Donations Or Gifts? Examining The Nature Of Campaign Funds

Political campaigns in the US are financed by a combination of private and public funding, with varying rules and limits on contributions. The Federal Election Commission (FEC) sets rules on what activities are considered independent or coordinated with a campaign, but these rules have become increasingly complex and unclear. The Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act (BCRA) of 2002, for instance, increased contribution limits for individuals donating to federal candidates and political parties. In the context of this complex and evolving regulatory landscape, it is important to understand whether a $2000 contribution to a political campaign is considered a gift.

Explore related products

Campaign Finance: What Everyone Needs to Know®

$12.77 $16.95

The Campaign Finance Cases: Buckley, McConnell, Citizens United, and McCutcheon (Landmark Law Cases and American Society)

$20.67 $29.99

Citizens Divided: Campaign Finance Reform and the Constitution (The Tanner Lectures on Human Values)

$19.84 $32

The New Campaign Finance Sourcebook

$31.83

Campaign Finance & American Democracy: What the Public Really Thinks and Why It Matters

$2.99 $32

Campaign Finance and Political Polarization: When Purists Prevail

$29.95

Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA) regulations

The Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA) is the primary US federal law regulating political campaign fundraising and spending. It was enacted in 1971 and signed into law by President Richard Nixon in 1972. The legislation sought to regulate the raising and spending of money in US federal elections, including corporate and union spending in campaigns for federal office.

FECA has been amended several times since its enactment. In 1974, the act was amended to create the Federal Election Commission (FEC) and to further regulate campaign spending. The FEC is an independent agency that enforces the law, facilitates disclosure, and administers the public funding program. The act was amended again in 1976 in response to the provisions ruled unconstitutional by Buckley v. Valeo, and again in 1979 to allow parties to spend unlimited amounts of hard money on activities like increasing voter turnout and registration.

FECA sets limits on campaign expenditures for broadcast media, newspaper advertisements, and telephone calls. It also limits the amount campaigns can spend on broadcast media to 60% of their total campaign spending limitation. The Act requires media companies to offer equal broadcast time to candidates for federal office and mandates public disclosure of campaign donors. Additionally, FECA prohibits promises of rewards or gifts, meaning that a candidate for office cannot offer employment or other benefits in exchange for donations or other forms of political aid.

In terms of contributions, FECA regulates who can and cannot contribute to campaigns. Campaigns may not accept contributions from the treasury funds of corporations, labor organizations, or national banks. National banks and federally chartered corporations are also prohibited from making contributions in connection with any election. A candidate's salary or wages earned from bona fide employment are considered personal funds, but compensation paid in excess of actual hours worked or for work not performed is generally considered a contribution from the employer. Incorporated charitable organizations are also prohibited from making contributions in connection with federal elections.

FECA also sets out requirements for reporting contributions. Reports are to be sent to the Comptroller General of the Government Accountability Office for Presidential elections, the Secretary of the Senate for Senatorial elections, and the Clerk of the House for House of Representatives elections. Candidates must also report finances to the Secretary of State's office in the state they are running for elected office in.

Limits on contribution amounts

In the United States, the Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA) regulates the financing of federal election campaigns, including limits on contribution amounts. The Federal Election Commission (FEC) is responsible for enforcing these regulations.

Limits on Individual Contributions

Individuals are allowed to contribute up to $2,000 per election to a federal candidate's campaign. This limit applies separately to each election in which the candidate participates, such as primaries, generals, runoffs, and special elections.

Limits on Political Action Committees (PACs)

Political Action Committees (PACs) are organizations that pool contributions from multiple donors to support candidates or causes. There are different types of PACs with varying contribution limits:

• Connected PACs: Also known as "non-connected PACs," these are independent from political parties and may accept unlimited contributions from individuals, corporations, labor organizations, and other PACs. However, they are not allowed to contribute directly to candidates.
• Super PACs: These are independent-expenditure-only political committees that may accept unlimited contributions from any source, including corporations and labor organizations. They can use these funds to advocate for or against a candidate but cannot coordinate directly with a candidate's campaign.
• Hybrid PACs: Similar to Super PACs, Hybrid PACs can accept unlimited contributions but can also make limited direct contributions to candidates.

Limits on Party Committees

National party committees, such as the Democratic National Committee or the Republican National Committee, have separate contribution limits from their Senate and House campaign committees. These limits apply to specific accounts, such as those for the presidential nominating convention, election recounts, legal proceedings, and national party headquarters buildings.

Prohibited Sources of Contributions

Certain sources are prohibited from making contributions to federal election campaigns. These include:

• Corporations, labour organizations, and national banks
• Federal government contractors
• Incorporated charitable organizations
• Treasury funds of corporations, labour organizations, or national banks

State-Specific Contribution Limits

In addition to federal regulations, individual states may have their own contribution limits for state and local elections. For example, New York State has established limits on contributions that can be given and received by candidates and political committees, as well as limits on contributions from individuals and entities such as corporations, LLCs, and PLLCs.

Who can and can't donate

Political campaigns can raise millions, if not billions, of dollars through personal and business donations. This money can be used to pay for travel, administration, salaries, and any other campaign-related expenses. However, there are rules in place that dictate how money can be spent, and campaigns must keep diligent records of where the money comes from and how much is spent.

Who Can Donate?

• Individuals who are under 18 years old may make contributions to candidates and political committees, subject to certain limitations.
• Unincorporated tribal entities can be considered a "person" and are therefore subject to contribution prohibitions and limitations.
• State PACs, unregistered local party organizations, and nonfederal campaign committees may, under certain circumstances, contribute to federal candidates.
• Independent-expenditure-only political committees (or "Super PACs") may accept unlimited contributions, including from corporations and labor organizations.
• A candidate’s authorized committees may accept a contribution of up to $2,000 per election from the authorized committee of another federal candidate.
• Political action committees (PACs) can collect millions of dollars in contributions.
• Individuals can give to candidates and party committees.

Who Can't Donate?

• Campaigns may not accept or solicit contributions from federal government contractors.
• Incorporated charitable organizations and other corporations are prohibited from making contributions in connection with federal elections.
• Charities face additional restrictions on political activity under provisions of the Internal Revenue Code.
• Federal law prohibits contributions, donations, expenditures, and disbursements solicited, directed, received, or made directly or indirectly by or from foreign nationals in connection with any federal, state, or local election.
• A contribution made by one person in the name of another is prohibited.
• A candidate may not use campaign funds for personal use.

Explore related products

Analysis of Federal and state campaign finance law, summaries, and quick-reference charts

$25.99

Buying the Vote: A History of Campaign Finance Reform

$23.87 $51

When Money Speaks: The McCutcheon Decision, Campaign Finance Laws, and the First Amendment

$6.99 $19.99

Inside Campaign Finance: Myths and Realities

$48

Campaigns, Congress, and Courts: The Making of Federal Campaign Finance Law

$95

Unfree Speech: The Folly of Campaign Finance Reform

$52.25 $55

What happens to leftover funds

Political campaigns are funded by donations from individuals, corporations, labor organizations, and other political committees. These donations are considered contributions and are subject to regulations and limits. For example, an individual can donate up to $2,000 per election to a federal candidate's campaign.

Once a political campaign is over, there are rules and regulations in place that dictate how any leftover funds can be spent. Candidates are prohibited from using these funds for personal expenses, such as mortgage payments, groceries, clothing, or vacations. Instead, leftover funds can be used for various purposes, including:

• Paying off any outstanding expenses or debts incurred during the campaign, such as rent, polling fees, transportation, and staff salaries.
• Donating to charitable organizations. Former Senator Joseph Lieberman, for example, transferred leftover funds from his campaign to a college scholarship fund.
• Donating to other political campaigns or candidates, including national, state, or local party committees, and federal, state, or local candidates, depending on state campaign finance laws.
• Saving for a future campaign or transferring funds to a "leadership PAC," a political committee controlled by the former candidate that supports a political agenda or other candidates, rather than the individual's campaigns.
• Refunding donors or providing gifts.

Independent expenditures

In the United States, an independent expenditure is a political campaign communication that advocates for or against a clearly identified political candidate. This expenditure is not made in cooperation, consultation, or concert with a candidate, their authorised committee, or a political party. Any independent expenditure requires a disclaimer, which must identify the person or organisation paying for the communication and state that it was not authorised by a candidate or their committee.

The Federal Election Commission (FEC) defines an agent as someone with "actual authority, either express or implied" to act on behalf of a campaign. If an agent becomes "materially involved", the expenditure is no longer considered independent. For example, if an agent suggests creating an advertisement, the independent expenditure could be invalidated. To prevent this, some groups may sequester staff in the months leading up to an election.

The legality of independent expenditures has been the subject of court rulings, such as the 1976 case Buckley v. Valeo, in which the Supreme Court upheld the law's limits on contributions to candidates for Federal office but did not uphold limits on independent expenditures. In 2010, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit held that groups making independent expenditures could accept contributions without restrictions on source or size. Despite these rulings, some argue that FEC regulations are regularly flouted through loopholes, and that a significant amount of independent expenditure is coordinated with candidates.

Frequently asked questions