Voice Age: A Constitutional Conundrum?

The Voice is a proposed amendment to the Australian Constitution to establish an advisory body that empowers Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples to provide input on decisions, policies, and laws made by the government and parliament. This amendment aims to address the lack of constitutional recognition of Australia's First Peoples and provide them with a permanent representation in the country's decision-making processes. While supporters argue that a broad remit is necessary for the Voice's effectiveness, opponents have raised concerns about the potential impact on the powers of the Commonwealth and the role of the courts. The success of this amendment hinges on a double majority vote, requiring support from a majority of states and an overall majority during the referendum.

Explore related products

The Beyond - Issues 027 & 028 (Golden Age Rare Vintage Comics Collection Book 14)

$2.99

Your Amazing Itty Bitty™ Coming Out at Any Age Book: 15 Key Steps to Living Your Life in Truth

$8.99

Blue Beetle: The Charlton Files - First Series: All Ten Issues (1964-1965) --- Great Silver Age Comic Action -- All Stories -- No Ads

$36.15 $43.77

The Only World Geography Activity Book for Kids Ages 8-12: 250+ Fun Facts and Colorful Workbook Challenges to Build Map Mastery and Cultural Curiosity Without Boring Exercises

$10.99

Dadoune Goes To School

$12.99 $12.99

Revelations

$9.99

The Voice referendum and proposed constitutional amendment

The referendum seeks to amend the Australian Constitution to establish the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice. This amendment aims to address the absence of any mention of the continent's first peoples in the current Constitution. The Voice will be an advisory body empowered to make representations on matters relating to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. It will not, however, have veto or law-making power, nor the ability to issue commands to Parliament. The power of the Voice lies in its ability to make representations, and Parliament can decide whether and when these representations are considered by the Executive.

The proposed amendment has sparked debates among legal experts and political parties. Some argue that the wording, particularly the phrase "executive government," could imply an obligation for the entire federal government and its agencies to consult the Voice. This interpretation raises concerns about the potential expansion of Commonwealth powers over the states. On the other hand, supporters of the proposal emphasize the importance of a broad remit, allowing the Voice to advise on a wide range of matters affecting Indigenous peoples. They argue that a narrow scope could lead to legal challenges and hinder the Voice's effectiveness in addressing evolving concerns.

The Law Council of Australia has supported the proposed amendment, stating that it is just and legally sound. They emphasize that a constitutionally enshrined Voice provides security and legitimacy to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples' representation. Additionally, the amendment responds to the call for constitutional reform outlined in the Uluru Statement from the Heart. The referendum, triggered in September 2023, required a double majority of votes, with voting being mandatory for eligible Australian citizens. The outcome of this referendum will significantly impact the recognition and participation of Indigenous peoples in Australia's decision-making processes.

The Voice's role in providing permanent representation and recognition for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples

Throughout history, the voices of these First Nations peoples have been structurally silenced, with governments defunding and dissolving groups designed to represent them at a national level. This has resulted in a lack of equal representation and recognition in the country's decision-making processes. To address this, various Indigenous advisory bodies have been established since 1973, with five national Indigenous bodies advising Australian governments, four of which were elected.

In 2015, over 40 Indigenous leaders presented the Kirribilli Statement, rejecting non-substantive constitutional changes and demanding more than just symbolic recognition. This led to the creation of the Referendum Council, which released a discussion paper outlining proposals for an Indigenous voice. The council engaged with over 1,200 Indigenous Australians, leading to the First Nations National Constitutional Convention in 2017. The convention's delegates composed the Uluru Statement from the Heart, which included a request for a First Nations Voice enshrined in the Constitution.

The Voice is intended to provide permanent representation and recognition for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples by giving them a say in Parliament and the Executive Government on matters relating to their communities. It will be an advisory body, independent of Parliament and chosen by the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, with a focus on being gender-balanced and inclusive of youth. The Voice will not have veto or law-making power but will provide advice and make representations on a broad range of matters, including policies, programs, and laws that affect Indigenous communities.

The proposed amendment to the Constitution, known as the Constitution Alteration (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice) 2023, aims to provide constitutional recognition and security for the Voice. This will make it more challenging for future governments to abolish, requiring another referendum to do so. The amendment also aims to facilitate the participation of Indigenous peoples in law and policy-making, ensuring their views and needs are considered in decisions that affect them.

The impact of the Voice on policy and law-making

The Voice is a proposed amendment to the Australian Constitution that seeks to recognise Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Peoples of Australia and establish an advisory body to provide input on decisions, policies, and laws made by the government and parliament. This amendment aims to address the lack of representation and recognition of Indigenous Australians in the country's Constitution.

Secondly, the Voice enhances the democratic process by improving the quality of decisions, policies, and laws through the inclusion of First Nations' perspectives and experiences. This is supported by decades of research and on-the-ground experience, which demonstrates that outcomes are improved when Indigenous peoples are empowered and involved. The Voice, therefore, has the potential to lead to more informed and effective governance.

Additionally, the Voice provides a level of security and certainty for Indigenous representation. Once established, it cannot be easily abolished, as any changes to the Constitution would require a referendum. This gives the Voice strong popular legitimacy and ensures that the rights and interests of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples are protected in the long term.

However, it is important to note that the Voice will not have veto power or law-making authority. While it can make representations and provide advice, the government and parliament are not compelled to follow these recommendations. The Voice, therefore, acts as a consultative mechanism rather than a decision-making body.

The specific impact of the Voice on policy and law-making will depend on its implementation and the extent to which its recommendations are considered and adopted by the government and parliament. The Voice has the potential to bring about meaningful change and improve outcomes for Indigenous Australians, but its effectiveness will ultimately be determined by the level of engagement and collaboration between all stakeholders.

Explore related products

Be a Buddy, Not a Bully

$12.95 $12.95

Essential Life Skills for Every 10-Year-Old: How to Master Emotions, Be Safe, Crush Your Goals and Other Cool Superpowers for Tween Boys and Girls

$0.99

Transformers: The Last Knight

$3.79

A Silent Voice: The Movie - Limited Edition Steelbook [Blu-ray + DVD]

$18.89

CLYOR Voice37- All Natural Voice Remedy for Singers - Boosts Your Voice - Soothes and Relieve Hoarseness - Lubricates Vocal Cords - Removes Mucus - Enhances Your Singing and Speaking - 2 oz

$35 $44

Little Voice

$30.98

The Voice's advisory nature and lack of veto power

The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice, also known as the Indigenous Voice to Parliament, the First Nations Voice, or simply the Voice, is a proposed Australian federal advisory body. It would comprise Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and represent the views of Indigenous communities. The Voice would be empowered to make representations on matters relating to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples.

The Voice's advisory nature means that it would not have the power to make laws, develop or administer policies, or decide disputes. It would only be able to make representations to Parliament and the government, which could be considered or ignored. The Voice would not have the power to veto any decisions made by Parliament or the government. This has been confirmed by constitutional experts and legal counsel, who have stated that the Voice would not pose any threat to Australia's system of representative government.

The Voice is intended to provide a mechanism for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples to have a say in how policies, programs, and laws affect them, leading to more informed decision-making. It would also provide a form of constitutional recognition for Indigenous Australians, who are currently not mentioned in the Australian Constitution. Constitutional change would also give the Voice security and certainty, as it could only be abolished through another referendum.

While the Voice's advisory nature and lack of veto power have been established, there are concerns about its broad remit. Some argue that the Voice could present its views on a wide range of issues, such as setting interest rates or formulating climate policy. However, proponents of the Voice argue that it is necessary and appropriate for it to speak on a diverse range of matters, as it is impossible to know in advance the issues that Indigenous peoples will find interesting or concerning.

The process of changing the Australian Constitution

The Australian Constitution is difficult to change, and this was an intentional decision made by its framers. They did not want the Australian Constitution to be altered by "every blast of popular opinion". Instead, they wanted control over the constitution to rest in Australian hands.

For a constitutional amendment to be made, it must first be approved by an absolute majority of each house of parliament, or passed twice by an absolute majority of one house, with a three-month interval in between. This gives the federal government control over what is put to a referendum. Once a referendum is held, the amendment must be passed by a majority of all electors who vote. Amendments must also achieve majorities in parliament, federally, and in a majority of states.

The Voice is a proposed amendment to the Australian Constitution, which would recognise Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Peoples of Australia and establish an advisory body to Parliament and the Executive Government. This would provide constitutional recognition of Indigenous Australians, which does not currently exist. The Voice would be empowered to make representations on matters relating to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, such as the development of policies, programs, and bills.

The Law Council of Australia has advised that the Voice amendment is just and legally sound and should be passed in its current form. The amendment has also been supported as a way to achieve constitutional reform, as outlined in the Uluru Statement from the Heart.

Frequently asked questions