The Constitution: Betrayal Or Evolution Of The American Revolution?

The American Revolution, a struggle against monarchical and aristocratic power, was an attempt to establish common freedom and a government founded on the consent of the governed. The Constitution of 1787 was created to address the flaws of the Articles of Confederation and to develop a stronger and more effective governing body. While some view the Constitution as an embodiment of the American Revolution, others argue that it betrayed the Revolution by not living up to its ideals, particularly those expressed in Thomas Jefferson's Declaration of Independence, which stated that all men are created equal.

Explore related products

The Constitution of the United States and The Declaration of Independence

$1.99 $14.95

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights

$9.99 $9.99

The American Revolution: A Concise History from Colonial Rebellion to the War for Independence to the Constitution

$14.53 $14.95

The U.S. Constitution: Explained--Clause by Clause--for Every American Today

$9.97 $12

Two Revolutions and the Constitution: How the English and American Revolutions Produced the American Constitution

$22.99 $22.99

The History of the Constitution: Notable Events for Young Readers

$4.99 $7.99

The Constitution's conception of freedom

The US Constitution was created in 1787, a few years after the American Revolution ended. It was established to address the flaws of the Articles of Confederation and create a stronger and more effective governing body while upholding American virtues of freedom. The Constitution was a conscious attempt to bound the state and preserve freedom.

The Constitution's basic conception is that man pursues different, often selfish, interests. This conception of freedom as an outcome of contending interests, each guaranteed inalienable rights, constituted the American Revolution. The three principles of rights, checks and balances, and limited government were established to preserve freedom. The US Constitution was the first in world history to be founded on the consent of the governed and the rule of law.

The American Revolution was a struggle against monarchical and aristocratic power, and an explicit attempt to establish common freedom. The leaders of the revolution were influenced by liberal philosophers such as John Locke, whose ideas on liberty shaped the political thinking of the time. The theory of the social contract influenced the belief among the Founders that the people had a natural right to overthrow their leaders if those leaders betrayed the historic rights of Englishmen.

The rights of Englishmen, such as consent in taxation, were important to the American colonists, who believed that the government should protect the rights already endowed to humans by their Creator. The Constitution was created to enshrine these rights, including freedom of speech and religion, in the Bill of Rights.

Despite the Constitution's role in enshrining certain freedoms, some believe that it betrayed the Revolution by not living up to its ideals. The strong central government established by the Constitution was seen by some as oppressive and undermining the autonomy of individual states. The Constitution's conception of freedom, based on contending interests and inalienable rights, was a key aspect of its creation and its impact on American society.

The role of the state

The American Revolution was a struggle against monarchical and aristocratic power, and an attempt to establish common freedom. The leaders of this movement were influenced by liberal philosophers such as John Locke, who advocated for the right of the people to overthrow their leaders if they betrayed the historic rights of Englishmen. This was known as the social contract. The American Revolution also drew on the English tradition of common law and rights, as well as the ideas of the Radical Whigs, who valued liberty and opposed tyrannical government.

The Constitution of the United States, established in 1787, was an attempt to preserve this freedom by limiting the power of the state. The basic conception of the Constitution is that man pursues different, often selfish, interests. The three principles of rights, checks and balances, and limited government guided the American Revolution. The Constitution's First Amendment established a republic and a minimum, balanced government.

However, some argue that the Constitution did not live up to the ideals of the Revolution and instead betrayed it. The strong central government established by the Constitution undermined the autonomy of individual states, which was a concern for many. The Constitution was also criticised for not embodying the "Spirit of '76", a term used to describe the revolutionary ideals that were spread during the revolution through documents, pamphlets, and slogans. Thomas Jefferson's Declaration of Independence, for example, stated that "all men are created equal", but not all people had the same rights and freedoms in practice.

In conclusion, while the American Revolution sought to limit the power of the state and establish freedom, the role of the state as defined by the Constitution was a balance between providing effective governance and preserving individual liberties. The Constitution was designed to address the issues of the time, but it also faced opposition and criticism for not fully embodying the ideals of the Revolution.

The rights of individuals

The American Revolution was a struggle against monarchical and aristocratic power, and an attempt to establish the greatest possible common freedom. The leaders of the revolution were influenced by liberal philosophers such as John Locke, who believed in the "right of revolution". Locke's ideas on liberty also influenced the political thinking of English writers, whose ideas, in turn, influenced the American Patriots. The theory of the social contract influenced the belief among many of the Founders that the right of the people to overthrow their leaders, should those leaders betray the historic rights of Englishmen, was one of the "natural rights" of man.

The American Revolution was followed by the creation of the United States Constitution in 1787, which was an attempt to develop a stronger and more effective governing body while upholding virtues of freedom. The Constitution was meant to shackle the power of the State and preserve freedom. The basic conception of the Constitution is that man pursues different, and often selfish, interests. The three principles of Rights, checks and balances, and limited government, constituted the American Revolution.

However, some believe that the Constitution did not live up to the ideals of the Revolution. The Declaration of Independence, written in 1776, stated that "all men are created equal", but not all people had the same rights and freedoms. The Constitution, which is the foundation of the American government, has provided the basis for human rights in America, such as those stated in the Bill of Rights, including freedom of speech and religion. However, it has been argued that the Constitution did not embody the "Spirit of '76", and that it was a betrayal of the Revolution.

The Constitution established a republic and a minimum, balanced government, which was initially agrarian but later evolved into an industrial, mixed free market-socialist democracy. The freedoms of the republic were congenial to vigorous free-market growth. The United States became the first constitutional republic in world history founded on the consent of the governed and the rule of law.

Explore related products

The Origins of the American Constitution: A Documentary History

$15.52 $24

The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution: Fiftieth Anniversary Edition

$17.95 $27

Plain, Honest Men: The Making of the American Constitution

$17.61 $20

Unruly Americans and the Origins of the Constitution

$16.87 $20

Federalist Papers and the Constitution of the United States: The Principles of American Government

$7.99 $15.99

A More Perfect Union: The Story of Our Constitution

$7.5 $11.99

The influence of philosophers

The Constitution of the United States was influenced by several philosophers and their works. The philosophical ancestors of the American Revolution were the English liberals, including Sir John Harrington and John Locke. Locke's ideas on liberty influenced the political thinking of English writers, whose political ideas, in turn, influenced the American Patriots. Locke's work also inspired symbols used in the American Revolution, such as the "Appeal to Heaven" on the Pine Tree Flag, which alludes to his concept of the right of revolution. The theory of the social contract influenced the belief among many of the Founders that the right of the people to overthrow their leaders, should those leaders betray the historic rights of Englishmen, was one of the "natural rights" of man. The Americans relied on Montesquieu's analysis of the wisdom of the "balanced" British Constitution (mixed government) when writing the state and national constitutions. Montesquieu's theories of republican government were widely known and assumed to be understood by the readers of pamphlets and newspapers.

The Framers were influenced by the idea of constitutionalism, natural rights, and republicanism. They believed in the superiority of constitutional government and the necessity of a written constitution as its foundation. The concept of natural rights was expressed in the Declaration of Independence in 1776 and influenced political and legal developments in the following decades. The belief in "equality by creation" and "rights by creation" was widespread in late eighteenth-century America. The influence of Locke and the European Enlightenment, including thinkers like Hobbes, on the founders of the United States, such as George Washington, John Adams, and Thomas Jefferson, was significant. They concurred that laws, rather than men, should be the final sanction and that governments should be responsible to the governed.

The legacy of the revolution

The legacy of the American Revolution is complex and multifaceted, with some arguing that the Constitution was a betrayal of its ideals, while others see it as an embodiment of the Revolution's principles.

The American Revolution was a struggle against monarchical and aristocratic power, inspired by liberal philosophers like John Locke, and sought to establish common freedom and limit state power. The Revolution resulted in the creation of the first constitutional republic in world history, founded on the consent of the governed and the rule of law. The United States Constitution of 1787 was an attempt to create a stronger and more effective governing body while preserving American values of freedom.

However, some argue that the Constitution did not live up to the ideals of the Revolution. The "Spirit of '76," exemplified by Thomas Jefferson's Declaration of Independence, proclaimed that "all men are created equal," yet not all people enjoyed equal rights and freedoms. The Constitution's strong central government may have undermined the autonomy of individual states, and the document failed to address issues such as excessive democracy and runaway inflation.

On the other hand, the Constitution is seen by some as the embodiment of the Revolution's ideals. It established a republic with a minimum, balanced government, and guaranteed basic human rights, such as freedom of speech and religion. The Constitution was a conscious attempt to limit state power and preserve freedom, influenced by the English tradition of common law and rights.

The legacy of the American Revolution thus remains a subject of debate, with the Constitution being interpreted as both a betrayal and a fulfillment of the Revolution's principles, depending on the perspective.

Overall, the American Revolution had a significant impact on political philosophy, inspiring future revolutions and shaping the development of nations. It challenged monarchical power and aristocratic privilege, promoting the idea of freedom and the preservation of natural rights. The Revolution's legacy can be seen in the creation of a constitutional republic, the establishment of new governing principles, and the ongoing interpretation and debate over the role of government in preserving freedom and ensuring the rights of its citizens.

Frequently asked questions