The Constitution: Still Relevant, Still Needed

how to prove we still need the constitution

The United States Constitution, signed on September 17, 1787, has been amended and improved over time, but it still faces threats from political whims and individual interpretations. The Constitution outlines the fundamental principles of equal justice, liberty, and human rights, and it is the responsibility of all branches of the government to uphold it. Recent events, such as President Trump's actions and statements questioning the right to due process, have provoked constitutional crises and highlighted the need to protect the Constitution from infringement. The Constitution's endurance and evolution demonstrate its continued relevance and the need to safeguard it for future generations.

Characteristics Values
The Constitution should be upheld by the President The President should uphold the Constitution of the United States
The Constitution is amended and improved over time Amendments are made to the Constitution to improve it and resolve its contradictions
The Constitution should not be changed based on political whim Changes should be made only when there is a broad societal agreement
The Constitution lays out the powers of Congress Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution outlines the powers of Congress
The Constitution guarantees equal justice and human rights The Constitution ensures equal justice and human rights for all
The Constitution is ratified by the Conventions of nine States The Constitution is established between the States that ratified it
The Constitution guarantees a Republican form of government to every State The Constitution ensures that the United States guarantees a Republican form of government to each State
The Constitution provides for the common defence The Constitution establishes measures for national defence
The Constitution promotes the general Welfare The Constitution includes provisions to promote the general welfare of the people

cycivic

The Constitution upholds justice, liberty and equality

The US Constitution is a document that outlines the country's fundamental laws and principles. It serves as a framework for the nation's governance and establishes certain ideals that the country should strive for. One of the key objectives outlined in the preamble of the Constitution is to "establish Justice". This phrase signifies the intention to create a system of governance that promotes fair treatment and equality under the law.

The Constitution's pursuit of "justice for all" is one of its most profound contributions. This ideal is engraved in the Pledge of Allegiance and is a cornerstone of the document. The Supreme Court has played a significant role in interpreting and applying this mandate, with landmark cases such as Brown v. Board of Education, which utilised the Equal Protection Clause to deliver justice to marginalised communities. The Equal Protection Clause prohibits states from denying any person within their jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws, helping to combat discrimination and ensure equal treatment in the eyes of the law.

The Due Process clauses in the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments are also crucial to achieving "justice for all". Due process guarantees fair treatment, equality before the law, protection against arbitrary power, and promotes transparency and accountability. It is intrinsic to the concept of justice and ensures that the promise of "justice for all" is more than just rhetoric. The Constitution establishes an independent judiciary, with the Supreme Court and other federal courts interpreting the Constitution and striking down laws that are deemed unconstitutional, thus upholding the principles of justice.

The Constitution also serves to "secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity". This includes protecting individual liberties and limiting governmental power. For example, the Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable searches and seizures, while the Fifth and Sixth Amendments guarantee rights fundamental to a fair trial, such as the right to due process and a speedy and public trial.

The Constitution is a living document that continues to guide the nation and uphold the values of justice, liberty, and equality. It establishes a system of checks and balances, with an independent judiciary interpreting and enforcing the law, ensuring that these values are protected and that the government acts within its constitutional boundaries.

cycivic

It provides for the common defence

The US Constitution is a crucial document that outlines the rights and responsibilities of the government and citizens, ensuring a democratic society. One of its key provisions is to "provide for the common defence", which has significant implications for national security and the role of Congress.

The phrase "provide for the common defence" is explicitly mentioned in Article 1, Section 8 of the Constitution, which outlines the powers of Congress. It states, "The Congress shall have Power... To provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States". This provision grants Congress the authority to establish and maintain a national defence force, ensuring the protection of the country against external threats.

The Founding Fathers intended for Congress to have the necessary powers to defend the nation effectively. This includes the ability to raise and support armies, organise and arm militias, and appropriate funds for military purposes. However, there are also limitations placed on Congress's power to maintain a balance. For example, the Constitution limits the appropriation of money for maintaining armies to a maximum of two years, ensuring that Congress regularly reviews and justifies military spending.

The "provide for the common defence" clause has been invoked in recent legislation, such as the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). This act demonstrates Congress's commitment to fulfilling its constitutional duty by restoring fiscal discipline to the defence budget, supporting military families, and ensuring the armed forces are prepared for modern challenges.

Additionally, the Constitution also addresses defence at the state level. It guarantees each state a republican form of government and protection against invasion and domestic violence. This aspect of "common defence" highlights the Constitution's role in safeguarding the stability and integrity of individual states within the Union.

In conclusion, the Constitution's provision to "provide for the common defence" remains essential in the present day. It grants Congress the authority and responsibility to ensure national security while also establishing checks and balances to prevent the abuse of power. By upholding this aspect of the Constitution, the nation can honour its commitment to service members and protect the freedoms and welfare of its citizens.

cycivic

It establishes a more perfect Union

The preamble to the US Constitution opens with a powerful declaration of purpose: "We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union..." The writers understood that the definition of perfection varies from group to group, and even within groups, there are differences on how to achieve it. Thus, the use of "more" coupled with "perfect" implies a recognition of imperfection and a collective effort to improve and strengthen the union.

The phrase "a more perfect Union" reflects the aspiration of self-governance and the understanding that the Constitution is a living document that can be amended and improved over time. It acknowledges that the nation is a work in progress and that there is always room for growth and improvement. This phrase also emphasizes the importance of unity and working together to create a stronger and more cohesive nation.

Throughout American history, the interpretation of "a more perfect Union" has been the subject of great debate. For example, extending voting rights to people without property, the women's suffrage movement, and the long struggle for civil rights for all races have all been part of the ongoing dialogue about what constitutes justice and a more perfect union. These debates continue today, as Americans strive to ensure that the principles of justice, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness are accessible to all.

The phrase "promote the general welfare" in the Constitution further emphasizes the importance of collective well-being. This clause reflects the framers' concern for the welfare of individuals and the American community. It serves as a reminder that the nation's economic competitiveness and health outcomes directly impact the overall welfare of its citizens.

In conclusion, the concept of "a more perfect Union" in the US Constitution is a call to action for Americans to continuously strive for improvement and unity. It is a recognition of the nation's imperfections and a commitment to addressing them through collective effort and dialogue. As Congressman John Garamendi stated, the task is to "seek to improve the state of our union while knowing that [...] our collective efforts [...] will still be imperfect."

Cartoonist's Take on the US Constitution

You may want to see also

cycivic

It guarantees a Republican form of government

The United States Constitution guarantees a Republican form of government. This is known as the Guarantee Clause, which requires the United States to guarantee to the states a republican form of government and protect them from foreign invasion and domestic violence.

The Guarantee Clause is based on the idea of majority rule, where the people govern through elections. It imposes limitations on the type of government a state may have, preventing any state from imposing rule by monarchy, dictatorship, aristocracy, or permanent military rule, even through majority vote.

The Clause does not speak to the details of the republican government that the United States is to guarantee. For example, it does not address state denial of the right to vote based on race, sex, age, wealth, or property ownership. While it requires states to produce governments by electoral processes, it does not require a particular form of republican governmental structure.

The Guarantee Clause has rarely been formally invoked, and there is debate over whether it can be challenged in federal court. The Supreme Court has held that questions involving the Guarantee Clause are nonjusticiable, meaning that any remedy for a violation lies with Congress or the President. However, more recently, the Court has suggested that the justiciability of a Guarantee Clause challenge must be decided on a case-by-case basis.

cycivic

It promotes the progress of science and useful arts

The US Constitution's Copyright Clause, also known as the Intellectual Property Clause, Copyright and Patent Clause, or the Progress Clause, is a powerful tool for promoting the progress of science and useful arts. The clause grants Congress the power to secure, for limited periods, the exclusive rights of authors and inventors to their respective writings and discoveries. This provision, enshrined in Article I, Section 8, Clause 8 of the Constitution, is the foundation of US copyright and patent laws.

By granting authors and inventors exclusive rights to their work, the clause provides a strong incentive for creativity and innovation. It recognises and values the contributions of those who generate new knowledge and creative works, fostering an environment conducive to scientific and artistic advancement. This incentive structure encourages individuals to invest their time and resources in scientific and artistic pursuits, knowing that they will have control over the fruits of their labour.

The Copyright Clause's reference to "useful arts" is particularly interesting. In this context, "useful arts" does not refer to artistic endeavours in the traditional sense, but rather to the work of artisans and those skilled in manufacturing crafts. This broad interpretation ensures that the clause encompasses a wide range of creative and innovative activities, reflecting the importance of applied knowledge and practical skills in societal progress.

The interpretation of "sciences" in the clause is also noteworthy. It extends beyond modern scientific inquiry to encompass all forms of knowledge. This inclusive definition recognises that progress is not limited to any specific field or discipline, but rather arises from a multitude of intellectual pursuits and endeavours. By securing intellectual property rights, the clause encourages the dissemination and application of knowledge, fostering progress in diverse areas of human endeavour.

The Copyright Clause's role in promoting progress is further strengthened by its flexibility. The limited duration of copyrights and patents prevents the stagnation of knowledge and ideas. By ensuring that intellectual property rights are not perpetual, the clause strikes a balance between incentivising innovation and promoting the sharing of knowledge. This balance is essential for sustaining long-term progress and ensuring that society as a whole benefits from scientific and artistic advancements.

Frequently asked questions

The U.S. Constitution outlines the nation's most fundamental laws and principles, including the establishment of a more perfect union, the establishment of justice, the protection of domestic tranquility, the provision for the common defence, the promotion of the general welfare, and the securing of liberty for all citizens.

The U.S. Constitution has been amended and improved over time to address societal changes and challenges. It provides the framework for the nation's laws and ensures that the government's power flows from the people, protecting their rights and liberties.

The U.S. Constitution has been amended several times since its inception to address contradictions and shortcomings. For example, while the original Constitution excluded marginalized groups such as Black people, Indigenous people, and women, amendments have been made to extend rights and liberties to these groups over time.

Every branch of the U.S. government has an equal responsibility to uphold and protect the Constitution. When one branch veers off course, it is the job of the others to counterbalance and ensure that the nation's principles are maintained.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment