Wealth And The Constitution: Who Benefits?

The United States Constitution has been criticised for being written for the wealthy. The 55 men who gathered in Philadelphia in 1787 to draft the Constitution were wealthy, white landowners, and the document they produced has been accused of protecting the interests of the ruling class. The Constitution was also influenced by the Magna Carta, which was written to ensure the rights of barons or business leaders. The US Constitution has been criticised for only protecting the rights of the wealthy, with justice only being afforded to those who can afford it. The 6th Amendment provides for a speedy trial, but this right has had to be extended to ordinary citizens through amendments. The US Constitution has also been criticised for its lack of representation for those without property, slaves, indentured servants, and women.

Explore related products

Engine of Inequality: The Fed and the Future of Wealth in America

$29.65 $13.75

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights

$9.99 $9.99

Wealth Inequality in America: Causes, Consequences, and Solutions: The Destruction of the American Middle Class

$9.95 $18.95

How Democratic is the American Constitution? Second Edition

$12.51 $21

Pirate Money: Discovering the Founders’ Hidden Plan for Economic Justice and Defeating the Great Reset

$14.54 $17.87

The Deep State: The Fall of the Constitution and the Rise of a Shadow Government

$13.65 $19

The US Constitution was influenced by the Magna Carta, which was written by wealthy landowners

The US Constitution was heavily influenced by the Magna Carta, a 13th-century pact written by wealthy landowners. The Magna Carta's principles spread to the American colonies and influenced the legal terminology used in the US Constitution. The phrase "by the law of the land" from the Magna Carta, for example, was used in all American documents before the Constitution. The Founding Fathers also drew inspiration from the Magna Carta when drafting the US Constitution, aiming to create a Magna Carta for a new era.

The US Constitution was written by elite property owners, indicating that it was created from the perspective of the wealthy. The Founding Fathers, including George Washington, John Hancock, Benjamin Franklin, and Thomas Jefferson, were all very rich men. The Constitution's focus on property rights and its failure to address the interests of those without property, slaves, indentured servants, and women further suggest that it was written for the benefit of the wealthy.

The Constitution's original text also excluded women, people of color, and Indigenous people from the definition of citizenship and suffrage, reflecting the writers' narrow view of citizenry. However, it is important to note that the Constitution's framers intended to create a system of government controlled by the citizenry rather than elites. They introduced groundbreaking concepts such as legal equality, regardless of social rank, and guaranteed rights to trial by jury, exemption from cruel and unusual punishment, and legal representation.

The influence of the Magna Carta on the US Constitution is evident in the Bill of Rights, the first ten amendments ratified by the states in 1791. Amendments five through seven set rules for fair and speedy jury trials, while the Eighth Amendment prohibits excessive bail and fines, echoing the 20th clause of the Magna Carta. The Founding Fathers' understanding of the Magna Carta shaped their interpretation of the rule of law, due process, and individual liberties in the US Constitution.

In conclusion, while the US Constitution was influenced by the Magna Carta, it is important to recognize that it was also shaped by the social and economic context of its time, including the interests and perspectives of the wealthy landowners who drafted it.

The Founding Fathers were wealthy men with a vested interest in protecting their wealth

The United States Constitution was written by 55 wealthy, white men, many of whom were slave owners, and all of whom were property owners. These men were the Founding Fathers, and they had a vested interest in protecting their wealth. George Washington, for example, was the richest person in America, and John Hancock, Benjamin Franklin, and Thomas Jefferson were also very rich men.

The Founding Fathers were members of the colonial ruling class, and they had overthrown British rule to prevent unfair taxes. They were concerned with creating a government that would protect their interests and wealth. The Constitution was written to ensure certain freedoms and rights, but these were largely afforded to the wealthy. The Founding Fathers had a narrow view of citizenry, and the Constitution did not reflect the interests of the disenfranchised. Four groups were not represented at the Constitutional Convention: those without property, slaves, indentured servants, and women.

The Constitution was also influenced by the Magna Carta, which was written 572 years earlier to ensure the rights of British barons. Similarly, the US Constitution has been criticised for only protecting the rights of the modern-day barons and their families. The 6th Amendment, for example, provides for a speedy trial, but this right had to be amended to include ordinary citizens. The Constitution has also been criticised for its lack of a presumption of innocence, which is a legal principle rather than a constitutional guarantee.

The Founding Fathers were wealthy men who wrote the rules to keep themselves in power and protect their wealth. The Constitution was written with a pro-wealthy agenda, and the government that was formed as a result was dominated by wealthy men. This has had a lasting impact on the country, with the upper class maintaining their power and influence.

The Constitution was written by elite property owners, excluding the interests of the disenfranchised

The United States Constitution was written by wealthy, white men, many of whom were slave owners. These men were elite property owners, and as such, the document they created was inherently exclusive of the interests of the disenfranchised.

The writers of the Constitution, such as George Washington, John Hancock, Benjamin Franklin, and Thomas Jefferson, were all very rich. They were also slave owners, and as such, the Constitution did not reflect the interests of slaves. It also did not represent the interests of those without property, indentured servants, and women, who were not considered to be the equals of white men and were disenfranchised. The Constitution was written to protect the interests of the wealthy, and this is reflected in the fact that voting qualifications at the state level often required the owning of property, thereby excluding those without property, women, and racial minorities.

The Constitution was also influenced by the Magna Carta, a document drafted by business leaders and the Archbishop of Canterbury to ensure the rights of the church, protection for barons, swift justice, and limitations on taxation. Similarly, the US Constitution was created to protect the interests of the wealthy and their economic processes. The wealthy had to control the government directly or control the laws, and this was the thinking behind the creation of the Constitution.

The economic system of capitalism, which the Constitution helped to solidify, was designed to enrich wealthy business owners. This is evident in the vast income inequality in the United States, where the top 20% have 14 times more wealth than the bottom 80%. The Constitution has also been criticised for only protecting the rights of the wealthy and not providing a presumption of innocence for ordinary citizens.

The writers of the Constitution had a narrow view of citizenry, and while they intended to create a system of government controlled by the citizenry, their definition of "citizen" excluded many groups. The Constitution was written by the wealthy, for the wealthy, and as such, it is not surprising that the government has become highly pro-wealthy over time.

Explore related products

Markets, Constitutions, and Inequality (Critical Studies in Jurisprudence)

$41.79 $54.99

A Theory of Justice: Original Edition

$29.19 $40

Presidents, Populism, and the Crisis of Democracy

$18.85 $22

Reflections On The Formation And Distribution Of Wealth

$30.95 $9.45

Before the Deluge: Public Debt, Inequality, and the Intellectual Origins of the French Revolution

$45.5 $55

A Theory of Justice

$40 $40

The Constitution was amended to include the right to a speedy trial, but this right is only accessible to those who can afford it

The US Constitution has long been a subject of debate, with critics arguing that it was written for the wealthy. This claim is supported by the fact that the document was crafted by elite property owners, excluding those without property, slaves, indentured servants, and women from the Constitutional Convention. The Constitution's original text also failed to consider women and people of color as equals, and the right to a speedy trial, guaranteed by the Sixth Amendment, has been inaccessible to those who cannot afford legal representation.

The Sixth Amendment to the US Constitution, ratified on December 15, 1791, grants criminal defendants a series of rights, including the right to a speedy trial. This right ensures that criminal trials are conducted without unnecessary delay and are open to the public and media, except in cases of privacy requests, public safety, or national security concerns. However, the accessibility of this right has been called into question due to the cost of legal representation.

While the Constitution guarantees the right to legal counsel, it initially did not address the issue of providing representation for those who could not afford it. This changed with the 1963 Gideon v. Wainwright case, which established that defendants are entitled to free legal counsel. The appointed lawyer is expected to provide substantial and effective aid to their clients, ensuring that the right to a speedy trial is more accessible regardless of financial means.

Despite this amendment, the perception that the Constitution favors the wealthy persists. This perception is influenced by the historical context in which it was written, with wealthy individuals like George Washington, John Hancock, Benjamin Franklin, and Thomas Jefferson playing prominent roles in the nation's founding. Additionally, the Constitution's focus on property rights and the protection of economic processes has been interpreted as favoring the interests of the wealthy over the disenfranchised.

In conclusion, while the Sixth Amendment guarantees the right to a speedy trial, the historical exclusion of marginalized groups from the Constitutional Convention and the financial barriers to legal representation have contributed to the perception that the Constitution was written for the wealthy. The ongoing interpretation and expansion of constitutional rights, such as the right to counsel, reflect efforts to make these rights more accessible and inclusive for all citizens.

The US government has become highly pro-wealthy, with politicians reliant on donations from the wealthy

The US Constitution was written by 55 wealthy, white men, many of whom were slave owners, including George Washington, the richest person in America. The document was created to benefit the wealthy, with the knowledge that they had to either control the government directly or control the laws. The writers of the Constitution had a narrow view of citizenry, and it did not occur to them to consider women and people of colour as their equals.

The Constitution was also influenced by the Magna Carta, which was drafted to ensure the rights of the church, protection for barons from illegal imprisonment, access to swift justice, and limitations on taxation. Similarly, the US Constitution was written to protect the interests of the wealthy, with the right to property being a key concern. The 6th Amendment to the Constitution provides for a speedy trial and access to swift justice, but this had to be amended to provide that right for ordinary citizens.

The US tax system has also been designed to benefit the wealthy. The Sixteenth Amendment, ratified in 1913, granted Congress the authority to issue an income tax without having to determine it based on population. While this was initially proposed as a way to tax the wealthy more fairly, it has instead shifted the way the federal government receives funding, with the middle class and poor continuing to pay tariffs and income taxes.

Frequently asked questions