California's Constitution Of 1849: A Legacy Of Consequence

The California Constitution of 1849 was the state's first constitution, banning slavery and setting the foundation for California's entry into the Union as a free state. This constitution has had significant consequences, including shaping California's political landscape and legal system. The 1849 constitution has been amended numerous times, addressing issues such as taxation, direct democracy, water rights, and labor relations. The ease of amending the constitution has led to criticisms of a bloated document filled with irrelevant detail. Nonetheless, California's constitution has been influential, with provisions such as enhanced free speech rights and a prohibition against cruel or unusual punishment. The evolution of California's constitution reflects the state's dynamic response to changing social, economic, and political needs.

Explore related products

Constitution of the State of California: 1849

$8.99

The Constitution of the State of California: Adopted in Convention at Sacramento, March 3, 1879, Ratified by a Vote of the People May 7, 1879,together ... 26, 1915, Ed. by Edward F. Treadwell, LL. B

$39.95

The Delegates of 1849: Life Stories of the Originators of California's Reputation as a Bold and Independent State

$3.69 $15

Three Years in California [1846-1849]

$8.9 $22.99

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights

$9.99 $9.99

CALIFORNIA STATE CONSTITUTION 2E P (Oxford Commentaries on the State Constitutions of the United States)

$44.87 $80

The 1849 California Constitution was ratified on November 13, 1849, and published in English and Spanish

The 1849 California Constitution was approved on November 13, 1849, and published in English and Spanish. This original constitution was adopted at the California Constitutional Convention in Monterey, and it marked a significant step towards California's admission as a new state, which was achieved in 1850.

The 1849 Constitution was derived from the New York and Iowa constitutions, and it included a Declaration of Rights, modelled on New York's constitution. This Declaration of Rights remains largely intact in the current California Constitution. The 1849 Constitution also defined the structure of the state's government and protected individual rights, including some that were not safeguarded by the federal Constitution. For instance, it covered topics such as direct democracy, water rights, and labour relations.

However, the 1849 Constitution soon proved inadequate to meet California's rapidly evolving needs. It failed to curb the legislature's freedom to impose high fees and taxes, spend excessively, and grant itself large salaries. As a result, from 1911 to 1986, the California Constitution underwent numerous amendments and revisions, with over 500 changes made during this period. The constitution became increasingly lengthy and bloated, leading to attempts to convene a third constitutional convention, but these efforts were unsuccessful.

Instead, California employed revision commissions and ballot initiatives to propose amendments, which resulted in a more politically charged and challenging revision process. The current California Constitution, last revised in 1976, is one of the longest in the world, and it continues to evolve as voters amend it to meet the state's changing requirements.

It was derived from the New York and Iowa constitutions, but proved inadequate for the state's needs

California's original constitution, adopted in 1849, was largely derived from the constitutions of New York and Iowa. The 1849 constitution included California's version of the federal Bill of Rights, known as the Declaration of Rights, which was primarily based on New York's constitution. This document remains mostly intact today, with the original rights it enshrined still largely protected by the current constitution.

However, the 1849 constitution soon proved inadequate to meet the state's evolving needs. For instance, it gave the legislature free rein to impose high taxes and spend excessively, including on their own salaries. This was a pressing issue given the state's rapidly changing demographics following the discovery of gold in California in 1848, which triggered a gold rush and a sharp increase in the state's non-native population.

The inadequacies of the 1849 constitution led to its continual evolution, with numerous amendments and revisions over time. From 1911 to 1986, during the Progressive Era, the constitution was amended or revised over 500 times. This was partly in response to widespread public dissatisfaction with the powerful railroads that dominated California's politics and economy at the turn of the century.

The numerous amendments have resulted in a lengthy and detailed constitution. As of 1962, it was 75,000 words long, making it one of the longest state constitutions in the world at that time. The ease of amending the constitution has been a subject of debate, with critics arguing that it has led to a document filled with irrelevant details and conflicting policies.

It has been amended over 500 times since 1879, making it one of the world's longest constitutions

The California Constitution of 1849 has been amended over 500 times since 1879, making it one of the world's longest constitutions. The original constitution was drafted in English and adopted in 1849, the year after gold was discovered in California, triggering the historic gold rush and a rapid increase in the state's non-native population.

The constitution has been amended an average of five times per year since its enactment, and California's progressive politicians have often been at the forefront of these changes. The state's constitution-making process is unique in that it has an ongoing constitutional convention, with voters regularly approving amendments. This has resulted in a lengthy and detailed constitution, filled with policies created by conflicting majorities attempting to impose their will on each other.

The ease of amending the constitution has been a source of criticism, with politicians and political scientists arguing that the procedures are too lax. This has resulted in a constitution filled with irrelevant details and incoherent policies. The constitution-making process in California has also been marked by a lack of faith in elected officials and the influence of powerful railroads at the turn of the 20th century, which led to a wave of amendments aimed at countering this influence.

The California Constitution is also notable for its robust direct democracy provisions, which give voters broad powers to adopt new statutes, amend the constitution, repeal existing statutes, and recall elected officials. These provisions were added in 1911 and have resulted in a barrage of voter-initiated political activity, including the enactment of statutes, constitutional amendments, the quashing of legislative enactments, and the recall of six elected state officials, including the governor in 2003.

Explore related products

Report of the Debates in the Convention of California, on the Formation of the State Constitution, in September and October, 1849

$8.95 $19.99

Three Years in California [1846-1849]

$38.75

Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California

$8.95

Report Of The Debates In The Convention Of California, On The Format Of The State Constitution, In September And October, 1849

$20.99

History's Greatest Escapes with Morgan Freeman (TV Series)

$2.99

A People's History of the United States

$18.79 $23.99

The constitution has been criticised for being filled with irrelevant detail and incoherent policies

The California Constitution, first drafted in 1849, has been criticised for its excessive length and the incoherence of its policies. The constitution has been amended numerous times since its original enactment, with an average of five amendments per year. This has resulted in a lengthy document filled with what some argue is irrelevant detail. From 1911 to 1986, for example, the constitution was amended or revised over 500 times, leading to a bloated document that was likely difficult to navigate and understand. By 1962, the constitution had grown to 75,000 words, making it one of the longest state constitutions in the US at the time.

The ease with which the California Constitution can be amended has been a contributing factor to its length and perceived incoherence. Amendments can be enacted by a simple majority vote in a referendum, and this has led to accusations that the procedures for amending the constitution are too lax. Politicians and political scientists argue that the ballot process allows conflicting majorities to impose their will, resulting in incoherent policies and irrelevant details being included.

The length of the California Constitution has been attributed to several factors, including the influence of previous Mexican civil law, a lack of faith in elected officials, and the fact that many initiatives take the form of constitutional amendments. The constitution has also undergone several comprehensive revisions, including one by the California Constitution Revision Commission, which removed about 40,000 words from the document between 1964 and 1976.

The original 1849 constitution was drafted by American pioneers, European settlers, and Californios (Hispanics of California) following the Mexican-American War and in advance of California's Admission to the Union in 1850. It was written in both English and Spanish and adopted at the 1849 Constitutional Convention of Monterey. The constitution has since been rewritten several times, with the current version dating to 1879.

The California Constitution is one of the longest in the world, and while it has been simplified over time, the revision process is still considered politically charged and challenging. The constitution's length and complexity have led to criticisms of irrelevant detail and incoherent policies, with efforts made at various times to streamline and revise the document.

It protects direct democracy, limits taxation, and secures individual liberty and rights

California's constitution, first adopted in 1849, has been amended numerous times since its enactment and is now one of the longest in the world. The constitution defines the structure of the state's government and protects direct democracy, limits taxation, and safeguards individual liberty and rights.

The constitution's length is due to several factors, including the influence of previous Mexican civil law, a lack of trust in elected officials, and the fact that many initiatives are constitutional amendments. The constitution has been amended an average of five times each year since its enactment, and if California were a sovereign state, it would have the second or third-longest constitution in the world by word count.

The 1849 constitution was inadequate in addressing the state's rapidly changing needs. For example, it allowed the legislature to impose high fees and taxes, spend excessively, and grant itself large salaries. In response to public disgust with the powerful railroads that controlled California's politics and economy at the start of the 20th century, politicians began aggressively amending the state constitution to address these issues.

The California Constitution has a Declaration of Rights, which is the state's version of the federal Bill of Rights. The Declaration of Rights was derived from New York's constitution and remains largely intact today, although it has been amended several times. The constitution also includes a stronger prohibition against "cruel or unusual punishment" than the Eighth Amendment of the US Constitution, which prohibits "cruel and unusual punishment." It also guarantees equality of rights for women in business, professions, and employment, and it shields Stanford-owned property from taxes as long as it is used for educational purposes.

The California Constitution also covers topics not addressed by the federal Constitution, such as direct democracy, water rights, and labor relations. The state constitution has been interpreted as protecting broader rights than the Bill of Rights in the federal constitution. For example, in the Pruneyard Shopping Center v. Robins case, California courts found an implied right to free speech in private shopping centers, which goes beyond the First Amendment to the US Constitution.

Frequently asked questions