Recount Rules: Presidential Elections Explained

An election recount is a repeat tabulation of votes cast in an election to verify the accuracy of the original results. Recounts typically occur in the event of a close margin of victory, following accusations of election fraud, or due to possible administrative errors. In the United States, recounts are conducted at the state level for presidential elections, and each state has different criteria for optional recounts. Recounts can be automatic or requested by a candidate or voters, and they must be completed within specific deadlines. While recounts rarely change election outcomes, they are an important mechanism to ensure fair and accurate election results.

Explore related products

Recount: The Story Of The 2000 Presidential Election [DVD]

$8.19

Recount: The Story of The 2000 Presidential Election (W/bonus Features)

$7.29

Mr. Beat presents...The Ultimate American Presidential Election Book: Every Presidential Election in American History (1788-2020)

$21.54 $29

Unprecedented - The 2000 Presidential Election - 2004 Campaign Edition [DVD]

$5.63

Recount

$14.62

Hanging Chads: The Inside Story of the 2000 Presidential Recount in Florida

$48.78 $54.99

Criteria for recounts

The criteria for conducting a recount in a presidential election vary across different jurisdictions. In the United States, recounts are managed at the state level, with each state having its own specific criteria and procedures. Here are the key criteria that generally apply:

Close Margin of Victory

One of the most common criteria for triggering a recount is a close margin of victory. Many states have specific thresholds for initiating an automatic recount. For example, Oregon mandates an automatic recount for statewide and federal elections when the margin between the winning candidate and the closest opponent is less than or equal to 0.2% of the total vote. Similarly, in Singapore, recounts are automatically triggered when the margin of difference falls within 2% of valid local votes.

Accusations of Election Fraud or Administrative Errors

Recounts may also be warranted in response to accusations of election fraud or the possibility of administrative errors. These can include human factors, such as transcription errors, or machine errors, like misreads of paper ballots or malfunctions in electronic voting systems.

Requests by Candidates or Voters

In many states, candidates who were not the winners or groups of registered voters have the option to request a recount. In some cases, a petition must be filed, stating valid grounds for the recount, such as a close margin of votes or suspected errors in counting paper ballots. The deadline for requesting a recount varies by state, typically ranging from a few days to several weeks after the election or the finalization of election results.

Payment for Recounts

The financial responsibility for recounts can fall on the requester, such as the candidate, their political party, or interested voters. However, if the recount leads to a reversal of the election outcome in favour of the requester, the jurisdiction may refund the costs incurred.

It's important to note that the criteria and procedures for recounts can be intricate and subject to change, so consulting the specific laws and regulations of each jurisdiction is essential for a comprehensive understanding.

Who can request a recount

The criteria for what constitutes a recount in a presidential election vary across different jurisdictions. In the United States, recounts are conducted at the state level for federal offices, including presidential elections. Each state has its own laws and procedures regarding recounts, with varying criteria for initiating a recount.

Now, who can request a recount?

Candidates or their Agents

In the United States, candidates who were on the ballot but did not win the election may request a recount. This is a common provision in many states, allowing candidates to seek verification of the accuracy of the initial results. In some states, candidates can request multiple recounts if they continue to dispute the results.

Voters

In certain states, a group of registered voters may also have the power to initiate a recount. For instance, in some states, a group of five or more registered voters can request a recount of any ballot measure. This empowers citizens to take an active role in ensuring the integrity of the election process.

Election Officials and County Clerks

Election officials, including county clerks, are also authorised to request recounts, typically at the county's expense. They may request either partial or full recounts for offices and ballot measures. This ability allows election officials to proactively address any concerns or discrepancies that may arise.

Courts

In certain circumstances, a defeated candidate who has been denied a recount by the returning officer may petition the courts for a recount. This legal route ensures that candidates have recourse if they believe their request for a recount has been unjustly denied.

It's important to note that the specific rules and procedures for requesting a recount can vary from state to state, and there may be additional criteria or limitations in place. The requesting party is typically responsible for the costs associated with the recount unless the recount changes the election outcome in their favour, in which case, the costs may be refunded.

Recount deadlines

The criteria for what constitutes a recount in a presidential election vary across different jurisdictions. In the United States, recounts are conducted at the state level for federal offices. Each state has its own laws and procedures regarding recounts, and these can vary significantly.

Recount request deadlines occur soon after the canvass, and in some states, the recount must be requested within a specific timeframe, such as no later than two days following the canvass. The deadline for completion varies, with some states requiring automatic recounts to be completed within a set number of days after the recount was ordered. For example, in Oregon, the deadline to request a recount is no later than 42 days after the election. In the case of presidential elections, the deadline is typically stricter, such as five days after the secretary of state finalizes the election results.

It is important to note that the requesting party is usually responsible for the costs associated with the recount unless the recount changes the election outcome in their favor, in which case the costs may be refunded. Additionally, there may be specific grounds or criteria that must be met for a recount to be granted, such as a close margin of victory, accusations of election fraud, or the possibility of administrative errors.

The specific rules and regulations regarding recount deadlines can vary by state and type of election, so it is essential to refer to the laws and procedures of the relevant jurisdiction for precise information.

Explore related products

2004 Presidential Election Electoral College Battleground, Bush versus Kerry Your Complete Guide to the Contested Election Laws, Rules, and Court Cases on Recounts, Challenges, Voting Equipment, Ballots, Help America Vote Act (HAVA) and the Federal Election Commission, Voting Rights Act, Civil Rights and Disenfranchisement, Provisional Ballots, Voter Fraud and Intimidation, Military and Overseas Ballots, Florida 2000 Recount and Supreme Court Cases (DVD-ROM)

$14.94 $25

Recount

$4.29

Making of the President 2016: How Donald Trump Orchestrated a Revolution

$14.31 $35

2 USA Political History Charts - Size: 23x52 inches - Timeline of Presidential Elections and Parties (1789-1880) Civics Homeschooling Teachers Educational Classroom Poster Map Gifts

$49.95

1880 Timeline of Presidential Elections (1789-1880) - 16x68 inches - Poster of Presidents US United States - History Buff Gifts - Homeschooler Chart - Teacher Wall Map - Educational Classroom Decorations

$67

The Destruction of Hillary Clinton: Untangling the Political Forces, Media Culture, and Assault on Fact That Decided the 2016 Election

$26.65 $24.06

Recount costs

The total cost of conducting a recount varies depending on the nature of the race. Races at the municipal or county level tend to cost less than statewide races, as they garner fewer votes. For example, Washington's 2004 gubernatorial election recount cost an estimated $1.2 million, whereas Minnesota's 2008 United States Senate election recount was automatic.

In the United States, recounts rarely reverse election results. From 2000 to 2015, out of 4,687 statewide general elections, only 27 were followed by a recount, and only three of those changed the original outcome. Recounts are conducted at the state level, even for federal offices.

In the case of presidential elections, recounts are carried out at the state level and must be completed no later than six days before the meeting of the Electoral College. For presidential elections, only a full recount is sufficient to change the election outcome. The requester is responsible for the costs associated with the recount unless the recount changes the election outcome in the requester's favor, in which case the costs are refunded.

In some instances, the state or county must cover the costs of a recount. In other instances, an interested party—usually a candidate or voter—must pay. Staff salaries, location rental, vendor support, and legal services are common costs involved with recounts.

Recount reversals

Recounts in elections are a repeat tabulation of votes cast and are used to determine the accuracy of the initial count. Recounts are typically carried out when the initial vote tally is extremely close, following accusations of fraud, or due to administrative errors. Recounts can be automatic or requested by a candidate or voters. In the United States, recounts rarely reverse election results.

Between 2000 and 2015, there were 4,687 statewide general elections, and only 27 yielded recounts, with only three resulting in a change of outcome. These were the 2004 Washington gubernatorial election, the 2006 Vermont Auditor of Accounts election, and the 2008 United States Senate election in Minnesota. In each case, a Democratic candidate overcame an initial vote deficit to defeat the Republican candidate.

In the 2000 US presidential election, a recount was stopped by a 5-4 vote along partisan lines by the US Supreme Court, with George W. Bush ascending to the presidency by a margin of 537 votes in Florida.

In Oregon, an automatic recount is required in the event of a tie or when the margin between the winning candidate and the next closest candidate is less than or equal to 0.2% of the total vote. Candidates or voters may request a full or partial recount, and in the case of presidential elections, only a full recount is sufficient to change the outcome.

Recounts in Canadian elections are known as "judicial recounts" as they are overseen by a superior court judge. In federal elections, recounts are automatic in the event of a tie or a difference of 0.1%. Electors and candidates may also petition for recounts within four days of the final vote count. In Irish presidential elections, recounts occur only with the approval of the High Court, and candidates or the Director of Public Prosecutions may petition for a recount within seven days of the election.

Frequently asked questions