How The Albany Plan Influenced The Constitution

The Albany Plan of Union, proposed in 1754, was an attempt to unite the Thirteen Colonies under a unified government, marking a significant event in American history. Benjamin Franklin, a prominent leader and delegate from Pennsylvania, played a pivotal role in drafting this plan. While the proposal was never implemented, it served as a precursor to the United States Constitution, influencing its structure and key elements such as proportional representation. The Albany Plan's impact extended beyond the Constitution, with its ideas resonating in later reform efforts and fostering a sense of confederal growth. Despite its rejection, the plan introduced the concept of a strong union and remains an important chapter in the evolution of American democracy and federalism.

Explore related products

U.S. Founding Documents: Albany Plan, Declaration of Independence, Articles of Confederation, and the Constitution

$8.59

The Constitution of the United States of America: The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights

$9.99 $9.99

The Imperial Republic: A Structural History of American Constitutionalism from the Colonial Era to the Beginning of the Twentieth Century (Routledge Revivals)

$34.95 $45.99

A More Perfect Union: The Story of Our Constitution

$7.5 $11.99

History of the Labor Movement in the United States, Vol. 1: From Colonial Times to the Founding of the American Federation of Labor

$20.69 $21.99

Muslim National Communism in the Soviet Union: A Revolutionary Strategy for the Colonial World (Volume 11) (Publications of the Center for Middle Eastern Studies)

$37

The Albany Plan's influence on the Constitution

The Albany Plan of Union, proposed in 1754, was an attempt to unite the Thirteen Colonies under a unified government. Benjamin Franklin, a delegate from Pennsylvania, was the driving force behind the plan, which was largely inspired by his observations of the Iroquois and their system of common government. The plan called for a "general government" to be administered by a President-General, appointed by the British Crown, and a Grand Council, chosen by representatives of the colonial assemblies.

The Albany Plan was never ratified by any colony or by Britain, but it played a significant role in shaping the Constitution. During the debates over the federal Constitution of 1787, Franklin republished the plan as proof that the idea of a strong union was well-considered and not a hasty decision. Certain important elements of the Constitution can be traced back to the Albany Plan, such as proportional representation. Additionally, the plan's emphasis on uniting the colonies for defence and other general purposes laid the groundwork for the creation of a centralised government in the United States.

The Albany Plan's influence can also be seen in the structure of the federal government proposed in the Constitution. The President-General and Grand Council in the Albany Plan bear resemblance to the executive and legislative branches of the US government, with the President-General holding similar powers to the eventual US President, including the power to appoint military and civil officers. The Grand Council, consisting of representatives from each colony, reflects the idea of a representative democracy, which became a fundamental principle of the US political system.

Furthermore, the Albany Plan's recognition of the importance of collaboration between the colonies in areas such as taxation, treasury, and military strategy influenced the development of a more unified and cohesive government under the Constitution. The plan's rejection by both the colonial assemblies and the British government highlights the challenges of establishing a centralised authority that balances the interests of the individual colonies and the Crown. This tension would later be addressed in the Constitution through a system of checks and balances and the separation of powers.

Overall, while the Albany Plan of Union was never officially adopted, it served as a significant influence on the Constitution and the development of American political thought. It introduced the concept of a strong union, emphasised the benefits of centralised governance, and laid the groundwork for the creation of a unified and representative government in the United States.

The Albany Congress

The major initiative proposed at the Congress was the Albany Plan of Union, prepared by Benjamin Franklin, a senior member and delegate from Pennsylvania. The plan was the first attempt to unite the Thirteen Colonies under a single government, administered by a President-General appointed by the Crown, and a Grand Council chosen by representatives of the colonies. Franklin's plan was based on his observations of the Iroquois system of government and their ability to form confederations. The Albany Plan represented an early attempt at forming a union of the colonies for defence and other general purposes.

The Albany Plan was never ratified by any colony or by Britain. Colonial assemblies wanted more independence, while British officials felt the plan gave too much power to the colonies. Despite this, the plan was an important precursor to the United States Constitution, ratified in 1787. Certain elements of the Constitution, such as proportional representation, can trace their origins to the Albany Plan. Franklin republished the plan during debates over the federal Constitution, highlighting its relevance.

Franklin's Short Hints

Benjamin Franklin's "Short Hints" was a proposal to unite the Northern Colonies under a single government, which he drafted before the Albany Congress of 1754. It served as the basis for the Albany Plan of Union, which was adopted by the Congress but rejected by the colonial assemblies and the British.

Franklin's "Short Hints" was circulated among his friends before the Albany Congress. It proposed a union of the Northern Colonies to counter the growing threat on the frontier. The colonies of Massachusetts and Connecticut authorized their delegations to discuss this matter, but other colonial governments were suspicious of any plans that might limit their autonomy. Despite this, the delegates in Albany formed a committee to draft a plan of union, taking Franklin's "Short Hints" as their starting point.

Franklin's "Short Hints" argued that the colonies needed to band together for their own protection. Tensions were rising between the British and French over control of North America, and both powers wanted to control the strategically important Ohio River Valley. This struggle drew Native American tribes into complex alliances with either side. Franklin realized that the colonies needed to unite to survive, and his "Short Hints" reflected this urgency.

Franklin's proposal was a significant step towards colonial unification and a precursor to the United States Constitution. While the Albany Plan was never implemented, it introduced the colonies to the concept of a strong union. Certain elements of the Constitution, such as proportional representation, can be traced back to the Albany Plan and Franklin's "Short Hints".

Franklin himself acknowledged the significance of his proposal, writing about the rejections: "The colonial assemblies and most of the people were narrowly provincial in outlook, mutually jealous, and suspicious of any central taxing authority." He believed that the colonies' narrow outlook and jealousy stood in the way of forming a much-needed unified government.

Explore related products

There Is Power in a Union: The Epic Story of Labor in America

$19.6 $23

A Sacred Union of Citizens: George Washington's Farewell Adress and the American Character

$30.95

Syllabus of American colonial history from the beginning of colonial expansion to the formation of the Federal union

$10.65

The History Of The Union, And Of The Constitution: Being The Subject Of Three Lectures On The Colonial, Revolutionary, And Constitutional Periods Of ... The Virginia And Kentucky Resolutions Of '98.

$7.75

The Pirates of Colonial North Carolina

$8.99 $10

The Secret War for the Union: The Untold Story of Military Intelligence in the Civil War

$15.95 $35

The Iroquois Influence Thesis

The "Iroquois Influence Thesis" is the claim that the Albany Plan of Union was influenced by the political system of the Iroquois Confederacy. Benjamin Franklin, who drafted the plan, was a keen observer of American Indian government, particularly that of the Iroquois. The Iroquois Confederacy was a multi-state government that ensured individual governance and freedoms. It represented five tribes: Mohawk, Onondaga, Cayuga, Oneida, and Seneca, with the Tuscarora joining later in 1722. This structure was federal in nature, operating under the Great Law of Peace, a doctrine of 117 codicils where individual tribes handled their own affairs but came together to solve issues of common importance.

Proponents of the Iroquois Influence Thesis argue that the federal structure of the U.S. Constitution and notions of individual liberty and the separation of powers were influenced by the Iroquois Confederacy. They contend that Franklin's Albany Plan, which called for a general government administered by a President-General and a Grand Council, reflected this influence. The Albany Plan was rejected, but it laid the groundwork for the unification of the colonies and the creation of a strong union.

However, others dispute the Iroquois Influence Thesis, arguing that there is a lack of direct evidence in U.S. constitutional debate records. They point to examples of European antecedents for democratic institutions and differences between the Great Law of Peace and the original U.S. Constitution, such as the denial of suffrage to women and majority rule rather than consensus. While the influence of the Iroquois Confederacy on the development of colonial society and culture is acknowledged, some scholars believe it did not significantly impact the creation of the U.S. Constitution.

In 1988, the U.S. Congress passed Concurrent Resolution 331, formally acknowledging the influence of the Iroquois Confederacy on the U.S. Constitution and Bill of Rights. This resolution stated that the confederation of the original 13 colonies into one republic was influenced by the political system developed by the Iroquois Confederacy, as were many of the democratic principles incorporated into the Constitution. Despite this official recognition, the debate over the extent and nature of Iroquois influence on the U.S. Constitution continues among historians and scholars.

The Albany Plan's rejection

The Albany Plan of Union was a plan to place the Thirteen Colonies under a unified and centralised government. Representatives from seven of the British North American colonies adopted the plan during the Albany Congress on July 10, 1754, in Albany, New York. The plan was suggested by Benjamin Franklin, then a senior leader and delegate from Pennsylvania.

The plan was rejected by colonial assemblies and British representatives. Colonial governments, fearing a loss of power, territory, and commerce, either rejected the plan or chose not to act on it. The colonial assemblies wanted more independence than the plan provided, while British officials felt it gave the colonies too much power. The plan was also never ratified by a single colony or by Britain.

Despite the rejection, the Albany Plan was a significant step towards the formation of the United States of America in 1776. It introduced the colonies to the idea of their union and served as a forerunner for the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution, which incorporated some features of the plan.

• Fear of Power Loss: Colonial governments were wary of losing power, territory, and commerce to other colonies and the British Parliament. They perceived the plan as a threat to their authority and territorial rights.
• Independence Concerns: Colonial assemblies desired greater independence and felt that the plan did not provide enough autonomy. They wanted to maintain their decision-making power without external interference.
• Centralised Authority: Both colonial assemblies and the British government were suspicious of any central taxing authority. They preferred to keep control over their finances and resources rather than consolidate power in a centralised government.
• Scope of the Congress: The Albany Plan exceeded the original scope of the Congress, which was primarily focused on developing a plan of defence against the French and Indian threat. The plan's proposal for a unified government was seen as diverting from this immediate concern.
• Lack of Representation: Not all colonies sent representatives to the Albany Congress. The plan proposed the union of all British colonies, but some colonies, such as Georgia and Delaware, were not directly involved in the discussions.
• Competing Interests: The rejection was also spurred by both sides not fully getting what they wanted. The colonial assemblies and British representatives had competing interests and priorities, making it challenging to reach a mutually agreeable solution.

Frequently asked questions