Understanding Collective Bargaining Agreements In Labor Disputes

Collective bargaining is a process in which employees, typically represented by a labour union, negotiate with their employers to determine the terms of employment, including pay, benefits, hours, leave, and health and safety policies. The goal of collective bargaining is to reach a collective bargaining agreement, which is a written contract outlining the rules of employment for a set number of years. In the United States, the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) grants employees the right to engage in collective bargaining and protects them from retaliation or discrimination for doing so. The NLRA also covers most collective agreements in the private sector, excluding certain categories of workers such as federal and state government employees. The process of collective bargaining can be intense and stressful, and may involve labour strikes or employee lockouts if the two sides struggle to reach an agreement.

Explore related products

The Handbook of Dispute Resolution

$61.81 $115

The Labor Arbitration Career

$19.99

Beyond Neutrality: Confronting the Crisis in Conflict Resolution

$21.87 $48

Labor Arbitration Practice: An Advocate's Handbook

$229.95

Managing Public Disputes

$27.51 $65

Dispute Resolution: Negotiation, Mediation, Arbitration, and Other Processes [Connected eBook with Study Center] (Aspen Casebook)

$237 $359

The right to bargain collectively

The National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), also known as the Wagner Act, explicitly grants employees in the United States the right to collectively bargain and join trade unions. It covers most private, non-agricultural employees and employers engaged in interstate commerce. The NLRA makes it illegal for employers to discriminate against, harass, or terminate employees due to their union membership and protects employees' rights to engage in collective bargaining activities, form unions, discuss pay and grievances, and strike.

The Railway Labor Act of 1926 granted collective bargaining rights to railroad workers and now covers many transportation workers. In the case of a labour dispute, arbitration is often used as a method of dispute resolution, where a neutral third party, or arbiter, is selected to issue a binding decision.

While the right to bargain collectively is widely recognised, there are variations in its implementation across different countries and industries. For example, in Sweden, collective bargaining agreements cover a high percentage of employees, despite the absence of legal mechanisms to extend them to entire industries. In contrast, some states in the US have outlawed union security clauses, allowing some beneficiaries of union contracts to avoid contributing to the costs of negotiation.

Overall, the right to bargain collectively is a crucial aspect of labour relations, providing employees with a means to negotiate their terms of employment, including pay, benefits, hours, and working conditions, and ensuring their grievances are addressed.

Terms of employment

The terms of employment are a crucial aspect of any collective bargaining agreement, encompassing various factors that significantly impact the rights and well-being of workers. This process involves negotiations between an employer and a group of workers, typically represented by a labour union, to establish rules and standards that will govern their professional relationships.

The scope of terms of employment is comprehensive and covers a wide range of topics. At the forefront are discussions surrounding salaries and compensation, ensuring that employees receive equitable pay for their labour. This includes considerations for wage markups, where union members often secure a 5-10% higher wage compared to their non-unionised counterparts.

Working hours are also a pivotal point of negotiation, addressing the number of hours worked per week and the distribution of those hours across the days. This ties into considerations for work-life balance, exploring ways to help employees manage their professional and personal responsibilities effectively.

Benefits are another essential aspect of terms of employment. This covers a range of advantages offered to employees beyond their standard compensation, such as healthcare, retirement plans, and other perks that enhance their overall job satisfaction and sense of security.

Working conditions are a critical factor in the terms of employment, focusing on health and safety in the workplace. Unions play a pivotal role in securing safe working environments for their members, ensuring that employers adhere to regulations and prioritising the well-being of their workforce.

Negotiations regarding terms of employment also extend to leave policies, encompassing various types of leave such as vacation, sick leave, parental leave, and other forms of time off that provide employees with the necessary breaks and support during different stages of their lives.

Union dues

The National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) allows unions and employers to enter into union-security agreements, which require the payment of dues or dues equivalents as a condition of employment. Federal law permits unions and employers to enter into such agreements, mandating that all employees in a bargaining unit become union members and start paying union dues and fees within 30 days of being hired. However, employees can opt-out of union membership and only pay dues associated with their representation, such as collective bargaining and contract administration. This option, known as the Beck right, must be communicated to all covered employees by the unions.

It is worth noting that some states in the US have outlawed union-security clauses, allowing beneficiaries of union contracts to opt-out of paying for their portion of contract negotiation costs. Additionally, the Supreme Court has ruled that an individual's union dues cannot be used without their consent to fund political causes that conflict with their personal beliefs.

Explore related products

Labour Dispute Resolution in Turkey

$76.57 $89.99

Examples & Explanations for Dispute Resolution

$50 $58.95

Dispute Resolution and Lawyers, A Contemporary Approach (Interactive Casebook Series)

$292.6 $308

Labour Dispute Resolution: A Southern African Perspective

$81

Labor Law and Labor Dispute Resolution(Chinese Edition)

$27.2

Labor dispute resolution system(Chinese Edition)

$29.3

Dispute resolution

During collective bargaining, disputes may arise due to differences in proposed terms between the employer and the union. In such cases, dispute resolution mechanisms are employed to reach a consensus and establish a collective bargaining agreement. One common method of dispute resolution is arbitration, where both parties agree to select a neutral third party, known as an arbiter or arbitrator, to preside over a formal or informal hearing. The arbiter's decision is binding on both parties and helps resolve the dispute without litigation. Arbitration is governed by federal and state laws, providing a legal framework for the process.

In some cases, collective bargaining can involve labour strikes or employee lockouts if the two sides struggle to find common ground. These measures are considered drastic and are typically a last resort. Most industrialised countries have laws protecting the right to engage in collective bargaining and form unions, although certain industries or worker categories may be excluded from these protections. For example, in the United States, federal, state, and local government employees and agricultural labourers are not covered by the NLRA.

The International Labour Organization (ILO) asserts that collective bargaining is a fundamental right for all employees, enabling them to present and negotiate their grievances with employers. This process helps reduce workplace inequalities and provides workers with labour protection. Additionally, collective bargaining agreements can include "fair share" provisions, requiring non-union members to contribute a proportionate share of the costs associated with the collective bargaining process and contract administration.

In summary, dispute resolution in the context of collective bargaining involves finding a resolution that satisfies both the employer and the union. Arbitration is a key tool in this process, providing a structured yet flexible framework for reaching a binding decision. By utilising dispute resolution mechanisms, collective bargaining agreements can be established, ensuring fair and equitable employment terms for workers.

Enforceability

The enforceability of a collective bargaining agreement depends on the jurisdiction in which it is implemented. In the United States, the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) of 1935, also known as the Wagner Act, forms the basis for most collective bargaining agreements. The NLRA grants employees the right to collectively bargain, join trade unions, and engage in union activities without fear of retaliation. It also prohibits employers from discriminating against, harassing, or terminating employees based on their union membership. The NLRA is enforced by the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), which was established by the act. The NLRB's decisions and regulations supplement and define the provisions of the NLRA.

State laws in the US also play a role in regulating collective bargaining and making collective agreements enforceable. For example, certain states have outlawed union security clauses, which require all employees, including non-union members, to pay a proportion of the costs of union representation. In the case of Harris v. Quinn in 2014, the Supreme Court ruled that the First Amendment prohibits the collection of union fees from employees who do not wish to join or support the union.

In addition to federal and state laws, arbitration is commonly used as a method of dispute resolution in collective bargaining agreements. Arbitration involves the selection of a neutral third party, known as an arbiter, to hold a formal or informal hearing and issue a binding decision. Arbitration agreements and the decisions of the arbiter may be enforceable under state and federal law. The Federal Arbitration Act and the Uniform Arbitration Act (adopted by 35 jurisdictions) provide the legal framework for arbitration in the US.

In Sweden, the coverage of collective agreements is high, despite the lack of legal mechanisms to extend agreements to entire industries. This reflects the dominance of self-regulation over state regulation in Swedish industrial relations. In Australia, collective bargaining has its roots in the early 20th century with the introduction of a conciliation and arbitration system, which has since undergone transformations due to changing government priorities and the shifting balance of power between employers and unions.

Frequently asked questions