the regulations and restrictions on political campaign ads vary across different countries and states. For example, the United States has a relatively free market for broadcast political messaging, while the United Kingdom and Ireland have stricter restrictions, allowing only a limited period for political broadcasts during the election season.

cycivic

Regulations and disclaimers

Political campaign advertisements are subject to various regulations and disclaimer requirements that vary depending on the jurisdiction and the platform used for advertising. Here is an overview of some key considerations regarding regulations and disclaimers in political campaign ads:

Regulations:

The regulations for political campaign ads differ significantly across countries and even within countries. For example, in the United States, there is a very free market for broadcast political messaging, and the country has seen the rise and prevalence of televised political attack ads. On the other hand, countries in the European Union, like the United Kingdom and Ireland, have stricter restrictions on political advertising. Paid advertisements are often forbidden, with political parties allowed only a limited number of broadcasts during the election period.

Disclaimers:

The disclaimer requirements for political campaign ads depend on the type of advertisement and the entity that funded it. Disclaimers are typically required to identify the committee or entity that authorized or paid for the advertisement. For instance, in California, a social media disclosure law mandates that campaigns include the text "Who funded this ad?" followed by a link to information about the funding source.

Additionally, television and radio advertisements authorized and financed by a campaign must include the candidate's audio, stating their name and approval of the message. Similar requirements apply to print, television, radio, and internet ads, with specific variations depending on the platform. For example, rates for radio and television advertisements are regulated by the Federal Communications Commission in the United States.

It is important to note that the specific regulations and disclaimer requirements for political campaign ads can vary by location and platform, so it is essential to consult the relevant laws and guidelines applicable to your specific situation.

cycivic

History of political campaign ads

Political campaign advertisements have been a part of American culture for a long time. The use of broadsides, which are large sheets of paper printed on one side, were used from the first presidential elections through to the turn of the 20th century. These broadsides were posted on walls or the sides of buildings and were used by anti-slavery advocates, women's suffrage organisations, temperance societies, political parties, and union leadership, among others.

In the 1920s, Presidents Calvin Coolidge and Herbert Hoover recognised the value of public relations tools in gaining a political edge, and listened to the advice of adman Bruce Barton. In the 1930s and '40s, Franklin Roosevelt continued to experiment with advertising, bringing in Hollywood talent like Jack Warner, Humphrey Bogart, and Orson Welles to craft entertaining radio ads for his 1944 reelection bid.

In the 1952 presidential election, Dwight D. Eisenhower, also known as "Ike", defeated Adlai Stevenson with the help of a catchy jingle that played on his nickname: "I like Ike, I like Ike, everybody likes Ike". This was one of the first television ad campaigns, with Rosser Reeves convincing Eisenhower that television was the "essence of democracy".

Since then, political advertising has continued to evolve, with Kennedy's team using footage of him to generate excitement for upcoming campaign stops, and Nixon attacking his opponent's defence plans by having a hand swipe away toy military figurines in a web-only ad. In 2004, George W. Bush's successful reelection bid included an attack ad on Democratic challenger John Kerry, portraying him as indecisive by showing footage of him windsurfing.

cycivic

Social media and political campaign ads

Social media has become an important tool for political campaigns to reach larger groups of constituents with minimal physical effort or expense. It is a crucial advertising channel for building a campaign's online presence and engaging prospective grassroots donors. Most social media advertising takes place on Facebook and Instagram, although Twitter is also used.

Since 2020, there has been an explosion of political advertising on social media, with campaigns spending billions on these platforms. Social media video lets politicians broadcast their own news and chat with constituents. Live video encourages meaningful and personable dialogue and is powerful for politicians addressing local issues not covered by bigger outlets.

However, social media advertising is not without its challenges. Trolling and harassment, comment spam, and mass reporting are common issues faced by those managing social media for political campaigns. In addition, the degree of control that should be placed on social media platforms when it comes to political advertising is still being debated. The use of personal information to target individual voters with personalised political advertisements has raised concerns about privacy and data protection.

Each social media platform has its own policies regarding political advertising, and these are constantly evolving. For example, California has a social media disclosure law that requires campaigns to include the text "Who funded this ad?" followed by a link to a disclosure about the campaign or committee that provided funding. As such, it is important for campaigns to be aware of the per-platform political advertising policies and restrictions when creating their social media content strategy.

cycivic

Effectiveness of different ad formats

Political campaign advertising uses various media channels to influence political debates and, ultimately, voting behaviour. While the specific regulations and periods for political advertising vary across countries, the format and content of these ads can significantly impact their effectiveness.

In terms of format, television and radio advertisements have traditionally dominated political campaign ad spending. Cable television, in particular, is one of the most expensive advertising types to buy. However, the rise of digital advertising has introduced new formats, such as Connected TV (CTV) and social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter. CTV allows advertisers to reach voters through streaming and take advantage of better ad targeting. Social media advertising is crucial for building an online presence and engaging prospective grassroots donors.

The effectiveness of different ad formats depends on various factors, including the content of the ad and the preferences of the target audience. For example, while positive ads have been found to encourage voter turnout, negative or attack ads can suppress turnout but may be more effective at swaying voters' decisions. Additionally, video ads, including campaign videos and CTV ads, can better hold viewers' attention and create an emotional connection with voters through visuals, sound, and storytelling. On the other hand, audio ads, including broadcast radio ads, are becoming more popular due to the rise of podcasts and audio entertainment, providing an opportunity to capture voters' attention directly.

While there is no one-size-fits-all formula for effective political campaign ads, a multi-channel strategy that leverages different ad formats can increase the chances of reaching and influencing target voters.

Frequently asked questions

Political campaign ads are a form of advertising used in political campaigns to influence a political debate and, ultimately, voting. They are designed by political consultants and campaign staff and can take many forms, from television and radio advertisements to print, online and social media strategies.

Some examples of political campaign ads include:

- Richard Nixon's televised political attack ads during his reelection campaign in the 1972 United States presidential election.

- Ronald Reagan's positive and emotional campaign ads during his reelection bid in the 1984 United States presidential election.

- George H. W. Bush's negative campaign ads against Michael Dukakis in the 1988 United States presidential election.

The regulations for political campaign ads vary depending on the country and the platform used. For example, in the United States, there is generally little regulation of political advertising content, while in the European Union, many countries do not permit paid-for TV or radio advertising. On social media, platforms like Twitter have banned paid political advertising, while others have implemented fact-checking measures. Most political advertising must include a disclaimer or source identifier to explain who paid for the ad, with specific requirements for print, television, radio, and internet ads.

The effectiveness of political campaign ads can vary. While they can be a powerful tool for influencing voters and spreading a campaign message, some research has found that many adults do not fully understand the regulatory environment and funding sources for political ads. Additionally, the rise of social media and online advertising has made it more challenging to distinguish between paid political ads and organic content.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment