Labor And Capital: Constitutional Constraints

The constitutions of various countries, including India, the Philippines, and the United States, contain provisions that directly or indirectly affect labor and capital. These provisions outline the rights and protections afforded to laborers, employers, and capital owners within the respective countries. For instance, the Indian Constitution provides a comprehensive framework for safeguarding labor rights, promoting equality, and ensuring dignified treatment of workers. Similarly, the Philippine Constitution's Article III establishes the relationship between individuals and the state, emphasizing the protection of human dignity and the reduction of social, economic, and political inequalities. In the United States, constitutional provisions have addressed issues such as freedom of contract, minimum wage legislation, and the right to unionize, with amendments and laws like the Thirteenth Amendment, the Fair Labor Standards Act, and the National Labor Relations Act playing significant roles in shaping labor relations. These constitutional provisions reflect each country's unique historical context and values, influencing the dynamics between labor and capital.

Explore related products

An Introduction to Labor Law

$12.05 $14.95

The Beginner's Guide to Labor Arbitration Practice: Tips & Strategies for Improving Your Case

$19.99

Understanding Labor Law (Understanding Series)

$49.19 $55

Essential Guide to Federal Employment Laws, The

$37.98 $49.99

The SHRM Essential Guide to Employment Law: A Handbook for HR Professionals, Managers, Businesses, and Organizations

$35.49 $39.99

Employment and Labor Law

$19.51 $388.95

Labor laws and standards

In the United States, labor law has undergone significant changes over time, with a shift from a laissez-faire approach to a more regulated system. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) of 1938, enacted after the Wall Street Crash and Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal, set federal minimum wage standards and overtime pay requirements for most employees in private and public sectors. This marked a turning point in labor law, as it ended the "Lochner era," which prioritized freedom of contract and allowed employers to discharge employees at any time.

The National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) of 1935 is another key piece of legislation, guaranteeing employees the right to unionize, collectively bargain for fair wages, and take collective action. The NLRA explicitly permits unions and employers to agree on certain requirements, such as dues or "agency shop fees." However, the Supreme Court has also upheld the right of employees not to associate with unions, particularly in the public sector, where unionization can give employees significant influence in the decision-making process.

To ensure the protection of labor rights, the Indian Constitution provides legal remedies and a framework to defend against exploitation, guaranteeing laborers' fundamental rights, including the right to equality and justice. Similarly, the Philippine Constitution values the dignity of every person and guarantees full respect, while also promoting social justice and full employment. These constitutional provisions on labor standards aim to strike a balance between individual rights and the common good, ensuring that labor contracts are subject to laws on collective bargaining, strikes, wages, and working conditions.

In conclusion, labor laws and standards are shaped by constitutional provisions that vary across nations. These provisions aim to protect laborers' rights, promote full employment, and ensure social and economic equality, while also recognizing the public interest in labor relations and the need for regulatory measures. By doing so, constitutions provide a foundation for equitable treatment and social development, safeguarding laborers from exploitation and promoting their fundamental welfare.

Right to equality and justice

The Right to Equality is a fundamental right enshrined in the Constitution of India. Articles 14 to 18 of the Indian Constitution contain all the provisions related to the Right to Equality, which form the cornerstone of justice and fairness in society. These articles ensure that everyone is treated equally before the law, given equal opportunities in certain matters, and is not discriminated against on grounds such as religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth, among others. This right is extended not only to citizens but also to foreigners and legal persons such as companies. The Right to Equality is a fundamental human right that is recognized in various international treaties and national constitutions worldwide, signifying that all people should be treated equally and without discrimination.

The Indian Constitution also recognizes and protects laborers' fundamental rights. It establishes legal remedies and a framework to defend these rights, ensuring that workers are treated with dignity and respect and are not exploited. The Directive Principles of State Policy, which play a significant role in the development of new labor legislation in India, provide a framework for improving laborer welfare, ensuring adequate means of livelihood, and protecting their health and dignity.

The Right to Equality in the Indian Constitution has certain exceptions outlined by the Supreme Court. While Article 14 forbids class legislation, it permits the reasonable classification of persons, objects, and transactions by law, as long as the classification is not arbitrary, artificial, or evasive. Additionally, certain immunities are enjoyed by the President of India and the Governor of States, as per Article 361.

The Constitution of the Republic of the Philippines also includes provisions for social justice and equality. It states that the state shall afford full protection to labor, promote full employment, and ensure equality of employment opportunities for all. It guarantees workers' rights to self-organization, collective bargaining, negotiations, and peaceful concerted activities, including the right to strike.

In the United States, the historical context of labor rights and the Constitution is important. President Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation and the Thirteenth Amendment abolished most forms of slavery, and the Fourteenth Amendment ensured equal access to justice. However, the Civil Rights Act of 1875, which aimed to ensure equality in access to housing and transport, was deemed unconstitutional by the Supreme Court, allowing racial segregation to continue. The judiciary has had notable dissents, such as Justice Holmes' argument that collective action by unions causing economic loss was legitimate, and Justice Harlan's dissent that people were left "practically at the mercy of corporations" even after formal freedom.

Freedom of contract

The concept of freedom of contract is deeply rooted in the history of common law, where the employer had the right to discharge an employee at any time, and the employee had the equivalent right to quit at any time. This principle was often applied in the context of labour relations, with courts upholding the freedom of employers to subcontract work or make decisions about their operations without being required to bargain with employees' unions.

In the United States, the right to make and enforce contracts is embedded in Title 42 of the US Code. This includes the freedom to form, perform, modify, and terminate contracts, as well as to enjoy the benefits and privileges of the contractual relationship. However, it is important to note that the concept of freedom of contract has evolved over time, with modern interpretations recognising the need to balance individual freedoms with labour rights and protections.

For instance, in the late 19th century, English judiciary embraced the idea of "freedom of contract" as a fundamental aspect of public policy. This perspective shifted in the 20th century, with critics like Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. arguing that courts were making laws based on economics rather than interpreting the constitution. He disputed the very existence of "Liberty of Contract", a viewpoint shared by Roscoe Pound, who highlighted numerous cases where labour rights were compromised in the name of freedom of contract.

The Indian Constitution, which serves as the foundation for all laws in the country, also recognises and protects labourers' fundamental rights. It establishes legal remedies and frameworks to defend these rights, ensuring workers are treated with dignity and respect. This includes provisions for protection against forced labour and child labour, promoting equality, justice, and social rights.

Explore related products

Labor Law for the Rank & Filer: Building Solidarity While Staying Clear of the Law

$11 $15

Labor Law in a Nutshell

$62 $62

California Employment Law 2025: The SHRM Guide for Employers

$57.96 $59.99

Employer's Legal Handbook, The: How to Manage Your Employees & Workplace

$37.51 $49.99

Employment and Labor Law

$60.88 $291.95

California Labor Code [2025 Edition]

$39.99

Child labor laws

In the United States, the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (FLSA) is the primary legislation regulating child labor. The FLSA establishes standards for wages and overtime pay, and restrictions on working hours for youth under 16 years of age. It also prohibits the employment of children under 18 in certain hazardous occupations. The act is administered by the Wage and Hour Division of the Department of Labor, which enforces compliance with child labor provisions.

Despite these laws, child labor law violations continue to be a concern in the United States. Recent years have seen an alarming increase in infractions, with the hospitality and meatpacking industries identified as significant violators. The National Child Labor Committee, formed in 1904, has played a crucial role in advocating for the abolition of child labor and mobilizing support for state-level child labor laws.

While the federal legal system in the United States has limited powers to pass child labor laws due to constitutional rights granted to parents, individual states have taken the initiative to create their own laws with varying age and schooling requirements. This has resulted in a diverse landscape of youth employment regulations across the country.

The Indian Constitution and the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 in the United States provide a foundation for protecting children from exploitative labor practices and ensuring their right to education and a safe work environment. However, ongoing violations underscore the need for continued vigilance and enforcement of these critical child labor laws.

Union rights

The National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) guarantees employees the right to join or form a union without interference, restraint, or coercion from their employer. This includes the right to unionize, to join together to advance their interests as employees, and to refrain from such activity. It is unlawful for an employer to interfere with, restrain, or coerce employees in the exercise of their rights. For example, employers may not respond to a union organizing drive by threatening, interrogating, or spying on pro-union employees, or by promising benefits if they forgo the union.

The NLRA also applies to most workers in the private sector, but not all. Public-sector workers, such as school employees, county social workers, and firefighters, are covered by individual laws at the state level. Additionally, some workers, such as independent contractors, supervisors, and managers, are excluded from labor law coverage altogether.

Under the NLRA, employers are required to meet and bargain in good faith with the union about wages, hours, and working conditions; vacation time, insurance, safety practices, and other mandatory subjects. However, some managerial decisions, such as subcontracting and relocation, may not be mandatory subjects of bargaining.

The right to unionize is also recognized in the Indian Constitution, which provides a framework for the preservation, promotion, and equitable treatment of labor rights. The Indian Constitution includes provisions such as the right to equality, justice, and social rights. It also guarantees the abolition of forced labor and the prohibition of child labor.

In the United States, there has been a question of whether employees have the right not to associate with a union. While compulsion has been permitted for the economic purposes of collective bargaining, the Supreme Court has upheld that employees cannot be compelled to support a union against their wishes and beliefs.

Frequently asked questions