Hartford Delegates: The Constitutional Amendments They Proposed

The Hartford Convention of 1814 was a meeting of delegates from New England states, held in Connecticut. The delegates proposed several amendments to the US Constitution, including diminishing the influence of slaveholding states in the legislature, limiting federal restrictions on foreign trade, and setting stricter conditions for declaring war. The amendments were proposed in response to the War of 1812, which had negatively impacted the region's economy, and to protect New England's interests and assert its authority over what they saw as unconstitutional infringements on its sovereignty. The Hartford Convention's proposals were never adopted, and the Federalist Party lost much of its political power following the convention.

Explore related products

The Constitution of the United States and The Declaration of Independence

$1.99 $6.95

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights

$9.99 $9.99

The Architecture of Constitutional Amendments: History, Law, Politics

$54.85 $60.95

The Constitution of the United States: And All Its Amendments

$6.97 $6.97

The Constitutional Amendments: 1789 To the Present

$86.39 $149

Loaded: A Disarming History of the Second Amendment (City Lights Open Media)

$11.98 $16.95

The Hartford Convention proposed seven amendments to the US Constitution

The Hartford Convention, which took place in December 1814, was a meeting of delegates from New England states in Hartford, Connecticut. The delegates intended to propose amendments to the US Constitution to protect their section's interests and make arrangements for their military defence. The convention was a response to the War of 1812, which had negatively impacted the region's economy.

Additionally, the Hartford delegates proposed limiting the power of the national government by creating a supermajority requirement for non-defensive wars and placing limits on Congress's power to issue embargoes. They also suggested softening the power of the president by instituting a one-term limit and creating a geographic balance by preventing the election of presidents from the same state in two successive terms.

The Hartford Convention's proposals were not well-received. The secret nature of the meetings and the possibility of secession raised by the proposals harmed the Federalist Party's electoral prospects. When the proposals reached Congress, news of the American victory in New Orleans and the signing of the Treaty of Ghent overshadowed them, and they were never ratified.

The amendments aimed to diminish the influence of slaveholding states

In 1814, New England Federalists met in Hartford, Connecticut, to propose amendments to the US Constitution. Twenty-six delegates attended the secret meetings, which continued through January 5, 1815. The stated purpose of the convention was to propose constitutional amendments to protect New England's interests and to make arrangements with the federal government for their own military defence. The Hartford Convention's final report proposed several amendments to the US Constitution, including removing the three-fifths representation advantage of the South.

The amendments proposed by the Hartford delegates aimed to diminish the influence of slaveholding states. The three-fifths representation advantage of the South was removed. This was designed to handle the apportionment of the substantial enslaved population across the country, specifically for measuring the number of seats the individual states should have in the House of Representatives. The Fugitive Slave Clause, located in Article IV, Section 2, further asserted that a slave who was bound by the laws of their home state remained a slave wherever they went, even if they fled to a non-slavery state. This clause was reinforced in the 1857 Supreme Court case of Dred Scott v. Sandford, which undermined the abolitionists' use of the Fifth Amendment to argue against slavery.

The Hartford Convention also proposed prohibiting any trade embargo lasting over 60 days and requiring a two-thirds Congressional majority for the declaration of offensive war, admission of a new state, or interdiction of foreign commerce. These proposals were intended to embarrass the President and the Democratic-Republicans in Congress and to serve as a basis for negotiations between New England and the rest of the country. Some delegates may have favoured New England's secession from the United States and the formation of an independent republic, although no such solution was adopted at the convention.

The Hartford Convention's proposals were ultimately unsuccessful. The amendments were proposed just a month before the Battle of New Orleans, and they seemed irrelevant and disloyal following this military victory. After the convention, the Federalist Party lost much of its political power and never truly recovered. However, the efforts of the Hartford delegates reflected the growing abolitionist movement in the North, which eventually led to the Thirteenth Amendment to the US Constitution, abolishing slavery.

They also wanted to limit federal restrictions on foreign trade and shipping

The Hartford Convention, which took place in December 1814, saw delegates from New England states meet in Connecticut's capital, Hartford. The delegates proposed several amendments to the US Constitution, including limiting federal restrictions on foreign trade and shipping.

The delegates aimed to protect New England's interests and assert its authority over what they viewed as unconstitutional infringements on state sovereignty. They sought to limit the power of the national government and strengthen state control over commerce and militias. Specifically, they wanted to restrict the federal government's ability to interfere with foreign trade and shipping, an issue of significant concern to the region due to the War of 1812's negative impact on the economy.

The proposed amendment regarding foreign trade and shipping aimed to address this by prohibiting any trade embargo lasting over 60 days and requiring a two-thirds Congressional majority to interdict foreign commerce. This proposal reflected the delegates' desire to increase New England's influence and protect its economic interests.

The Hartford Convention's proposals were submitted to Congress as resolutions, but they were never adopted. The Federalist Party, which dominated the convention, lost much of its political power following the convention, especially as their proposals were overshadowed by the American victory in New Orleans and the signing of the Treaty of Ghent.

While secession was discussed at the convention, it was ultimately rejected, and the final report did not propose it. Instead, the delegates focused on using the amendments to strengthen New England's position within the Union and address their grievances with the existing constitutional framework.

Explore related products

The Second Amendment Primer: A Citizen's Guidebook to the History, Sources, and Authorities for the Constitutional Guarantee of the Right to Keep and Bear Arms

$12.99 $12.99

The Founders' Second Amendment: Origins of the Right to Bear Arms

$21.08 $28.95

The Thirteenth Amendment and American Freedom: A Legal History (Constitutional Amendments)

$78 $78

The Second Amendment: A Biography

$9.99 $18.99

The People’s Constitution: 200 Years, 27 Amendments, and the Promise of a More Perfect Union

$18.34 $45

The Constitution of the United States of America, with the Bill of Rights and all of the Amendments; The Declaration of Independence; and the Articles of Confederation

$4.5 $4.5

The delegates proposed stricter conditions for declaring war

The Hartford Convention, which took place in December 1814, saw delegates from New England meet in Hartford, Connecticut, to propose amendments to the US Constitution. The delegates were unhappy with the War of 1812 and sought to reduce the political power of the Southern and Western states while increasing New England's influence.

The Hartford Convention's proposals aimed to protect New England's interests and assert its authority over what it saw as unconstitutional infringements on its sovereignty. The delegates sought to diminish the influence of slaveholding states in the legislature and remove the three-fifths representation advantage of the South. They also wanted to limit the power of the president by instituting a one-term limit and creating a geographic balance, ensuring that presidents did not come from the same state in successive terms.

The Hartford Convention's final report proposed these amendments to the Constitution, but they were never adopted. The Federalist Party, which dominated the convention, lost much of its political power after the convention, and the proposals were seen as irrelevant and disloyal following the American victory in the Battle of New Orleans.

The convention was a defeat for militant Federalists

The Hartford Convention, which took place from December 15, 1814, to January 5, 1815, was indeed a defeat for militant Federalists. The convention was held in response to growing anti-war sentiment in New England, particularly in Massachusetts, where even the Democratic-Republican candidate for governor, Samuel Dexter, opposed the national party's commerce policies. The stated purpose of the convention was to propose constitutional amendments to protect New England's interests and to make arrangements for their own military defence. Twenty-six delegates from Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Vermont, and New Hampshire attended the convention, which was dominated by Federalists.

The convention discussed various grievances, including the War of 1812, the Embargo of 1807, and the Louisiana Purchase. The Federalists also expressed their opposition to James Madison's administration, particularly his request for a conscription bill, which they saw as further proof of the Democratic-Republicans' intentions to bring military rule. While secession was mentioned, the more moderate Federalists, led by Harrison Gray Otis, prevailed in blocking radical proposals. The final report of the convention reflected on secession but ultimately recommended against it, citing George Washington's Farewell Address.

The convention proposed several amendments to the Constitution, including prohibiting trade embargoes over 60 days, requiring a two-thirds majority in Congress for declarations of war and the admission of new states, and removing the three-fifths representation advantage of the South. However, these amendments were proposed just before Major General Andrew Jackson's victory in the Battle of New Orleans, which swept the Northeast and led to an increased sense of nationalism. The Federalists were discredited and disgraced, and their proposals seemed irrelevant and disloyal. As a result, the Federalist Party lost much of its political power and never fully recovered.

In conclusion, the Hartford Convention did indeed contribute to the downfall of the Federalist Party, as the militant Federalists' efforts to propose secession and radical changes were blocked by the more moderate faction. The timing of the convention, so close to a significant military victory, further discredited their proposals and led to their defeat in the broader political landscape.

Frequently asked questions